News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by indymike on Sunday May 29, 2022 @12:03PM (#31550198)
Privacy regulations can make it very difficult for competitors to gain traction for incumbents, so there is active lobbying to get regulatory barriers to competition in play. At the same time, far too much money is being made to allow laws and regulations to kill revenues... so it gets complicated. The easy way is to just say you are all for privacy, and then oppose it at every turn.

Another issue is this: breaking some of these privacy laws both in force and proposed, is really quite easy to do - as easy as a misconfigured logger or a developer including the wrong field in a query.

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by cycomanic on Sunday May 29, 2022 @05:07PM (#31552877)
>Another issue is this: breaking some of these privacy laws both in force and proposed, is really quite easy to do - as easy as a misconfigured logger or a developer including the wrong field in a query.

So if I drive accidentally over the speed limit I should not get a ticket? That's a weird argument isn't it? Moreover, we are talking about companies with billions of revenue, they can afford to pay people to make sure things work. If you are worried about large incumbents using the laws as barriers (a weird argument, should we not protect people first, not companies?), just lobby for fines to be a fraction of revenue.

Moreover, the behavior of the big companies in Europe shows that they have and continue to intentionally skirt and break the rules as much as possible until they get hit with fines. I really have very little empathy with Google, Meta et al.

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by ouid on Sunday May 29, 2022 @06:32PM (#31553533)
You should not get a ticket for accidentally driving over the speed limit (unless you are driving over every plausible speed limit), but a corporation should. This is not an arbitrary distinction, and equivocating as you have hurts your argument.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by the_cramer on Monday May 30, 2022 @01:22AM (#31555714)
You should absolutely get a ticket for accidently driving over the speed limit, as the company should too. Its about safety and awareness. If you are not paying attention to the road signs and/or your cars speed, who knows what else you are not aware of. Maybe a child crossing the road in front of you.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by dwhit on Monday May 30, 2022 @11:41AM (#31560193)
Should you get a ticket for accidentally driving over the speed limit because your speedometer was broken? Should the company who made the speedometer get the ticket? What if the speedometer was broken due to a bug software the speedometer company bought? Should that company get the ticket?
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by hansvm on Monday May 30, 2022 @02:09PM (#31561827)
Not a lawyer, but I'm pretty sure the burden is on the consumer in the USA to have their speedometer calibrated appropriately (10% error in the few states I've checked), and not doing so violates additional laws. Details could get complicated if you had proof that you did your part (OTA updates, can they prove you drove by a speed sign and should have known the speedometer was broken, ...), but you might be able to argue your innocence and might have a civil claim against one or more parties who touched your car.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by thfuran on Sunday May 29, 2022 @12:37PM (#31550474)
Plenty of existing laws take intent into consideration so its not unreasonable to suppose that a log that happens to accidentally contain some information that it shouldn't before being destroyed and the bug patched would be quite legally distinct from a log containing the same information but has a business unit processing and profiting from it.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by xyzzyz on Sunday May 29, 2022 @02:24PM (#31551453)
It is not unreasonable, I agree. However, the privacy laws passed by government are mostly intended to play performative and punitive role, and actual interest of the people in balancing their privacy and usability concerns are tertiary at best. The politicians pass those laws to look good on one side, and to attack the companies on the other. User concerns are mostly ignored.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by K0SM0S on Monday May 30, 2022 @12:56AM (#31555610)
> User concerns are mostly ignored.

Indeed and I don't see how that changes _structurally_ when people "in the know" are always going to be a tiny minority — they say that about 3% of the population has the profile to work in tech, and I tend to agree anecdotally.

I feel it's comparable to the inception of medicine for instance, and the solution was auto-regulation of the field by itself through the application of a loud (public and transparent) set of deontological rules of practice ("Primum non nocere", etc).

Awareness of society about these issues re. privacy and information sanctity in a democracy will not come naturally, structurally as time goes by. Just like they don't really know how doctors make life-or-death decisions on the spot. Nevertheless, the right principles should eventually exist, be known, and abode to, by those who work in the field. It should be loud and clear that we all have ethics (rules, implementing guiding principles), and which exactly.

