News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by helen___keller on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:11PM (#31533612)
> prohibit app stores from hosting apps that enable transactions in China’s digital yuan

I think it would be reasonable to restrict usage of digital yuan by US businesses, but complete deplatforming seems annoying

I get that “China bad” is a popular position, but all you’re doing is punishing Americans who might want to travel to China or interact with Chinese friends (or worse: force those Americans to buy Chinese phones to avoid the deplatforming)

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by dahdum on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:28PM (#31533821)
Conveniently, this bill sounds like it will also help protect the profits of our parasitic payment networks.

WePay/AliPay merchant fees are around 0.6%, competing against that could dull some shine.

I’m not claiming it’s the only or main reason, but I expect a lot of lobbying dollars will be backing it.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by turndown on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:33PM (#31533876)
The obvious reply here is that WePay/AliPay are also parasitic payment networks, whose parent companies are propped up by the CCP for gains of their own. I also enjoy the spirit of this law, frankly, because China has a default-no attitude towards the outside world, so why the hell would we openly accept something like Digital Yuan? I see no reason why we should let China out of it’s corded-off world only when it finds it beneficial.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by helen___keller on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:45PM (#31534021)
> why the hell would we openly accept something like Digital Yuan?

Define “accept”? If I, an American with an American phone, travel to China and can’t buy lunch because the American government mandated deplatforming of the payment app, that’s really annoying to me.

I agree that nobody in the US should be using the e-CNY in place of the USD, but a more targeted law could accomplish this without trying to police the applications I can install on my iPhone

I frankly doubt e-CNY even has a chance to take off here, in my local Chinatown everyone pays by credit card not by Alipay or Wepay.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by bassman9000 on Friday May 27, 2022 @06:28PM (#31535647)
If you go to China, get a burner, or buy a Chinese cell phone, the same you're buying a plane ticket, or paying for a hotel. If it's for work, ask your company to pay for it.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by turndown on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:59PM (#31535412)
> an American with an American phone, travel to China and can’t buy lunch because the American government mandated deplatforming of the payment app, that’s really annoying to me

Politicians only like hammers so all problems are nails, maybe you are right that the enforcement mechanism is overly broad but I also think the situation you paint is inaccurate/made to seem more difficult than it actually would be. My parents went to China and did fine paying for things 13 years before Digital Yuan was created, my (naive) assumption is that, like all places tourists are herded in any country, the place you go will accept both native currency and USD, watches, nice shoes, jewelry…

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by helen___keller on Friday May 27, 2022 @07:00PM (#31535920)
You would think but just in 2019 I’ve run into places where pay is by app only, restaurants where you order/pay by scanning QR code, etc. honestly my thought on the way home is that China is way ahead of us in terms of convenience technology on phones (for better or worse)

With the pandemic US has caught up a lot though

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by alaricus on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:17PM (#31533693)
> I get that “China bad” is a popular position

America needs a new bogeyman now that Muslims are not scary anymore.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by rootusrootus on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:19PM (#31533716)
It helps that the CCP routinely does things worth despising them for.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by epgui on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:21PM (#31533742)
Every government routinely does things worth criticism. I don’t mean to do moral equivocation between all possible different wrongs, but some wrongs do get amplified way more than other comparable wrongs.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by throwaway0x7E6 on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:38PM (#31533934)
how many countries did China invade and/or bomb in the last 30 years?

how many millions of civilians are dead or displaced directly or indirectly because of China's actions?

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by rootusrootus on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:42PM (#31533973)
How many genocides has the US government undertaken?
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by alaricus on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:44PM (#31533999)
China did not spend 20 years murdering people in the Middle East, resulting in the death and displacement of millions.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by rootusrootus on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:31PM (#31535170)
Yes, war is bad. But if you're really trying to equate it with genocide, I don't know what to say.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by alaricus on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:44PM (#31535285)
How many people did American wars in the Middle East kill?
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by jessaustin on Friday May 27, 2022 @04:12PM (#31534329)
In addition to the more recent observations of sibling comments:

The actions on the western frontier were explicitly intended and contemporaneously described as genocide. After we ran out of Native Americans to kill, we hopped the Pacific to Philippines where more than 10% of the population perished in five years. CIA managed the Indonesian massacres of well over a million innocent people. The answer must be at least... three genocides? Historians might discover more! For instance, are we sure there are no American fingerprints on Cambodia? I think rather we feel lucky not to have found any undeniable links yet...

