Are they proposing kicking you off your insurance? From the bill:
> SUMMARY OF SPECIFIC PROVISIONS:
Every New York resident will be eligible to enroll, regardless of age, income, wealth, employment, or other status. There would be no network restrictions, deductibles, or co-pays. Coverage would be publicly funded. The benefits will include comprehensive outpatient and inpatient medical care, long-term care, primary and preventive care, prescription drugs, laboratory tests, rehabilitative, dental, vision, hearing, etc. all benefits required by current state insurance law or provided by the state public employee package, Family Health Plus, Child Health Plus, Medicare, or Medicaid, and others added by the plan.
As someone that has lived in NYC for 15 years, I'd really love to see this happen.
Edit:
> Private insurance that duplicates benefits offered under New York Health could not be offered to New York residents.
So yes, I guess it would be kicking those off of their current private insurance. It sounds like it'd force private insurers to offer plans that would augment off of a base of public care.
I'm still fine with this.
Per employee costs go up due to health care payroll taxes.
Per employee costs come down due to not paying for health insurance.
Overall, net-neutral cost to companies and simplifies health care payments for hospitals, clinics, etc so fewer employees to explain and collect payments so cost of care comes down. Seems like a win - win - win.
>>>> Person complaining about how his previous state-run health care system was awful
>>> Person replying that your current plan will still be there, no one will force you to take the state run plan
>> Person commenting on how funding for the bill will kill it
> Response that funding will come from the money that companies were paying on health plans.
So if everything in this one thread is true, then
- Companies will continue to offer the health plan they currently offer
- The state will provide a single payer health plan
- The money that companies currently pay on health plans will pay for both of those, with no increase in cost to the employee
Clearly that's not realistic.
> - Companies will continue to offer the health plan they currently offer
I think the GP (GGP?) reading was that the current health plans would have to change; they can't duplicate the state mandatory coverage. (But they can build on top of it).
So theoretically a $1k/mo plan paid by the employer might turn into a $400/mo plan for extra coverage, and the baseline would cost $600/mo and that part would be taken over by the state. Best-case they can streamline that portion and decrease the cost through economy of scale; worst-case you have 2x the operating costs for two different insurance plans and the quality goes down because of the duplication and billing uncertainty for providers. (I'd hope that the bit covered by the state would be good enough for many people to have as their only coverage though).
Yes, to this day, it doesn’t cover dental or vision, which is BS if you ask me, and there is some co-pay for certain prescriptions; regardless, it is a fantastic system, and I miss it so much every time I need to go to the doctor here in the US. The main reason is uncertainty: in the US, I can never know how much something is going to be, even if it starts as a mere visit to a family doctor, because there are uncountable variables that may factor in the final cost.
As a result of this, I try to avoid going to the doctor as much as I can, and it makes me think about all the people who really cannot afford healthcare, and don’t qualify for Medicare either.
I think the closest thing you can get to the cost experience of universal healthcare in the US is one of the better HMO providers like Kaiser. Everything is a known cost up front.
Of course coming from any other country, this is ridiculous. But it goes to show you how out of touch many Americans are with how the rest of the world works.
My wife, a practicing physician, did fellowships in multiple countries like this.
I asked her for her opinion given her experience with their systems, and our systems, and also being on the provider end.
"excellent emergent care, comparable to better US hospitals"
"horrible waiting periods for elective care, and non-emergent surgeries"
It's just weird how people argue for the US system as if it's superior but it really has the same problems as other countries with even more downsides. If we're supposed to be "good" at elective surgeries we're giving up a lot to be pretty mediocre.
Same as in the US. Three months is the minimum.
Hell, I couldn't even schedule a tooth cleaning with a new dentist less than six months out - I called close to 10 dentist offices.
big nope.
Wife is booking emergent same day, and depending on the case length and type, 1-2 weeks for most cancer cases, up to a month for a complex deep inferior epigastric perforators flap breast reconstruction surgery which is a long surgery if bilateral; getting that much OR time is a challenge. They'll book for saturdays if they need. Cases that can be done in a surgery center are quick; major cases that require a hospital OR, and other physician clearances take longer to coordinate.
