I learned quickly that the constants were the slopes of the best fit on a log graph. And that you could never intersect that curve with $today, you had to estimate your delivery date and use the intersection at that point for all planning. E.g.: vram budget for textures, polygon count limits, etc…
I’ve never seen this kind of thinking by management at any level, in any industry outside of computer game development.
I’ve tried explaining it to IT managers to no avail.
E.g.: don’t get a 10% discount now by buying 200 servers up front in a single sale! Buy 100 now at full price and 50 servers that are twice as powerful two years later.
Nope… got to get those sweet volume discounts…
Otherwise known as "Skate to where the puck will be, not where it has been. -- Wayne Gretzky."
This is fairly common in other software-related industries, eg. mobile. Uber was not physically possible when the company was founded in 2008 - most phones didn't have GPS, and when they did, it drained the battery too quickly for the phone to charge from a car. Same with Whatsapp's founding in 2009 - the push notifications that let it catch on weren't actually available until a year after the product first came out. I know a number of Silicon Valley drone transportation companies that know their product isn't feasible today, but are betting on improvements in battery technology.
Oftentimes the market (and underlying technology) pivots into the startup, the startup doesn't pivot into the market. Many of the big pandemic successes like Zoom, Toast, Marco Polo, Peloton, etc. already existed before the pandemic, they just happened to luck out when everybody got shut up at home.
I've had this experience myself. I usually find that I was overlooking important inputs to, constraints on or goals behind the decision.
> Buy 100 now at full price and 50 servers that are twice as powerful two years later
As someone who buys a lot of hardware for my employer, I can tell you that performance is only one of several interrelated considerations that goes in to purchasing decisions, and is far from the most important.
For that matter, exactly the same thing can be said about the price.
Of course! Unfortunately and somewhat sadly, later on I discovered that these constraints and goals boiled down to one of a few categories:
1) Got to spend the budget this FY, otherwise we get our budget cut.
2) A big enough sale at once means the sales person is more likely to give me a kick-back.
3) The overhead of the procurement process is so obscenely enormous that it swamps any potential cost saving. A single procurement cycle instead of two is literally cheaper overall than, say, a $500K saving on the hardware.
4) The procurement process is not that expensive, but I am that lazy. It's not my money, so why bother optimising it? It is my time and effort to do the procurement twice however...
5) I can't count, and that 10% discount looked really sweet. There is some techo telling me to buy most of this stuff later, but what does he know? I studied finance! I'm an MBA! I'm a business person now!
All Intel-compatible servers have been essentially perfectly compatible with each other for decades.
All major brands will keep selling server kit. It's not like you have to throw away your IBM brand Intel-based servers and replace them with ARM chips from some no-name vendor!
My point is that in next year and the year after, and the year after that IBM will sell you faster and faster servers. Also... bigger and bigger. At roughly the same price point. With largely (if not entirely) compatible management systems, drivers, etc...
Speaking of drivers: VMware and similar hypervisors have almost completely eliminated driver compatibility as a concern. Clusters can contain wildly different gear without issues.
There's a lack of understanding in the industry by older managers that gained their experience in the "before times" when even the firmware had to be consistent for a cluster of servers.
For example, the local budget airline Jetstar would buy used servers from Ebay.
Why?
Why not!
Why would you need "support" if a server dies? It is stateless (diskless!) and just 1% of your capacity! Just throw it out.
Why would you care about driver updates if all of your VMs are using emulated hypervisor drivers only?
Why would you care if a server is "used" if chips don't "wear out"?
Etc...
Where can we sign up?
Also the machines have to go somewhere and that costs a lot because if someone can do it cheaper they'll just sell VPSs for cheaper than you can host them. Doing it cheaper means more compute per rack/watt which means newer hardware.
There are also sometimes nontechnical business considerations that matter enough that you make tradeoffs around them.
That is why so little storage is being built, thus far. Costs for storage are falling even faster than wind or solar ever did, because there is nothing to be overcome except limits on scaling manufacturing. The physics of energy storage, chemical schemes excepted, are a matter of freshman physics, so the drive is only how to apply the same principles more cheaply.
