News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by _delirium on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:30PM (#31525753)
I've found high-wattage USB-C chargers to have very poor reliability. All the 18-W chargers I've owned have lasted multiple years, but the compact 90-W+ chargers have a lifespan measured in months.

Of course, they all purport to offer a warranty, but if you try to claim, they will not honor it. They will claim it's because you bought from Amazon and they don't warrant Amazon purchases (despite this being their main retail outlet, and the fact that they advertised the warranty IN the Amazon sales materials). Or something similar.

Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by rektide on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:38PM (#31525789)
I have a ravpower, a hyper, and just bought the new ugreen. The ugreen is too new to judge, but the others have ran for over two years, and a good amount of that time has been outdoors in the sun.

I constantly expect failures. This seems like an absurd task I'm putting them up to. But they are all still alive & doing the job.

I've had a kill-a-watt so I can see their power consumption. A large amount of their life is spent ~60 watts, but there's definitely hours on end & heavy usage days, where they go up to or stay at 90+.

My anecdotal data looks different than yours.

Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by _delirium on Friday May 27, 2022 @12:09AM (#31525942)
My Ravpower device died within 8 months, and they refused to honor the warranty, giving as the reason that the purchaser of record was Amazon LLC, not Ravpower. Even though they advertised a warranty on their Amazon page, which was the main way they sold the devices.
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by gorbypark on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:07AM (#31527506)
Does Amazon not honour the warrenty in that case? I've never had to deal with a similar situation but I kind of figured that Amazon would do something if the page advertised a warranty and the company refuses to honour it.
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by AshamedCaptain on Friday May 27, 2022 @08:00AM (#31528518)
I have never been able to get Amazon to honor a warranty when the manufacturer refused, even though the law in my country clearly says the retailer is responsible in the first place. In fact the button to return a product disappears from the order after a couple months, and they don't even have a category in their support system for this.
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by ThePowerOfFuet on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:55PM (#31535382)
Talk to Amazon customer service and tell them you'd like to make a claim pursuant to consumer rights law.
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by retcon on Friday May 27, 2022 @12:47AM (#31526089)
... dreams of the EPA obtaining warrants for the fraud on the public for the disposal costs of so much wasted electronics...
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by thathndude on Friday May 27, 2022 @07:42AM (#31528381)
I smell a class action.
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by londons_explore on Friday May 27, 2022 @02:31AM (#31526610)
In the EU you get 2 years warranty for all items from every retailer by law, and most generally honour them.
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by gambiting on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:21AM (#31527578)
So this is a very frequently repeated misconception about what the EU law actually says.

Yes, there is an EU law that says retailers are responsible for 2 years(6 in a some cases) for any item they sold......but only to rectify any manufacturing defects. The law additionally states that any defect found in the first 6 months is presumed to be a manufacturing issue, anything after the first 6 months it's the responsibility of the customer to prove that the product has failed due to a manufacturing problem. I'm sure you can appreciate that this can be very hard to do.

It's not a "warranty" in the sense that most people mean warranty. If your laptop fails 18 months after purchase, the retailer only has to fix it if you can prove that it failed due to a manufacturing defect. It's different to manufactuer's warranty, which usually covers any defect no matter the reason.

And yes, there is also the law that states that products should last a "reasonable" amount of time - but what is reasonable is not a strict definition, and again, unfortunately sometimes has to be argued in small claims court. It's not so straigtforward.

Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by danieldk on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:38AM (#31527655)
However, in practice most good retailers do not make a big deal out of the burden of proof as long as there is no visible damage that could cause the issues.

I have used warranty frequently after 6 months and never had to prove it is a manufacturing defect. Of course, if you buy at some shady webstore or known-bad retailer, you might have more issues.

Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by tinus_hn on Friday May 27, 2022 @06:02AM (#31527794)
These are not EU laws, they are EU directives directing the member countries to implement laws. But these laws are not all the same, for instance in how much effort a customer has to make to ‘prove’ that a device failed due to a manufacturing defect.
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by torginus on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:31AM (#31526961)
I agree - I wonder why Chinese junk that basically barely works and not for long even then has managed to establish such a strong foothold on the retail market (particularly Amazon). I had the same experience - moreover my charger had multiple ports, but as soon as you plugged more than one thing into it, the wattage would drop drastically. my 100W charger would do 30W on port 1 and 10W on port 2. And that was the optimal case - more often than not, using more than one port would make devices randomly disconnect.
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by solarkraft on Friday May 27, 2022 @06:51AM (#31528061)
It's cheap and there's little responsibility for selling crap. Amazon is the only site I'm aware of where you can actually somewhat judge the quality of a product through reviews, and those too are often dodgy as hell. Otherwise it's all just the same fake pictures and outright lies about specs. And nobody cares because it's cheap.

