Tying 2FA to hardware is for most of the common use cases a bad idea. Instead always use TOTP and keep the seed in a secure storage with multiple backups.
If on top of that you like to keep it on your phone to generate the code that way, fine. But at that point you can destroy the phone and it doesn't matter, you'll still have access.
> While I don't like passwords and understand their very real security limitations.
When used correctly, password are a fairly great solution with fewer limitations than competing solutions. By properly I mean generate yourself 128 bits from /dev/random, never reuse and store securely.
For me, I don't consider that to be true.
I have a Yubikey on my keyring, and a backup Yubikey in my safe.
Losing my keys is an extremely rare thing (I've never actually lost my keys, closest I've come in the last 30 years is temporarily misplacing them or locking them inside).
I'm happy enough to deal with losing my digital access (via 2FA) tea[orarily under the same sort of circumstances where I've lost my keys. I might need to call a locksmith to get inside my house/car if I've locked them inside, or possibly to get me inside so I can replace the locks (and get my backup Yubikey out of the safe).
When I travel for work, I at least try to make sure I can get into critical systems using TOTP (on my phone and backed up with cloud accessible seeds), to protect against losing th4e Yubikey while abroad. I don't usually bother doing too much of that when I'm on vacation travelling.
To me the critical difference would be that my house keys are single purpose and only serve at a single location. I lost/broke keys a few times in my life, and the only issue was to wait outside the house for a few hours.
I didn't need to authorize 3d secure transactions when paying for the hotel or a taxi, didn't need to authorize accessing my Gitlab account at work, nor validate that I'm really me in the flurry of 2FA services. Nowadays phones and computers are more akin to wallets, and I'm actually more in trouble when losing access to my phone than when losing my wallet.
The world really hasn't appropriately quantified our reliance on little black fondleslabs.
When dealing with hardware, hardware access tokens should be required. When dealing with software, software access tokens should be required.
That way, you never have hardware compromised by remote tokens, and you never lose access to your software because you lost some hardware.
E.g., hardware tokens to login to a laptop, but only a software token (password) to get on a flight.
Of course there are a lot of use-cases inbetween with varying needs (escrow boxes with digital locks, intelligence services who need to verify the identity of their agents when entering/exiting premises), but I posit those come with requirements outside of the "ordinary".
The issue is if you have a fire and both your keys are melted, you're f'ed.
If there were one more layer of abstraction where all N of my keys prove that I'm "me" (or proves that I'm some entity) and the "me"-ness is the principal that gains access, that would be nice, but that's directly at odds with not wanting to rely on some third party identity/authentication provider.
Authentication is hard.
For some reason, this use case was not considered for Webauthn.
What is the life of a yubikey? Do they degrade over time horizons?
The reason I ask is that if you have a backup that you never hope to use it's likely to be accessed only very rarely - which makes me kind of wonder what if your primary yubikey fails in 15 years due to natural wear/tear/degradation due to the passage of time and your backup has succumbed to the same problem due to being just as old?
I don't think it's an issue in practice, certainly not for someone using them as they were intended, even heavily, but in theory a JavaCard implementation (like most of the smart card ecosystem, Yubikeys are still JC devices as far as I know) could "wear out" from use because of the way they work internally[1].
I've never personally seen that happen, and all of my Yubikeys still work, even the ones I bought over 10 years ago which were used far more heavily (20-30 ssh/gpg/piv operations per hour, every day, for years) than most people would use a FIDO key.
I've only managed to break other manufacturers smart cards by severely misusing them (as a USB-connected Linux HWRNG, I doubt the RNG command was designed to be called every few seconds for years).
[1] The JavaCard standard requires certain (all? I can't remember, it's been a while) objects in applet code to be written to persistent storage (meaning flash/eeprom), which has endurance limits. In practice they're not expected to be treated as permanent storage devices, if a card fails it's supposed to be replaced with another, revoke the old key pairs, register the new ones, etc.
I've carried one in my pocket for ~10 years without a problem, now I want to replace it because it's too old to support ed25519. That's likely a fraction of its useful hardware life.
Not that I could see over about 4 years. I've been using one YubiKey (USB-A) for over four years now and a second one (USB-C) for over two. Each has been carried with my keys for at least two years.
But the right approach anyway is to use this excellent tutorial: https://github.com/drduh/YubiKey-Guide and generate your keys yourself, storing a backup in a secure location. This is what I do — so even if my keys get completely destroyed, it will be possible to recreate them from backup.
A public/private key alone would have a similar issue, but the browser for FIDO keys gives the domain it's actually talking to. The domain is authenticated with TLS or the browser on an uncompromised machine won't send that domain over. The device only signs the challenge with the private key generated for that specific domain.