Simplicity is the greatest virtue: if you can make a storage system with just one moving part, you have the makings of a winner. Many involve anchoring something to the sea floor: an air bladder with a hose to an air pump and turbine onshore, charged by pumping in air; a float with a cable down to a pulley, thence to a winch and motor/generator onshore, charged by dragging the float down to the bottom; an air tank with an electric pump/turbine just wired to shore, charged by evacuating the tank.
The overwhelming majority of storage will not be batteries, ever. But molten metal batteries have massive advantages over lithium, longevity and heat tolerance probably most important. Iron-air batteries are much cheaper.
Hydrogen and ammonia synthesis will not be as cheap as the others, but have the massive advantage that, because tankage is cheap and transportable, storage capacity is unlimited; and when as much tankage as you care to keep is full, any extra generating capacity yields a high-demand product, thus extra revenue. Furthermore, if your local storage gets looking likely to run dry, you just buy more.
Compatibility with existing natural gas generators is a plus; thus, compressed air, liquified nitrogen, hydrogen and ammonia. Burning something with compressed air increases efficiency.
Energy Vault is bald grift, the Theranos of storage.
Why not? Lithium iron phosphate batteries work fine, don't cost too much, don't have a thermal runaway problem, are good for 10,000 cycles, require little maintenance, have good energy density per unit volume, and you can buy them right now. They're heavier than lithium ion batteries, but in stationary installations, that doesn't matter. Something better may come along, but they're good enough to deploy now.
Utility batteries, where used, will be iron-air or molten metal. Light weight is no virtue in that use.
If those numbers are correct and we want cars that each have 50 kWh batteries, we can have up to about 2.2 billion cars, so we either get more lithium (seawater is 1000x more in quantity but IIRC not economical at this time), or we don’t all get to have electric cars.
This is making me go back to an older preference of mine, which is to have a really fat wire (order of 1m^2 cross section) going around the planet. Take years (literally) to mine and process that quantity, but in principle you can get winter solstice pre-dawn energy from your antipode. The losses, while large, are not catastrophic.
Long distance transmission has become very practical as the top-line cost of generation has fallen far below historic lows.
You don't need a square meter in cross section. There will be a hell of a lot of long distance transmission lines. Singapore is all in on one to northern Australia. UK has signed a deal for one to Africa.
If there’s any single entity I expect to have both the economic power and originational capacity to do that, it’s the Chinese government.
The main reason is that the cables are much cheaper than the storage (so a massive incentive if you can do it), but 15000 km * 1m^2 * density of copper is 1.3e8 tons, and current global annual production is 2e7 tons, and a similar problem for aluminium. Need a lot of organisation of the wider economy to pull that off.
https://www.pv-magazine.com/2021/11/15/chile-wants-to-export...
Pretty big categorical statement.
The problem with the "one moving part" storage systems is that their energy density is surprisingly bad. Gravitational potential energy in particular is terrible. Compressed air systems can be OK, especially the ones using underground reservoirs, but have an efficiency limited by the physics of gas expansion.
It's pretty hard to beat redox reactions for energy density. As you say, tankage is cheap, so can this be done with "flow batteries"?
But the real reason lithium is winning is the incredible power of path dependence and manufacturing efficiency. Is it the optimal chemists's whiteboard solution to churn out a billion 18650 cells? No. Is it the one that's easier to actually do in the world as it exists today? Possibly.
Chemical synthesis systems suffer on cost per watt to charge, but hit it out of the park on joules stored per dollar. Further pluses are bulk-shippable storage media that may be bought and sold, and can be discharged using existing gas turbines, even in places where you have not installed any synthesis apparatus.
It's probably best if we increase the carbon price until the market figures out how much storage is economical.
Huh? Why would you not charge your utility battery bank with surplus solar or wind power?
Bonus: at the point when solar or wind power would be curtailed (when it is generating more supply than the grid demands), is also when the wholesale price per MWh is zero or negative, making it free or profitable to charge your batteries.
