News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by jasinjames on Friday June 10, 2022 @12:57AM (#31690221)
I just graduated from Cornell, and I'm not surprised. Some student posters around campus which read "Hong Kong stands with Ukraine" had the "Hong Kong" scribbled out by someone else. [1] I saw students point and laugh at a similar poster. On multiple occasions, I saw scraps left behind where posters criticizing Xi Jinping or the CCP had hung.

[1] https://i.postimg.cc/25LM9hZJ/7297-B1-DB-5-CB3-4019-BCF3-8-F...

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by zaptrem on Friday June 10, 2022 @01:32AM (#31690421)
I'm a current senior at Cornell and I'm conflicted.

> On Friday, the administration told students in an emailed statement "we have an expectation and responsibility to engage with viewpoints that we disagree with," but that "we must also respect that walkouts are a legitimate form of protest and an appropriate expression of disapproval."

I like free speech as much as the next Hacker News user, but many of the actions of these students (they have an organization and a secret group chat to coordinate stuff like this) absolutely fall into the toleration of intolerance paradox. On the other hand, walking out is just about the most polite form of protest you can conduct. Certainly better than the mob that tried to prevent the law school Boston Flag SC case debate from occurring this semester.

However, even without imposing actual consequences, the administration absolutely should have rebuked those using their free speech in favor of human rights abuses. They should have done more to defend Rizwangul NurMuhammad.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by colordrops on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:10AM (#31691042)
Sorry but I'm disgusted with this thought process that has taken hold over the last several years. You decide the truth value of something and based on that you further decide that a topic is off limits. It's shockingly self-centered and leaves no room for the possiblity that you might be wrong about the matter, and that you are moving the goalposts for what is considered acceptable speech. The road to hell is paved with good intentions.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by mariusor on Friday June 10, 2022 @05:15AM (#31691775)
> You decide the truth value of something and based on that you further decide that a topic is off limits

I would normally agree with this viewpoint, but there are things which have an objective quality of being immoral. Supporting the persecution of a group of people because of their ethnicity (or whichever other criteria) is such a thing. Please tell me how I'm wrong about that.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by colordrops on Friday June 10, 2022 @11:26AM (#31695485)
You are wrong about that because it's not possible to know if something is true with certainty. Hearing about things in the news and social media doesn't make it true. See: Iraq WMD.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by kmonsen on Friday June 10, 2022 @12:49PM (#31696570)
I feel that is a really bad example. I was an adult at the time and it was really clear back at the time that the Iraqi wmd was made up allegations, or at least the evidence we got to see was not worth anything.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by colordrops on Friday June 10, 2022 @04:50PM (#31699215)
It's pretty clear to me that Xinjiang is not as bad as the US is making it in their propaganda war. I haven't seen any concrete evidence of genocide.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by mariusor on Friday June 10, 2022 @11:32AM (#31695574)
I am not arguing about something that is true or not. I am arguing that someone that supports an objectively immoral act is objectively immoral and even though they might be free to espouse that point of view, any private individual or organization is equally free in shunning them.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by lenkite on Saturday June 11, 2022 @07:12AM (#31703632)
Moral arguments are used by US state propaganda ALL THE TIME to get rid of the bad guys. I no longer trust 'objectively moral' arguments now. Folks who believe such are generally in the camp of the young, the brainwashed or the true 'change' fanatics who don't care about body count in pursuit of beliefs.

Saddam is a bad guy with WMD - let's get rid of him with shock&awe. Oops, we lied to the world and caused 200k deaths, but we are really moral!

Gaddafi is a bad guy who's oppressing the Arab Spring revolution (and threatening the USD). Let's get him with air-strikes and 'freedom-fighters'. Oops Libya fell-apart from a state that had guaranteed healthcare and education to a mess of conflicting factions and a multi-million casualty count. But hey - we are the good guys doing war for 'morality' and freedom. "We came, we saw, he died!"- Hillary Clinton.

Assad is a bad guy who's killing rebels (and siding with bad Russia). Let's get rid of him by giving his opponents (Obama's moderate rebels) infinite ammo, arms and armour. So what if they chained and raped women, united and transmogrified into the ISIS and invaded Iraq - we get another opportunity to bomb the bad guys!

All these 'moral American arguments' are responsible for multi-million deaths and casualties in the world - but doing it for morality makes it OK.

