News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by ncmncm on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @09:00PM (#31429465)
Until averaged renewable generating capacity entirely matches averaged demand, money spent on storage is mostly wasted, because to charge it up you would need to burn fossil fuels. It will be radically cheaper, soon enough.

That is why so little storage is being built, thus far. Costs for storage are falling even faster than wind or solar ever did, because there is nothing to be overcome except limits on scaling manufacturing. The physics of energy storage, chemical schemes excepted, are a matter of freshman physics, so the drive is only how to apply the same principles more cheaply.

Simplicity is the greatest virtue: if you can make a storage system with just one moving part, you have the makings of a winner. Many involve anchoring something to the sea floor: an air bladder with a hose to an air pump and turbine onshore, charged by pumping in air; a float with a cable down to a pulley, thence to a winch and motor/generator onshore, charged by dragging the float down to the bottom; an air tank with an electric pump/turbine just wired to shore, charged by evacuating the tank.

The overwhelming majority of storage will not be batteries, ever. But molten metal batteries have massive advantages over lithium, longevity and heat tolerance probably most important. Iron-air batteries are much cheaper.

Hydrogen and ammonia synthesis will not be as cheap as the others, but have the massive advantage that, because tankage is cheap and transportable, storage capacity is unlimited; and when as much tankage as you care to keep is full, any extra generating capacity yields a high-demand product, thus extra revenue. Furthermore, if your local storage gets looking likely to run dry, you just buy more.

Compatibility with existing natural gas generators is a plus; thus, compressed air, liquified nitrogen, hydrogen and ammonia. Burning something with compressed air increases efficiency.

Energy Vault is bald grift, the Theranos of storage.

Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by Animats on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:53AM (#31431510)
The overwhelming majority of storage will not be batteries, ever.

Why not? Lithium iron phosphate batteries work fine, don't cost too much, don't have a thermal runaway problem, are good for 10,000 cycles, require little maintenance, have good energy density per unit volume, and you can buy them right now. They're heavier than lithium ion batteries, but in stationary installations, that doesn't matter. Something better may come along, but they're good enough to deploy now.

Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by ncmncm on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:02AM (#31431961)
We need the lithium for cars. There is literally not enough lithium known of to build enough utility storage. And, they cost way more than alternatives.

Utility batteries, where used, will be iron-air or molten metal. Light weight is no virtue in that use.

Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by ben_w on Thursday May 19, 2022 @12:17PM (#31436597)
This seemed surprising, so I looked up the estimate of the available lithium reserves (20 million tons, seems low) and lithium needed per kWh (160g), which means we can make up to 113 TWh of batteries.

If those numbers are correct and we want cars that each have 50 kWh batteries, we can have up to about 2.2 billion cars, so we either get more lithium (seawater is 1000x more in quantity but IIRC not economical at this time), or we don’t all get to have electric cars.

This is making me go back to an older preference of mine, which is to have a really fat wire (order of 1m^2 cross section) going around the planet. Take years (literally) to mine and process that quantity, but in principle you can get winter solstice pre-dawn energy from your antipode. The losses, while large, are not catastrophic.

Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by ncmncm on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:59PM (#31438649)
China has announced an intention to build a cable from China to Chile to pick up Chilean solar power in the austral summer daytime. (Chile is very nearly antipodal to China.) Surprisingly, transmission loss is calculated to be only around 50%, which is completely tolerable. I doubt they will build it, in the end, but they really, usefully could.

Long distance transmission has become very practical as the top-line cost of generation has fallen far below historic lows.

You don't need a square meter in cross section. There will be a hell of a lot of long distance transmission lines. Singapore is all in on one to northern Australia. UK has signed a deal for one to Africa.

Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by ben_w on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:16PM (#31439626)
Ooh, neat, I missed that news. 50% losses is basically what I was expecting, it’s what you get from just using state-of-the-art HVDC cables.

If there’s any single entity I expect to have both the economic power and originational capacity to do that, it’s the Chinese government.

The main reason is that the cables are much cheaper than the storage (so a massive incentive if you can do it), but 15000 km * 1m^2 * density of copper is 1.3e8 tons, and current global annual production is 2e7 tons, and a similar problem for aluminium. Need a lot of organisation of the wider economy to pull that off.

https://www.pv-magazine.com/2021/11/15/chile-wants-to-export...

Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by dzdt on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:59PM (#31439401)
The usual definition of stated "reserves" is the amount of natural resource known to exist in explored, proven deposits. As the demand for a resource increases, more exploration is done and reserves increase. It is wildly incorrect to use reserves as an estimate of the total amount of the resource available.
Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by ncmncm on Thursday May 19, 2022 @05:09PM (#31440202)
It's the total amount available in the next few years.
Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by pydry on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:31AM (#31432109)
Pumping water uphill requires no lithium.
Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by pjc50 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @05:33AM (#31432469)
Requires some pretty specific geography, though. You're not going to see one in Florida.
Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by ncmncm on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:02PM (#31438689)
There are other methods practical in Florida. You could read up on them.
Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by pjc50 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @05:30AM (#31432445)
> The overwhelming majority of storage will not be batteries, ever

Pretty big categorical statement.