Because you spent the money on more generating capacity, instead, and displaced exactly that much more carbon emission.
You put any excess power on a transmission line to someplace else that would otherwise be burning fossil fuel, and collect revenue. Maybe spend that on more generation.
If you are maxing out your transmission lines, spend money building those out. The more of those you have, the more places you can get revenue from.
When it starts to look like there will be nobody left to sell your excess to, then build storage.
Just from an economic standpoint it can also be a valid choice to build storage next to unpredictable generating capacity, for example if you build a wind farm and want to sell during daytime (when prices are highest) as much as possible.
(Technically, a 100% renewable grid could go negative I'd there were separate subsidies, but as soon as renewable goes below that level it would just be shut off rather than pay money to generate.)
That is better though for when the renewable plant isn’t running.
But I do like the idea that these industries might actually be motivated to progress faster now if people hold off on getting on board. Seems like its enough of a reality that they can justify r&d to make the last push toward real competitiveness.
Then again my brains fried from work and I don't know what I'm talking about.
All I know is I want me some solar panels and an electric F150.
The best thing for a house power bank is a used-up electric car.
Instead, for the maximum cleaning up of energy, we should build nuclear for the grid and use batteries on transportation.
But in particular, the iron-flow battery story going around recently stinks pretty badly. It's being heavily promoted almost entirely by one company, ESS, and their first real client is -- wait for it -- SoftBank [1]. The academic reports on iron-flow batteries [2] make the technology sound a lot less mature than the ESS website [3], which incorrectly refers to vanadium and lithium as "rare-earth metals".
A 2018 publication [4] from Narayan's group at USC boasts that:
>Thus, by operating at 60°C and a pH of 3 with ascorbic acid and ammonium chloride, we achieved a coulombic efficiency of 97.9%. While this value of coulombic efficiency is among the highest values reported for the iron electrode in the context of the all-iron flow battery, further improvement in efficiency is needed for supporting repeated cycling.
However, further work by Narayan's group led them to replace iron chloride by iron sulfate in 2020 [5] which was celebrated by USC in a press release [6].
It was shortly after this that ESS burst onto the scene claiming iron chloride batteries with extremely long cycle life using "carbon composite" electrodes, "porous polyethylene separator" and a "polypropene spacer" [3], which are suspiciously similar to the graphite electrodes, mesoporous hydrocarbon-polymer-not-disclosed (Tokuyama A901 [7]) anion-exchange membrane, and polypropylene housing used in the Narayan group's 2016 paper [8] proposing all-iron-flow batteries for grid storage. It's worth noting that chemically unmodified polyethylene is probably not a suitable material for an ion-selective membrane, but it wouldn't even be the second-worst mistake on the page.
Yet ESS, despite having supposedly solved major problems that are obviously of scientific interest to active researchers, does not appear to have any names on its website, and cites no publications. Frankly, it sounds like another EEStor.
1: https://cleantechnica.com/2021/10/07/first-ess-iron-flow-bat...
2: https://dornsife.usc.edu/labs/narayan/all-iron-redox-flow-ba...
3: https://essinc.com/iron-flow-chemistry/
4: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S245191031...
5: https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1149/1945-7111/ab84f8/...
6: https://news.usc.edu/166306/flow-battery-renewable-energy-el...
7: https://watermark.silverchair.com/jeecs_18_2_024001.pdf
8: https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1149/2.0161601jes/pdf
A dollar spent on renewables buys several times what a nuke could produce, and immediately, not ten years from now and buying fuel in the meantime. The money spent just on the fuel over that time would mostly pay for building the renewables.
Is it possible to just spend infinite dollars today and solve the climate crisis by tomorrow?
https://www.lazard.com/media/451905/lazards-levelized-cost-o...
Every year the cost of nuclear increases because we have fewer examples of successful construction and more examples of failed construction. The industry is in shambles, effectively dead. The US attempts at construction of AP1000s resulted in 2/4 failing, and the other two reactors being several multiples behind in schedule and pricing. The latest excuse for the failure is that they began construction before design was complete, so of course they failed. However this was the request of the nuclear industry, in an attempt to bring down prices, and the entire regulatory approval process was changed to accommodate this, which was supposed to bring down prices and prevent the failure of construction. Look at any attempt to build nuclear in a modern economy and you will find failure, not success.