It starts with your campus culture, then those same folks become members of the US state department and want to change the world by through cancelling nation states or enacting sanctions that cause economic collapse and famine.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by colordrops on Friday June 10, 2022 @11:53AM (#31695857)
Let's talk about the word "objective" here. It means outside of any person's perspective, the same for everyone. Like the laws of physics for instance. "objective" and "moral" are contradictory, considering that "morals" are defined by individual perspectives. Even murder and child molestation were considered normal in some cultures historically (e.g. classical Greece). There is no such thing as objective morals, which is why the same story told by two different people can have vastly different tones. It's why we have laws to draw lines, and courts to get around the confusion about where those lines lie.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by mariusor on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:33PM (#31698476)
Let's not argue semantics, please. I am pretty sure you understood what I meant.

Persecuting a group of people for various criteria is unethical, immoral, evil, whatever you want to call it. I also claim that it is objectively so, and I would like you to argue in good faith how I am wrong about these two facts, instead of - like you accused grand-parent - moving the goal posts.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by colordrops on Friday June 10, 2022 @04:53PM (#31699253)
No, it's not semantics. You can't say something that is not logical then argue that it's semantics when someone points that out. I don't know what you mean. There really isn't any situation that has an objective moral grounding. Just look at abortion. Both sides have pretty strong and reasonable narratives why their stance makes sense, and they both believe themselves to be objectively morally in the right. What is really happening is that both sides are small minded, thinking the other side is blind and nuts, and making the same mistake that you are.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by davorak on Friday June 10, 2022 @07:10PM (#31700363)
> No, it's not semantics.

It is easy to interrupt you argument as semantics, because you can remove 'objectively' from mariusor's statement and the intended meaning does not seem to change much:

'I am arguing that someone that supports an immoral act is immoral and even though they might be free to espouse that point of view, any private individual or organization is equally free in shunning them.'

The main point of the statement does not seem to revolve around or or depend on 'objectively', so your argument can come off as arguing over an irreverent detail, which is one definition arguing over semantics.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by colordrops on Friday June 10, 2022 @07:56PM (#31700637)
It wouldn't have been confusing if not for them changing the subject and move the goalposts from their original statement, where the use of "objective" was absolutely material to their meaning, which was that the act is unquestionably immoral:

>> You decide the truth value of something and based on that you further decide that a topic is off limits

> I would normally agree with this viewpoint, but there are things which have an objective quality of being immoral. Supporting the persecution of a group of people because of their ethnicity (or whichever other criteria) is such a thing. Please tell me how I'm wrong about that.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by davorak on Friday June 10, 2022 @10:20PM (#31701387)
It looks like mariusor gave you a statement, with no direct connection to a real group of people, that is almost tautologically true.

> Supporting the persecution of a group of people because of their ethnicity (or whichever other criteria) is such a thing. Please tell me how I'm wrong about that.

To reword a little bit, it is immoral to persecute(or support the act) a group for arbitrary and trivial detail(s).

So if you agree with that then you and mariusor would have some common ground and could build from there.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by colordrops on Friday June 10, 2022 @10:36PM (#31701466)
I don't agree with the characterization that there's no direct connection to a real group of people with this statement, as it would be a non sequitur at best, and an intentional misdirection at worst. I, and probably most people reading this thread, are under the impression that we are talking about the Uyghurs of Xinjiang considering the topic of the post, and it's kind of absurd to assume otherwise.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by davorak on Saturday June 11, 2022 @01:25AM (#31702178)
It is a common technique, in my experience, to generalize parts of an argument to make it easier to find a shared philosophy or principle. Then Shared understanding can cooperatively be built on the common ground formed by the shared philosophy or principle.

mariusor generalized their argument, tried to separate his argument form any specific group, with:

> I am arguing that someone that supports an objectively immoral act is objectively immoral and even though they might be free to espouse that point of view, any private individual or organization is equally free in shunning them.

After common ground is found the next step is to apply the shared understanding or philosophy to the specifics of the issue at hand. This often allows both parties to separate themselves from their biases, at least some, and think more clearly.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by pas on Saturday June 11, 2022 @01:05AM (#31702085)
The thought process that taken hold over the last several years... like the last 250?

The thought process that using various means to try to achieve human rights goals?

