News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by bradlys on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:10PM (#31451967)
My advice? Same as ever. Suck it up. Do it - it's hardly the worst part of the job and not doing it will mean you make less money. You're very unlikely reaching $500k+/yr by avoiding LC compared to how trivial it is to reach once you accept it.

If you think leetcode is the worst part of being in this workforce - you live one incredibly privileged life. Wait until you have to deal with toxic management that exists in virtually every company and in virtually every leadership position. Wait until you have to deal with people who have a personal vendetta against you because of prejudice and will block any achievements you can make at a company. Are you excited for stack ranking? It exists at nearly every company and if it doesn't explicitly - it happens mentally. Are you excited to see incredibly huge churn in your industry? Are you excited to see the best and brightest constantly shutdown due to favoritism (and you will likely not be in that in-group)? Are you excited to watch people over the years lose all their hope and become soulless corporate ghouls who become the shill LinkedIn promoters that they themselves condemned a few years previously? Are you excited to work 60+ hour weeks to get PIP'd because that's just the way it is? (It will happen) Are you excited to put nights and weekends in at startups to see a round where the execs lose no value but your stock sees 3x+ dilution and no increase in value?

These are common problems at companies within SV. Leetcode is hardly a problem when you see how fucking terrible the rest is.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by PragmaticPulp on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:33PM (#31452178)
> You're very unlikely reaching $500k+/yr by avoiding LC compared to how trivial it is to reach once you accept it.

I wouldn't say it's "trivial". It may feel that way once you've made it and been promoted up the ranks, but outside of that bubble I see a lot of people who have failed out of multiple attempts at FAANG interviews (despite practicing LC), burned out of FAANG jobs after a couple years, moved away from cities with those salaries (not every place offers remote work), or simply been unable to get through the promotion process to reach the upper ranks.

Don't get me wrong: Practicing LC and grinding at FAANG is a remarkably easy way to reach $500K/yr salary compared to other options, but we need to stop pretending like it's automatic or easy. It's still hard and requires some degree of sacrifice/luck/location to get there.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by bradlys on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:39PM (#31452229)
In no way am I saying it's easy. I'm saying it's trivial compared to other options. Other options are basically fucking impossible. At least with FAANG and staff roles - there's a chance. Even if it might be this meme: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wGdhc9k07Ms
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:56PM (#31452397)
> requires some degree of sacrifice/luck/location to get there.

Bingo. You can answer everything perfectly and still not get it depending on interviewer or other applicants.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by curiousDog on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:30PM (#31452144)
Very well said.

To the OP: if you really are a good programmer, then mastering LC is just a matter of time and effort and really, the problems aren't that hard. You're also hired at most companies to solve problems; not just be a code monkey. It's a matter of interest and motivation not whether you're good at LC or not.

LC is the best proxy we have for aptitude and general problem solving ability at this time. So best to suck it up and grind.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by boredtofears on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:33PM (#31452166)
Grinding LC is the definition of being a code monkey.
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by ethanwillis on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:23PM (#31452088)
Sorry, but no. I refuse. The industry can continue to pump out subpar solutions with their toxic culture until the VC money dries up. Out of principle I will not memorize your LC problems.

I won't deny it's a great filter for getting the exact type of people that will tolerate, enable, and expand this culture.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by kjeetgill on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:39PM (#31452858)
> their toxic culture until the VC > Out of principle I will not memorize your LC problems. I won't deny it's a great filter for getting the exact type of people that will tolerate, enable, and expand this culture.

Hm. I hope this comes of gently - I don't know you, your skills, your background, your experience or your goals for that matter - but this feels overdramatic and even a little condescending.

If you have your CS fundamentals together it really shouldn't be that much effort? I know some whiteboard interviewers will ask unreasonably obscure algorithms, but LC hasn't ever been that unreasonable. I really don't get the absolute vitro people have. Sure it's not an ideal measure - but hey: eat your vegetables. It's not some unfathomable distant unrelated set of hoops to jump through.

LC questions can be a little bit of a chore but I've never spent more than an hour or two brushing up before interview cycles if I reviewed them at all and have done pretty well in my interviews. I've tanked my share of interviews but it's never been so dramatically unreasonable. It's not like they're asking you to write paragraph upon paragraphs on why you'll be the perfect fit and this opportunity is unlike any other for you. Cover letters are at least 70% more bullshit.