As for spending infinite dollars to solve climate change, no, that is not possible. There are real productive limits to capacity to build things. The solar, wind, and storage industries are growing at massive rates, but still its only barely enough to meet the speed needed for our energy transition.
If we had infinite money to spend on nuclear, we still would not be able to build sufficient new restore by, say 2040. In the US alone we would need to build ~100 reactors simply to replace those reaching their end of life. We do not have the construction capacity for that, much less a design to build, or willing financial backers.
For the foreseeable future, nuclear is a dying industry in the US, not because of regulation or public backlash, but because the industry can't build.
The only hope for nuclear in the US or Europe is for small modular reactors, a design that in the past has been rejected for being too expensive. But since it's closer to manufacturing (like a plane) than like construction, there's hope, even if it's a long shot.
I.e., if you are trying to scare up money for a big enough nuke plant to be worth installing, the stakeholders you would need on board will see noplace to skim off the money they demand to greenlight the project.
Thus far solar and wind seem thus far resistant to graft, for reasons that are easy to speculate about, but hard to prove.
It's much easier to take some graft off a super size construction project with few bidders and massive transaction costs compared to small repeatable transactions that happen with smaller projects.
Nuclear construction often ends up with people in jail. It's happening in South Carolina, and happened in South Korea too, and up until the corruption was found, SK had been touted as a modern nuclear success story that could maybe be replicated in the US.
So we are left with only China and Russia's Rosatom as the only builders that claim to be able to deliver at a reasonable cost. We just need to trust the builders enough to construct in our countries, with our workforces, and somehow get a hugely complex construction project with lots of high-precision welding and construction pours done on time and accurately.
Solar projects are useful at smaller sizes, so need fewer stakeholders, making it easier to find honest ones. People choosing to be involved with renewables are more often self-selected for idealism.
That's because the graft happens earlier in the process before the actual "build the thing" portion so you don't notice. The developer typically pisses away money directly or indirectly getting on the good side of the local powers that be before actually pulling the trigger on the project.
Contrast with nuclear or any other centralized power generation where the state gets involved. Sure, money gets pissed away in similar ways on those projects (pay off special interest X, promise a favorable rate for Y, etc) but it tends to not technically be graft because it's all done through the official processes.
Prices for big solar installations are in the public record. And for nukes. Recently North Carolina and Georgia spent, what, $15B for exactly 0 watts out. They were quoted another $10B to get the 2GW they had signed up for, which they had expected to pay, what, $8B for, total? They won't get any of it back.
The corruption tax on nukes is withering. Nobody involved wants the money to ever stop flowing, as actually delivering would cause.
The best I have seen for nukes is $2B/1GW, but nobody knows how to get that with any reliability; and that is discounted by a huge government disaster-insurance subsidy, and excludes ~$1B end-of-life decommissioning. I see $1B/1GW for recently finished solar projects, but prices are still falling fast.
No. Factories need to be build, infrastructure needs to be build with infinite money and an coordinated centrally planned effort it should be possible within 15 years to be net neutral.
This would include: electrifying all of africa, world wide giga grid, replacing all combustion motors, building a new fleet to replace all cargo vessels, build rail to curb all non trans ocean flights, radically cut down militaries all over the world, build a lot of heat pumps, building a lot of buildings in a carbon neutral way, also a lot of other environmental concerns (species protection, eco system protection) would need to be curbed for it to happen in 15 years, more flexibility if you relax that timeframe.
Modular thorium reactors would be a huge win if realized.
You need to watch some thorium debunking videos. I live near Indian Point, recently shut down. They tried thorium, early on. It cost too much. Every single thing about nukes costs too much.
I skimmed the Indian Point reactor -- it appears to be a non-LFTR reactor, and that seems to be where the excitement continues.
