News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Sound of Bells – The acoustics, sound, tuning and his... by enriquto on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @11:48AM (#31328515)
As if there was just material for a single PhD thesis! I would guess that the mathematical theory of bells is pretty much open. The shape of a bell (a solid of revolution) can be described by one function u:R->R. Given u, you can compute the vibration spectrum of the sound by standard methos. But if you are given a desired timbre, how to find u? Nobody knows. The most that we can do is optimization starting from a close solution candidate.
Re:The Sound of Bells – The acoustics, sound, tuning and his... by Someone on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @12:15PM (#31328862)
> The shape of a bell (a solid of revolution) can be described by one function u:R->R

If you phrase it that way “surface of revolution” describes bells much better than “solid of revolution”.

I think “solid of revolution” is the better term, though. That allows you to model varying wall thickness. You’d need more than a function u:ℝ->ℝ to do that.

Also, I don’t a priori see why the shape of a bell would be limited to such functions. If the edge of a bell bends inwards into the bell and goes up a bit, I think I would still call it a bell, especially if it somewhat sounds like one.

Finally, rotational symmetry isn’t required for a bell. Your typical cow bell, for example, is elliptical or even rectangular (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cowbell_(instrument))

⇒ the design space is a lot larger than you indicate.

Re:The Sound of Bells – The acoustics, sound, tuning and his... by cpp_frog on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @12:48PM (#31329316)
Surface of revolution is 'okay', 'solid' would mean its interior is completely filled. What you're describing is an active area of research in numerical analysis (adjacent to my own MS thesis topic, buckling of shells).

> That allows you to model varying wall thickness

That's mentioned in the first chapter of this book [0].

[0] The Finite Element Analysis of Shells – Fundamentals, Chapelle & Bathe

EDIT: I'm aware it is not a surface, but the notion is closer than that of a solid of revolution.

Re:The Sound of Bells – The acoustics, sound, tuning and his... by Someone on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @03:34PM (#31331565)
> ‘solid' would mean its interior is completely filled.

I disagree. Mathematically, I wouldn’t know how to define a solid other than “anything with a volume”.

Certainly, a bell, when defined as a surface of revolution, doesn’t have an interior in a mathematical sense (https://mathworld.wolfram.com/Interior.html), does it?

There’s the convex closure, but that would, for the prototypical bell, add volume ‘outside’ the bell, too.

Also, I think varying wall thickness in bells for centuries was the only known way to tune them. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pieter_and_François_Hemony#Lif...:

“When struck, a bell produces a number of partials which, if imprecisely tuned, can create an unpleasant sound and which prevents it from harmonizing in accordance with other bells. To address this problem, the Hemony brothers gave their bells a particular profile and thickened it in certain places. The bells were then tuned by hollowing ridges from specific parts of the inner wall until the first few partials were acceptably in tune.”

(Aside: if you want your work to be used for centuries, becoming a professional bell caster seems a good bet)

Re:The Sound of Bells – The acoustics, sound, tuning and his... by nomel on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @01:45PM (#31330028)
> Surface of revolution is okay

But surface, by definition, has no concept of thickness, right? Surely there's a better term?

> 'solid' would mean its interior is completely filled.

I think the easiest way to define a bell would be the difference of two solids of revolution (front surface, back surface). What do you call the difference of two solids of revolution?

Re:The Sound of Bells – The acoustics, sound, tuning and his... by cpp_frog on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @01:57PM (#31330195)
I meant it from a numerical analysis/differential geometry perspective (the reason I attached the reference). While not being strictly a surface, it is characterized by a mid-surface, and a thickness t. After having that information, for each point in the mid surface, a normal vector is drawn and scaled by a magnitude of t/2 in both directions of the normal, giving a thickness of t to the object that, I should have made it clearer, is not a surface but characterized by one.
Re:The Sound of Bells – The acoustics, sound, tuning and his... by enriquto on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @03:19PM (#31331385)
I don't think that a bell is correctly modelled as a shell of variable thickness. The inner surface is smooth, and the outer surface has ridges. These ridges are apparently important to the timbre, thus it may be more appropriate to consider it as a solid volume of arbitrary shape. Of revolution, if you want to stay with a one-dimensional model.
Re:The Sound of Bells – The acoustics, sound, tuning and his... by crustycoder on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @04:31PM (#31332278)
Nah, the mouldings are entirely decorative. And bells are tuned by taking off material on a lathe at various positions on the inside of the bell.

https://funwithbells.com/nigel-taylor/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JEJkMalMVv4

Re:The Sound of Bells – The acoustics, sound, tuning and his... by enriquto on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @05:21PM (#31332891)
Wow, it's good to know, thanks for the clarification!
Re:The Sound of Bells – The acoustics, sound, tuning and his... by a1369209993 on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @03:20PM (#31331400)
> You'd need more than a function u:ℝ->ℝ to do that.

Actually, if you normalize the bell height to 1, you can take u from 0 to 1 as the inner surface (tracing down from the top), and u from 1 to 2 as the outer (tracing back up from the bottom). I'm not sure that's mathematically convenient, but it does work. (You could also use a periodic function on 0..pi for inner and pi..tau for outer, which might be nicer math-wise and also allows you to say that the height (pi) is half of whatever the function's period is.)

Re:The Sound of Bells – The acoustics, sound, tuning and his... by mellavora on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @03:33AM (#31336889)
I've got a fever, and the only prescription is more cow bell!
Re:The Sound of Bells – The acoustics, sound, tuning and his... by cpp_frog on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @12:54PM (#31329375)
Yes, it's a vibration of an elastic axisymmetric thin shell (surface of revolution, as you meantioned). Going deeper into the theory, to know or characterize the sound it makes one should have a model of free or forced vibration and find the eigenvalues of the resulting linear system. That system is typically (K-omega^2 M) U = F, where K is the stiffness matrix of the material, M the mass matrix, U the displacement matrix, F the force matrix and omega the frequency.

Now, to find the displacement given the eigenvalues (spectrum) is possible in a finite-dimensional setting, in infinite dimensions it's trickier. I'm sure there are approximation results of this kind, but not if there is an exact way.

Re:The Sound of Bells – The acoustics, sound, tuning and his... by sitkack on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @04:22PM (#31332171)
If drums are bells, you should see how Nicolas Bras [1] modifies the sound by damping some of the nodes of the drum. Are you saying all bell are radially symmetric?

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fXavtyyyj34

Re:The Sound of Bells – The acoustics, sound, tuning and his... by nonrandomstring on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @12:50PM (#31329332)
This site is quite old and IIRC I had bachelors students building additive synthetic bells from the amazing data he's collected. Also great tales of acoustic archaeology, building bell sounds based on models from the foundry drawings and metallurgy data.
Re:The Sound of Bells – The acoustics, sound, tuning and his... by crustycoder on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @02:12PM (#31330418)
It's been around for a while but he's still active in the field (he recorded & analysed our bells a couple of years ago) and he's revamped the site fairly recently.
Re:The Sound of Bells – The acoustics, sound, tuning and his... by hprotagonist on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @11:53AM (#31328597)
The pitch perception work alone is probably a few degrees, if you get deeper into it.