For context: I joined the industry in 2012 where whiteboard interviews were the normal but before leetcode, hacker rank, etc. were common, but I've interviewed plenty since then.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by ethanwillis on Friday May 20, 2022 @06:33PM (#31453357)
> Cover letters are at least 70% more bullshit

Agreed. And yes, on LC problems they are a chore. I've been thinking about this a lot and here is my take on all of this from a different direction that re-inforces my opinion that it is a toxic culture.

The fact that developers are required to do a dance and memorize LC problems to regurgitate them in a timed setting is because there is a fundamental lack of trust on the hiring side. This is actually offensive.

Now, we might say, okay well LC problem regurgitations provide actionable signal. Definitely more than a cover letter! But is it a significant signal for software production ability? I don't think it is except in cases where the domain is well-trod.

I get why we need some kind of signal with the current way employment and hiring is structured. We need something actionable, something to build trust. But I think that's the problem. Trust should come first, otherwise we enter this current world where hiring is slow, fraught with problems, no one can fill their positions (and I don't think it's for lack of a talent pool).

I haven't through all of the implications of this part yet, but here is where I'm at. VC backed companies and VC backed company copycats will say they are doing all of this to avoid false positives. All so they don't waste their time on the Wrong hires. How long does it really take to know, when actually working with someone, that they are the wrong hire? Not long in my experience. Let's say 1 month. Just hire people on a temporary basis, pay them, it's a more ethical take home project in a way. And what is the current state? Well the current state is filtering so harsh on a low significance signal that it takes a company many months to fill a position. Are our assumptions about the false negative rate so wrong that it's actually very high? I think so.

I've had some pushback on the hire fast, fire fast methodology before as being bad for candidates. However, I don't think it's any worse than the current experience they receive.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by kjeetgill on Friday May 20, 2022 @07:36PM (#31453904)
> The fact that developers are required to do a dance and memorize LC problems to regurgitate them in a timed setting is because there is a fundamental lack of trust on the hiring side. This is actually offensive.

> Now, we might say, okay well LC problem regurgitations provide actionable signal.

Oof. You keep calling it "regurgitation" and "memorization" as if there's no way that one could possibly be capable of thinking through those problems with a bit of experience. Maybe it's just me but I don't think a brief test of your fundamentals is that out of line. You're not supposed to memorize your times tables to 100, you're supposed to know how to multiply.

I think there's plenty of reasonable criticisms to be made, but if you're equating LC problems to StarTrek trivia I'm not sure you're making them.

> But I think that's the problem. Trust should come first, ... How long does it really take to know, when actually working with someone, that they are the wrong hire? Not long in my experience. Let's say 1 month. Just hire people on a temporary basis, pay them, it's a more ethical take home project in a way. And what is the current state?

> I've had some pushback on the hire fast, fire fast methodology before as being bad for candidates. However, I don't think it's any worse than the current experience they receive.

That is in no way more ethical and it's so, so much worse. It shoves tremendously more cost and risk onto individuals vs companies. I don't know your situation or experience or what's driving these conclusions but your concerns just don't connect to your conclusions for me here.

The following is a chunk of my reply very similar comment recently: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30889389

> I can't even fathom in what ways you think "time to hire more, and fire fast?" is more "effective and equitable"? You just shove even more risk onto individuals who might be getting their footing still.

> You're just turning a 8-9 hours commitment to an interview into a 6 month commitment. Sure, you get paid but you also have to deal with churn and burn.

> I mean, did you think stack ranking was a good idea?

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by PragmaticPulp on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:45PM (#31452289)
Which is fine! Nobody has to do LC and nobody has to apply to companies that use LC interviews.

The reality is that when most people sit down and think about the math behind the finances, avoiding LC on principle comes with a massive opportunity cost that can exceed millions of dollars over the span of a career. Which again, totally fine if that's not your thing, but we should still let people know what's at stake.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by ethanwillis on Friday May 20, 2022 @06:36PM (#31453381)
I agree, it is fine if people choose to do this! It doesn't change my perspective on it however. There is definitely an opportunity cost. However, not in all cases. A single developer who is talented can take a variety of paths outside of this system to make significant or more money.

