It's just confused thinking on their part (very common, judging by some of the comments here).
(All of this is about "pushing" or "forcing", not about "encouraging", which I believe to be very different).
IMO, my role as a parent is to expose my kids to as many things as I can. If the like it, I give them more, if they don’t, then we move on to something else.
I think ultimately the problem is that the child has the first-hand knowledge of their own experience, but not the mature perspective of age; and the adult has the mature perspective of age, but not the first-hand knowledge of the child's experience.
I have a toddler. Sometimes he knows he's tired needs to sleep; sometimes he needs to sleep but he refuses to accept that; sometimes he knows that he's not tired and won't be able to sleep.
I know that he often gets tired around a certain time, and that he often refuses to accept that he actually needs sleep.
So sometimes when he refuses sleep, I insist, and then he conks out immediately. I was right: my greater perspective as an adult was more accurate his immediate experience of wanting to stay awake.
But sometimes when he refuses to sleep, and I insist, he spends the next two hours tossing & turning and not being able to sleep. He was right: his personal experience of not being at all tired outweighed my greater perspective as a parent that he's normally tired at the time.
Neither one of us has enough information to make an informed decision on our own.
I think something similar happens with children. Children don't really know the potential reward of putting up with the grind of practicing for years, or the regret as an adult of missing out on those skills. But if it's excruciatingly painful, they certainly know it.
Adults know the potential reward of putting in the time, but they don't know the child's experience. So, when a child balks, is it because they're just facing the normal barrier of effort that everyone faces? Or are they really experiencing something excruciatingly painful? If it's the first and you push them, they'll be glad in the end. If it's the first and you don't push them, they'll regret it. If it's the second and you push them, they'll be resentful; if it's the second and you don't push them, everyone will be happier.
Neither the child nor the parents actually has all the information required to make an accurate decision.
Kids don’t know what it is they like or don’t like. They might think they dislike something, but usually they are just afraid of the unknown. Once something is tried at least once, then they can make an informed decision.
As a parent I had all these ideas for them - socially it can be good to be in a team sport, it's nice to have something that you're good at that you can also still do as an adult, if you move cities later its a way to meet people there so do something a lot of people do in an organized way... But we'll see what they end up with. The oldest is into (inline) skating.
I think it's absolutely healthy to push kids to a certain extent. That extent is just something that's probably different for every kid and activity, and I get that it's probably hard for a parent to figure out when to push and when to give up.
This thread (started by irjustin) is about this though. And, where do you draw the line?
I‘m all for encouragement, like: „Ok young one. You had half a year of ballet lessons now. It’s a bit different than you imagined, and you’re often exhausted afterwards. You can quit anytime you want, but how about you give it another shot and see if you can rest more between drills?“ And if she still wants to quit - let her.
This was the down side of lenient parents who never forced us to do things we didn’t like, and let us quit even things that were good for us.
I started practicing electric guitar at the ripe age of 20 (with a teacher I met at compulsory army service), and after 6 years of that, played in a band for five years (including a gig in front of four thousand people). My parents only ever once saw me play live - and I think that actually helped, because I never felt forced to practice (as was the case with the piano).
There are heaps of things that just aren't that fun but that are actually important.
So I'd say pushing kids away from those things is necessary. Beyond that, I'm not so sure.
Forcing children to do one particular thing (above and beyond what is required to survive in this cruel world) is probably bad. Making sure the options they have to choose from are healthy, non-addictive, and engaging is probably necessary, though.
Additionally, if we just limit screen time too much, that might lead to a feeling of scarcity, and overindulgence when the chance presents itself.
It’s tricky to let your kids socialize but also keep them away from toxic platforms like TikTok, Facebook, Instagram, etc.
Neither extreme (Wild/Stepford) is a good thing, Wild Children tend to get into and cause a lot of trouble, and end up missing out on opportunities both personal and interpersonal due to their lack of grounding and inability to meet societal pressures/standards.
Stepford kids (at least in my anecdotal experience) tend to end up rebelling hard, or developing a need to hide their flaws and issues out of fear of reprisal, and sometimes end up having huge breakdowns because their fundamental emotional and developmental needs aren't being met.
Sounds like Wil was forced to be a Stepford child, and this is the consequence of that, not to mention his mother both abusing him and allowing him to be abused by other people while wringing every penny she could get out of him in the process. That's pretty shitty.
The question is about pushing your kids to do things you think they should like.
Parents sometimes need to push their kids.
I did the exact same thing, except now I'm a skilled keyboardist (and multi-instrumentalist) who gets paid for gigs. I still spend most of my time fucking around and improvising. Every bit of theory I discovered through fucking around and just exploring freely. I never do scales: I just pick a key and start improvising.
If my parents had pushed me to 'actually practice', I would have rebelled and quit altogether. They did for a couple of years. And I did quit. Fortunately, I found my way back to it, on my own terms, because I simply loved playing instruments -- but I loved doing it on my own terms, not someone else's.
The frank truth is that some people really like playing instruments, and some are just 'meh' about it. Those who have a tendency to enjoy playing an instrument just need to have access to one -- and then they'll find their way. On the other hand, if a child is 'meh' about an instrument, is it really worth punishing and forcing them through all of it? What's the goddamn point? Isn't life to be enjoyed? Is it really just a series of skills to stoically master?
That said, as a result I can busk a bit, and have come to realise that physical tasks to be done in a repeatable way are outside my ability. So the world has not lost a great pianist.
Surprised to read this. There have been many well-documented cases of children not wanting to learn math, science, history, etc, or go outside for exercise, where the parents denied their children’s agency and forced them to do so. Long-term studies indicate a tendency towards positive outcomes.
The main thing is to not chase some dumb good-parenting metric but to give your kid suitable obstacles so she can experience overcoming them and feel success and gain self-confidence. That's what parenting is all about: the little push that helps kids reach their potential. Easier said than done of course.
I agree though that if that does not stay in the fun zone, the outcome will most likely be bad. Especially if there is some vicarious competition in the parent's head.
> What is a healthy amount of pushing vs too much?
There is no healthy amount of pushing, period. If you stop applying pressure, children will find their own thing, and that’s the best outcome for them. Just make sure they know the possibilities of what they could do.
What would you have liked to do instead of learning piano? Did you need pressure from your parents to have those ideas?
I asked my parents for a keyboard. My mother said that I‘d need to learn piano first - so I agreed to take lessons instead. 8 years later, I gave up on piano lessons, with no keyboard in sight. Haven’t touched the piano since. I wonder what would’ve happened if they had just bought me that cheap keyboard instead.