Oh well maybe you think the civil war was fought on a nice delightful afternoon between tea and cake, and folks shook hands after, slaves were freed and everyone went home, and the president recommend soldiers to go get some tan in the south for the photo op next year.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by colordrops on Saturday June 11, 2022 @12:55PM (#31705960)
Yes, keeping slaves and saying words you don't like are equivalent crimes worthy of warfare.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by wesleywt on Friday June 10, 2022 @04:08AM (#31691357)
Free speech absolutionist, like you, also seem to be against the consequences of that speech, such as being "cancelled". I am for both free speech and getting cancelled for it. In this way, standards acceptable to our society can be policed without interferance from the government.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by effingwewt on Friday June 10, 2022 @04:26AM (#31691475)
This is where I find myself as well. You are free to say things, you are not free of the consequences.

I expect someone to deck me for saying certain things.

Growing up in Texas we had a saying- 'Them's fightin' words.'

ie if someone said something out of bounds, they were headed for a scrap, or at least that wad a very real possibility.

Having said that I would still defend their right to talk shit.

edit- screw cancel culture though, that shit ruins lives over even perceived slights. I don't believe any adult hasn't said something stupid or asinine we regret now. The thought that can ruin a life or career is crazy. If you don't like what someone says don't listen. If they aren't inciting violence or something.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by Dracophoenix on Friday June 10, 2022 @04:59AM (#31691693)
> Growing up in Texas we had a saying- 'Them's fightin' words.' ie if someone said something out of bounds, they were headed for a scrap, or at least that wad a very real possibility.

From a legal viewpoint, even if said speech meets the Chaplinsky definition of "fighting words", that does not exonerate or justify one man's violence against another. I have a hard time seeing that most would accept hitting a person as an acceptable response to what is perceived to be distasteful speech. Millions of people lambasted Will Smith not so long ago for doing just that.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Friday June 10, 2022 @11:08AM (#31695246)
Even if someone is hurling a monstrous slew of verbal insults at you, hitting them is both morally wrong and illegal.

Today's awareness of mental trauma and triggers is a good thing, but it blurs the line a bit between physical and verbal attacks. Personally, I strongly believe that words should be treated fundamentally differently than physical violence. Sticks and stones, etc.

That said, if you're the one hurling insults, you're intentionally trying to evoke an emotional response, and you should not be surprised if the person you're insulting responds emotionally and violently.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by effingwewt on Saturday June 11, 2022 @12:22AM (#31701895)
I think it's more about it making you choose your words carefully.

For the record I'm very against what will smith did (posters above mentioned it), but I'd have felt differently if it hadn't been a comedian telling jokes, but say someone got in will's face and called him the N word with malice. I think it'd be perfectly reasonable to knock someone out over that. If the other person knows this is a good possibility, they may only use those words if they mean them enoughto accept the consequences.

I'm not saying my way is right, I'm just saying how it was growing up, and how that's shaped me.

In another thread I mentioned a friend of mine getting hurled insults at her abortion appointment. Had any of them been a man I'd have definitely gotten in some trouble that day. My belief is they have the right to say it, not protection from the consequences. But I'm also very against cancel culture. Am I weird for all of this? Alone in these beliefs? Totally wrong? Quite possibly, I know the world now confuses the shit out of me, and sometimes I feel like I am the only sane one for seeing some things (ie- trading our lives to the rich for a pittance, rules for thee but not for me, etc). Truly I could be very wrong, and if so I will accept that and try and change my views. I do try and live by the scientific method.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by Gnob on Friday June 10, 2022 @12:19PM (#31696200)
"Millions of people lambasted Will Smith not so long ago for doing just that."

Wasn't that due to the fact that he acted in a way that looked as if he actually cared to defend his woman?

afaik it had nothing to do with violence but more against having personal honour or pride and thinking of one's woman as him alone and having a sacred relationship with her that anyone insulting / degrading her is directly insulting the man, and that idea triggers the feminists to the moon and back I guess.

"even if said speech meets the Chaplinsky definition of "fighting words", that does not exonerate or justify one man's violence against another." Then what is a man supposed to do? go to court over an insult? be rude and start a shitshow of exchanging insults? take it and move on? wait for the other party to initiate the fight? or what?

I am not a westerner by any means, just curious.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by Dracophoenix on Friday June 10, 2022 @01:51PM (#31697301)
> Wasn't that due to the fact that he acted in a way that looked as if he actually cared to defend his woman?