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by rootusrootus on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:33PM (#31535187)
I save my outrage for governments and politicians that are actually in power today. Whether China, the US, Russia, whoever. Sins of the parents and all that.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by alaricus on Saturday May 28, 2022 @04:16AM (#31538558)
So, when do we expect to see that outrage for the people that invaded and destabilized Iraq, Afganistan, Libya, Syria and continue to kill countless people with drone murders?
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by jessaustin on Saturday May 28, 2022 @12:37AM (#31537644)
I have the distinct feeling that your "outrage" is even a fair bit more selective than that... Anyway, don't look my direction for "outrage". Only chumps get upset about wet rain-clouds or imperialistic capitalism.

I sincerely attempted to answer your question. It wasn't obvious that you meant "how many in the last two weeks?"

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by hunglee2 on Friday May 27, 2022 @06:42PM (#31535773)
are you serious? It is irrefutable that the US is built on the genocide of an entire continent of people who lived here before settler colonialism. Hundreds of cultures, millions of people, hundreds of millions who would've been born but now never will be. These are basic facts
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by throwaway0x7E6 on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:52PM (#31534105)
considering that Russia's actions in Ukraine are now the threshold for a genocide, the US and its allies have committed four genocides just in the last 20 years - in Iraq, in Afghanistan, in Libya and in Syria
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by AnimalMuppet on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:49PM (#31535350)
It's a pretty big stretch to tag Russia as an ally of the US in their invasion of Ukraine.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by HKH2 on Friday May 27, 2022 @08:40PM (#31536527)
It is. Yet I can't see how your comment is relevant.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by AnimalMuppet on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:58PM (#31536951)
Ah, I see. I misread throwaway's comment.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by sofixa on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:01PM (#31534826)
No, the threshold for genocide is actions like erasing whole cities off the map with zero regard for civilian life, and mass kidnapping of children.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by alaricus on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:30PM (#31533833)
You mean how Americans are despised for their murders in the Middle East?
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by droptablemain on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:25PM (#31533782)
This is true of all governments, but the CCP does far more good for China that the U.S. government does for the U.S.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by munk-a on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:29PM (#31533828)
Yeaaaa... no, no it doesn't.

Even with all the anti-government rhetoric in the US when it comes to political discussions and the dysfunctional state of congress it's pretty clear that the US has a much more pleasant form of government to live under.

[dead]
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by munk-a on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:41PM (#31533965)
This feels like an extremely unproductive remark that essentially adds nothing to the discussion:

> Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.[1]

1. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by alaricus on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:46PM (#31534041)
This is deflection, nothing more.

Based on what exactly? You made a claim, without anything to back it up.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by munk-a on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:58PM (#31534181)
As someone who isn't a huge cheerleader for America I'll add a few specific points.

The US rather recently used tear gas to disperse a crowd in an absolutely unjustifiable action - while China has been regularly assaulting Hong Kong residents that are trying to preserve their comparatively free local government.

China is chomping at the bit to seize and annex the Republic of China (aka Taiwan) while the US has (granted, with a fair bit of awful execution) generally entered into wars without the explicit goal of bringing more territory under a dictator.

On American internet I can criticize Biden, Trump, Manchin and Cruz without being concerned over what consequences the government will try and visit on me for my disloyalty.

As a young teenager I watched a neighbor of mine flee the country after 9/11 due to their Omani heritage and relations and I was horrified at how middle-easterners were treated. Some Americans were even kidnapped in the middle of the night and detained (I'd argue illegally) in Gitmo. China has routinely rounded up anti-party agitators.

In my early adulthood I watched a semi-serious debate in Vermont about voluntarily leaving the union - anyone even talking about advocating for a free and independent Tibet is routinely arrested.