A deontology of information technology and its practice in relation to human beings is one big "TODO" of this century, and it should concern anyone even remotely skilled to understand the problem.

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by thfuran on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:17PM (#31551971)
>However, the privacy laws passed by government are mostly intended to play performative and punitive role

Yeah, that seems to pretty well describe most all legislature these days.

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by shadowgovt on Sunday May 29, 2022 @04:23PM (#31552553)
How much did Google get smacked for for collecting unencrypted packet data while they were building out their SSID-based localization improvements?
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by sneak on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:21PM (#31552012)
...and the national military surveillance operationalizing it.

This isn't just about revenue. People are assassinated by the US government without trial based on metadata.

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by scarface74 on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:04PM (#31551843)
So what are the chances that a judge cares about “intent” on site that doesn’t conform to their belief system?
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by thfuran on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:15PM (#31551951)
You're asking what the odds are that a judge will refrain from flagrant malfeasance. I'd imagine it's pretty high, though surely not 100%.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by scarface74 on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:19PM (#31551993)
You trust the legal system far more than I do.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by thfuran on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:52PM (#31552303)
So, what, we shouldn't attempt to have privacy protections because some corrupt judge might fine a company that shouldn't have been fined?
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by scarface74 on Sunday May 29, 2022 @04:02PM (#31552387)
We shouldn’t give the government more power for them to abuse…period.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by paulryanrogers on Sunday May 29, 2022 @05:24PM (#31553007)
Better defacto, unelected governments in the form of huge companies with armies of lobbyists and forced arbitration agreements.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by scarface74 on Sunday May 29, 2022 @05:59PM (#31553283)
Because of how both the electoral college works and gerrymandering, the elected officials don’t represent the majority.

Besides, private companies don’t have the force of law to force people to do anything.

Giving the government more power over your freedom is never the answer.

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by paulryanrogers on Sunday May 29, 2022 @06:04PM (#31553329)
> Besides, private companies don’t have the force of law to force people to do anything.

As more and more consolidation happens I'm not so sure this is still true. If all grocery stores become zero-human Amazon markets and their AI decides your long forgotten, hobby EC2 instance is past due then can you buy food?

Rent an apartment?

Fly on a plane?

Elections in the US need reformed, no doubt. And governments have a monopoly on legal violence. The answer isn't to keep handing the keys to the government over to whomever/whatever has the most money.

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by scarface74 on Sunday May 29, 2022 @06:34PM (#31553548)
Only 5% of all IT spend is on any cloud provider:

https://accelerationeconomy.com/cloud/amazon-shocker-ceo-jas...

The grocery store market is definitely not a monopoly

https://www.statista.com/statistics/818602/online-and-offlin...

And Whole Foods makes up less than 2%

There is definitely not a “tech monopoly” on renting an apartment. On the other hand, the government can and does take away peoples property through both imminent domain and civil forfeiture.

The government already controls who can fly and who can’t via “no fly lists”

https://www.aclu.org/issues/national-security/grounded-life-...

So no, I have no desire to give government more power.

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by thfuran on Sunday May 29, 2022 @05:47PM (#31553206)
Should we close down all air traffic control to make sure no air traffic controller ever screws up?
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by scarface74 on Sunday May 29, 2022 @05:59PM (#31553289)
Can air traffic controllers take away my freedom and my rights?
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by thfuran on Sunday May 29, 2022 @07:00PM (#31553725)
I don't understand. You want rights but don't want the government to have any power to enforce them? What should happen when a company does something that you feel violates your rights?
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by scarface74 on Sunday May 29, 2022 @07:29PM (#31553887)
The government doesn’t “enforce rights”. They take rights away from people. Laws by definition limit what you can do.

A company can only “violate my rights” if I choose to use those services. It’s much easier not to for instance use a phone with an operating system controlled by an adTech company than it is to not have to deal with a government.

