That's not true. The typical credit card processing fee ranges from about 1.3% to 3.5%. Average international remittance fees are about 7%. For comparison the average Bitcoin fee is about $1 right now, so 1% on a $100 transaction. So Bitcoin compares favorably to its competitors.
2) why did you pick $100 as your basis? If I try to buy a $5 sandwich in Bitcoin and have to pay 20% transaction fee that is not a good platform for transactions.
I like some parts of crypto, but transaction fees on most coins right now are not one of those parts.
As far as I understand ACH doesn't work globally
> 2) why did you pick $100 as your basis? If I try to buy a $5 sandwich in Bitcoin and have to pay 20% transaction fee that is not a good platform for transactions.
Or use lightning and pay a fraction of a cent transaction fee
No thank you. I’ll stick with my credit card. If I want to pay for something semi anonymously I’ll use cash.
You should stick with your credit card, that was literally always allowed.
People aren't doing this now though.
They are buying bitcoin and holding (hodl) or they are trading that bitcoin for other crypto.
I think most people aren't using it as a currency, more so speculation
Incidentally this is why austerity in debt-laden countries is kind of a terrible idea. You're taking a broken economy and removing what little slack remains in the system. And if the economy was broken due to corruption or incompetent government, you're kind of just betting on regime change at this point, which (apart from the human toll) won't be great economically either.
Deflationary currency is undesirable as a means of exchange because you don't want to use it, and that is also one of the reasons why central banks target low inflation rates.
isn't the prohibitive electric bill to reconcile the distributed ledger the ultimate showstopping friction?
It looks like you have the causal relationship there backwards. A bitcoin currently has value, so there's a lot of effort miners put in to get the block rewards + fees. But the amount of effort a miner puts in doesn't make the price go up, the price can move independently to hashrate.
Its digital gold thats it, its no more a store of value than antique's, rare cars, fine arts etc etc and unsurprisingly those markets can also see the bottom drop out of them for decades. Ultimately its people en masse who decide what something is worth, but big players can manipulate those markets with resources, laws, taxation, media sentiment and its easy to spook people when they value something, so dont get attached to anything if you dont want to be manipulated.
The other thing to note is, it only takes a few hundred million £ on the Asian market to get the GBP to drop against the USD in time for European markets. So there are very few entities who can cause the crypto market to fall like this. Think about that.
An antique desk that loses all value in the open market can still be used as a desk or at least firewood.
A rare car can still be used to transport yourself, as a prop in a movie, or scrap for other projects.
A "worthless" painting can still inspire, liven up a room, or gifted as a gag.
Crypto that loses its value has no other underlying utility over and above the output of /dev/random. That's a MASSIVE difference and more clearly demarcates BTC as a money laundering/Ponzi scheme rather than "digital gold" or a viable currency.
Its a decentralised currency, its not backed up by a country and their nuclear arsenal rammed down people's throats as we will possibly be seeing with Ukraine.
Notes/currency only has value where the threat of violence extends to prevent any counterfeiting attempts, so just like you see matches or cigarettes used as currency in a prison, it still has value. Its value went up when the Greeks had their financial crisis because the Greek banks stopped money leaving the country and this is the important thing, crypto is the thing that helps people move money out of a country fast across borders in a crisis. If you tried to move gold in or out of Switzerland you'll get stopped at the border, they are hot on that sort of stuff but it also shows their level of intelligence in world affairs. Crypto if done properly has a level of privacy affordable to anyone, not just the super rich but also a level of transparency to maintain its integrity from counterfeiting by criminals or the central bank.
Then there's the lack of an FDIC equivalent for crypto, which is HUGE for the "not just the super rich" demographics. The 19th and 20th centuries had many examples of runs on the bank where life savings were wiped out. Crypto exchanges have already screwed thousands, and maintaining your own wallet and transfers is not ever going mainstream even if crypto had any intrinsic worth beyond speculation—which it doesn't.
If you have the assets to gamble, that's for you to decide. I myself would rather rely on assets with underlying value that extends beyond speculation.
My house is worth way more than I think it should be. Helps my credit score. But if it and all the homes in the area suddenly and magically dropped to $0, I'd still live there, because it's a home. The reason I purchased it wasn't for speculation or my credit score; it was to live in. You can't live or eat or build in BTC. When the bottom drops out, you will only get to keep the bits and the memories of a more naive era.
If US or EU inflation hit 2000% there would be global consequences. There is no reserve asset currently large enough to redenominate US denominated assets, aid payments would collapse, and currencies pegged to the dollar would collapse. Betting on BTC for such a world is reasonable, as there would be a reasonable chance your gold reserves would be become inaccessible, seized, or both. However ammunition might be a more effective financial hedge in this situation.
If they're allowed to. Which underscores that the true innovation of Bitcoin is to circumvent rules and regulations.
How are they going to buy groceries with their BTC? Pay rent? Taxes?
Go to the local black market and exchange it for local currency? You can do that just fine with USD, too.
Does doing black-market deals in BTC somehow make you immune to arrest, prosecution, and execution?
