News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by pavlov on Friday May 13, 2022 @08:59AM (#31366997)
…Will not get taxed as income but instead as capital gains.

Americans are familiar with this system, it’s how short-term and long-term capital gains work in the USA.

Edit — my misunderstanding, German system is different after all. See asldjajlfkj's reply below.

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by asldjajlfkj on Friday May 13, 2022 @09:49AM (#31367565)
No. A "Privatverkauf" is tax free after one year. If you sell before that it is taxed as income. Crypto is never taxed as capital gains in Germany.
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by pavlov on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:08AM (#31367820)
Thanks for the clarification! I edited my reply.

I have to say, this blows the mind for Americans who assume European countries are tax hells. The IRS will tax everything, sometimes before you’ve sold it: I had to pay mark-to-market capital gains tax on unrealized gains in a foreign mutual fund I’d bought before moving to USA.

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by _zoltan_ on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:31AM (#31368146)
Then you'll be surprised to learn that Switzerland doesn't even have capital gains tax on any security (crypto, ETF...).
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by pavlov on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:32AM (#31368934)
Not really surprised about that. Switzerland, Luxembourg - they're well known as attractive tax regimes. The surprising aspect is that there's so many options in the middle. Even in the EU, every country has a unique combination of tax features, and knowledge about one or two of them doesn't translate. Portugal is unlike Italy is unlike France is unlike Germany is unlike Sweden is unlike Finland.

My humble opinion is that some of this should be harmonized on the EU level. There's no reason to leave so many tax loopholes for those able to exploit them, other than each country's wealthy lobbying to maintain their own peculiar benefits.

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by mbeex on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:24AM (#31368833)
But property tax AFAIK (contrary to Germany)
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by _zoltan_ on Saturday May 14, 2022 @02:26PM (#31380828)
That depends on which Kanton you are in. In Kanton Zürich this doesn't exist, but you get a wealth tax.
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by SZJX on Saturday May 14, 2022 @02:34AM (#31375583)
They are tax hells. Crypto has been such a special case in Germany, which feels much more an exception than the norm.
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by 0daystock on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:31AM (#31368920)
Same as in the US: MFJ gets to claim up to $83,350 of long-term capital gains without any tax.
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by niij on Friday May 13, 2022 @12:08PM (#31369374)
Capital gains are tax free if your total taxable income is below that $83k (including w-2/1099 earnings as well). Not just income from capital gains.
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by stiltzkin on Friday May 13, 2022 @12:51PM (#31369924)
Best summary so far.
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by ben_bai on Friday May 13, 2022 @09:10AM (#31367101)
German income tax rate is progressive, and maxes out at 45%. While capital gain tax is a flat 25%
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by rcMgD2BwE72F on Friday May 13, 2022 @09:25AM (#31367281)
If you're poor and only have your work to sell, you'll get taxed progressively until you're rich enough to save money and invest. Meaning your effective tax rate increases as you get reasonably rich (from work) and then when you're really rich, the rate slowly decreases down to the level of capital gain tax. I don't understand why this is accepted. I find this revolting as I'm in the position to benefit (my tax rate going below that of people far less wealthy than me).
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by chii on Friday May 13, 2022 @09:28AM (#31367321)
capital gains is income from investing, which is how new productivity gets funded (via buying new plant and equipment, etc).

Encouraging investments is not a bad idea. Of course, it's possible to be too pro-investment, but a 25% flat rate on investment based income is not too low, but not too high. It's slightly lower than wage income as an incentive for people to save and invest.

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by rcMgD2BwE72F on Friday May 13, 2022 @09:40AM (#31367452)
>capital gains is income from investing, which is how new productivity gets funded (via buying new plant and equipment, etc).

How does that justify taxing work more than capital? For people with high salary, any extra income (from work) is taxed almost 2x that of capital gains.

Also, only a small % of investment actually goes funding productivity. Most is just rich people's money changing hands, base only on speculation with zero regards for impact on businesses/society.

>a 25% flat rate on investment based income is not too low, but not too high

Do you have a study on this, or is this your opinion?