Do you really think a government that always pushes the limit on being a surveillance state cares about your “privacy”?

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by jeramey on Sunday May 29, 2022 @08:12PM (#31554183)
That’s a very interesting example you choose. I wonder if you’d have a choice of mobile phones today had the US government not exercised its anti-monopoly authority with the Kingsbury Commitment and later the break-up of the Bell System.

Prior to 1983, nearly everyone in the US and Canada had to lease their physical telephones (wired and wireless) from Ma Bell, and if you didn’t like the phone Ma Bell gave you, tough luck. Your other choice was to simply not have access to the PSTN.

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by scarface74 on Sunday May 29, 2022 @11:07PM (#31555122)
The government granted AT&T its monopoly before taking it away.

https://www.encyclopedia.com/finance/encyclopedias-almanacs-...

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by jeramey on Monday May 30, 2022 @02:58AM (#31556187)
The US government accepted AT&T’s natural monopoly of telephone communications (this is the Kingsbury Commitment of 1913 mentioned in the link you provide) in exchange for their divestment of their control of other forms of telecommunication—namely telegraph communications via their controlling interest in Western Union—which was the other major important telecommunication technology at the time in the early 20th century. I can only imagine what things might be like if AT&T was allowed to keep an unchallenged natural monopoly over all forms of telecommunication and further allowed to hold that monopoly to the present day.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by scarface74 on Monday May 30, 2022 @05:48AM (#31557202)
We already know what would happen, landlines would still become irrelevant as cellular took over. There are and were still local “natural monopolies” with phone services.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by thfuran on Monday May 30, 2022 @07:24AM (#31557848)
>The government doesn’t “enforce rights”. They take rights away from people. Laws by definition limit what you can do.

If you want to have rights in any meaningful sense, people's actions must be limited such that they don't violate them overmuch.

>A company can only “violate my rights” if I choose to use those services.

That's complete nonsense. But even if it were true, how do you suppose that would help you if you don't have a handy oracle that provides you perfect information about every company's actions past, present, and future? It's not as if a company is likely to advertise practices they don't want you to know about. And there's nothing (aside from the government) preventing them from deciding the day after you purchase goods from them that, for example, they're not going to honor warranties anymore. And, of course, you don't have to buy from a company for them dump industrial waste on your property.

>It’s much easier not to for instance use a phone with an operating system controlled by an adTech company than it is to not have to deal with a government.

Is it easier to purchase all your goods and services from companies that have no objectionable practices? You probably don't have many choices of ISP and it's increasingly difficult to find a TV without some manner of integrated as tech.

>Do you really think a government that always pushes the limit on being a surveillance state cares about your “privacy”?

"The government" is not a single entity with only a single goal. Do I think that well-written legislation aimed at protecting privacy would, in effect, tend to protect privacy? Of course. Do I think that would stop the NSA from violating citizens' right to privacy? Of course not.

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by scarface74 on Monday May 30, 2022 @08:51AM (#31558448)
This gets back to the 11 chapter 99 chapter GDPR that all it gave us was shitty cookie banners. Do you think US state governments would do any better?

The last law related to tech that I can think of that was user friendly was phone number portability.

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by DANK_YACHT on Sunday May 29, 2022 @01:22PM (#31550873)
> Privacy regulations can make it very difficult for competitors to gain traction for incumbents

This is an oft repeated argument that makes no sense. The point of privacy legislation is not to increase competition. The point is to increase privacy. The government has other legislative tools to increase competition should it wish to do so.