Nope. Some of the few who supported Will Smith have used that line of thought to justify his actions, but that's not why he was lambasted. The main reasons cited are that:

1) he attacked and subsequently threatened to harm Chris Rock, a comedian and fellow actor simply doing his job as a host and jester.

2) he diverted all the attention of Oscars away from the achievements of all the other winning actors with his petty slap

3) he behaved inconsistently as he himself had laughed at the GI Jane joke just before attacking Mr.Rock

I can't speak for the supposed feminists you've come across, but many actors, directors, and members of the public stateside expressed shock and disapproval towards the physical violence. Some like Jim Carey were angry at the audience for giving Mr. Smith a standing ovation while he gave a poorly reasoned justification for his actions during his award speech.

> Then what is a man supposed to do? go to court over an insult? be rude and start a shitshow of exchanging insults? take it and move on? wait for the other party to initiate the fight? or what? I am not a westerner by any means, just curious.

Well firstly, he himself wasn't insulted and his wife isn't a defenseless child. As Mr. Smith was not the object of derision, he, in legal parlance, would have no reasonable claim to sue (much less attack) Chris Rock.

As far as insults go, Mr. Smith was the only foul-mouthed participant during the altercation. He already started the shitshow while Mr. Rock had instead attempted to end it by placating him. It's plainly evident from his actions that Mr. Rock had no interest in initiating a fight.

If Mr. Smith truly had a problem with his wife's alopecia being made fun of, he could have done what any normal person did and Tweet about how bald jokes aren't funny or how they hurt people's feelings or meaningless drivel like that. If he was more serious, he could have put money in some sort of campaign for alopecia.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by the_only_law on Friday June 10, 2022 @11:10AM (#31695270)
Especially when street fights can easily wind up a manslaughter or murder case.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by colordrops on Friday June 10, 2022 @11:40AM (#31695682)
Not sure what your point is, but I'm not suggesting any law that forces private entities to allow free speech. I'm also expressing my own opinion on the matter in a social context, using social energy rather than legal means toward the person who is telling me to shut up, using my own social vote to influence what standards are acceptable in society. Not out of line with what you are saying at all.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by DarkWiiPlayer on Friday June 10, 2022 @05:02AM (#31691708)
> also seem to be against the consequences of that speech, such as being "cancelled"

Getting shot for saying the wrong thing is also just another consequence. Is that also acceptable to you? I'm sure it's not, but that would also mean your whole point is BS.

There's a line when it comes to social consequences of speech and people like you are conveniently ignoring that fact to avoid having to explain why it should be drawn so cancelling falls on the acceptable side.

But the thing is, if you advocate for any personal consequences against the person expressing their opinion, then you're arguing directly against a human right.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by jgwil2 on Friday June 10, 2022 @07:30AM (#31692601)
>> also seem to be against the consequences of that speech, such as being "cancelled"

> Getting shot for saying the wrong thing is also just another consequence. Is that also acceptable to you? I'm sure it's not, but that would also mean your whole point is BS.

OP never said any consequences were acceptable; we have laws against shooting people so clearly such a consequence is proscribed in civil society.

> But the thing is, if you advocate for any personal consequences against the person expressing their opinion, then you're arguing directly against a human right.

By that logic, if someone says something racist and then loses friends or a job because of it, that violates their human rights. But surely we cannot force people to associate with someone who says abhorrent things without in turn violating their rights.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by DarkWiiPlayer on Friday June 10, 2022 @07:52AM (#31692768)
> By that logic

My logic is that, in order to guarantee the right to freedom of expression, there needs to be a line. The moment the "consequences" of expressing an opinion are predominantly punitive is where it needs to stop.

So no, by my logic, you're totally allowed to not be friends with someone who says something racist. As for losing a job, in an ideal world where this person could just get another job, yes, that'd be acceptable. But when it turns into losing the right to have any job whatsoever, then no, that's definitely not okay either.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by davorak on Friday June 10, 2022 @08:50AM (#31693343)
> But when it turns into losing the right to have any job whatsoever, then no, that's definitely not okay either.

wesleywt seems to be against this too since removing a legal right like that would require government action and they are againts that as seen in:

> I am for both free speech and getting cancelled for it. In this way, standards acceptable to our society can be policed without interferance from the government.