Because fiat volatility in inflation/rate hikes respectively (ie the NPV of a USD) completely dominates the other factors.
The volatile leg here is the fiat dollar, and everything denominated in it is whipsawing around as its value changes.
S&P has only retraced to March 2021. Nasdaq to Oct 2020. A bunch of COVID plays like Zoom, Peloton, etc only back to summer 2019 levels. That's only 3 years back.
If you look at the dot-com boom, S&P bottomed out in 2002 back to 1997 levels. That's a 5 year retracement. Currently S&P has barely gone back 14 months.
The GFC was worse - bottomed in Dec 2008 hitting 1996 levels - a 12 year retracement. I'd say going back beyond an entire economic cycle is probably actually oversold.
And there isn't any definition. And particularly in response to exogenous events the markets may decide to keep dropping even though they've dropped a lot. If markets always moved in a straight line it would be easy to make a ton of money off of them so they don't. However, if markets never moved in a straight line though it would be easy to make a ton of money off of them so every now and then they do.
And mostly I'm weighing what I'm seeing, which is that the yield curve isn't inverted yet, the broader economy is healthy and job growth is good and there's way more jobs than there are job seekers, along with no signs that something of substantial size has detonated in the economy yet (CMBS or whatever). Letting the air out of the overpriced tech stocks and venture capital also just doesn't seem large enough to start to tank the economy, larger corrections have happened during mid cycle slowdowns before. And UST-Luna is barely a pimple on the broader economy.
Right now I don't believe this is the start of the next recession, so the fact that COVID plays are back to summer-2019 levels suggests to me that a lot of work has actually gotten done in repricing.
Show me an inverted yield curve and CMBS popping or maybe Russian gas to Germany gets abruptly turned off and then I'll start expecting those longer scale kinds of retracements.
...Things have corrected SLIGHTLY from an absolutely historic bubble and you think it's OVER sold?
Meanwhile, we have significant inflation, rising interest rates, supply shocks that still haven't been sorted out and signs of economic slowdown.
Prices have been out of touch with reality for a long time. We aint anywhere near a bottom yet IMO.
That is normalized to 1 in late 2007. At the end of 2021, it was 2.53; at the end of the first quarter of this year it's at 2.37. In 1Q 2020, it was 1.80. Stock prices have been increasingly disconnected from the economy 2014-2015.
This is not true, at least not for the U.S. stock market. Market indices are still up 20-30% over pre-pandemic levels.
GOOG for instance, was making a trailing $160B per year going into COVID. Now it's making a trailing $270B per year. [1]
The S&P 500 P/E ratio is down to 20 from 25 on January 1, 2020, so the S&P 500 at least is 17% cheaper now than before COVID. [2]
And looking at mid-cap tech? Shopify is trading at a lower ticker price than at the bottom of the COVID drop on March 19, 2020 - despite having tripled their revenue since then.
A lot of companies are really cheap right now.
[1] https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/GOOG/alphabet/reve...
No!!!
The Fed is raising rates. That is reality. That is not an emotion. That is absolute economic fact. Inflation is high and will remain high for at least a year (maybe longer). The period from 2008 to 2022 is going to be remembered as an abnormal period when we experienced abnormally low rates. The low rates fueled speculation, and bid up certain stocks and assets.
The era of low rates is over. It is possible that you might live another 100 years and never again see a 14 year stretch where rates average as low as they did from 2008 to 2022.
Emotions? No. These are not emotions. Rising rates are a material fact that people need to adjust to.
And they've been playing this game since the 90s and the Greenspan fed did it first a blew up the housing bubble that popped in 2008. This cycle goes beyond the memories of Millennials. It just keeps getting worse every cycle.
It’s infuriating how much the game is rigged against laborers.
Is it? Month over month inflation numbers are only slightly elevated, in the annualized 3% range. This isn't particularly high - the high inflation already happened, it's over.
CPI and PPI numbers both came in good. PPI of particular note, services were up 0% month over month, and commodities 1.3% for a blended 0.56% (in line with expectations). Commodities of course are likely to correct hard and fast once the geopolitical situation resolves.
The market is forward looking, so don't get stuck on a dead narrative!
> The era of low rates is over.
I'm not sure we know this either. If the hikes play out, we'll land around what, 2-3% for the fed funds rate? That's low, historically. And that's a big if, IMO, since inflation is showing signs of being quite well controlled again, and the Fed's goal isn't to achieve a specific funds rate - just low inflation and high employment. High funds rate hurts the employment goal.
It's fun to speculate but important to remember, you're just speculating. So am I. There's no certainty here, and it's pretty easy to construct a compelling counter-narrative.
All we know for sure right now is the Fed funds rate is 1%.
But it's not the 0.1% that drove money out of other asset classes (i.e. bonds) because they couldn't generate any returns.
[1] https://www.treasurydirect.gov/indiv/products/prod_ibonds_gl...
The 2-3% is the Fed funds rate; actual rates on government and commercial bonds will be somewhat higher. (A friend recently pointed out the current 6% advertised rate on lower-grade commercial bonds.) Couple that with much lower risks (on things that aren't those 6% bonds) and it becomes a good third option for anyone whose previous choice was between -3% inflationary return on cash and stock market risks.