The longest backlog (1 year) in the practice is actually a 99% cosmetic plastic surgeon who is an instagram famous Michelangelo of Brazilian Butt Lifts.
I can corroborate the GP's experience of having to book several months in advance for non-emergency care—the fastest medical booking I've had in the past several years is surgery for my cat, which was about three weeks.
Certain areas of the US, particularly many big cities have a plethora of physicians and active competition between them.
The "billionaires" aren't lying to you. Look at the UK, a maximalist interpretation of universal government funded healthcare.
Lockdowns destroyed the NHS. The waiting list for care (not even just elective care, any care) is now closing in on 10% of the entire population!
https://dailysceptic.org/2022/04/15/lockdown-backlog-nhs-wai...
People are waiting hours for ambulances to turn up after heart attacks! People are dying inside ambulances sitting in queues to enter the hospital. My family has largely given up on seeing local general practitioners because so many have reduced hours during lockdowns and never brought them back, meaning they're working less with bigger demand due to backlogs. The system has indeed removed their ability to get appointments scheduled.
These are third world conditions, or perhaps more accurately, second world conditions - nobody has to pay but there are severe shortages all the time, and what you get may or may not be of acceptable quality. The USA doesn't have these problems. Heck, most places that aren't fully government run don't have these problems.
The problems are cutting through. My aunt, a lifetime public sector worker loyal to the NHS, was talking about getting private care last time we talked. It was a surprise but she said her experience was you just can't see doctors without it anymore. The net result is going to be a very expensive healthcare system for the UK - high taxes to pay for the NHS plus an ever larger shadow system of private healthcare on the side.
We in the US pay more per capita for worse care than most other developed nations (Canada/UK/Nordic countries). Name your country where the care is worse than the US please and let us know how much they pay for it per capita comparatively.
What is actually the case is that care available to the bottom quartile of Americans is below the care received on average in a top-tier universal care nation, and the US spends an absolute fortune delivering this quartile with substandard care.
We also spend a bit more than average providing exceptional care to everyone else, except that we also spend a truly ludicrous amount (compared with every place on earth except possibly Japan, which is still less than us but not quite as much less) on care for roughly everybody above the median during the last year of life, because we have baked some very expensive decisions in as the default (basically, if you don't specifically ask otherwise, you will get absolute treatment maximalism basically until 30 days from death)
If a quarter of our country has the worst healthcare in the developed world that is unacceptable.
Answers like this are just begging us to give up our humanity.
I was making statements about how things actually are, since no discussion about how to make the world we want is likely to be meaningful or useful if there is not a shared view of what is first.
I think a country which lets some get rich off of other’s cancer is an abhorrent, indefensible, system.
The idea of 'market forces dictating absolutely everything' is proven objectively wrong by countries that still have a large amount of doctors despite being paid less. The market theory would posit that all of those doctors and what not would move to a country that pays them more but there are many, many other factors other than just pay.
You should just assume I'm a misanthrope who enjoys watching people suffer. I mean, it's not true, but lots of idiots assume it.
lol
Is there a source for this? I'd guess that there's a percentile where American health care has better outcomes than other countries, but 50th seems pretty low.
We already pay to cover our own family members on our plans. Why are we being forced to now cover everyone else's family?
I'm more likely to move to the adjacent state than pay 15% higher tax rate and literally get LOWER quality care.
2) Leaving these people uninsured is not cheaper, you're paying for it already with significant healthcare costs. The same people complaining about the cost of healthcare turn around and deny preventative coverage to people who end up in the ER and you pay for it regardless.
3) It's the right thing to do, ethically, morally and financially (long term)
What an incredibly ignorant take, no wonder we don't have any healthcare solutions.
She already performs a significant amount of her practice as "charity care" where she gets no reimbursement whatsoever.
Given that for a fellowship-trained (3) board-certified (2) surgeon the train-up period is measured in ~2+ decades, not 4 years for regular professions.
