News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by colechristensen on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @01:10PM (#31584924)
Everyone on HN who loves urban density should read things like this. Quality of life cooped up in a dense urban setting, especially with a family, is awful. There's so much space in the world, we don't need to pack ourselves in tiny urban centers near "tech hubs" at all.
Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by tomtheelder on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @01:43PM (#31585376)
This comment makes no sense. Folks who love urban density... love urban density. Why would reading a comment from someone who feels differently be important to us? I totally respect the parent comments opinion, but their lived experience differs from mine entirely.

> Quality of life cooped up in a dense urban setting, especially with a family, is awful.

This is unbelievably subjective, and you simply cannot state this as if it's a fact. I have lived in rural, suburban, and dense urban settings, and my quality of life was by far, by far, the highest in the city. Almost every aspect of my life was improved when I moved to a dense urban center.

Urban centers are not simply desirable because of jobs! Many of us simply prefer the lifestyle they afford!

Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by fatnoah on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @05:07PM (#31588145)
>I have lived in rural, suburban, and dense urban settings, and my quality of life was by far, by far, the highest in the city. Almost every aspect of my life was improved when I moved to a dense urban center.

Same here, and the other families that lived in the dense urban center with us would agree. In fact, when we were thinking of moving from suburb back to city, we literally stopped families at parks in the city and asked them. Literally every one of the 10+ families we asked told us we should absolutely move!

Yes, we didn't have a driveway or big yard, but we did have a nearby park which became our yard, and most of our adventures didn't require a car, anyway. We'd simply walk out the door and go to one of the parks, restaurants, museums, etc. within a short walk. We'd bike or take the subway for longer distances. Without a yard or house to take care of, I had both weekend days available.

I could go on and on. My family and I found the energy of the city invigorating and I'm totally cool with the fact that others may not, or that going out and about all the time is not their idea of awesome.

Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by colechristensen on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @03:13PM (#31586615)
The people on HN want to push their preferences on everyone and change cities to appeal to their usually single-ish, 20s-ish lifestyle of appreciating a 600 sq ft apartment
Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by tomtheelder on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @05:10PM (#31588174)
Do they? Do you have examples? I really don't think that's something that actually happens on here.

Frequently you get people pointing out that highly dense areas require different approaches to planning and transportation, but that's hardly pushing some lifestyle on anyone who isn't interested in it.

Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by DragonStrength on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @03:24PM (#31586750)
Do they? When I was that age, I read all the time in tech-friendly press about how much I wanted those things, but I assure you I never did. It's always seemed like a narrative pushed by people who have just assumed the next generation will line up to spend even more money for less. I suspect if 25-35 year olds could reasonably afford 3 bedrooms in the Bay Area we wouldn't be having this issue at all, ignoring density of this area.

But don't make the mistake of conflating 700 sqft apts w/urban centers. On today's remote wages, an engineer can afford the kind of modest home in a walkable urban area in many parts of the US, but affording that on even NY and Bay Area Big Tech wages is looking out of grasp for that next generation. It certainly looks a lot riskier.

Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by wolverine876 on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @03:37PM (#31586894)
Could you provide some examples of that? Most of what I see is trying to impose the trend of the moment, that cities are bad.
Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by diob on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @03:24PM (#31586746)
I think it's more that folks wish we would build upwards more.
Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by kibwen on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @01:24PM (#31585128)
I grew up with one parent in the burbs and the other in the boonies, and today I live in a city and I'll never go back to anywhere that isn't eminently walkable. I don't value space, I value proximity to lots of people. I'm happy that WFH allows people who value the opposite to vacate the cities that make them miserable in order to free up room for people who crave density.
Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by criddell on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @02:18PM (#31585909)
For me, what I want has changed a lot over my life. In my 20's I craved density. I loved the energy and options of cities. 30 years later, I'm the opposite. I live in the suburbs in a house big enough to give me a home gym, workshop, office, etc... but if I had a self-driving car and could get great internet, I'd move way out of the city. I want a little more space and a lot less noise.
Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by kibwen on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @05:14PM (#31588217)
Regarding noise, I've told this story before on HN, but the loudest place I've lived was the aforementioned house in the boonies, where the noise from passing trucks and motorcycles at all hours of the night was intolerable. My place in the city is far quieter, ironic given that it's literally a hundred yards or so from a turnpike and a rail line (never once heard the train passing in all these years, somehow).

As for the gym, the workshop, the office, I'd personally rather share those with the community. As mentioned, I'm in the city because I enjoy being around people, which isn't to say that I want to work in an office (hell no), but I do want to work in public among people doing their own work (and who, unlike co-workers, won't be constantly pestering me with questions).

Which is to say, my riposte is that the older I get the more I realize that community is what I crave, and that I was dissatisfied with the community that I found in my rural and suburban lives: finding a community in the city is harder, because you actually have to try, but much more fulfilling IME.

Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by criddell on Thursday June 02, 2022 @08:36AM (#31594026)
Yeah, it's definitely going to be situational. I grew up in rural southwestern Ontario and it was very, very quiet. I moved to a city to go to university and at that time the extra noise didn't bother me (I definitely was responsible for my fair share of it), but I did miss being able to see the night sky.

If I'm honest, a big factor for me is probably related to my financials. When I was young, I was pretty poor and lived in shitty neighborhoods in low quality but high density buildings. Thirty years later, I live in a pretty great suburb in my own house with my best friend/wife, dog and my kids (who are home from university for the summer). The night sky here is decent, but I know it could be even better.

Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by wolverine876 on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @03:48PM (#31587039)
Many people follow the same pattern as they age. I think many in this discussion are attributing to WFH and other things what is a common outcome of just getting older.
Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by screye on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @09:11PM (#31590158)
> lot less noise.

Cities Aren't Loud: Cars Are Loud [1]

Having lived in many different types of cities, it is always the car-centric downtowns and suburban main-streets that are loudest. Well designed & walkable cities are actually pretty mild when it comes to noise.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CTV-wwszGw8

Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by screye on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @09:04PM (#31590116)
Both are the exact same problem.

Most of the US has outlawed the 'middle housing' [1], leaving us with massive crammed skyscraper concrete jungles or sprawling suburbia.

Cities in developed countries around the world do not have to made this trade-off between space and walkability. Apartments are sufficiently big for families, while having everything within arms reach.

If anything, public spaces allow for more amenities available for more people. Unless your definition of space is 'private' space (private gardens, private yards, private gyms), there is plenty of space in well planned cities.

Lastly, suburbs simply do not pay their fair share in taxes. [2] They are incredibly inefficient and deplete city resources such that the city goes bankrupt the second a recession hits. I would be fine with suburbs if that's what people want. But, pay your fair share in taxes, renounce any high ground on the climate change debate and for the love of God, stop making anything that isn't a suburb illegal to build. (looking at you Berkeley...and every other deep-blue liberal suburb)

[1] https://missingmiddlehousing.com/

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Nw6qyyrTeI

Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by angarg12 on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @08:44PM (#31589990)
But I do love urban density! I grew up and lived 90% of my life in big cities. Moving to a village was a big shift for me. I love the space but I also appreciate it's boring AF.

If I could choose I'd probably go for a house, not as big, within 1 hour trip to a big city. That way I could get the best balance for my lifestyle.

Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by countvonbalzac on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @01:54PM (#31585533)
Awful for you, but a lot of people love the walkability / bikeability of cities and the proximity to services, activities, and other people.
Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by lamontcg on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @04:26PM (#31587582)
This shouldn't really be an either-or.

People who want to and can work remotely should move to suburbs, dropping rents and housing costs in the dense urban centers.

Suburbs should also be redesigned with more neighborhood commercial so that they're less designed around driving for miles to massive clusters of big box stores.

It would also be interesting to have more decentralized density, so clusters of density out in present-day suburbia. That could provide a bit more population density to support the commercial real estate for the surrounding low density residential.

Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by wolverine876 on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @03:41PM (#31586946)
As others say, the density means you are walking distance - and otherwise public transit or bicycling distance - from all sorts of services, arts, etc. that aren't in the suburbs. I'll add that those services, arts, etc. include much that is far better than what is in the suburbs - better food, art, music, etc. etc. That doesn't appeal to everyone, of course, but if you care about it, then there is no substitute.

Look up a listing of music playing this weekend in NYC, for example. Look up arts and museums. etc.

Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by asdff on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @01:27PM (#31585169)
To be fair there is a lot more to do in urban centers. I felt cooped up in less dense places, that's why I moved away from there and into a denser place with no shortage of things to do throughout the year.
Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by legitster on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @02:08PM (#31585756)
I enjoy living in a big house in the country, but I also enjoyed city living. It's nice walking everywhere and not having to own a car!

I think the big kicker is that city living in the US is drastically overpriced.

Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by turtlebits on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @01:47PM (#31585448)
There are lots of suburban neighborhoods that will give short commutes. They just cost a bit more. I have a 7 minute commute, but live in a house with a yard - and walking distance to an Arboretum.
Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by Steltek on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @02:34PM (#31586158)
My kids have independence and freedom of movement long before they're even close to driving age. Something they can never have in the suburbs.
Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by goatcode on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @02:33PM (#31586138)
Disagree. Life in the country is horrible. Please don't come, stay in cities, everyone. You wouldn't like it here at all : >
Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by wffurr on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @01:44PM (#31585401)
"closer to family" seemed like a big part of the improvement here.
Re:Dreaded commute to the city is keeping offices mostly empty by angarg12 on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @08:46PM (#31590005)
We got a winner!

We moved to the countryside to be closer to my wife's family. My family lives in a big city in another country, so we could have moved there instead, if that didn't involve a massive pay cut.