News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google cancelled a talk on caste bias by rob74 on Thursday June 02, 2022 @08:57AM (#31594241)
> Soundararajan appealed directly to Google CEO Sundar Pichai, who comes from an upper-caste family in India, to allow her presentation to go forward. But the talk was canceled, leading some employees to conclude that Google was willfully ignoring caste bias.

> Pichai, the CEO, “is Indian and he is Brahmin and he grew up in Tamil Nadu. There is no way you grow up in Tamil Nadu and not know about caste because of how caste politics shaped the conversation,” Soundararajan told The Post. “If he can make passionate statements about Google’s [diversity equity and inclusion] commitments in the wake of George Floyd, he absolutely should be making those same commitments to the context he comes from where he is someone of privilege.”

Sounds like Mr. Pichai has some explaining to do...

Re:Google cancelled a talk on caste bias by hirako2000 on Thursday June 02, 2022 @09:26AM (#31594578)
It's rather you to work on the explaining there. Pichai isn't claiming to be unaware of how caste politics may work. I think it's not only OK but desirable for companies to stop ruining the workplace with societal politics. There is a law and public debates for castes and how to address the (no doubt existing even outside India) problem.

Prompting an employee of a tech company, even its CEO, reminding the audience of its ethnical background is what i find suspect.

Re:Google cancelled a talk on caste bias by bgdam on Thursday June 02, 2022 @10:17AM (#31595200)
> There is a law and public debates for castes and how to address the (no doubt existing even outside India) problem.

That's kinda part of the problem. In India there are laws dealing with caste based oppression and discrimination (how well they are enforced is another story). But in most other countries such laws do not exist. And caste-based discrimination is exceptionally easily and silently accomplished because for a vast majority of Indians, your last name gives away your caste.

Re:Google cancelled a talk on caste bias by hirako2000 on Friday June 03, 2022 @02:49AM (#31605045)
That's right, in the West at wide they roll up to anti discrimination laws, agreed they probably don't tackle the very specific problem castes pose, I would much rather have anti discrimination encompass them in a more generic form to tackle all forms of discrimination based on "classes" than making it an indian caste problem. I fail to see how the unambiguous distinction in names makes the problem solving any easier, it isn't only about identification, and if that identification is used to implement quotas or whatnot, since that's how companies then read the law, it will 1/ create a new problem, 2/ suddenly see a lot of people change their name for "business" purposes.
Re:Google cancelled a talk on caste bias by bgdam on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:33AM (#31606545)
While I am in favor of generic anti-discrimination laws, I don't think they can be generic and target caste based discrimination. Let me give you an example:

A hiring manager, gets two resumes. Both are equally qualified. He glances at one, see's the last name and decides on the spot to not hire him. Because of caste.

If he's slightly clever, he'll atleast schedule an initial call with the candidate before inventing a reason to reject him. How does a generic anti-discrimination law identify this as an instance of caste-based discrimination?

Re:Google cancelled a talk on caste bias by hirako2000 on Friday June 03, 2022 @08:24AM (#31607293)
Exactly as it would "just" solve the use case without getting into the castes system specific worry. E.g: Candidate selection should be based on the skillset and fitness of individuals for the scope of work/description, without discrimination attriuted to personal affiliation, ethnicity, religion, gender or sexual orientation, difference, + "group identity", . The employer would thus commit infringement if when faced with two somewhat equals in fitness candidates he folds some individual based on gender or whatever else that falls into personal, group identity factor or affiliation to a certain group. I think it covers the caste system issue we see at the workplace without having to talk about castes in the legislation, and the benefit is that it allows the text to cover other group identifications.

Btw we have other avenues, anti discrimination is one that covers shutting down labelled candidates. Nepotism is described as favoring relatives or friends, just add "or group identified with" to it and boom that covers the caste system issue (and beyond). I'm no legalist so of course I'm not drafting a clear definition of group identity but you get the idea, i hope. I suspect we are stuck on this because on some side we have identity politics and quotas advocates wanting the legislation to accommodate their wishes, hence forbidding group identified favoritism in the law. This avenue is being at best ignored as a potential simple solution, at worst battled against with teeth and nails for other unrelated motives.

Re:Google cancelled a talk on caste bias by heretogetout on Thursday June 02, 2022 @09:58AM (#31594951)
I don't think workplaces should operate outside of and without influence from society. They're just a group of people in a building (metaphorical or otherwise).
Re:Google cancelled a talk on caste bias by thebean11 on Thursday June 02, 2022 @05:26PM (#31600711)
> stop ruining the workplace with societal politics

Isn't the failure to do so the subject of the talk?

Re:Google cancelled a talk on caste bias by jcranberry on Thursday June 02, 2022 @10:52AM (#31595610)
>According to Gupta’s letter and Soundararajan, the decision to cancel the talk came from Gupta’s boss, Cathy Edwards, a vice president of engineering, who had no experience or expertise in caste.

Truly puzzling decision.

Re:Google cancelled a talk on caste bias by dekhn on Thursday June 02, 2022 @11:24AM (#31596029)
Nothing abot this is puzzling. beneath the surface of Google's attempts to "look happy", there is a huge amount of resentment between individuals, and between individuals and leadership. Even when I joined in 2007 it was noticeable, but by the time I left (the second time) in 2019, it was painfully obvious.

Sundar's goal has been to smooth over this resentment and prevent events that would exacerbate it. That often occurs by cancelling a venue for discussion/healing. GOogle sort of evolved itself into a state of weaponized progressivism, and is now realizing just how unrealistic its naive view of using technology to transform the world for good was, and how it needs to turn into everything that it said it wasn't to continue to succeed in the face of more determined competitors.

Re:Google cancelled a talk on caste bias by devnull3 on Thursday June 02, 2022 @09:23AM (#31594545)
I doubt it. In fact attrocities on brahmins is rarely discussed [1]. Infact his state TamilNadu there is a strong anti-brahminism sentiment in political sphere. This is one of the reason why lot of upper-caste men/women go outside India.

[1] https://www.firstpost.com/opinion/the-brahmin-files-why-atro...

Re:Google cancelled a talk on caste bias by ethanbond on Thursday June 02, 2022 @05:36PM (#31600809)
Doesn’t excuse any discriminatory behavior here in the States. Or, frankly, even in India.
Re:Google cancelled a talk on caste bias by devnull3 on Thursday June 02, 2022 @09:00PM (#31602851)
I never said that. Just because Sundar is of certain caste does not mean he has explaining to do.

It's like holding any white British person to explain all the bad things British did in their colonies.

Re:Google cancelled a talk on caste bias by thunkshift1 on Thursday June 02, 2022 @11:12PM (#31603819)
Don’t assume guilt based on association or membership to a class. Thats a form of discrimination too. Pichai is brahmin so he has some explanation to do—> no he doesnt. Its like asking any white man to explain why us cops are killing black folks.
Re:Google cancelled a talk on caste bias by newsclues on Thursday June 02, 2022 @09:15AM (#31594449)
He doesn’t have explaining to do because he holds the power and is choosing not to.