> What an incredibly ignorant take, no wonder we don't have any healthcare solutions
Please don't assign false morality to the compensation people expect when their working career is effectively halved due to their extensive training requirements, and their educational bills dwarf by comparison every other profession.
The US already subsidizes medical research and bigpharma profits for the entire planet. We're not the freeloaders you're making us out to be.
As a Canadian: yes.
And the bill was $0 at the end of my father's heart bypass and valve replacement surgery. My friend's sister cancer treatment also had a bill of $0.
Finished filing my taxes last month, and my average rate (provincial+federal) for last year was 21%. Happy to pay.
“ "Then I found out that this other country — which I thought had a healthcare system that was so superior to the U.S. — doesn't test for the tumour marker that saved my life, and doesn't cover this drug that is responsible for pushing my cancer into remission after traditional chemotherapy failed to do that."”
Pretty sure I'd prefer even a 5% chance versus a guaranteed 0%.
Funny because it’s just the sort of thing to cause more anxiety in an anxious person.
I’d also love hear how many Canadian cancer survivors have to put up gofundmes or go bankrupt for care.
I value having public health care. I hope the US can come up with a good public system so that Canada can stop resting on "at least we're not like the US!"
The issue is we fail most people and those we don’t fail we often bankrupt. That isn’t acceptable.
The only difference has been that 1 time the Canadian ER was busier and I waited my turn (based on an initial triage).
I feel, during my visit, I was appropriately handled in all 4 locations. After leaving the hospital in Canada I was done. However in the US, both times a few weeks later I got a bill for roughly $1000, and it actively makes me think twice about going to the ER (even though I can afford the $1000). In the US, I may have skipped the ER the second time if I hadn't felt strongly I was having an appendicitis. Truly scary to think I considered not going based on a bit of money.
If it wasn't clear, even being well off in the US, I prefer the overall experience in Canada.
Why do you ask?
No country pays more for healthcare per capita than the US. If we could capture some of the huge chunk that goes to private insurance companies (each company has its own redundant staff and technology systems, their own execs all getting their own bonuses, etc), we could provide healthcare even better than we already provide in the US to those who can afford it or qualify for public programs.
While we love to critique big insurance, and some of it may be earned, that industry is not known for the skyhigh profits OR margins like IT is.
Here is an HMO for ya
> OAKLAND, Calif. — Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc., Kaiser Foundation Hospitals, and their respective subsidiaries (KFHP/H) reported 2021 annual financial results. Total operating revenues for 2021 were $93.1 billion compared to $88.7 billion in 2020. Total operating expenses were $92.5 billion compared to $86.5 billion in the prior year. Operating income was $611 million, or 0.7% of operating revenues, compared to $2.2 billion in 2020. Increased care delivery expenses due to COVID-19 surges contributed to the decline in operating income.
> “After almost 2 years, the COVID-19 pandemic continues to impact Kaiser Permanente just as it does our daily lives,” said chair and chief executive officer Greg A. Adams. “We rapidly rolled out vaccines, and now boosters, and administered more than 9 million COVID-19 tests while managing new and unpredictable variants like delta and omicron as they surfaced. Throughout this crisis, gratitude goes to our dedicated employees and physicians who have remained focused on providing care and strong support for members and communities.”
> Like other organizations, Kaiser Permanente benefited from strong investment performance due to robust financial markets during the year, resulting in total other income and expense of $7.5 billion compared to $4.1 billion in 2020. This sharp increase in investment performance more than offset the $1.6 billion decrease in operating income, resulting in 2021 net income of $8.1 billion compared to net income of $6.4 billion in 2020.
> Capital spending totaled $3.5 billion compared to $4.0 billion the year prior. During 2021 Kaiser Permanente opened 11 medical offices. Kaiser Permanente now includes 734 medical offices, 39 owned and operated hospitals, and 58 retail and worksite clinics.
and regular insurance
> United Healthgroup Profit as % of Revenues 6%, Profits as % of Assets 7.8%, Profits as % of Stockholder Equity 23.5% for CY2021
It's big world - without knowing which country, this is of little help. I'd like to see a comparison of people forced into debt, bankruptcy or death due to the respective medical systems
This hits home because I have a friend that got cancer with "good" U.S. insurance and if he did not fight the insurance company he'd be in debt for 1mm+
Reality is it's pretty grim. Don't know if I'd recommend it to other countries to be honest.
