Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030
by kelseyfrog on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @08:01PM
(#31429107)
Since the early parts of sigmoid and exponential curves are indistinguishable, the singularity advocates opt for the more interesting of the two. The question people are most interested in "what's the saturation level?" of sigmoids has such a large prediction interval that it's next to useless to estimate from data.
Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030
by graycat on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @09:08PM
(#31429532)
Right, extrapolation from the present and past where the growth has been exponential is not promising. But if somehow know the saturation level, upper asymptote, then what are doing is more like interpolation than extrapolation. Then the sigmoid curve is the solution to the differential equation I posted here a few minutes ago here at
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31429475
and there is just the one free parameter k. Sometimes in practice have a shot at estimating k.
Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030
by flir on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @08:52PM
(#31429419)
> (Also, why don't Singularity advocates know about sigmoids?)
They think the curve goes so far up the y axis before it flattens off that it might as well be exponential to us monkeys stuck at the bottom of the slope.
Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030
by ben_w on Thursday May 19, 2022 @12:35PM
(#31436836)
While I think this, I have definitely seen at least one attempt to argue that progress follows a doubling time itself regularly halves and will actually reach infinite “real soon now”.
I also see, as a common trope, people talking about “the knee of the exponential”; as they clearly don’t know how the exponential function works, I have no idea what they think.
We have not yet hit the linear part of the sigmoid, and are not close. But the good modes out there take that sigmoid shape into account.
(Also, why don't Singularity advocates know about sigmoids?)