America has shifty credit score companies that dictate what you can and can't afford through opaque, mysterious and often quite flawed metrics - China has social credit.

America, as flawed as they may be, has elections, and, again as flawed as they may be, does have two parties - precisely one more party than China has. It'd be really nice if both countries actually had a sane number of political parties but hey 2 > 1.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by alaricus on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:45PM (#31535309)
> America, as flawed as they may be, has elections, and, again as flawed as they may be, does have two parties - precisely one more party than China has. It'd be really nice if both countries actually had a sane number of political parties but hey 2 > 1.

All those elections didn't stop a murderous rampage in the Middle East, resulting in the death and displacement of millions.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by munk-a on Friday May 27, 2022 @06:23PM (#31535618)
As mentioned above, I'm not a cheerleader for America and I think I've quite clearly pointed out a lot of awful qualities about the country - my comparisons weren't "Here's why America is unimpeachably awesome vs. something terrible about China" - I tried to pick especially warty examples for America.

If you want to say "America Bad" hey, I'm with you - but if you want to say "America is worse than China" then I think you've got some pretty rose tinted glasses on.

And, lastly, this entire thread has reeked of whataboutism. Given your objection I tried to actually provide an explanation, so feel free to take that as you will.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by alaricus on Saturday May 28, 2022 @04:17AM (#31538570)
"Whataboutism" is what hypocrites say when their hypocrisy ia pointed out to them.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by throwaway29812 on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:27PM (#31533807)
Are you including the prison camps for millions of their own citizens in that equation?
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by alaricus on Saturday May 28, 2022 @04:18AM (#31538577)
USA has more people in prison than China by a huge margin.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by throwaway29812 on Friday June 03, 2022 @05:22PM (#31613795)
Comparing criminals convicted of crimes (taking into account the unfairness of the law of course) with innocent people rounded up because they are the wrong ethnicity or religion is cynical, even for a tankie.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by hunglee2 on Friday May 27, 2022 @06:43PM (#31535787)
US leads the world in incarcerated rate. This is fact.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by honkdaddy on Monday May 30, 2022 @09:34AM (#31558778)
The difference being that those people stood trial, whether or not you think the sentence was justified.

Earnestly, can you see how that's different from being taken away from your home in the middle of the night because your provincial government decided they don't like the way you practice your religion?

Does it make sense to you, Hung, that those two situations are very different?

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by throwaway29812 on Friday June 03, 2022 @05:23PM (#31613801)
He needs them to be the same, so his worldview can stay intact.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by alaricus on Saturday May 28, 2022 @04:18AM (#31538573)
Not just lead, but lead by a huge margin.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by basisword on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:30PM (#31533839)
As does America. Internment of Japanese Americans, Vietnam War, Iraq War + the various war crimes committed there etc etc. most countries have things about them worth despising. Just depends on how long your memory is.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by rootusrootus on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:43PM (#31533990)
I'm okay letting go of things which happened before any current politician was in office. The past is the past, but I can despise the CCP for what they are doing right now.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by alaricus on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:46PM (#31534022)
Wars in Iraq, Afganistan, Libya, Syria, routine drone strikes, mass deportations, children in cages...

There is plenty to despise here.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by rootusrootus on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:35PM (#31535212)
Yeah, you're cheerleading for the CCP, I get it. The intent alone that underlies genocide is not at all comparable to the questionable wars the US gets involved in for reasons many of us don't agree with.

And think about the bright side. We can bitch here all we want about the US Government and I feel zero.... ZERO concern that they're going to track me down and punish me. Cannot say the same in China about the CCP.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by alaricus on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:47PM (#31535320)
I'm not cheerleading for CCP. Not everyone who disagrees with you is a cheerleader for someone else.

> We can bitch here all we want about the US Government and I feel zero.... ZERO concern that they're going to track me down and punish me.

Tell that to Julian Assange.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by rootusrootus on Friday May 27, 2022 @07:48PM (#31536242)
Okay, then blind hate for the US. You've actually attempted to equate civilian casualties of war with genocide, which is.... amazing.

> Tell that to Julian Assange.