But yeah, renewables are great and only getting better. If we had taken a trillion dollars out of the fiasco of the Gulf Wars (ostensibly for "energy security") we could have done significant things. For example, I'm enamored with the possibilities of geothermal around the Yellowstone caldera -- if we could figure out how to do that without destroying the local environment.
Rebuilding The Grid with HVDC would help too, as well as an ammonia economy to utilize excess power from wind. It all seems very technically doable, it's the politics and petrol people that stand between us and a carbon free energy ecosystem (well, with reasonable exceptions for aerospace and other special cases)
Really, anything that needs a steam turbine is going to cost too much to compete.
If your electricity generation is fossil moving to EVs is of questionable benefit.
> Instead, for the maximum cleaning up of energy, we should build nuclear for the grid and use batteries on transportation.
We are talking about solar power costs exponentially dropping and your suggestion is to build nuclear, the slowest to build and already much less economical than solar. By the time your nuclear power plants are build you could buy ~10 times the capacity in solar and likely would not need any battery storage.
Several of the established players are close to achieving dry-low-NOx 100% hydrogen gas turbines. Then you are talking about >500 MW power per unit and a thermodynamic efficiency of >65%. If you are in the "extremely abundant but too variable renewable power" scenario, these things will be the major stabilisers. You can easily imagine smoothing out even seasonal fluctuations with them.
There has been some work on modding how well this could work for changing EV rebate incentives, but getting legislatures to adopt such complicated ideas is nearly impossible.
Another approach would be to add a realistic, risk-adjusted carbon tax to gasoline (probably north of $200/ton co2, or $2/gallon gasoline) and let the market sort it out. Unfortunately when it comes to car purchasing, consumers are less economically rational than even legislators.
Over the long term, any batteries sold are good batteries, because batteries exhibit large economies of scale. Profit on existing sales can fund new production facilities; incremental improvements in battery technology; R&D into capacity increases; improved distribution networks; R&D into new sources of lithium; and so on. The way you get dirt-cheap storage is to build lots of it.
In the more exotic architectures and chemistries, what's moving the needle is the exotic military or medical need, where the battery can be 10x more expensive on the OEM BOM and barely move the actual end unit price to the final user.
There is no realistic way to GENERALLY determine the price of the kWh coming out of a grid scale battery due to the large number of variables, such as battery lifepan, wholesale production rates, land and permitting cost, etc.
Capacitors are capable of delivering high levels of power but have relatively small energy storage capacity compared to batteries.
Grid scale batteries need to be sized in terms of both charge/discharge rates (kW/MW) and energy storage (kWh/MWh)
Short-term storage wants high charge and discharge rate, efficiency and durability. Longer-term storage mainly favors cheap capacity, and tolerates low charging rate and low efficiency.
I don't quite understand what you think is missing though, every industry and company I've had experience with has forecast things and planned based on some estimated intersection of many moving parts.
The thermal coal industry has to forecast electricity demand, competition, coal demand, coal prices, building and mining prices, regulatory environment, etc. to build and operate mines and power plants., out to about 50 years.
I don't know how much renewables have really caught the industry off guard, but rapid advancements in technology has caused many to come unstuck, especially those in the technology industry (Nvidia et al killed SGI, Intel killed DEC and Sun, and so on).
It's not that it's just renewables catching the old dinosaurs off guard here, it's going both ways because energy is obviously very volatile and highly complex. The Moore's law era gains in transistor performance and density were obviously vastly larger changes but they were actually very consistent and easy to predict by comparison, some guy can't remember his name now even made up a trivial formula for it that held up extremely well for 50 years! With a few relatively minor tweaks. In contrast there have been proclamations for many years now that wind and solar have killed coal. That the price points have crossed over, that coal is dead and coal infrastructure is a worthless asset. Today, thermal coal prices are at historic record highs. Someone is buying it and someone is making a killing digging it up. And a lot of executives are kicking themselves for divesting at the bottom of the market thinking it was worthless except for the free kudos they thought it would get them boasting about something they were going to do for financial reasons anyway.
It's hardly anything to boast about predicting silicon device improvements when others struggle to predict energy markets.