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by littlecranky67 on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:28AM (#31368893)
This argument is brought up over and over, but people forget that companies in Germany pay roughly 30% (depending on county) tax on their profits. As a solo entrepreneur with a registered company, that would mean if I make 100€ of profit, 30€ company tax are deducted, and then 25% of the remaining 70€ as capital gains tax when I pay myself the dividends - so I am left with ~53€. That is 47% tax in total, which is actually higher than the maximum personal income tax bracket (42%).
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by leipert on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:43AM (#31369086)
But if you get dividends or profits from stock as a private person that doesn’t apply and you just pay capital gains.

If you have a company or are a solo entrepreneur you can also reduce your profits by expensing things via the company (tech, cars, etc.) or investing further.

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by littlecranky67 on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:50AM (#31369153)
I does apply equally if you got stocks - at least on a national level as AG (Aktiengesellschaft in Germany) pay equal amount of corporate taxes. But yes, it got kind of skewed with international companies like amazon etc. paying no taxes at all. But we should fix that (them not paying any corporate tax), and not punish small shops like me (again, I am a solo-enterpreneur/developer - if you tax me 30% corporate tax + 42% on dividends, I will leave germany next day).
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by leipert on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:58AM (#31369256)
I am just wondering which kind of „Selbstständigkeit“/incorporation you are talking about. If you are solo-selbstständig no special tax of 30% applies, maybe Gewerbesteuer which is much lower.

If you are running a GmbH or UG or GbR things might be different, but then why don’t you keep assets inside of the entity? Then the entity could grow its assets and you could only take what you need and save some assets for the future. (Assuming you make more than what you need to maintain your lifestyle)

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by littlecranky67 on Friday May 13, 2022 @12:02PM (#31369294)
Yes, a "Selbstständiger" is taxed with personal income tax, but as I wrote, I am incorporated ("1-Mann GmbH"). I was tax "Selbstständig" for over 5 years and moved to a GmbH (=LLC) for various reasons completely unrelated to tax discussions (mostly protection of private assets and limited liability but also other reasons).

Edit: Corporate tax in Germany consists of two parts, Gewerbesteuer and Körperschaftssteuer. Those vary depending on where you are incorporated in Germany (Hebesatz), but 30% is a good rough estimate.

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by littlecranky67 on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:53AM (#31369187)
Regarding cars: Yes, it is cheaper to run business cars but its pretty limited. There is the 1% rule in germany, then a monthly of 1% of the cars shop-price (we use the nice word Bruttolistenneupreis) is considered income and taxed regularly. If a car costs 30.000€, that means you have to add 300€/monthly (virtually) onto your tax bill that is taxed as personal income. There are limits to the "you can tax deduct everything as a business" in Germany.
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by chii on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:40AM (#31369041)
yes, this is double taxation, which i don't personally like.

In australia, there's franked dividends, which basically passes the tax credits down to shareholders (effectively, companies pay a 30% tax, but give that same dollar amount as credits to shareholders, who can then use it as tax paid in lieu). See https://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/frankeddividend.asp

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by chii on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:02AM (#31367734)
> a study on this, or is this your opinion?

it is an opinion. The policy setting is not a fact based research, but ideologically based opinion. i would argue that any research is basically paid opinion pieces to try and convince someone on the fence.

> How does that justify taxing work more than capital?

the justification is in my comment above - it is taxed less than wage income to encourage people to spend their money investing, rather than spending it in consumption.

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by BlargMcLarg on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:21AM (#31368009)
But capital gains tax alone doesn't make the entire equation of risk vs reward, unless you're putting capital gains tax all the way to 100%. Even if it was 90%, if the risk was zero, the time investment was near zero and the reward was your assets going up by 4% post-tax, you'd bet people would still invest, regardless of income tax.
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by chii on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:36AM (#31368990)
> if the risk was zero

no investment has zero risk.

in any case, the 90% tax would discourage the investment for some people - because that investment might not return enough to be worth the opportunity cost of consumption instead. The point is, more investments means more possible productivity in the future, and any consumption->investment switch is good.

This is the same calculus as wage tax of course, but since most people don't have a choice but to work for a wage, they don't need to be incentivized to work by lower taxes.

