I would normally agree with this viewpoint, but there are things which have an objective quality of being immoral. Supporting the persecution of a group of people because of their ethnicity (or whichever other criteria) is such a thing. Please tell me how I'm wrong about that.
Saddam is a bad guy with WMD - let's get rid of him with shock&awe. Oops, we lied to the world and caused 200k deaths, but we are really moral!
Gaddafi is a bad guy who's oppressing the Arab Spring revolution (and threatening the USD). Let's get him with air-strikes and 'freedom-fighters'. Oops Libya fell-apart from a state that had guaranteed healthcare and education to a mess of conflicting factions and a multi-million casualty count. But hey - we are the good guys doing war for 'morality' and freedom. "We came, we saw, he died!"- Hillary Clinton.
Assad is a bad guy who's killing rebels (and siding with bad Russia). Let's get rid of him by giving his opponents (Obama's moderate rebels) infinite ammo, arms and armour. So what if they chained and raped women, united and transmogrified into the ISIS and invaded Iraq - we get another opportunity to bomb the bad guys!
All these 'moral American arguments' are responsible for multi-million deaths and casualties in the world - but doing it for morality makes it OK.
It starts with your campus culture, then those same folks become members of the US state department and want to change the world by through cancelling nation states or enacting sanctions that cause economic collapse and famine.
Persecuting a group of people for various criteria is unethical, immoral, evil, whatever you want to call it. I also claim that it is objectively so, and I would like you to argue in good faith how I am wrong about these two facts, instead of - like you accused grand-parent - moving the goal posts.
It is easy to interrupt you argument as semantics, because you can remove 'objectively' from mariusor's statement and the intended meaning does not seem to change much:
'I am arguing that someone that supports an immoral act is immoral and even though they might be free to espouse that point of view, any private individual or organization is equally free in shunning them.'
The main point of the statement does not seem to revolve around or or depend on 'objectively', so your argument can come off as arguing over an irreverent detail, which is one definition arguing over semantics.
>> You decide the truth value of something and based on that you further decide that a topic is off limits
> I would normally agree with this viewpoint, but there are things which have an objective quality of being immoral. Supporting the persecution of a group of people because of their ethnicity (or whichever other criteria) is such a thing. Please tell me how I'm wrong about that.
> Supporting the persecution of a group of people because of their ethnicity (or whichever other criteria) is such a thing. Please tell me how I'm wrong about that.
To reword a little bit, it is immoral to persecute(or support the act) a group for arbitrary and trivial detail(s).
So if you agree with that then you and mariusor would have some common ground and could build from there.
mariusor generalized their argument, tried to separate his argument form any specific group, with:
> I am arguing that someone that supports an objectively immoral act is objectively immoral and even though they might be free to espouse that point of view, any private individual or organization is equally free in shunning them.
After common ground is found the next step is to apply the shared understanding or philosophy to the specifics of the issue at hand. This often allows both parties to separate themselves from their biases, at least some, and think more clearly.
The thought process that using various means to try to achieve human rights goals?
Oh well maybe you think the civil war was fought on a nice delightful afternoon between tea and cake, and folks shook hands after, slaves were freed and everyone went home, and the president recommend soldiers to go get some tan in the south for the photo op next year.
I expect someone to deck me for saying certain things.
Growing up in Texas we had a saying- 'Them's fightin' words.'
ie if someone said something out of bounds, they were headed for a scrap, or at least that wad a very real possibility.
Having said that I would still defend their right to talk shit.
edit- screw cancel culture though, that shit ruins lives over even perceived slights. I don't believe any adult hasn't said something stupid or asinine we regret now. The thought that can ruin a life or career is crazy. If you don't like what someone says don't listen. If they aren't inciting violence or something.
From a legal viewpoint, even if said speech meets the Chaplinsky definition of "fighting words", that does not exonerate or justify one man's violence against another. I have a hard time seeing that most would accept hitting a person as an acceptable response to what is perceived to be distasteful speech. Millions of people lambasted Will Smith not so long ago for doing just that.
Today's awareness of mental trauma and triggers is a good thing, but it blurs the line a bit between physical and verbal attacks. Personally, I strongly believe that words should be treated fundamentally differently than physical violence. Sticks and stones, etc.
That said, if you're the one hurling insults, you're intentionally trying to evoke an emotional response, and you should not be surprised if the person you're insulting responds emotionally and violently.
For the record I'm very against what will smith did (posters above mentioned it), but I'd have felt differently if it hadn't been a comedian telling jokes, but say someone got in will's face and called him the N word with malice. I think it'd be perfectly reasonable to knock someone out over that. If the other person knows this is a good possibility, they may only use those words if they mean them enoughto accept the consequences.
I'm not saying my way is right, I'm just saying how it was growing up, and how that's shaped me.
In another thread I mentioned a friend of mine getting hurled insults at her abortion appointment. Had any of them been a man I'd have definitely gotten in some trouble that day. My belief is they have the right to say it, not protection from the consequences. But I'm also very against cancel culture. Am I weird for all of this? Alone in these beliefs? Totally wrong? Quite possibly, I know the world now confuses the shit out of me, and sometimes I feel like I am the only sane one for seeing some things (ie- trading our lives to the rich for a pittance, rules for thee but not for me, etc). Truly I could be very wrong, and if so I will accept that and try and change my views. I do try and live by the scientific method.
Wasn't that due to the fact that he acted in a way that looked as if he actually cared to defend his woman?
afaik it had nothing to do with violence but more against having personal honour or pride and thinking of one's woman as him alone and having a sacred relationship with her that anyone insulting / degrading her is directly insulting the man, and that idea triggers the feminists to the moon and back I guess.