Okay, sure. Has he ever been in the custody of the US govt? Was he accused of criticizing the government, or helping someone else divulge classified info? Whether you think that's what he was doing or not, you're stretching a looooong ways here to try and make the US govt as bad as the CCP. You've got a long ways to go.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by alaricus on Saturday May 28, 2022 @06:16AM (#31539091)
Julian Assange is held in the UK because the US asked him to be extradited. Do you read news?

"Civilian casualties of war" -> This is some NK-level mental gymnastics. "It's ok when the US murders people, but not cool when the Russians do it". People die either way.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by jessaustin on Saturday May 28, 2022 @01:30AM (#31537858)
At the end of this giant thread, you're still claiming that Russia is doing a genocide in Ukraine? UN says 4000 Ukrainian civilians have died so far in this violent clash between heavily armed militaries. In the last eight years 14000 people died in Donbas alone because Ukraine government couldn't enforce the Minsk agreements on its own Nazi battalions. (These are real Nazis, whose grandparents are still honored in Ukraine for helping Germans liquidate Jews, Roma, and Poles. This ain't the Jan 6 buffalo-hat fake Nazis.) Of course both of those figures are dwarfed by the deaths in e.g. Yemen. How is it that you've picked out this smallest death toll as a genocide?
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by throwaway29812 on Friday June 03, 2022 @05:25PM (#31613835)
You would have to be purposefully blind of the truth at this point, which you are. That's something between you and your own sense of morality, stop wasting our time with this rubbish.

https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/exclusive-ukraine-inves...

https://twitter.com/nikicaga/status/1532802261696618496

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by jessaustin on Friday June 03, 2022 @11:27PM (#31616685)
Maybe most of USA war media pretends to believe everything that the infamously corrupt Ukraine government says, but I don't have to. I can remember at least five TV wars, and in every case we heard lots of manipulative lies from the TV over the first several months. There's no reason to believe this is an exception.

Not that I admire Russia or anything. It is a crime to invade another nation except in response to violent military action. However, that isn't genocide. Even if it were, we'd decide that after international experts had thoroughly investigated. That hasn't happened yet.

You seem kind of emotional. Perhaps deeply-felt emotion might cause someone to believe everything the TV says?

ps. wrong sockpuppet

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by throwaway29812 on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @11:17AM (#31655627)
"Yeah but what about Iraq" is not a response to any of the evidence supplied on Russian crimes in Ukraine, it's a way for you to feel better about supporting the enemies of your enemy.

And you aren't fooling anyone.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by jessaustin on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @02:17PM (#31658167)
I have not ITT mentioned Iraq. Supporting the enemies of one's enemy is fairly common, although again that's not something I've done here. My enemy, and that of all ethical Americans, is the USA military-industrial complex. No one in Russia or China or wherever is their enemy. People overseas are just resources for them, grist for their blood-mill. Soon enough we may find that we too have been reclassified into resources.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by throwaway29812 on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @05:26PM (#31660275)
> I have not ITT mentioned Iraq.

Yes you did. You just don't have the courage to say "because Iraq was wrong, Ukraine doesn't matter." Because that is what you are implying, but it's so nonsensical you must hide behind platitudes.

> Supporting the enemies of one's enemy is fairly common..

As the kids say, "lol".

> although again that's not something I've done here

My word you don't have to courage to stand behind any of your beliefs, do you?

> My enemy, and that of all ethical Americans, is the USA military-industrial complex. No one in Russia or China or wherever is their enemy.

Was the Russian invasion of Ukraine wrong, yes or no. Is the massive amount of evidence for a targeted killings of civilians proof of genocide, yes or no. And if your answer is "no one can know because they got Iraq WMDs wrong", don't bother.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by legutierr on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:51PM (#31534100)
Whether or not you agree with them, there are substantive reasons that sentiment in the US is turning against China. Your statement is too cynical.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by alaricus on Friday May 27, 2022 @04:51PM (#31534709)
The most important reason appears to be that China is surpassing the US in global influence and importance.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by legutierr on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:36PM (#31537112)
Perhaps you may wish this to be true, but it hasn't happened yet.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by the_only_law on Monday May 30, 2022 @09:40AM (#31558834)
Certainly seems to be the case though, they’re clearly doing big work to build their own sphere outside east Asia, and seem much more competent than Russia, whom NATO seems to be paralyzed with.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by oneoff786 on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:24PM (#31533766)
One would have hoped Russia would suffice. Maybe they don’t seem scary enough.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by munk-a on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:31PM (#31533855)
It's hard to position Russia as a state enemy when half the politicians keep apologizing for and justifying their every action and decreeing any criticism of them as "a hoax".