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by nybble41 on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:48AM (#31369139)
> and any consumption->investment switch is good

Not always: It is possible to over-invest and under-consume. Don't forget that the purpose of investment in the present is to enable consumption in the future. In the extreme case, a society which only invested and never consumed would starve to death. There is a natural balance point, and moving away from that point in either direction results in a less efficient allocation of resources.

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by chii on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:59AM (#31369264)
> It is possible to over-invest and under-consume.

certainly is, but i would argue that more people under-invest and over-consume! I would also argue that the minimal amount of consumption (let's say, you keep yourself alive, just barely), and maximizing your investment amount, is the best outcome for your future, and is the most efficient allocation of resources.

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by nybble41 on Saturday May 14, 2022 @03:41AM (#31375886)
> I would also argue that the minimal amount of consumption (let's say, you keep yourself alive, just barely), and maximizing your investment amount, is the best outcome for your future, and is the most efficient allocation of resources.

If you always prioritize your future over your present then your sacrifices are wasted—you live your entire life just barely keeping yourself alive and never claim any of the proceeds from your investments for yourself. As I said before, there needs to be a balance. Investment is pointless and wasteful without a plan to eventually consume more than you could have without investing.

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by rcMgD2BwE72F on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:21AM (#31368011)
>it is taxed less than wage income to encourage people to spend their money investing, rather than spending it in consumption.

Did you mean speculating? A few % of so-called investors are actually supporting new businesses. I believe it's obvious when you think about investing in crypto.

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by chii on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:37AM (#31368998)
investments don't have to be "supporting businesses" for it to be worthwhile. Speculative investments also work.
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by bckygldstn on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:43AM (#31369079)
By the same logic, income tax comes from working, which is how productivity gets done!

Besides, what are the wealthy going to do with their excess wealth except invest it?

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by ruggeri on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:51AM (#31369163)
That might be true if they couldn't move wealth outside the country.

But a concern is that those with savings might move money out of the country to invest in jurisdictions with lower capital gains tax.

One view is that this tax jurisdiction forum-shopping creates a race to the bottom.

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by snovv_crash on Friday May 13, 2022 @04:28PM (#31372202)
It's the same for workers, they can just perform their labour outside of the country and they would create a much larger problem.
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by idiotsecant on Friday May 13, 2022 @04:08PM (#31372038)
>investing, which is how new productivity gets funded

As opposed to working, which is how productivity actually happens.

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by pydry on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:34AM (#31368185)
>Encouraging investments is not a bad idea.

It definitely is if theres a glut of capital.

Which there is and has been for at least a decade.

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by stjohnswarts on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:58AM (#31369246)
I feel the same way. Income is income. Hell if I lose my $150k a year job and take a $120k job just because I need money coming in I can't get a $30k "capital losses" advantage on my taxes like I can with stocks. Tax system is rigged against middle and lower classes everywhere it seems.
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by pavlov on Friday May 13, 2022 @09:22AM (#31367246)
Yes, it’s the same in USA.

(The federal rates are lower, but state and local taxes can push your tax bill up to European levels, especially if you own property in a desirable area.)

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by mbeex on Friday May 13, 2022 @09:31AM (#31367360)
Point here is, crypto - as well as Gold and Real Estate - are considered a special case of capital. Contrary to stock they have - different - 'speculation periods' (Spekulationsfristen). If they are held beyond this period, no tax is collected for gains of the sale. This was true for stock too before 2009 (unfortunately).
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by edmundsauto on Friday May 13, 2022 @09:24AM (#31367265)
I think you're probably aware of this, but for non Americans - this is the same as in the US. Except I think the capital gains rate (holdings > 1 year) is 15%?

(America also has progressive income tax that caps out around 40% I believe... any gains from holdings sold < 1 year are "short term capital gains" which is at standard income tax rates)

Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by papito on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:33AM (#31368175)
With all the wining about European socialism, this is what I pay with combined NYC, state, and federal taxes, plus all the deductions for the safety net that the government should provide anyway.
Re:Germany: Crypto held for more than a year will not get taxed by recursive on Friday May 13, 2022 @02:09PM (#31370791)
American here. Did not know short-term and long-term were different things.