There are other forms of competition that work better. The form used in CA, OH, and MA is community choice aggregation, which lets municipalities buy electricity for their residents. Newton MA procures 80% of its electricity as renewable. Marin County CA is at 100%. CCAs reduce residential electric bills by 2-9% vs monopoly utilities. With CCA you get the price reductions of the free market, combined with the protections of regulation. The only opposition comes from utilities.
There certainly are. The one that works best is the free market.
Would you say food is in that category? The free market is the only system that has ever provided a consistent food surplus. The US, with its free market, became the first country with food security and you can see it in the statistics - the average height of Americans increased throughout the 19th century, peaking out around WW2.
> why we don't put municipal water on the free market
Instead we have water intensive almonds being grown in an arid area undergoing a record drought, alongside the government blocking desalination plants (California)
> why Texas can't keep the lights on
Texas is undergoing a record heat wave. Rolling blackouts are predicted this summer for California.
> no sane country would try to distribute healthcare on a free market
Health care in the US was cheap before the government got involved in it.
Modern food surplus is mainly thanks to the Green Revolution, thanks to advancements in fertilizers, pesticides, and machinery. A lot of that was government-lead.
On top of the heavily-controlled agriculture there is mostly a free market for consumer products (just needs to be regulated not to save costs by causing cancers), but that has innovated into making junk food cheaper than a healthy diet.
These are not failures of the free market. The growth of junk food can be attributed in large part to corn subsidies.
Now, if you attribute the success of agriculture to the government, why have all the collective farming systems failed completely? Why did the USSR have to import wheat from Kansas?
Modern wheat came from Norman Borlaug's research, which was funded by the Rockefeller Foundation - not a government project. He received a well-earned Nobel Peace Prize for it.
The Haber-Bosch process was developed at BASF, a private company, and was the first industrialized production of fertilizer.
> heavily-controlled agriculture
That's simply not true. A subsidy is not "control". The government does not direct what gets produced, who produces it, how it is produced, nor does it take the profits.
Only for those who were healthy and had employer provided insurance. Everyone else either went without or paid through the nose or was dropped as soon as they actually needed services. Healthcare premiums are more expensive now because the insurance is a much better product for many people.
On the other hand, the closer one gets to socialism, the worse it works :-(
No evidence? It's all around you. The US for mostly free market. It's done spectacularly well. For communism, how about the USSR, N. Korea, etc. They're not hard to find. Do you think they did well? I read somewhere that N. Koreans were 4 inches shorter than their southern neighbors. Does that sound like hard over socialism is a success?
Why is it that every country and society that tried collective farms starved, and sometimes resorted to cannibalism?
The Pilgrims tried collective farming for their first year. They starved. Jamestown tried collective farms. They starved. The Israeli Kibbutzen are propped up by the government, as they cannot produce enough food. Kansas was called the "Breadbasket of the Soviet Union." And on and on.
I saw on the news the other day an interview with a fellow trying to get in the US via the southern border. He has nothing. He spent 4 months getting from Cuba to that border. What would motivate someone to do that? Triumphant socialism in Cuba?
Europe is arguably a less free market than the US but it's by no means clear which one is working better. Somalia ruled by the warlords was a freer market but nobody was emigrating from the US to Somalia.
That kinda sank your argument, as Somalia is anarchy, not a free market.
> it's by no means clear which one is working better
The US economy does much better than the European one. Look at investment returns, for example. Look at which country all the FAANG companies are in.
> That kinda sank your argument, as Somalia is anarchy, not a free market.
A free market is an economical system, anarchy is a political one. They are orthogonal to each other. In fact there are anarcho capitalists (the most extreme liberterians) and anarchistic socialists.
> > it's by no means clear which one is working better
> The US economy does much better than the European one. Look at investment returns, for example.
Investment returns? There are many developing nations that have higher than both. They are significantly based on risk of the investment.
> Look at which country all the FAANG companies are in.
So? They are also in the most regulated (least free market) state in the US, that really doesn't prove anything.
The evidence is everywhere, and very strong.