It seems like you put cancelling on the acceptable side of the line when you say:

> So no, by my logic, you're totally allowed to not be friends with someone who says something racist. As for losing a job, in an ideal world where this person could just get another job, yes, that'd be acceptable.

I normally think of cancelling as individuals deciding who they want to associate with and any consequences that flow from that. Which seems to land on the acceptable side of the line you are drawing.

While government action would not be acceptable, which I agree with, but I would not call cancelling.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by DarkWiiPlayer on Friday June 10, 2022 @09:15AM (#31693654)
> I normally think of cancelling as individuals deciding who they want to associate with and any consequences that flow from that. Which seems to land on the acceptable side of the line you are drawing.

Yea but lets not forget the context entirely here; we're talking about a walkout at a university, and people are insinuating that there should be some form of punishment as a consequence.

You can construct a case where social consequences for an expression of opinion do happen and no human rights are infringed, but I'm not arguing that such cases can't exist, so you aren't really proving anything meaningful there.

My point is, to put it clearly: The idea that the right to either free speech or freedom of expression does not guarantee any form of protection from social consequences is completely incorrect.

> In this way, standards acceptable to our society can be policed without interferance from the government.

That's a cute way of spelling "mob rule". It sounds nice because it talks about avoiding "interference", but really, it's a way of avoiding democracy and due justice. If you can't convince the majority of society, then you take matters into your own hands. That's not a system I want to live in.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by mlyle on Friday June 10, 2022 @12:22PM (#31696225)
> Yea but lets not forget the context entirely here; we're talking about a walkout at a university, and people are insinuating that there should be some form of punishment as a consequence.

I think people are saying that:

- The university should repudiate their assertions with the university's words.

- The university should strongly seek to enforce its rules when there are harsher actions than a walkout, such as the vandalism coordinated by group chats.

> but really, it's a way of avoiding democracy and due justice. If you can't convince the majority of society, then you take matters into your own hands. That's not a system I want to live in.

If you convince everyone who would give someone a job that it's not worth the hassle to hire the super racist dude, that's hardly "avoiding democracy".

I mean, you seem to be arguing that the government should somehow force (someone?) to give the super racist person a job so they're not "cancelled."

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by DarkWiiPlayer on Monday June 13, 2022 @03:59AM (#31722541)
> If you convince everyone who would give someone a job that it's not worth the hassle to hire the super racist dude, that's hardly "avoiding democracy".

If you put in active effort to lobby businesses (I mainly care about larger businesses like google & al. here) to not employ people of certain opinions, then that's definitely punitive action rather than personal consequence. And as I said: specifically punishing people for holding certain opinions, whether it is done through the state or not, is antithetical to freedom of opinion and expression.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by mlyle on Monday June 13, 2022 @11:07AM (#31726636)
Conversely, having lots of super-racist-dudes in positions of power is antithetical to economic freedoms of the groups they're biased against. Paradox of tolerance, et al.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by endymi0n on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:07AM (#31691019)
And there we are again: Demonstrating that an absolutist take on free speech tends to destroy free speech itself in the long run.

„The paradox of tolerance states that if a society is tolerant without limit, its ability to be tolerant is eventually seized or destroyed by the intolerant. Karl Popper described it as the seemingly paradoxical idea that in order to maintain a tolerant society, the society must retain the right to be intolerant of intolerance.“

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by Dracophoenix on Friday June 10, 2022 @05:21AM (#31691816)
And what's ignored about the so-called paradox is the commonly omitted second half of Popper's quote:

"In this formulation, I do not imply, for instance, that we should always suppress the utterance of intolerant philosophies; as long as we can counter them by rational argument and keep them in check by public opinion, suppression would certainly be unwise. But we should claim the right to suppress them if necessary even by force; for it may easily turn out that they are not prepared to meet us on the level of rational argument, but begin by denouncing all argument; they may forbid their followers to listen to rational argument, because it is deceptive, and teach them to answer arguments by the use of their fists or pistols. We should therefore claim, in the name of tolerance, the right not to tolerate the intolerant."

This already fits well within the realm of free speech, free association, and the retributive justice system. The intolerant and the tolerant (both of which are in their common parlance subjective terms) are not required to associate with each other. Either party has the right to speak its mind. Only when force is involved would intolerance be justified. And even then, such intolerance should exist only in an objectively assessed proportion to the prior intolerant acts carried out and no more.

https://giggsboson.medium.com/stop-misusing-poppers-paradox-...