Companies selling under brands want a premium for them (Anker, Aukey) and "no name brands" you can actually put a little confidence into (Ugreen, Blitzwolf) are, for some reason, rare.

Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by tjoff on Friday May 27, 2022 @11:05AM (#31530461)
That isn't so surprising nor uncommon even among high-end chargers. Many multiple-port chargers can only generate one voltage other than 5V.

So, you charge your laptop at 100W means 20V*5A, then connect a phone that can only negotiate to 9V. Now your laptop can, at best, only get 45W. But laptop and phone might also have to share the same 5A, meaning something close to what you described. (or, your laptop might not support 9V ... in which case I'd guess one of the devices would disconnect?)

You might be better off using a USB-A port if the charger has one, then your laptop could perhaps remain at ~100W and your phone might still get ~10W. (Assuming charger and phone doesn't also have quickcharge which might complicate it further). Or, perhaps charge your phone via your laptop (yes, negates the point of a multiple-port charger, but if you are in hurry - otherwise, slow charging is preferably anyway)

A good review will test this, and a good product page will specify this (but if your are not looking/thinking about it it is easy to miss).

Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by scotty79 on Friday May 27, 2022 @04:18AM (#31527235)
Be happy the wattage dropped. When I connected 2 fast charging devices my charger just fried.
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by ncmncm on Friday May 27, 2022 @06:14AM (#31527865)
I just had a 4-port USB brick burst into flame. It certainly would have burned down the house if I had not happened to be in the room. It had sat untouched for an hour before the event.
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by Tijdreiziger on Friday May 27, 2022 @07:42AM (#31528383)
Wow, what brand?
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by torginus on Friday May 27, 2022 @08:17AM (#31528667)
These brands are like the ship of Theseus - you'll never get the same thing twice.
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by bombcar on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:31AM (#31530083)
Better than the brand is the picture of the device (before fire, hopefully) as all the yumcha brands off of Alibaba will usually keep the exact same physical characteristics.
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by Youden on Friday May 27, 2022 @06:48AM (#31528045)
I think you might be unlucky or buying low-quality models. I have a 100W Minix NEO P2 that was one of the first GaN chargers available near me and it's still going strong 2 years later.

I also have a 60W Satechi travel charger that's been powered-on 24/7 for 3 years now without the slightest hint of a problem. It's even been buried under cushions for hours at a time.

The only charger I've had actually die was a Hama-branded device. Hama is the cheapest possible Chinese junk the brand can find.

Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by pugz on Friday May 27, 2022 @01:09AM (#31526192)
What brands have you used? My Apple 96W USB-C charger is still doing fine after having it for just under two years now.
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by solarkraft on Friday May 27, 2022 @06:53AM (#31528078)
Apple cares about its brand. Chinese no name vendors don't at all, it's horrifying what plain illegal corner-cutting they often engage in. But that's of course what they're rewarded for.
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by bombcar on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:34AM (#31530118)
In fact, if you're in a bind and need a USB C charger that will work reliably, you may want to pay the cost to get a genuine Apple one. (I won't order Apple chargers from Amazon; I get them direct from Apple or a real retailer because I don't trust the co-mingling).

Some of the power-tool brands are beginning to make USB-C devices, those chargers should be reliable also. Here's Dewalt: https://www.dewalt.com/product/dcb094k/usb-charging-kit

Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by adrianN on Friday May 27, 2022 @12:54AM (#31526123)
If you bought the device off Amazon, I believe Amazon should be your point of contact for warranty claims.
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by solarkraft on Friday May 27, 2022 @06:46AM (#31528028)
I have had a couple of pretty cheap high wattage USB bricks for years (5-6 or so at this point) and none of them have died on me so far. Props to Ugreen, I guess!
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by SkyPuncher on Friday May 27, 2022 @01:19PM (#31532143)
I have an Anker GAN power block that's working extremely well.
Re:Ultra compact GAN ATX power supply delivers up to 250 Watts by lrem on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:03AM (#31526790)
My two Minix P2s had no issues over 1.5 years.