News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by nicoburns on Sunday June 05, 2022 @10:59AM (#31631551)
I feel like it’s not at all unexpected that the Elizabeth Line is fantastic (although this is probably a little over exuberant by British standards of praise). Over budget but well implemented seems to have been the pattern for public infrastructure projects in the UK for some time now.
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by nbevans on Sunday June 05, 2022 @11:29AM (#31631852)
Indeed - the expectations were very high for Crossrail before and during development. All that has happened is they have delivered the product exactly as described, albeit 4 years later and over budget.

It should be noted that 4 years ago the BBC were running documentaries about how successful the Crossrail project had been after the tunnels were finished and most of the stations were almost done. It seems that nobody expected the software and signalling to take an additional 4 years of time. Somebody somewhere really messed up that part of the project. Everything else - the main civil engineering project - did go extremely smoothly and was even ahead of schedule at times.

Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by trebligdivad on Sunday June 05, 2022 @11:47AM (#31632036)
It didn't help that about 4 years ago, just before it was due, they were declaring it was going to be one of the few projects that was going to be delivered on time and under budget, and only caved at the last minute.
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by basisword on Sunday June 05, 2022 @11:44AM (#31632005)
It’s not like software engineers to underestimate how long something will take :)
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by CraigJPerry on Sunday June 05, 2022 @12:05PM (#31632188)
How do we fix it though? I empathise with the developers involved - there’s an inclination to look at what they had to do as just engineer some software to manage some signals, some diagnostics and some trains. And to some extent that’s true but it overlooks the other part of their process which is more akin to painting a great artwork - when will you be done with that?

I frequently see one answer fail - we just need to plan it more thoroughly, don’t just estimate, go through exactly what you’ll need, identify dependencies now not during coding. These efforts always fall for the same reason, when it comes time to implement, the plan is hopelessly out of date, incomplete and just plain naïve.

It’s easy to deliver software on time up to around 10kLOC (i.e. single developer short project). Beyond that, the variables cascade and avalanche exponentially. The problem with this is all the interesting problems need >1dev and certainly more than 10kLoc!

On balance I’m more persuaded by XP than by Royce but honestly i don’t think either approach makes or breaks, both can work well.

Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by nbevans on Monday June 06, 2022 @06:01AM (#31638692)
It was a highly complex integration of 3 different railway signalling protocols. These are safety critical systems that need to be "proven" to be safe through extensive simulation tests and real-world testing. The Crossrail/Siemens team that worked on this integration split the project up into 4 parts. 3 parts for each signalling system. And then the final part to allow transitioning a train between each signalling system in a seamless way. They were testing the trains on the western, central and eastern parts of the line for years as a way of gaining confidence in their work. It has been reported that this is the first time anywhere in the world that a railway has been created to support multiple signalling systems and be able to transition seamlessly between them during service.
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by basisword on Sunday June 05, 2022 @12:12PM (#31632251)
I disagree with the artwork analogy. I think it’s quite easy to decide when a software project is “done” if you set the requirements in detail at the beginning.

I think the issue plaguing estimation of projects is that a lot of software development involves running into problems and trying to solve them. Sometimes figuring out solutions to these issues is difficult and solutions appear as if by magic (in this was the art analogy makes sense in terms of inspiration). I’m not sure how we can ever estimate large projects accurately while we often need these moments of inspiration in order to solve problems.

Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by CraigJPerry on Sunday June 05, 2022 @01:28PM (#31633027)
>> if you set the requirements in detail at the beginning

How do you do that though? If we’re only talking about nailing down requirements (so lets ignore the problem of dependencies for now), then a 300 page BRD buys you enough spec to gainfully employ 4 devs for maybe a month-ish? I’m going off fin reg style work, i have no idea how that might translate to civil engineering so my numbers might be well off?

The BRD wasn’t free to produce, it contains 3-9 errors (assuming human rate of error is 1 to 3 in 100), and it’s being updated to v2 as you’re working.

How is this getting us all to the overall goal with predictable timing?

Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by trebligdivad on Sunday June 05, 2022 @12:44PM (#31632604)
Oh I bet plenty of engineers knew the estimates weren't right. I've seen cases where people don't point this out to management because they expect if they do management would just put htem under more pressure rather than getting the timeline right.
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by solar-ice on Sunday June 05, 2022 @01:39PM (#31633142)
My understanding is that the train software got built, more-or-less, according to the spec given, in a synthetic environment.

The problem is that in real-world testing, conditions around the changeover points produced behaviour that was not addressed by the spec. It turns out that dealing with radio-based systems in the middle of a busy rail network in the middle of a city is really hard. Many of the problems were caused by radio interference in the area. It's definitely the sort of problem practically nobody on this forum works on.

Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by wolverine876 on Sunday June 05, 2022 @05:34PM (#31635042)
> It seems that nobody expected the software and signalling to take an additional 4 years of time. Somebody somewhere really messed up that part of the project. Everything else - the main civil engineering project - did go extremely smoothly and was even ahead of schedule at times.

I understand software and signaling took extra time, but those drove the costs too? Compared to the rest, they don't seem expensive.

Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by mrec on Sunday June 05, 2022 @12:35PM (#31632488)
> fantastic [...] is probably a little over exuberant by British standards of praise

Indeed. "Quite good" is usually considered the absolute pinnacle of fawning adulation.

Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by yetanotherloser on Sunday June 05, 2022 @01:54PM (#31633291)
Please. "Not bad at all, really."
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by nprateem on Sunday June 05, 2022 @01:52PM (#31633279)
Just one notch above the almost exceptional "not bad"
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by not2b on Sunday June 05, 2022 @04:19PM (#31634476)
If a Brit says that my presentation was "quite good", I know I am in trouble.
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by OJFord on Monday June 06, 2022 @12:34AM (#31637272)
My favourite thing (as a Brit) about 'quite' or rather trying to explain it, is 'quite good' vs. 'really quite good'.