Anyway, the user would likely still click the link in the email since they are trying to log in.
Sure, for devices that need to authenticate themselves it is a decent or maybe the best solution. For me as a user? I am not convinced. It cannot compete with passwords.
TOTP can be phished or man-in-the-middle'd and isn't as secure.
OTP is way less convenient than fido keys, so it's both convenience and security. The only downside is the cost, and the effort required for registering multiple keys which is easily compensated for by the ease of use during authentication than OTP.
The decryption keys for that data are only stored on your iDevices. It's E2EE after all. So while you can access your Apple account via the SMS 2FA backup, you won't be able access your actual iCloud Keychain data/passkeys without some sort of access to your iDevices. (it might be sufficient if they're online somewhere and you have their login credentials?)
A bit confusing, but if it really is E2EE, then you can see why SMS alone wouldn't be enough to recover your Passkeys.
https://support.apple.com/guide/security/secure-icloud-keych...
I hope they'll go away from this, or at least give the option. I won't use their password/key storage until they do. 2FA is only as good as the weakest link, and SMS is the weakest possibility.
They don't offer a standard like TOTP, so SMS is the only option.
In this case, it's just that one of the factors has a weak backup option.
This all seems very messy when bad things happen.
I think you still need to know your password, but that’s pretty reasonable.
They also added a similar feature to allow you to get into a loved one’s account/phone after their death if they set it up.
That doesn't solve it for me. None of my trusted contacts has an up-to-date Apple device.
I agree the inability to remove SIM as backup 2FA method is troubling. I would sign in blood any liabilities to be able to remove SIM as a backup auth.
I don't like to have my key chain in the cloud at all. Loss or lack of access is far more likely this way. I already hate that services profile my device or location.
When will this happen? How will it happen?
Websites/services just make this way too difficult. Banks will host official services (that require login) on domains like www2.citionline.com with no way to know whether it's legit or not.
Apple has a marketing site at offers.appletvapp.apple which leads to prompts to sign up - how is any normal person supposed to understand this is legit? That domain is virtually indistinguishable from some phishing site at apple-iphone-offers.online
Apple don’t know your unlock passcode, so they can’t do it for you, but this is designed to cover the “my house burnt down with all my devices inside” type of scenario, or your own “I no longer have access to a device”.
As per the Apple FAQ[1]:
"you can get a code sent to your trusted phone number via text message or an automated phone call instead. Click Didn't Get a Code on the sign-in screen and choose to send a code to your trusted phone number. "
I'm afraid I don't follow.
I don't know what you're talking about, but I thought I was talking about an the manner in which Apple provides an alternative to Apple hardware 2FA.
i.e. "normally / if available", Apple will do 2FA on your account by virtue of you being already logged in on another device. HOWEVER if that device does not exist (or you only own one Apple device), then as per my FAQ link, Apple DO provide an alternative mechanism that DOES NOT rely on the existence of a secondary Apple device.
This methodology is no different to any other 2FA alternative mechanism (e.g. "backup keys" or other websites/services that also use phone/SMS as backup, e.g. Microsoft Authenticator).
Thus I believe I was correctly answering the OP's question AND I don't see any problem with the way Apple does it because in practical terms its no different to anyone else in terms of "backup" for 2FA.
Thus I've no idea what you're claiming to be "fake", and I'm not sure if I want to be drawn into that discussion because it sure sounds like Apple bashing that is not factually supported.
I've heard this approach of cloud-based second-factor auth keys called "1.5FA". It's probably enough for most people, most of the time.
That said, in the case of a broken phone and away from your computer, you'd still need either a second device that's already logged into your vault or a backup recovery code. That's a good thing for all of us to keep in mind the next time we're traveling.
I see that many people are slowly moving this direction and just can't fathom why do they fall for this corporate trap.
Do you consider a U2F key a device?
And it's not exactly 2. It's n+1, where n is the number of 2FA physical factors you expect to lose/break. If you expect to lose/break 0, then you need 1. If you expect to lose/break 5, then you need 6.
This is always my issue with 2FA or passwordless auth. You're forced to have 2 devices and are kind of screwed if you don't hvae two on you.
I was on a trip and broke my iPhone. It had my plane tickets on it to get home. I was able to get a replacement from Apple, they just gave it to me and sent me on my way. When I turned it on it wanted me to authenticate with one of my other Apple devices. By dumb luck I happened to have my iPad with me. If I didn't have that, I'm not sure what I would have done.
A co-worker told me to move all my 2FA to Authy as a means to avoid locking 2FA to hardware, but I haven't sufficently looked into it yet.
While I don't like passwords and understand their very real security limitations. I'm also not a fan of my phone becoming my identity.