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by ls15 on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:24AM (#31691137)
I don't think it is a paradox. As soon as your practice of free speech limits other people's ability to practice free speech, you are not actually practicing free speech, but attacking people's freedom of speech.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by nhinck2 on Friday June 10, 2022 @04:20AM (#31691439)
I think you have failed to understand the paradox.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by ls15 on Friday June 10, 2022 @05:05AM (#31691730)
I just don't think it applies to free speech. And I don't interpret free speech as I can say whatever I want whenever I want, but I am free to express my opinion. This does not include freedom to attack other people's freedom.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by dorgo on Saturday June 11, 2022 @03:48AM (#31702740)
So, "I think other people should not be free" is not covered by free speech?
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by ls15 on Monday June 13, 2022 @04:43AM (#31722806)
I don't think that such a statement should have any legal (or other) consequences. It would (kind of) translate to "I don't believe in freedom", but it would not directly attack someone's ability to practice free speech.

Context matters here, I think:

If I said "The president should not be allowed to say this", this would most likely not affect the president's freedom of speech.

If the president said "ls15 should not be allowed to say this", this may more likely affect my ability to express my opinions.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by femiagbabiaka on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:22AM (#31691126)
Right wing activists have been doing this kinda stuff wrt Israel on campuses for decades. I agree, this kind of intolerance should be stamped out. The question is: whose morals become law?
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by systemvoltage on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:25AM (#31691145)
If you're in the US:

https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/amendment-1/

> Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

Emphasis mine.

There is a beautiful expansion by Blackstone. It makes me proud of this place:

> The liberty of the press is indeed essential to the nature of a free state; but this consists in laying no previous restraints upon publications, and not in freedom from censure for criminal matter when published. Every freeman has an undoubted right to lay what sentiments he pleases before the public; to forbid this, is to destroy the freedom of the press: but if he publishes what is improper, mischievous, or illegal, he must take the consequences of his own temerity. To subject the press to the restrictive power of a licenser, as was formerly done, both before and since the Revolution, is to subject all freedom of sentiment to the prejudices of one man, and make him the arbitrary and infallible judge of all controverted points in learning, religion and government. But to punish as the law does at present any dangerous or offensive writings, which, when published, shall on a fair and impartial trial be adjudged of a pernicious tendency, is necessary for the preservation of peace and good order, of government and religion, the only solid foundations of civil liberty. Thus, the will of individuals is still left free: the abuse only of that free will is the object of legal punishment. Neither is any restraint hereby laid upon freedom of thought or inquiry; liberty of private sentiment is still left; the disseminating, or making public, of bad sentiments, destructive to the ends of society, is the crime which society corrects.

Citation: https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/amdt1-2-1/ALD...

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by claudiawerner on Friday June 10, 2022 @04:31AM (#31691515)
>...is to subject all freedom of sentiment to the prejudices of one man, and make him the arbitrary and infallible judge of all controverted points in learning, religion and government

This doesn't seem right. Firstly, we generally operate under the principle that laws are created by the populace, not "one man", the censor. That seems to contradict the idea that a control on freedom of speech would be up to the whims of one person, if the censor is restricted in his activities by the voting populace and the lawmakers they elect. Secondly, this type of restriction has precedent in several other important areas of life, such as food and drugs. While many people disagree with the FDA's decisions, very few people argue for its abolition in its role as a 'censor' of which products can be sold and in what quantities on the American market.

Of course, the usual retort would be "I trust the state to regulate food and drugs more than I trust it to regulate speech", but to convince someone else of that point, you'd have to also provide evidence and reasoning that our hypothetical censor cannot be trusted to censor according to the law that the citizens vote for via their representatives. Another retort would be "Free speech is more important than food and drug availability", but that statement implicitly admits there's an issue with any food regulation, it's just not as important as speech, which leads to the question of why so few free speech absolutists care about abolishing the FDA.