(The former can vary with tone sure, but typically I think quite slating, as parent describes. Somehow saying it's 'really' so though turns it around completely, making it impressive.)

Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by richij on Monday June 06, 2022 @12:45PM (#31642754)
Yes! British English really is a tone language.
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by cormullion on Monday June 06, 2022 @09:18AM (#31640070)
not too shabby
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by kitd on Sunday June 05, 2022 @02:16PM (#31633482)
"Over budget" gets forgotten about in a few years. "Well implemented" lasts its lifetime.
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by Naga on Sunday June 05, 2022 @12:17PM (#31632308)
I’d take that. The Canadian pattern is over budget poorly implemented.
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by samwillis on Sunday June 05, 2022 @11:06AM (#31631630)
I think your right, however they don’t always pick the right projects to do. HS2 for example isn’t exactly thought of as the right place to spend a few 10s billion pounds.
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by Arbortheus on Sunday June 05, 2022 @11:34AM (#31631917)
Perhaps unpopular opinion but I think HS2 is the correct option. Firstly, more capacity is needed on the rail network and this is a key arterial route that is already running at/over capacity. Secondly, it'll allow freight to be added to the existing slower lines, which is key for decarbonisation. Finally, if you're going to build new railway lines, you might as well build something that isn't immediately obsolete. The alternative is to build something that is fast-but-not-quite-high-speed, which means not using what is essentially industry standard for new rail lines. It would be a bizarre choice.
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by scrlk on Sunday June 05, 2022 @11:46AM (#31632018)
>Firstly, more capacity is needed on the rail network and this is a key arterial route that is already running at/over capacity.

I always found it bizarre that most of the press around HS2 never really mentions the capacity issues of the West Coast Main Line.

Most people will ask "why spend £100 bn to shave 30 mins off London - Birmingham, can't you just upgrade the existing lines?", which IMO is a fair question to ask. They need to do a better job of explaining why it's not practical to upgrade the WCML & why building a new line is the better long term solution.

Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by chrisseaton on Sunday June 05, 2022 @11:54AM (#31632094)
I use the WCML a lot and it's pretty rickety. Parts of it are like a rollercoaster. I'm not sure you can go any faster on it and I guess it can't be straightened and levelled as (like most of the UK) the terrain is congested.
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by scrlk on Sunday June 05, 2022 @12:12PM (#31632253)
There were plans under British Rail [0] and Railtrack [1] to push running above 125 mph via realignments & resignalling. Virgin Trains proposed running at 135 mph via the Tilt Authorisation and Speed Supervision system [2].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/InterCity_250#Project_scope

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Coast_Main_Line#Modernist...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Coast_Main_Line#Increased...

Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by tialaramex on Sunday June 05, 2022 @01:19PM (#31632934)
A major problem you run into is that you really want in-cab signalling at these speeds and you might well do speed signalling when you take a big upgrade like that. A lineside position lamp arrangement which indicates "Caution: The next signal is at: Caution: The next signal is at: Caution: The next signal is at: DANGER" blurring past at 140mph is too much for humans to reliably appreciate their import and react to it in an efficient fashion.

Trains on HS1 have TVM or equivalent, in-cab signalling. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transmission_Voie-Machine#Cab_... - you can see at a glance that the computer says you're going 269kph, the limit here is still 270kph, but the signals indicate the limit ahead will be 220kph so you should be braking.

Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by vinay427 on Sunday June 05, 2022 @12:08PM (#31632226)
Out of curiosity, which parts are these? I’ve used it up to Preston several times and didn’t notice much out of the ordinary (compared to trains in Switzerland, for instance).
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by chrisseaton on Sunday June 05, 2022 @12:13PM (#31632267)
There's definitely twenty minutes south of Crewe where I have to put my laptop away or I'll feel sick, and can't have a full cup of tea on the table without a lid.
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by was_a_dev on Sunday June 05, 2022 @11:54AM (#31632097)
The inevitable happened with HS2. They scraped it heading further north. Now it is just a project to get to London quicker
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by chrisseaton on Sunday June 05, 2022 @12:06PM (#31632201)
I live in the North and I'd love to be able to get across the Pennines more quickly, and to be able to get to places like Leeds and Newcastle quickly.

But being realistic.... 90% of business, social, and civic activity is in London so that's where I need to get quickly.

Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by brigandish on Sunday June 05, 2022 @12:15PM (#31632282)
That's at least partly because London already has the best transport infrastructure. If other places had better infrastructure then they should attract more business and more of your attention.
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by jfk13 on Sunday June 05, 2022 @12:13PM (#31632257)
> 90% of business, social, and civic activity is in London

And that imbalance is what we really should be trying to fix. Will HS2 make any difference? I don't know...

[edit to add: speaking as one who lives less than 60 miles from central London.]

Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by M2Ys4U on Monday June 06, 2022 @06:52AM (#31638917)
They scrapped half of it going North - the Western leg to Manchester is still happening (although the government is refusing to allow for a proper station configuration at Manchester Piccadilly...)
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by 7952 on Sunday June 05, 2022 @12:35PM (#31632500)
Or the slow speeds on some of the other "mainlines" into London. Bournemouth is less than 100 miles and takes 2hrs+.
Re:Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line by pharmakom on Sunday June 05, 2022 @11:42AM (#31631990)
I support HS2 but as an alternative to more road building. Unfortunately the government seems to have chosen both!