And, shall we compare infant mortality figures? How about life expectancy? Europe does better than the US on all but mean income, which is skewed by billionaires. Having more billionaires does not favor your argument.
Life expectancy: America has a big problem with obesity, which is a side effect of prosperity. Obesity negatively influences life expectancy.
Income: income needs to be expressed in terms of Purchasing Power Parity. Besides, what evidence do you have that this is skewed by billionaires?
I'll stick with average height. It's a pretty good indicator of a prosperous country, up until the genetic potential is reached.
As for the Dutch, having traveled in Holland, they appear to have a culture of more healthy food. It's their choice, and this choice is available to Americans, too. Nobody makes Americans drink soda pop all day.
And, American obesity, and (more to the point) prevalence of metabolic disorder causing it, is not a product of prosperity. It is, ultimately, a product of dysfunctional government, with a consequence of falling prosperity.
That’s clearly a direct contradiction. So basically nobody is actually promoting free markets, they all have their own spin to get past these contradictions.
I don't know where the idea that free markets require perfect information comes from.
As for monopolies, the historical ones are ones set up and enforced by the government.
SO never had a market share that exceeded 90%. Throughout the years-long anti-trust trial, SO's market share declined, as competitors had learned how to compete with SO.
During the height of SO, the consumer price of kerosene dropped 70%. There is no evidence SO harmed consumers or charged monopoly prices.
As for Microsoft, they never had more than 90% share, there were always alternatives consumers could buy (Linux and Apple), and their market share has slipped quite a bit since the Justice Dept took no action against them. There's no evidence Microsoft charged monopoly prices - they charged with giving away free copies of their browser! They still give it away for free.
Nobody ever demonstrated any harm to consumers from Microsoft.
Standard oil was the massively dominant player which controlled enough of the oil supply to be able to set the market price because the competition had insufficient capacity to make up the difference and there was a lack of an equivalent substitute good(s). That’s the economic definition of a monopoly.
As to being convinced, it isn’t illegal to become a monopoly.
> set the market price
Again, the "market price" declined by 70% under SO's alleged monopoly.
“Every contract, combination in the form of trust or otherwise, or conspiracy, in restraint of trade or commerce among the several States, or with foreign nations, is declared to be illegal.”
Don’t constrain trade and it’s perfectly legal to become a monopoly. Not being a monopoly is a defense but so is not constraining commerce.
You run into situations where people can’t trust a gas station is actually selling gas when anyone can slap an Exxon sign up. Reputation networks fill some of these roles, but gatekeepers aren’t free markets.
Socialism is politics.
We have not yet hit the linear part of the sigmoid, and are not close. But the good modes out there take that sigmoid shape into account.
(Also, why don't Singularity advocates know about sigmoids?)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31429475
and there is just the one free parameter k. Sometimes in practice have a shot at estimating k.
They think the curve goes so far up the y axis before it flattens off that it might as well be exponential to us monkeys stuck at the bottom of the slope.
I also see, as a common trope, people talking about “the knee of the exponential”; as they clearly don’t know how the exponential function works, I have no idea what they think.
d/dt y(t) = k y(t) (b - y(t))
Solve that and get a sigmoid, lazy S, curve. Yup, the solution, easy closed form, first calculus, is in terms of exponentials.
Could use that to model, say, the growth of immunity to Covid-19. Once it was used to project the growth of FedEx -- pleased the BoD and saved the company.
Addition: Ah, will save you a little first calculus. In TeX,
$$ y(t) = { y(0) b e^{bkt} \over y(0) \big ( e^{bkt} - 1 \big ) + b} $$
For example, one of the big wins was diamond (I think?) cutters for crystalline silicon, which allowed panels to be made rig far less inputs. A big competitor before that was thin film, and maybe you have heard of Solyndra, who had a heat tech that was made obsolete because this advancement in cutting silicon.
Any improvement along the chain of silicon production to siping to assembly has a chance to reduce costs, and it's usually small incremental bits of 1% here or 2% there.
The reason we are getting steady cost reduction is steady volume increase in production.