I haven't really seen any convincing argument for a slippery slope when it comes to regulation of speech, nor any reasoned argument on why there ought to be an absolute constitutional protection on speech. That said, I'm not personally in love with the idea of a censor, as I've seen that censors in other countries have practiced unjustified censorship - but that seems like a problem with the democratic process and oversight rather than the idea of a censor.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by femiagbabiaka on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:45AM (#31691254)
The Constitution is a great document. We no longer live in a world where the spirit of the document matters. It’s a shibboleth, a proxy for the actual political discourse. It’s referred to when there’s a need to call on a talisman, in service of whatever opinion one has. Ultimately meaningless. So the question stands. If one is to legislate morals, whose will win? This is the real question of the last 4 decades of American politics (at least).
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by RhysU on Friday June 10, 2022 @06:11AM (#31692085)
> the spirit of the document

What do you mean by this?

> It’s a shibboleth

It is known by all. What definition are you using for "shibboleth"?

> It’s referred to when there’s a need to call on a talisman...

There's not a need to refer to the rules in any game unless one participant thinks that the rules have been broken.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by femiagbabiaka on Friday June 10, 2022 @01:16PM (#31696926)
If the rules can be reinterpreted depending on the disposition of the player with more power at a given time, then there are no rules, it’s just a bog standard power game. The drift in disposition of the Supreme Court itself is plain proof of this.

And as for shibboleth:

> The term can also be used pejoratively, suggesting that the original meaning of a symbol has in effect been lost and that the symbol now serves merely to identify allegiance, being described as "nothing more than a shibboleth". In 1956, Nobel Prize-laureate economist Paul Samuelson applied the term "shibboleth" in works including Foundations of Economic Analysis to an idea for which "the means becomes the end, and the letter of the law takes precedence over the spirit."[14] Samuelson admitted that "shibboleth" is an imperfect term for this phenomenon.[15]

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shibboleth

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by the_biot on Friday June 10, 2022 @02:48PM (#31697965)
It's not a shibboleth when some considerable portion of the population, including judges, regard it as an inviolate document of absolute truth.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by femiagbabiaka on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:08PM (#31698199)
What? The interpretation of the document by the highest court in the land changes according to the political affiliation of whoever happens to be on the court at the time. The very fact that it has to be interpreted means subjectivity is there from the beginning.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by chillacy on Friday June 10, 2022 @09:28PM (#31701149)
The justices on the Supreme Court all have pretty different* interpetations of this absolute truth, so I do kind of get OP’s point.

* different enough that it matters to people who care about modern day politics

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by dvt on Friday June 10, 2022 @02:47AM (#31690863)
> absolutely should have rebuked those using their free speech in favor of human rights abuses

I have no love for communists (having been born in the Eastern Bloc), but that's not how free speech works. Either you're for it (and all the icky stuff that comes with it) or you're against it. There's no "splitting the difference" here. We've debated and litigated this since the Enlightenment (from J.S. Mill to Skokie, IL): if you start banning one type of speech, that's a train you won't be able to stop.

Popper's Paradox of Tolerance is highfalutin nonsense.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by godelski on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:08AM (#31691022)
I also want to bring Blackstone's Ratio[0] into the conversation. I think it resonates with engineers really well because it is essentially the legal version of failure design. You design failure into your programs, bridges, and whatever (does your safe fail with an open lock or closed?). Why? Because when the thing fails, we want it to fail in a specific way to do the least amount of harm. We all know how terrible bad error messages are and how hard they make our life. This is such a key principle to almost every subject that I'm not sure why it isn't discussed more or ingrained into our societal thinking (it was ingrained into many of our constitutions).

Blackstone's ratio is:

> It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer

This is failure design. The legal system will fail. So when it does, do you want a guilty person to be set free or an innocent person to be imprisoned. We, of course, want to minimize the failure, but we have to ask which mode of failure is preferable.

The same is true for speech here. Who decides what to censor? The people in charge change frequently and with opposing views. What is the threshold? Explicit or implicit speech? There are limits on speech in America but the limits are low because that was the mode of failure that was planned.

I think one thing to recognize though is that there's ways to stop speech we don't like without banning it[1]. You just have to be creative.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/nov/18/neo-nazis-tric...

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by sofixa on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:18AM (#31691094)
From 1:

> Neo-Nazis are attracted to the town because Hitler’s deputy Rudolf Hess was once buried there. Though his remains were exhumed in 2011 and his grave was destroyed, far-right extremists still flock to the town year after year

And that's why all those dead after Nuremberg were cremated and their ashes were spread in rivers and seas. Nobody wants neo-Nazis shrines.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by dvt on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:25AM (#31691143)
> Nobody wants neo-Nazis shrines.