The interest rate is currently at 1%. In the 80s it hit 20%. I expect it'll go negative in the next 20 years.
Goodness, I hope not. The amount of progress we've seen in these years has been astounding. Deep learning, SpaceX, smart phones. I felt like things had gotten stagnant, then we truly started hitting our stride.
Which is why I’m kinda shocked that the US isn’t more gung ho about immigration because as long as there’s more useful work to do, and there is, we can fuel growth with capital plus people.
Rates are rising, but the yield curve isn't inverted yet, and the stock market is unlikely to continue this losing streak straight down. It normally doesn't happen that way. Emotions right now are very negative and a lot of people are going to make bets thats are exceedingly negative and in the 3-6 month short term period other people will make money off of them.
This does not feel to me like the start of the crash, possibly not even the top, although we might go sideways until the crash.
And there will be low interest rates again.
The point of the Fed raising interest rates on the low end is to tank the economy hard enough to eliminate wage inflation. Given the overhang of jobs over jobseekers (and likely the effects of COVID death and disability on the workforce and boomers retiring) this one is likely to be exceedingly painful.
When the Fed engineers the economy tanking that means that rates will get slashed again and >10 year bonds will not budge upwards.
What it will look like when long rates go up is that wage inflation will actually take hold consistently.
And low rates already blew up the dot com bubble in 2001 and the housing bubble in 2008. Read up on the Greenspan Fed.
They're going to jack rates up, tank the economy and then go back to ZIRP again.
Short rates != Long rates. Fed doesn't control long rates.
Expect more losses.
One of the benefits of allowing shorting of stocks is that it provides liquidity even in the worst of times.
Does it seem completely inconceivable that the SPX might not reverse and touch $4766 again? Well why don't you take up a leveraged short position which will be highly profitable if the SPX doubles its current fall which you won't be forced to cover unless the SPX bounces back up again. It's free money.
Except double tops in the market happen, precisely because people decide it's all over and at this point in the market take out short bets, and then get burned when it bounces back up and destroys them. As the market in a doomed economy actually goes upwards they all get burned and squeezed which fuels the short squeeze bounce, even though it violates conventional wisdom.
Once you've destroyed all those people who think they've found the gold mine of a safe leveraged bet then the second downwards move can exceed these lows because those people are licking their wounds (but triple-tops happen as well).
To a certain extent the stock market is an optimization engine that ruins literally everyone who thinks they understand the short term direction of the market. If it didn't, you'd be able to make safe money off of it.
The fact that everyone in this thread thinks its all falling, falling, falling means it is probably going to bounce up about now for a bit (of course if that was a 100% safe thing though you could make safe money off of it so nothing is ever entirely certain -- and Russia might launch a nuke at NATO tomorrow).
Everythinig was way overbought when considering the money for those past purchases came from an accommodative Fed that flooded the economy with $9 trillion that currently sits on its balance sheet, lowered interest rates to literally 0 and the government sending out stimulus like it was candy.
All of which are either done or ending.
So I think a better way to phrase it is that the market is repricing with the new information, it isn't oversold.
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WALCL
Funny how debt is ignored by big media and the short fiat rates get all the attention.
Edit: Fed balance sheet relative to GDP, 2003 to present:
To emphasize the uncertainty in your "probably", I will point out that Luna didn't bounce: https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/terra-luna/
Cryptocurrencies in general, and shares of stocks, do not hyperinflate.
Obviously, it crashed so much, the "bottom" was anyone's guess (well.. zero is the only one that makes sense now). But there are bounces all the way down. If you drop a bouncy ball down an infinite staircase it doesn't take a straight line down.
I think it would take something like Russia launching nukes at NATO to cause the stock market to tank in a straight line though.
Maybe less extremely, Russian nat gas going to Germany being shut off overnight might do it as well.
Stocks/securities/crypto usually never go straight down unless it has become apparent that they're fundamentally worthless. I don't see that becoming common sentiment with the US economy.
More likely we're going to see a short squeeze start around now though. WSB on reddit is likely piling into the SPY heavily short, expecting the market to drop line a stone like it did at the start of the pandemic and they're dreaming of chicken tendies. They'll likely get blown out in a squeeze.
Likely, likely, probably though.
I can also predict the winner of the premiere league today based on the odds, but they still gotta play the games.
I like your optimism but we are still well above what most people would consider reasonable valuations. That said there are trillions of new dollars out there that won't want to sit on the sidelines decaying at an 8% clip forever. It will be interesting to see how it plays out.
I mean everything is a bit oversold right now on negative emotions, both in the crypto space and in the stock markets.
There's probably going to be a positive bounce just because markets don't move in straight lines.
There is always the chance that something else explodes due to stress tomorrow and hits the headlines and crypto and/or stocks start melting down again (nothing is ever a sure bet), but it feels like we're closer to hitting a point of selling exhaustion and an inflection point of negative sentiment.