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by spicybright on Sunday May 29, 2022 @01:36PM (#31550992)
It's like saying "Regulations against dumping garbage into oceans can make it very competitors to gain traction for incumbents."
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by hhw on Sunday May 29, 2022 @01:36PM (#31550993)
I think the point he was trying to make is that big tech can use privacy regulations to keep out new competitors, rather than encourage them, as compliance with privacy regulations can create a higher barrier to entry
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by yulaow on Sunday May 29, 2022 @01:54PM (#31551149)
How? You just need to not save user data outside of that strictly required for providing your service and you easily comply even with the most stringent GDPR directives. To be honest caring about privacy lowers a lot your barrier to entry, unless you whole business is based around tracking ads or reselling of data to shady third parties.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by shadowgovt on Sunday May 29, 2022 @04:25PM (#31552578)
Or collecting samples of user-provided data to build machine learning systems, which is how Google bootstrapped its search, spam filter, and voice recognition technologies.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by nojs on Sunday May 29, 2022 @06:02PM (#31553317)
Here’s an example for you: https://www.streetlend.com/

> With sadness, StreetLend was shut down in April 2018, after five years of operation.

> Unfortunately the European Union's new GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation), introduced on 25th May 2018, creates uncertainty and risk that are impossible to justify for small non-profit websites.

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by account42 on Monday May 30, 2022 @09:32AM (#31558768)
That is an example of someone who chose to shut down due to perceived risk. There is no argument on the linked page that that perception of the risk of running a free non-profit website under the GDPR is based in reality. In particular, the does not seem to have been any GDPR enforcement against said site.

It looks more like someone who does not like the GDPR (because it affects them in some other way, because they are mislead, out of principle or who knows what reason) who then chose to sacrifice their pet project to make a statement.

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by CharlesW on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:03PM (#31551833)
> This is an oft repeated argument that makes no sense.

It's so nonsensical that occasionally I wonder if this is an argument made primarily by the incumbents themselves in order to maintain the status quo.

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by pessimizer on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:19PM (#31551987)
> The point of privacy legislation is not to increase competition. The point is to increase privacy.

There is no point without a person to have one. This is your point. It's absolutely impossible to generalize it to everyone who works to pass "privacy" legislation, and simply incorrect. Sometimes you try to pass privacy legislation to reduce privacy. Sometimes you try to pass privacy legislation because you have a product that would sell more if it passed. And yes, sometimes you try to pass privacy legislation because it adds so much red tape that you need a full time employee, a team, or a department to comply with it, and you know potential challengers can't afford that yet.

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by ghayes on Sunday May 29, 2022 @01:35PM (#31550977)
Yes, but the side-effects of laws are the direct effects of laws and cannot be simply dismissed. This is the primary concern for any law, that it may impose other costs on society than just its intended consequences.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by falcolas on Sunday May 29, 2022 @01:08PM (#31550734)
Reality is, many such consumer protection laws include revenue minimums to avoid this very problem. See, as an example, the proposed law in CA allowing parents to sue social media companies.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by endisneigh on Sunday May 29, 2022 @01:10PM (#31550759)
Why should your privacy depend on the revenue of the company?
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by falcolas on Sunday May 29, 2022 @05:29PM (#31553055)
It mitigates the fear about its primary use being regulatory capture. Which is also quite important.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by pkos98 on Sunday May 29, 2022 @01:22PM (#31550876)
Because the insights from the data do depend on the scale of the dataset. Thats why the number of users is taken into account in data privacy laws such as GDPR (No. of users correlates with revenue).
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by izacus on Sunday May 29, 2022 @01:47PM (#31551095)
Obviously when the little car mechanic at the end of the street sells your private information to data aggregators for ad spam, it's all fine.

/s

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by t-3 on Sunday May 29, 2022 @01:19PM (#31550842)
How are the loopholes gonna be exploited if there aren't any loopholes? C'mon, get with the program.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by Spooky23 on Sunday May 29, 2022 @01:32PM (#31550952)
That’s the social media equivalent of “guns don’t kill people, people do”.

Nobody is unseating social incumbents. The industry is out of the growth phase and needs a firmer hand.

Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by heavyset_go on Sunday May 29, 2022 @07:44PM (#31553989)
Similar laws proposed in the EU limit the applicable companies to those with market caps over $80 billion.
Re:Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work ... by 8note on Sunday May 29, 2022 @05:44PM (#31553180)
There's a nit in there:

Privacy regulations can make it very difficult to for competitors to start up with abusing information.