Be careful what you wish for!
I had cancer five years ago, spending the better part of six months receiving inpatient treatment, during which I couldn’t work. I had recently moved jobs beforehand too—I have literally no idea what I would have done under an American-style system.
It’s bursting at the seams (through no fault of its own), and yet still we never bankrupt people with life threatening illnesses, we don’t bill people for ambulances, we don’t force seriously ill people and their families to do battle with blood-sucking insurance companies over byzantine coverage terms.
It’s the last damned thing this nation has actually feels like it exists for the common good of the people. I would recommend it to other countries—wholeheartedly.
Most people don't encounter this stuff until it's too late, which is partially where all the praise comes from for the American healthcare system in my opinion.
Did you know that until 2017 the NHS literally funded homeopathy?
I'm not even joking.
As someone who's never experienced the UK health care system, and only know one person who has (as a foreigner, so they paid out of pocket and said the experience was positive, but otherwise not a good data point) ... I'd like to hear a bit more detail about how it's pretty grim, if you're willing to elaborate.
There's no incentive for these people to be helpful or polite, because they get paid anyway and there's no market, so they aren't.
My American colleagues see a doctor every year for a checkup to catch things like cancer before they're fatal. The NHS would laugh in my face if I said I wanted to see a doctor for a checkup, unless I literally had an arm falling off.
That said the reason we don't do as much in the way of screening and yearly physicals of young healthy individuals is because there's very limited evidence that it's even helpful and sometimes even evidence that it's harmful.
That isn't to say they don't sometimes save a life, but they also cause unnecessary medical procedures and needless medical anxiety. What kind of early cancer detection is really happening at a yearly physical? You could argue that a doctor telling you to lose weight might help reduce obesity or diabetes, but so far that doesn't seem to be working.
Even if you do catch and treat a cancer, was it a slow progressing cancer that never would have caused an issue for the patient? This is particularly significant when you're looking at someone in their 80s.
If you have any health conditions, have a family history of disease, are taking repeat prescriptions or are above 40, you will start being offered regular checkups and screening.
You can also book a private GP or checkup if you want, or even just pay for a periodic blood test. The NHS/NICE has decided the evidence base doesn't exist to support it, but you're free to decide otherwise if you wish.
Also, I'm actually not sure that a yearly physical in the US does much for cancer screenings. The last one I had in the US did blood tests for cholesterol, urine tests for kidney disease, and some other common tests, but I don't remember getting screened for forms of cancer. I think this is dependent on the healthcare provider you go to, and what your insurance covers.
Also, I just spent a total of seven hours last week making calls just to get insurance to even process my prescription that they had previously approved.
If you never want to see your GP again then yeah petition for the UK system.
There's no way my insurance would pay for random "I don't think anything's wrong but I want to look for something anyway" outside of yearly physicals either.
Yearly physical == check up. Same thing. Going to the doctor once a year for a general check that you aren't developing any issues that you weren't aware of yet and to monitor your health.
I don't have either. I haven't seen a doctor for about five years I think, under the NHS system.
If I phoned my NHS GP and said 'it's been a year I'd like you to generally check my physical health' they'd tell me to fuck off.
I'm not a doctor but that doesn't seem often enough for an older person. I'm an American in my 30's and I just had a checkup, and my doctor told me to come back every two years. Of course the American system is pretty awful in its own ways, especially for those who are uninsured.
Similar to the UK, my in laws in Canada can’t get annual physicians scheduled either - there needs to be something wrong before a doctor will take an appointment.
It has its own wrinkles of course. For example, doctors make less money and their working conditions are worse than private hospitals. Because of that, it's common to get asked to pay a "knife fee" in secret for operations. Some doctors ask for an expensive bottle of whiskey etc. I haven't experienced this myself but heard about those incidents many times.