Two party political systems are the worst.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by oneoff786 on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:13PM (#31534977)
That’s not really accurate. Even Mitch McConnell is pretty vocally anti Russia. Just the most shameless borderline treasonous of the alt right.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by jessaustin on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:23PM (#31533755)
Raytheon weapons don't sell themselves! Ukraine has generated $54B this year, but where will the profits be next year? In-the-know lobbyists say: "Taiwan!"
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by throwaway29812 on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:28PM (#31533823)
Right, threats against Ukraine and Taiwan were made up by checks notes Raytheon. Is the current, ongoing war in Ukraine "fake news" too ?
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by jessaustin on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:59PM (#31534199)
The idea that USA has any interests whatsoever in Ukraine was definitely "made up" by someone. [0] If anything, Taiwan's outsized international commercial importance makes it less likely to be the next site of disastrous war. Or so I hope...

"Fake news" has become a flag phrase, like "whataboutism". The first comment in the thread to include it, either to praise or to damn, was made by the biggest moron.

[0] https://www.opensecrets.org/news/reports/capitalizing-on-con...

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by throwaway29812 on Friday June 03, 2022 @05:16PM (#31613730)
That's decidedly not what we are talking about. Interesting use of projection to get out ahead of anyone accusing you of whataboutism/appeal to hypocrisy.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by somenameforme on Friday May 27, 2022 @04:40PM (#31534614)
When war is so unimaginably profitable to the people with an outsized influence in the running of country, that is going to play a significant role in deciding how we shape our geopolitical relations. This is precisely what Eisenhower warned about in his famous farewell address. [1] Literally everything he warned society about has come to pass.

[1] - https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/eisenhower001.asp

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by munk-a on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:35PM (#31533898)
Two things can simultaneously be true - the military industrial complex can exploit global politics to make money above and beyond what's necessary to actually provide aide to countries.

I think the last big weapons deal the US signed before agreeing to help Ukraine was subsidizing Saudi Arabia killing Yemenese in a bid to extract value from their civil war.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by lalaland1125 on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:41PM (#31533966)
> was subsidizing Saudi Arabia

Seems really odd to call a deal where Saudi Arabia was paying us for weapons in Yemen a "subsidy". You can argue that we shouldn't have allowed the sale, but it was a net profit for America.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by munk-a on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:42PM (#31533975)
That seems like a fair point, yea - we weren't really subsidizing and more just enabling.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by throwaway29812 on Friday June 03, 2022 @05:19PM (#31613757)
Or just part of an international trade in weapons that > 10 other countries participate in.

https://www.cnn.com/2018/11/22/middleeast/arms-exports-saudi...

But that doesn't fit the narrative, now does it?

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by throwaway0x7E6 on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:48PM (#31534064)
no, but they (and their peers) are the ones making bank off it

Ukraine does not get a check for N billion dollars, it gets N billion dollars worth of outdated equipment at MSRP

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by alaricus on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:31PM (#31533850)
Raytheon shareholders are counting on you!
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by lalaland1125 on Friday May 27, 2022 @02:50PM (#31533346)
Terrible bill written by the typical set of tech ignorant senators.

The digital yuan is basically a bank with a nice API and should be treated similarly.

The real solution is to fix our financial system so that transferring USD is cheap, fast and easily done through an API.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by toomuchtodo on Friday May 27, 2022 @02:58PM (#31533455)
Currency controls are the purview of nation states. Sometimes preventing the currency from leaving, sometimes from using the currency of an adversary.