I'm going to get ahead of the idea of the risk of stability and the implication I'm saying a software developer would be banking on risk/reward of a technology startup. I'd like to say that they can also use all the skills and knowledge of a software developer in a non-tech company with great success and similar or higher compensation with similar risk profiles.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by bradlys on Friday May 20, 2022 @06:48PM (#31453505)
> A single developer who is talented can take a variety of paths outside of this system to make significant or more money.

Please write a post about this then. I'd love to know roles that are regularly paying $500k+/yr.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by netizen-936824 on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:24PM (#31452693)
The reality is that's only from one super limited perspective and fails to consider the ideals of the applicant and how they think companies should operate ethically. Becoming wealthy isn't the only thing in life, this includes considering which companies you're willing to work for based on how they operate and what they do.

If we constantly have people buying into a damaging system just for the money, it compounds issues and they get worse down the road

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by boredtofears on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:32PM (#31452158)
When the VC money dries up I expect things to get worse, not better for candidates.
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by mountainriver on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:00PM (#31452441)
Agree, I’ll do literally anything than buy into this nonsense. You can take your crappy devs that memorized Leetcode problems and I’ll stick with people who solve actual problems and can demonstrate it.

Leetcode isn’t a good measure and will be phased out in coming years as this is realized.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by hiq on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:28PM (#31452743)
> Leetcode isn’t a good measure and will be phased out in coming years as this is realized.

Given how long it's been around and the lack of credible alternatives for hiring at scale, I'm having doubts.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by mountainriver on Friday May 20, 2022 @07:39PM (#31453919)
It _hasn't_ been around long, this is a recent phenomenon in the last 3-5 years, and its a cargo cult like so many other things in tech. It doesn't work well because most of the really bad engineers I know just grind leetcode and end up at FAANG. This will be seen in time
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by hiq on Saturday May 21, 2022 @02:58AM (#31455853)
CtCI has been first published in 2008, meaning that such interviews had already been widespread for a few years by then. Since then, websites like Leetcode have apparently become viable as businesses. As a career choice, I find it unwise to bet on this practice disappearing anytime soon.
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by dhanna on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:38PM (#31452226)
My problem is that I hate leetcode and I’m also burnt out from all the nonsense you mentioned
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by depr on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:16PM (#31452018)
So why are you in this industry?
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by bradlys on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:20PM (#31452058)
Money. Compared to other industries - it’s much easier to make $500k/yr or more.

I’ve had jobs where I was at $1m+. This would never happen in other industries unless I had X prestigious university on my resume or was married to the boss’ daughter.

I could’ve been a surgeon, a lawyer, etc. but most of those have even worse hours, more time in college (debt+non-earning-years), and tend to not favor my background. (Poor rural upbringing) I’m already an outcast in tech in SV - I’ve come from the smallest town, least educated, and poorest family of anyone I’ve met here under 35.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by simplehuman on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:50PM (#31452342)
I don't get why you are working at all :) what do you plan to do with all this money ... Only to do leetcode?
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by Kranar on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:12PM (#31452563)
I'm also someone who entered the field for money. As someone who grew up in a family of poor immigrants who pushed me to work hard and opened the door to opportunities that I'd have never been exposed to in their home country, it's really great to know that my family will never have to endure that hardship and will enjoy one of the highest qualities of life and that I can give back to my parents who struggled to give me this quality of life.

If anything, one of the challenges I face raising my own family is to make sure my kids don't become complacent and squander the opportunities available to them.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by mountainriver on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:01PM (#31452448)
Lol exactly, get a mission for Christs sake
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by lupire on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:34PM (#31452181)
I would love to be an outcast at work for $1m/yr.
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by bradlys on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:36PM (#31452207)
It sounds better on paper than in reality. I quit that job and took one for a massive paycut. I ended up getting divorced partially due to this job.

Is it worth losing your marriage over? YMMV.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by curiousDog on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:40PM (#31452863)
We have some that make way more than that in my FAANG company
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by depr on Friday May 20, 2022 @06:03PM (#31453075)
I hope that means you can retire at 40? Because otherwise I'm not sure if you're aware you're going to die one day and you can't bring your money.
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by bradlys on Friday May 20, 2022 @06:44PM (#31453464)
I know no one who is on my path who wants to be working past 50. Almost everyone like myself is trying to find a way to save money + pick the right place to work for fast returns.