Ironic, considering the Pyramids at Giza are literal monuments to slavery.

Free speech -- i.e. the free exchange of ideas, ergo the natural extension of freedom of thought -- is a fundamental and transcendental ideal, and it's a hill I've died on and gotten downvoted for plenty of times. Germany, Nazis, and the USA probably won't be around 200 millennia from now, but the ideal of free speech certainly will. We think too much of ourselves and of our times.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by kybernetikos on Friday June 10, 2022 @05:34AM (#31691888)
According to some things I've read, the latest view is that slave labor was not primarily used for building the Pyramid at Giza. Wikipedia suggests 'conscripted laborers' as the main workers.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by zen_1 on Friday June 10, 2022 @11:21AM (#31695409)
Have you tried moving the pyramids? Pretty difficult I hear :)

On a more serious note, when I went to see the pyramids, the guide pointed out several rows of nearby tombs for the laborers who built the things, talked about how they were free skilled laborers, and in fact treated quite well (for the time at least).

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by koonsolo on Friday June 10, 2022 @02:59AM (#31690944)
If they are residents, I agree there is nothing you can do about it.

But since they seem to be exchange students, you could say "We don't welcome people with such views here in our country", and just send them back to the country that is ruled by their beloved government.

Just because you have free speech doesn't mean you can't select foreigners based on their beliefs and values.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by godelski on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:11AM (#31691048)
When we're talking about fundamental rights, I don't think we should treat foreigners any different than citizens. That's cruel. Is that really the country we want to be? Humane only to our citizens? We say that the mark of a man is how he treats those he sees as lower than himself. I think the same applies to countries.

Now I'm not saying being a foreign national you should have "the right" to open a US bank account, buy a house, or even get a job. But if we're talking about what we call "basic human rights," then that's a different story.

Of course, Universities are different, but I think the point still stands.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by koonsolo on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:23AM (#31691132)
They didn't break the law, so you don't lock them up. In the end, they still have that fundamental right.

But if you act as an idiot abroad, you shouldn't be surprised when they send you back.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by glogla on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:01AM (#31690969)
Even if they are residents, you can absolutely be expelled from university for bullying, hate speech and other abuses.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by koonsolo on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:24AM (#31691140)
This could indeed be seen as bullying or discrimination.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by drran on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:24AM (#31691138)
You should watch this couse: http://justiceharvard.org/justicecourse/ .

Free humans are not free to kill or enslave. Free speech is not free to hate.

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by dvt on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:30AM (#31691170)
Seems like an Ethics 101 course, I have an undergraduate degree in philosophy. I am intimately familiar with arguments on both sides, and I think you should read some John Stuart Mill, specifically his seminal On Liberty[1] (maybe not as engaging as a YouTube video course, though).

Free speech absolutism is a pretty hardline position, but I think it's probably correct.

[1] https://www.econlib.org/library/Mill/mlLbty.html

Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by drran on Friday June 10, 2022 @04:21AM (#31691445)
I assume, your point is that US government doesn't represent Chinese immigrants, right? This is true. Why this is a problem and what solution to the problem you propose?
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by zaptrem on Friday June 10, 2022 @01:18PM (#31696945)
By rebuked I don't mean actual disciplinary consequences. Instead, the university should (verbally/textually) condemn speech in favor of human rights abuse.
Re:Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate by sofixa on Friday June 10, 2022 @03:15AM (#31691070)
Free speech isn't an absolute all or nothing. In fact, all countries that give the right of free speech, and the UN declaration of human rights, impose limits on it.

For instance, outright neo-Nazism is forbidden in most EU countries. Same goes for stoking racial or religious hatred, etc. Even in the US with their old constitution and "textualist" interpretations of it that really want to take it to the absolute, have restrictions on free speech (e.g. "obscenity", "speech that violates intellectual property law", etc.)

Absolute free speech is incompatible with a modern society of today. Maybe it isn't with somebody's utopia, but we're not there.

The paradox of tolerance, however, is real. You can see it in work the recent rise of mis and disinformation from far-right folks, Russia, etc. For instance in France there was a presidential candidate who was convicted of inciting racial hatred more than once, and wanted to deport all Muslims and migrants from France, of course with frightening stories about why that is necessary to save France from the Muslims/Blacks/Arabs/Jews/whatever.