The digital yuan is a form of Chinese soft power projection (as the US dollar is similarly), and it's not entirely unreasonable to dissuade its use (depending on your geopolitical views).

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by rmbyrro on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:16PM (#31533682)
The US Dollar is quite a strong power projection tool.

They can shut a country financial system down at any moment.

I bet they are afraid of being victims of what they know it's possible with such powers.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by satao on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:09PM (#31533587)
right. but then when other countries want to get away from the us dollar they are either invaded or sanctioned to hell.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by car_analogy on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:15PM (#31533657)
That doesn't make not wanting to come under China's soft power any less rational.

"You invaded someone else therefore you should allow yourself to be invaded."

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by PKop on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:16PM (#31533687)
You seem to be implying being hypocritical isn't the optimal geopolitical strategy.

Akin to saying, "it's bad when you do things that make you powerful, but good when we do them" which is unquestionably true from the perspective of any individual great power.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by ben_w on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:19PM (#31533708)
Yes, because the people in charge the dollars take the geopolitical view that dollars are better than every other currency.

(One reason I could never be a politician is that I can’t empathise with nationalism like that; I recognise it, but it feels a bit dirty to me).

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by car_analogy on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:27PM (#31533808)
That's not nationalism - that's imperialism.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by toss1 on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:32PM (#31533873)
If you think it is nothing more than a "bank with a nice API", I've got some oceanfront property in Kansas to sell you.

It is a specific CCP initiative to project power and track both its citizens and foreigners and undermine the power of western democracies and the power of the Euro and Dollar.

We were fools to not resist the offer to give away strategic manufacturing technologies and capabilities to China in exchange for cheap labor and a few quarters of profit. We'd be even greater fools to allow this next camel's nose under the tent (Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me...).

Even if the senators are typically Luddites, this is a very good move and cannot happen soon enough.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by esahione on Friday May 27, 2022 @02:58PM (#31533445)
It's not about technology. It's about the monopoly of the government as it relates to taxation and money over its land. China would do the same.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by xster on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:00PM (#31533479)
It does. US dollar purchase is subject to an annual limit per person.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by trompetenaccoun on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:52PM (#31534108)
It's not USD purchase specifically, it's exchanging your RMB for any foreign currency that's restricted. The Communist Party keeps people's money hostage and the reason is very clear: The rich obviously do not trust that they're safe. There is no rule of law, you can be arbitrarily locked up and have your savings taken from you at any time. All it takes for example is a change in leaders, as the Xi purge has shown. So they take their money abroad. To Canada, to the US, the UK and elsewhere.

The bill is probably needed but this is a bad look for the US whichever way you view it. I could go into long details but in short the situation we have now with increasing trade restrictions, stock delistings and so forth is the culmination of catastrophically failed policy towards the Chinese regime. The US and other developed countries were completely wrong and naive in the way they dealt with China. In fairness, in the 80s and 90s no one could have foreseen the current development and it was a reasonable assumption that with economic growth the country would liberalize. Even under Hu/Wen, I can see how people could convince themselves into believing increasing economic ties would make things better. Although already back in the late 2000s it was clear that the promise to open up the markets was a lie that never happened. Foreign ownership continued to be restricted, companies were forced into joint ventures (aka "thanks for the blueprints, suckers"), the Yuan control actually got tighter...

Western countries plus Japan, Korea and Taiwan made the Communist Party rich and powerful. Without all that foreign investment and technology transfer Mainland China would still be a broken backwater. Corporations in the developed world had gold glittering in their eyes when they looked at China and it's massive population. The Chinese regime found that one fatal flaw in free market capitalist systems: While economically they work, there is no incentive for the corporate leadership to do what's best for the country. Those who spearheaded the outsourcing of jobs and factories profited massively. As did the shareholders initially. It only came at the cost of the future of all the less wealthy people in the respective countries. Plus now they have a nuclear power pouring more and more billions into their military, preparing for war, while running concentration camps and allying with Russia and Iran.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by keyeug555 on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:03PM (#31533517)
I don’t know all the details about digital yuan but USA has enjoyed an exorbitant luxury by being the world’s reserve currency. I can see how senators with more political and macro economic experience than I would favor this ban.