For decades we have been massively under-served in PV production volume. Even now, we are still somewhere in the middle of that S-curve.
I haven't seen such data, but panel in the early C20th probably followed a similar learning curve to PV now.
Don't forget that all those optimization methods developed by Soviet mathematicians found great adoption by corporate planners in capitalist societies!
The book Red Plenty is a great book about both these ideas and the history of the USSR. I can't recommend it enough for technical folks, it's a book that made me interested in economics like never before.
With companies like Amazon taking over large sections of retail consumption and allocation in our economy, the ideas are extremely relevant today. What could Amazon do with a massive AI that the USSR could not do? Definitely more, but they probably can not solve the computation problem of an entire economy.
Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos differ from Lenin and Mao mainly in firing people instead of executing them.
The biggest refutation of historial materialism is that it was Russia and China, nearly feudal societies, that tried to adopt his ideas and skip the capitalist stage, or at least have the capitalist stage be managed by committed Marxists that would shepherd the transformation. Of course the USSR faltered, and China has adopted more and more capitalism as of late, and it's hard to classify as Marxist other than it is authoritarian and oppressive, a natural consequence of any society build on Marxist ideals.
And perhaps all these capitalist societies in the West will eventually become what Marx envisioned, once there is adequate abundance, but I personally doubt it heavily. Marx's conception of the labor theory of value, in addition to historical Materialism, are pretty well shot down as terrible theory, IMHO. And I say that as someone who aspires to a socialist society. Marx had some good ideas and some really terrible ones, but I think Marxists of today are some of the biggest obstacles towards advancing to more socialism, just as much an obstacle as Libertarians or all stripes of conservatives.
I would also note that opposition to Marx has been a consistent thread throughout socialist history, so I'm not alone on this.
Even the libertarians will acknowledge that the rights of money and property are protected by force.
Note that this does not involve forcing anyone to do anything. It just says what people cannot do.
All societies force their members to do something to be part of them, and some societies do not allow people to leave, even if they disagree with core parts of that social contract.
I disagree with large chunks of the US social contract, but find it a good balance overall. Yet I am still forced to take part in many systems that I would rather not take part in.
It's inescapable.
And even if I were to find my spot, generate massive wealth, and I'm outside any society forcing me to do anything, I will now find that other societies I'm not part of, that have lots of weapons, might want to come and take whatever wealth I have generated, by force. And who will stop them unless I use force back?
If you don't feel that society in the US forces you to beg Ave in certain ways, then either you have somehow licked intro eh one society that perfectly matches your views on every single matter, or you are not aware of how our society is forcing you to do things that you would rather now do.
http://bactra.org/weblog/918.html
"Attention conservation notice: Over 7800 words about optimal planning for a socialist economy and its intersection with computational complexity theory. This is about as relevant to the world around us as debating whether a devotee of the Olympian gods should approve of transgenic organisms. (Or: centaurs, yes or no?) Contains mathematical symbols but no actual math, and uses Red Plenty mostly as a launching point for a tangent."
I made it about a quarter of the way through before I had to return my copy to the library - not because it wasn't well written, but my attention span has been shot by the internet and smart phones.
If we wish to reap the "wisdom of the crowd" benefits of "free market" ideals then we need to make sure that wealth remains relatively well distributed.
So much of the industry is caught completely flat-footed, and projections and modeling are tweaked and changed until the projections for solar, wind, and storage, are often out of date and wrong by the time they are published.
Utilities are used to planning with five year time frames, but they will often use estimates from publications that are years old, and the publication may have been under review for a year, in addition to data collection time. So it's not unusual for utilities to do planning with numbers that are 10 years off of where they should be. It takes private citizens to cajole utilities and Public Utilities Commissions to practice basic good decision making.
There are two exceptions to the complete lack of innovation in the industry: Renewable Portfolio Standards that force utilities to change their production by force of law, and open markets in places like Texas where people can see how bad the decision making is from the old school and outcompete with their own generation sources. (and each of these states has had their own planning failures, both connected to improper governance at the PUC level, which is likely due to captured regulators.)