My problem is that I've got a real knack for choosing partners that drain accounts dry instead of adding to it. (One part where I differ from my peers)

I'd love to tap out by 40 but that ship sailed and sunk.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by junon on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:41PM (#31452256)
Jobs as a software engineer at 1m/year? Sorry, I simply don't believe you.
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by bradlys on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:44PM (#31452278)
Stock appreciation is a hell of a drug. I have worked with multiple engineers making multiple millions a year. They were all ICs.

To break into the 1% in SV - you need to make $3.6mil/yr. Just let that sink in. It's a very rich place.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by junon on Friday May 20, 2022 @07:28PM (#31453833)
I didn't get that stock was part of that equation. I took it as base salary. SV is an outlier, really wish people would stop talking as though that's a universal amount, and that if you don't make that amount then you're not senior. I lived in SV and it's a disgustingly money-oriented culture.
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by bufferoverflow on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:33PM (#31452780)
There are software engineers that make much more

https://techcrunch.com/2010/11/11/google-offers-staff-engine...

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by runako on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:44PM (#31452281)
You need to speak to more senior people who work at companies that make their money selling software or Internet services. ("Senior" is not 5 years of experience. Think engineers in their 30s & 40s.)
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by junon on Friday May 20, 2022 @07:28PM (#31453842)
I wish people would stop talking to me as if I don't realize this. This conversation gets had every week on HN and people talk as though seniority is this rich person only club that applies everywhere.
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by runako on Friday May 20, 2022 @11:14PM (#31454960)
Nevermind, carry on then. Top engineers usually max out at around $200k all-in. Sorry for the confusion.
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by korijn on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:20PM (#31452056)
I don't think they said they currently are. I hope for their sake they moved on because it doesn't sound like they had a particularly great time.

On topic: there are plenty of great employers in our industry but you will have to make an effort to find them. And of course it's never going to be perfect.

Maybe this is an odd proposition, but if you can't find no-whiteboard employers in SV, why don't you go looking elsewhere?

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by naniwaduni on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:22PM (#31452076)
It's still paying the bills and 80% of these problems aren't industry-exclusive?
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by bradlys on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:32PM (#31452162)
I agree. A lot of these are not industry exclusive to tech/SV. However, we take it a bit further at times and more importantly we advertise that we're different. We like to think we're different. Other industries don't try to act like they're different. You go into law, biz, med, etc... You know what you're signing up for. You need to be a little brown nosing subservient ass hat - and everyone knows it. And everyone knows when you get to the top - you get to subject everyone everyone else to your whims, your hazing rituals, and so forth. They know that's the reward for getting to the top. Boss says you do X even if it's unethical to ask - in other industries you do it anyway. In SV, we act like it's okay for you to question it even if your boss will still fire you for insubordination.

The difference is subtle but it's that SV at least tries to act like it's different even if they're not. That's what rubs me wrong about this industry the most. The virtue signaling without any real actions behind it. It is truly ghoulish.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by angarg12 on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:16PM (#31452610)
In the big scheme of things, there are worse things that grinding leetcode in order to land a 6 figure job.
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by 0x20cowboy on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:20PM (#31452063)
> These are common problems at companies within SV. Leetcode is hardly a problem when you see how fucking terrible the rest is.

Am I understanding this logic? Are you saying let’s keep terrible, arguably pointless interview processes and needless gate keeping because there are other bad things in this world?

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by bradlys on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:21PM (#31452070)
No, I’m saying there are bigger fish to fry. LC is easy compared to this other shit.

LC makes your job search terrible. The work culture makes your life terrible.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by mountainriver on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:04PM (#31452478)
Cultures that accept LC are more likely to make your life terrible.

I work for a company that pays well and doesn’t do LC because of all the obvious reasons, and that is a representation of the culture.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by bradlys on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:09PM (#31452540)
$400k+/yr well for senior eng or “I think it’s enough”?
Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by knorker on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:37PM (#31452218)
Sometimes you have to do the stupid thing because the boss or the client tells you to.

Some of those times you get to say "I told you so", later.

But the reason you get paid is because someone wants to pay you to do it. You can try to convince them to do it right, but in the end it's their money. Do you want it?

When you have the control you can try to make the better hiring system, but since you're asking i assume you're not in a position to dump your balls on the table and say you won't play their game, but they should still hire you.

It's a gamble to as your first impression show that you're not a team player.

Re:Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leet... by mountainriver on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:04PM (#31452487)
Exactly, yeah let’s all keep going along with this nonsense cause ya know?