I’m curious to learn what the realpolitik behind this really is.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by jessaustin on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:19PM (#31533721)
Are these the same geniuses who "attacked" RUB? They "damaged" it so much it's up 25% over USD this year and the central bank has had to slash interest rates... I'm sure the Chinese are very concerned.

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/26/business/russia-rates-rub...

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by sebzim4500 on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:28PM (#31533811)
Yeah but no one is allowed to sell it.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by jessaustin on Sunday May 29, 2022 @11:43PM (#31555277)
...no one is allowed to sell it.

Temporarily true in certain jurisdictions, but OTOH one may with RUB purchase oil, natural gas, palladium, nickel, copper, steel, aluminum, wheat, fertilizer, etc. So, those who need e.g. catalytic converters, especially if they live on the 70% of the planet where there are no limits on RUB whatsoever, will probably continue to use it.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by somenameforme on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:51PM (#31534084)
The currency controls have been repeatedly loosened, though it's difficult to try to find what the latest rules are. Russia's now growing concerned that the Ruble is growing too strong. That can hurt exports and exporters, as it means [relatively] higher domestic costs + lower profits.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by RappingBoomer on Friday May 27, 2022 @06:34PM (#31535697)
the american elites wanna keep americans on the low-interest plantation of america
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by xster on Friday May 27, 2022 @02:59PM (#31533466)
America innovated rather than banned its way to the top in the last century
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by mensetmanusman on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:07PM (#31533564)
The west has learned how easy it is for China to take advantage of price arbitrage. This is especially true when they block access to their market for the thing being competed.

For example, some of my colleagues used to work at US solar companies before they all collapsed due to the market being flooded by below cost Chinese panels.

If a country‘s government is willing to back technology below cost (or by blocking their market only for competitors), that is an appropriate place for tariffs or banning.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by zardo on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:13PM (#31533641)
I don't get the idea that China subsidizing solar panel manufacturing is bad.

Rather, the U.S. failure to do so is bad.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by PKop on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:25PM (#31533774)
Agree. And this is similar to policy US itself took (and many other rising economic powers) in the early 1800's [0]

"The American System was an economic plan that played an important role in American policy during the first half of the 19th century. Rooted in the "American School" ideas of Alexander Hamilton, the plan "consisted of three mutually reinforcing parts: a tariff to protect and promote American industry; a national bank to foster commerce; and federal subsidies for roads, canals, and other 'internal improvements' to develop profitable markets for agriculture".

The establishment of a protective tariff, a 20%–25% tax on imported goods, would protect a nation's business from foreign competition. Congress passed a tariff in 1816 which made European goods more expensive and encouraged consumers to buy relatively cheap American-made goods."

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_System_(economic_plan...

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by mensetmanusman on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:27PM (#31533801)
The unelected Chinese government created a system wherein the Chinese taxpayers were (unknowingly) subsidizing panel production so that Chinese companies could sell their panels in other markets below the cost of materials.

This prevents competition from forming… yes the US government should do more, but it is slower in a democracy to respond…

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by xster on Monday May 30, 2022 @02:36AM (#31556045)
To be fair, most US competitive products in the private sector arose from the public sector taking most of the risk away in publicly funded research from consumer electronics or aerospace to pharmaceutics. The internet and agent orange came from project AGILE in ARPA. How much electing did you partake in either?
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by zardo on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:40PM (#31533959)
The US is slow to respond because it's an oligarchy with a powerful interests in prolonging the fossil fuel age.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by mensetmanusman on Friday May 27, 2022 @08:41PM (#31536535)
That’s one small reason, another is that in a democracy orders of magnitude more people have a voice so everything is slower.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by zardo on Friday May 27, 2022 @11:57PM (#31537484)
What democracy? Popular opinion has an effect indistinguishable from random chance on US policy.

When the ruling class interests align, the US acts swiftly.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by mensetmanusman on Saturday May 28, 2022 @09:53AM (#31540338)
The democracy where there is voting…
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by rmbyrro on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:18PM (#31533704)
Government subsidies almost always leads to inefficient capital and labor allocations, which create waste.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by TrapLord_Rhodo on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:28PM (#31533810)
>inefficient capital and labor allocations, which create waste.