"even if said speech meets the Chaplinsky definition of "fighting words", that does not exonerate or justify one man's violence against another." Then what is a man supposed to do? go to court over an insult? be rude and start a shitshow of exchanging insults? take it and move on? wait for the other party to initiate the fight? or what?
I am not a westerner by any means, just curious.
Nope. Some of the few who supported Will Smith have used that line of thought to justify his actions, but that's not why he was lambasted. The main reasons cited are that:
1) he attacked and subsequently threatened to harm Chris Rock, a comedian and fellow actor simply doing his job as a host and jester.
2) he diverted all the attention of Oscars away from the achievements of all the other winning actors with his petty slap
3) he behaved inconsistently as he himself had laughed at the GI Jane joke just before attacking Mr.Rock
I can't speak for the supposed feminists you've come across, but many actors, directors, and members of the public stateside expressed shock and disapproval towards the physical violence. Some like Jim Carey were angry at the audience for giving Mr. Smith a standing ovation while he gave a poorly reasoned justification for his actions during his award speech.
> Then what is a man supposed to do? go to court over an insult? be rude and start a shitshow of exchanging insults? take it and move on? wait for the other party to initiate the fight? or what? I am not a westerner by any means, just curious.
Well firstly, he himself wasn't insulted and his wife isn't a defenseless child. As Mr. Smith was not the object of derision, he, in legal parlance, would have no reasonable claim to sue (much less attack) Chris Rock.
As far as insults go, Mr. Smith was the only foul-mouthed participant during the altercation. He already started the shitshow while Mr. Rock had instead attempted to end it by placating him. It's plainly evident from his actions that Mr. Rock had no interest in initiating a fight.
If Mr. Smith truly had a problem with his wife's alopecia being made fun of, he could have done what any normal person did and Tweet about how bald jokes aren't funny or how they hurt people's feelings or meaningless drivel like that. If he was more serious, he could have put money in some sort of campaign for alopecia.
Getting shot for saying the wrong thing is also just another consequence. Is that also acceptable to you? I'm sure it's not, but that would also mean your whole point is BS.
There's a line when it comes to social consequences of speech and people like you are conveniently ignoring that fact to avoid having to explain why it should be drawn so cancelling falls on the acceptable side.
But the thing is, if you advocate for any personal consequences against the person expressing their opinion, then you're arguing directly against a human right.
> Getting shot for saying the wrong thing is also just another consequence. Is that also acceptable to you? I'm sure it's not, but that would also mean your whole point is BS.
OP never said any consequences were acceptable; we have laws against shooting people so clearly such a consequence is proscribed in civil society.
> But the thing is, if you advocate for any personal consequences against the person expressing their opinion, then you're arguing directly against a human right.
By that logic, if someone says something racist and then loses friends or a job because of it, that violates their human rights. But surely we cannot force people to associate with someone who says abhorrent things without in turn violating their rights.
My logic is that, in order to guarantee the right to freedom of expression, there needs to be a line. The moment the "consequences" of expressing an opinion are predominantly punitive is where it needs to stop.
So no, by my logic, you're totally allowed to not be friends with someone who says something racist. As for losing a job, in an ideal world where this person could just get another job, yes, that'd be acceptable. But when it turns into losing the right to have any job whatsoever, then no, that's definitely not okay either.
wesleywt seems to be against this too since removing a legal right like that would require government action and they are againts that as seen in:
> I am for both free speech and getting cancelled for it. In this way, standards acceptable to our society can be policed without interferance from the government.
It seems like you put cancelling on the acceptable side of the line when you say:
> So no, by my logic, you're totally allowed to not be friends with someone who says something racist. As for losing a job, in an ideal world where this person could just get another job, yes, that'd be acceptable.
I normally think of cancelling as individuals deciding who they want to associate with and any consequences that flow from that. Which seems to land on the acceptable side of the line you are drawing.
While government action would not be acceptable, which I agree with, but I would not call cancelling.
Yea but lets not forget the context entirely here; we're talking about a walkout at a university, and people are insinuating that there should be some form of punishment as a consequence.
You can construct a case where social consequences for an expression of opinion do happen and no human rights are infringed, but I'm not arguing that such cases can't exist, so you aren't really proving anything meaningful there.
My point is, to put it clearly: The idea that the right to either free speech or freedom of expression does not guarantee any form of protection from social consequences is completely incorrect.
> In this way, standards acceptable to our society can be policed without interferance from the government.
That's a cute way of spelling "mob rule". It sounds nice because it talks about avoiding "interference", but really, it's a way of avoiding democracy and due justice. If you can't convince the majority of society, then you take matters into your own hands. That's not a system I want to live in.
I think people are saying that:
- The university should repudiate their assertions with the university's words.
- The university should strongly seek to enforce its rules when there are harsher actions than a walkout, such as the vandalism coordinated by group chats.
> but really, it's a way of avoiding democracy and due justice. If you can't convince the majority of society, then you take matters into your own hands. That's not a system I want to live in.
If you convince everyone who would give someone a job that it's not worth the hassle to hire the super racist dude, that's hardly "avoiding democracy".
I mean, you seem to be arguing that the government should somehow force (someone?) to give the super racist person a job so they're not "cancelled."
If you put in active effort to lobby businesses (I mainly care about larger businesses like google & al. here) to not employ people of certain opinions, then that's definitely punitive action rather than personal consequence. And as I said: specifically punishing people for holding certain opinions, whether it is done through the state or not, is antithetical to freedom of opinion and expression.