However, wait times aren't long. Appointments are organized electronically through E-State portal. Although wait times in ER can be long based on your triage, that's the case with United States anyway.
The benefits of single payer healthcare outweigh the drawbacks by a wide margin. You never worry about unemployment. You don't have homeless people due to their mental problems as they're treated in mental clinics. You don't worry about "getting bankrupt" suddenly from an unforeseen health issue. Healthcare costs are low even if you're not insured. That means drugs are cheap even though state won't cover 100% of the cost. Even private insurance is cheap (~$1000 a year).
Yes, taxes are high in Turkey, but healthcare system costs make up a very small portion of it (~5%).
I think it’s crazy that your access to healthcare is dependent on your employment.
I agree with the idea of public healthcare, but not as a legislated monopoly. And that's true for government services generally. Monopolies don't benefit anyone except the monopolist, and competition makes everyone stronger. If the government wants to use it's buying and borrowing power (and maybe even taxation to the extent voters tolerate it) to provide a universal healthcare option, that's a big win. But if they want to push out other market participants in the name of some kind of fairness - well instead of having two-tier healthcare, everyone is on the bottom tier
Triage is a pretty universal concept.
Healthcare has difficulty with competitive market effects because the amount anyone is willing to pay to live is essentially infinite.
This has actually been studied, and is not true.
So does every private insurer under the sun. You've never had insurance deny access to care? No insurer can afford to give an MRI to everyone a doctor wants.
Doctor's prioritize need. More sicker, more quicker 'service' / treatment.
> I agree with the idea of public healthcare, but not as a legislated monopoly.
There is no monopoly on health care in Canada: if you want to cut a cheque you can get private care. What is legislated is that if you take provincial funding you cannot also take private funds. It's either-or.
[0] e.g. https://www.timelymedical.ca/
For healthcare in Canada, the monopolist is the Canadian people.
Of course in the US, there are costs beyond just insurance, but if you had to pay for coverage out of pocket it would be $16,000/yr for a family of 4.
That would depend completely on their job in the US. If they're a line cook, care was better in Canada. If they're a software engineer, it's better in the US.
Also, in my experience, public healthcare _can_ be quite good, but the quality of service varies a lot across regions and institutions.
Sure you are. There is no government monopoly on health care in Canada: if you want to cut a cheque you can get private care. Nothing illegal about it.
All (family) doctors in Canada are private businesses. It's just that most of them hook into the provincial payment system. Similarly for hospitals: they are not government run, just funded through government. If you wish to set up a private clinic and/or hospital and not take government funding, there is no legal impediment to do so.
What is legislated is that if you take provincial funding you cannot also take private funds. It's either-or.
> It's all hush-hush because those in power are the primary users of that parallel system.
It's not hush-hush, it's just most of us plebes cannot afford fancy pants clinics.
I did not anticipate that they would grant themselves special kind of access to healthcare. Like I said, very, very naive.
Any hint you can provide of how to look into this? I know there are private clinics for certain things, but I would be very interested to see what options there are for my family
"Private insurance that duplicates benefits offered under New York Health could not be offered to New York residents."
So in other words, private insurances can only be offered if they provide benefits that surpass whatever the public option has.
I imagine that private insurances will logically offer more benefits regardless, otherwise why would someone pay extra to use them over the public option?
Of course many systems, including Canada's have this problem. The primary motivation for governments to prohibit private competition is specifically so that they can pretend that it can't be better elsewhere, to keep their system alive.
If people realized how likely they were to suffer for years utterly unnecessarily, they wouldn't be willing to put up with the government health systems they have. But because the government banned competition to keep them ignorant of the alternative, people remain peaceful while they wait in pain for years to get treatment that is utterly routine in America.
It's not a zero sum game.
Healthcare in the US isn't fair for anyone.
That's how it ends up working in many places with government care
I am not hugely in favor or capitalism, but I can't see anything better or a way to replace it even though I am a social democrat. Let people with money spend them as long as we provide a decent floor for everyone.