The problem with the "one moving part" storage systems is that their energy density is surprisingly bad. Gravitational potential energy in particular is terrible. Compressed air systems can be OK, especially the ones using underground reservoirs, but have an efficiency limited by the physics of gas expansion.

It's pretty hard to beat redox reactions for energy density. As you say, tankage is cheap, so can this be done with "flow batteries"?

But the real reason lithium is winning is the incredible power of path dependence and manufacturing efficiency. Is it the optimal chemists's whiteboard solution to churn out a billion 18650 cells? No. Is it the one that's easier to actually do in the world as it exists today? Possibly.

Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by ncmncm on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:06PM (#31438738)
What matters is not joules per unit mass or unit volume, but per dollar, and also watts charging or discharging per dollar. Gravity and compressed air systems excel on that axis (Energy Vault excepted, of course).

Chemical synthesis systems suffer on cost per watt to charge, but hit it out of the park on joules stored per dollar. Further pluses are bulk-shippable storage media that may be bought and sold, and can be discharged using existing gas turbines, even in places where you have not installed any synthesis apparatus.

Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by adrianN on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:03AM (#31430984)
Suppose for the sake of the argument that renewables only produced power around noon. If you build more renewables until they produce more power than you need before you invest in storage you run your fossil fuel plants a lot more than if you invest a little in storage to be able to shift massive overproduction around noon to other times of the day.

It's probably best if we increase the carbon price until the market figures out how much storage is economical.

Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by NortySpock on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @09:09PM (#31429534)
'money spent on storage is mostly wasted, because to charge it up you would need to burn fossil fuels'

Huh? Why would you not charge your utility battery bank with surplus solar or wind power?

Bonus: at the point when solar or wind power would be curtailed (when it is generating more supply than the grid demands), is also when the wholesale price per MWh is zero or negative, making it free or profitable to charge your batteries.

Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by ncmncm on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @10:01PM (#31429864)
> Why would you not charge your utility battery bank with surplus solar or wind power?

Because you spent the money on more generating capacity, instead, and displaced exactly that much more carbon emission.

You put any excess power on a transmission line to someplace else that would otherwise be burning fossil fuel, and collect revenue. Maybe spend that on more generation.

If you are maxing out your transmission lines, spend money building those out. The more of those you have, the more places you can get revenue from.

When it starts to look like there will be nobody left to sell your excess to, then build storage.

Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by WJW on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:02AM (#31431957)
This is already a reality on several grids across the world though. On weekend days with lots of sun and wind (ie low demand and high supply), prices dip below zero.

Just from an economic standpoint it can also be a valid choice to build storage next to unpredictable generating capacity, for example if you build a wind farm and want to sell during daytime (when prices are highest) as much as possible.

Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by ZeroGravitas on Thursday May 19, 2022 @06:02AM (#31432615)
Those negative price stories have been around for years but the last time I checked, they still weren't because we had 100% renewables, which people assume to be the case. There's someone paying that negative price and it's generally fossil producers.

(Technically, a 100% renewable grid could go negative I'd there were separate subsidies, but as soon as renewable goes below that level it would just be shut off rather than pay money to generate.)

Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by idontwantthis on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @09:33PM (#31429687)
The point is that until all fossil fuel plants are shut down, when you have “excess power” that means you could either shut down FF plant or charge some batteries. If you choose the latter then the FF plant is effectively charging the battery.

That is better though for when the renewable plant isn’t running.

Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by pkdpic on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @09:42PM (#31429751)
Yeah, I dont know if its pointless to get in early (as if now is really early) given the subsidies in some areas. And it does seem realistic to become an energy independent home for not that much investment which 10 year old me still cant believe is actually a reality.

But I do like the idea that these industries might actually be motivated to progress faster now if people hold off on getting on board. Seems like its enough of a reality that they can justify r&d to make the last push toward real competitiveness.

Then again my brains fried from work and I don't know what I'm talking about.

All I know is I want me some solar panels and an electric F150.

Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by ncmncm on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @10:07PM (#31429894)
Domestic is a whole different domain from utility-scale.

The best thing for a house power bank is a used-up electric car.

Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by _ph_ on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:52AM (#31431895)
At least here in Germany, at the grid scale, there isn't a real surplus of renewable energy most of the time, especially if you subtract all coal and gas power going into the grid. Of course on smaller scales, batteries make much more sense. For example, it is profitable to combine your private solar generation with a battery, as you don't get much by feeding your surplus generated power to the grid.
Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by tfigment on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @09:37PM (#31429717)
Also most utilities will not let you charge from grid. Its very hard to get interconnect agreement if a battery is involved
Re:1 TW of solar to be deployed annually by 2030 by natmaka on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @11:01PM (#31430173)
A distributed approach may solve many problems, enabling charging with surplus produced by renewables, and discharge when people are at work/home (<=> most of them not driving their electric cars): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle-to-grid