You can thank this 'inefficient capital' to almost all modern innovations. In reality, the US System has evolved to be no different than China, only slightly more people have their hand in the pot in the US.

We also heavily subsidize electric energy production, manufacturing and all other manners of industry. We just don't allow sweat shops in manufacturing anymore, only tech.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by zardo on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:22PM (#31533748)
Almost is doing a lot of work there
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by PKop on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:22PM (#31533751)
Globalization and free-trade were beneficial when US was unipolar hegemon (though arguably not being protectionist against China enabled China's rise)... but in earlier periods of America's primary growth, "bans" of foreign good through protectionism favoring domestic industries is what made America strong.[0]

Innovation is not antithetical to taking heavy-handed policy targeting adversaries, whether through trade or monetary/financial policy.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_System_(economic_plan...

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by lalaland1125 on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:31PM (#31533849)
Exactly. There is nothing magical about a digital yuan. It's just a bank with a nice API.

The only reason why it's popular is because our traditional banking system is so anti innovation and refuses to offer decent APIs.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by vasco on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:32PM (#31533871)
Have you heard of TRIPS and how that was negotiated and led by the US? Might change your mind
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by outside1234 on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:06PM (#31533551)
Given the Russian shitshow, we can't take any more dependencies on China, and honestly need to start unwinding the ones we have. So I'm all for this.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by jimbob45 on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:32PM (#31533869)
I don’t understand what a CBDC is. To the best of my knowledge, it seems like money that is backed by a SQL DB in DC or Beijing rather than paper with anti-counterfeiting measures.

It sure seems a lot harder to trust that a CBDC wouldn’t be abused than a cash-based system, which at least has a paper trail (literally).

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by TrapLord_Rhodo on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:38PM (#31533939)
As long as everyone agrees on a global form of payment (USD) with swift and a 'Friendly?' globalistic enviroment there will continue to be no need for crypto.

However as we start to see fragmentation in the payment space between Russia, China and the EU/US along with an explicit writing in the transactions to disallow crosstalk, there start to be some kind of 'use' for crypto again.

The need for a verifiable, self-soverign, uncontrollable medium of exchange starts to become useful again.

Problems with the above:

Low liquidity, uncontrollable is a loose term here. If the US forces publicly traded companies to dump crypto it will cause a huge crypto winter and a huge amount of money to be 'eaten up' by the bulls.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by hunglee2 on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:03PM (#31533516)
'your freedoms must be protected by restricting you from exercising those freedoms' bill
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by TrapLord_Rhodo on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:30PM (#31533837)
Every government historically becomes an entity in it's own right. Government rights slowly become more important than citizens rights.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by athrowaway3z on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:14PM (#31533644)
the freedom argument is not without some irony regarding the Digital Yuan.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by metacritic12 on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:36PM (#31533904)
Would this make the Digital Yuan more banned than Terra or Ethereum?

That would show the true colors of how much of America's liberalism (e.g. free markets) is conditional on free markets being favorable for American hegemony.

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by corner_case2 on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:09PM (#31533586)
This, on top of the covid shitshow in China, will stifle the Chinese economy for decades. They might even drop to #3.
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by helen___keller on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:53PM (#31534119)
In what world does this even affect the Chinese economy? We’re talking about restricting Chinese payment apps from American app stores. The Chinese economy is driven by users who have access to the Chinese app stores
Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by rmbyrro on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:19PM (#31533722)
Sure, yeah, the Japanese will produce 5x more stuff the next year.

Prepare to see Made in Japan in everything you buy.

Oh, and every item will also cost 5x more. But it's just a detail...

Cheers!

Re:Senators Draft Bill to Ban Use of Digital Yuan in US-Base... by bboygravity on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:59PM (#31535414)
You mean a USB cable will cost 2,50 instead of 50 cents and will last longer than 1 use and will be made out of materials that don't cause cancer and neurotoxicity and my purchase will not be sponsoring a world-war-hungry genocidal regime?

oh noes!