[0] https://www.kff.org/medicare/issue-brief/how-many-physicians...
New York State will not necessarily implement the same program your home country has.
> Since moving to the US, it is more expensive (than next to nothing), but I actually get good care. Several conditions that were ignored or misdiagnosed for me are now cured. My life might be significantly shorter had I not come here.
It's not really news that the (relatively) rich can get better things by paying more. The well-known consequence of the US system is that many people get no care, because they don't have the money to afford it. That includes people with health insurance, which often doesn't pay for anything at all until you've paid thousands out-of-pocket to hit your deductible.
But that doesn't mean the US would have to pay less per capita in a single-payer system.
So we could keep getting what we pay for in terms of capacity, etc, if we want. You would expect a wealthy country to be able to pay a premium to get a premium.
1) In the USA, one must be pretty well situated to get the quality of healthcare you describe. MANY people go without prescriptions, and get inadequate care already.
2) If you add up what we pay in health insurance premiums plus employer contributions, especially if you have a family, we're generally in the same league of paycheck-subtraction as a European country with universal healthcare.
So while I agree with your overall point that it could end up worse than where we started, I don't think thats a guaranteed outcome.
Americans are already paying more than most places for healthcare but not getting a good return.
An adjacent issue is that certain groups don't receive preventive care due to financial issues leading to increased long term costs.
But note, even in all cases we're paying way too much.
The part you're missing is that there is an arms race of pricing between healthcare corporations (there have been massive mergers of hospital systems) and insurance companies in terms of prices. We, the patients, are caught in between the giants while prices are going sky high and we are at our most vulnerable.
The hope is this will fix prices to a reasonable level so if we choose to go for private care, those prices will also be reasonable. A lot of specialists that I see ask for cash payments and don't accept insurance. They are also overbooked because a lot of healthcare providers are being driven out of industry from the conditions.
EDIT: My MTR is ~42% so my ETR can't be 40%. I don't have a payslip to calculate and searching the interwebs isn't helping a lot right now.
There is also a lower rate om capital gains such as stock or real estate, sales (like a VAT), gas tax, vehicle tax, utility tax, phone tax, cable internet tax, etc.
Plus, of course, employers are paying some extra payroll taxes per employee.
Sure in UK and Norway healthcare and University is free, but healthcare is provided by my employer in the states. So for me it is a wash.
But hey in the US I get to pay for the largest army on the planet.
What I would say is that in the US my taxes feel the most "unfair" since my tax rate is sort of the max. Richer people have ways of avoiding taxes and poorer people pay less tax.
My european friends from big economies there brag about their insurance coverage, some working in the states with some global coverage plan, and as soon as I ask about something seemingly basic: “oh thats elective or cosmetic, why would that be covered”
I think there is a way to make it work with American expectations, American resources, no equivalent tax burden.
Do you have an example?
Afaik pricing of medical procedures is defined by government (probably with insurers and practitioners).
It's high quality but fairly expensive (relative to GDP or salary vs other European countries)
Profits are regulated (sometimes down to zero) in CH. Profits are unregulated in the US.
US has a massive free healthcare system called "Medicaid" which is similar to the basic plan for low income individuals and families, the scale of which is unknown to many:
> Medicaid is the largest source of funding for medical and health-related services for people with low income in the United States, providing free health insurance to 74 million low-income and disabled people (23% of Americans) as of 2017, as well as paying for half of all U.S. births in 2019.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medicaid
In addition, each state has other provisions. For example, California's Medical system is used by a third of California's population:
> Benefits include ambulatory patient services, emergency services, hospitalization, maternity and newborn care, mental health and substance use disorder treatment, dental (Denti-Cal), vision, and long term care and supports.
Since moving to the US, it is more expensive (than next to nothing), but I actually get good care. Several conditions that were ignored or misdiagnosed for me are now cured. My life might be significantly shorter had I not come here.
If NY does this, the near zero chance of my moving there ever would go to absolute 0. It is a terrible system for any place that does not have infinitesimal state or national government expenses and more-than-60% kind of taxes (e.g., Scandinavian countries).