News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by diogenescynic on Sunday May 08, 2022 @09:39PM (#31309634)
Monsanto also pays shills to comment positively about pesticide use and try to brow beat anyone who is has a negative opinion their products. It's crazy how aggressive it is. Basically any thread on Twitter or Reddit the same users will defend Monsanto. You see the same thing about other controversial products, such as BPAs. It seems like some tactic they learned from Big Tobacco and Big Oil to just push as much doubt/skepticism as possible to make the public nihilistic/cynical. Meanwhile, most of these products don't even need to be used. We're just letting a few companies pollute the earth and get rich for a minor gain of convenience to the public.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by tptacek on Sunday May 08, 2022 @10:35PM (#31309882)
I've defended Monsanto repeatedly on HN (there are some extraordinarily popular beliefs about Monsanto that turn out, from what I can tell, to be just completely false, and they used to wind up here a bunch). I'm not carrying any water for them. I'm pro-GMO just in principle, but neutral-to-skeptical about any company of Monsanto's size. I'm sure the company itself is perfectly amoral. I'm just calling actual issues like I see them.

Naturally, plenty of people on HN think I'm a paid shill (what makes this funnier is the company I founded and worked at for most of my time on HN was named "Matasano", which was so frequently confused for "Monsanto" that we put a sign on our window about it in our Mountain View office).

My point is just: your intuition for whether comments are paid shillage are likely to mislead you.

Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by epgui on Sunday May 08, 2022 @11:42PM (#31310358)
+1

I’m a biochemist and while I’m not interested in sticking my neck out to defend any company, a lot of the criticism directed at Monsanto is unfair, uninformed and/or unintelligent.

This is particularly true of criticism levied against glyphosate (one of the least-bad herbicides I know of) and GMOs (which people are usually just super confused about).

Disclaimer: zero conflict of interest, I make all my money building software in the non-bio world.

Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by raxxorraxor on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:50AM (#31312605)
If you run "ad campaigns" like Monsanto I don't think you can really call it unfair at this point. Why demand fairness here?

If you are a biochemist you may have been either a victim or a participant in their campaigns. You should be angry at them if they damage scientific integrity apart from that because it will reflect on anyone working in that field.

Here is the multi billion dollar company trying to influence reporting but this comment from a random redditor is wrong and a bit unfair? I don't get the incentive to even mention that.

Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by netizen-936824 on Monday May 09, 2022 @09:31AM (#31313766)
Even if Monsanto is trying to influence reporting, that doesn't mean that the criticism against GMO is automatically correct. That doesn't even make sense

The previous commenters are talking about the criticism of GMO in which GMO organisms are suddenly killing babies because there's corn making fish proteins. The criticisms literally don't make sense from a biochemical mechanism standpoint, and the previous commenters are pointing this out.

That means that the previous commenters are standing up for scientific integrity while you come along saying "big company bad, therefore everything big company says is lie"

Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by raxxorraxor on Monday May 09, 2022 @09:53AM (#31313990)
A genetically modified mold is used to create citric acid for a hundred years now and it used in almost all types of food. Maybe better if people don't know but even there are still problems with intellectual property.

Still, not the point. The topic of the article is corporate propaganda and you hand wave criticism away by making fun of "big company bad" remarks. To feel better than some of the most stupid criticism? That doesn't elevate you that much higher.

Yes, big company is bad. It did influence reporting and research for its own interest. That is very, very bad. Much worse than a criticism not hitting the mark by miles.

Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by car_analogy on Monday May 09, 2022 @09:59AM (#31314072)
> I don't get the incentive to even mention that.

"The best way to damage a cause is to advocate for it badly."

If you allow bad anti-GMO/Monsanto arguments to proliferate, the good ones will have a harder time reaching the light.

Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by tptacek on Monday May 09, 2022 @12:33AM (#31310663)
Neat, I have a kid graduating with a biochem undergrad degree right now. Reassure him about his job prospects! :P
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by epgui on Monday May 09, 2022 @02:30AM (#31311232)
There's no money in life science except at the very top. All the (dear) nutjobs that want to "follow the money" should look into software engineering haha.
[dead]
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by epgui on Monday May 09, 2022 @02:29AM (#31311227)
I have spent 12 years considering all aspects of the question (and for what it's worth, I will never be done learning), but thank you for checking. You have a very strange idea of what it's like to study and do science/research.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by eurasiantiger on Monday May 09, 2022 @04:28PM (#31319285)
Am I wrong in saying there are plenty of academics who pursue a career primarily in acquiring grants and funding? What is the ratio of those people to those who are in it for the truth?

Truth often doesn’t pay the bills.

Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by epgui on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @05:57AM (#31325255)
Uh... In many countries, almost all academics spend a significant portion of their time applying for funding, but I'm not clear on why you think these scientists don't have a genuine interest in the "truth" lol.

Lay down your tinfoil hat.

Scientists who discover new things, disprove some other thing, reshape human knowledge or otherwise change the status quo... these are rockstar-scientists, and everyone wants to be them and do exactly that. You can't just be a contrarian though: you have to be right.

Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by izzygonzalez on Monday May 09, 2022 @02:14AM (#31311156)
Non sequiturs are not helpful during polarized conversations. I can infer your meaning, but the idea that you're gesturing at seems absurd to me.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by eurasiantiger on Monday May 09, 2022 @04:30PM (#31319310)
It seems absurd to you that Monsanto would try to affect academics and the scientific world view? Did you not read even the headline of the OP article?
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by izzygonzalez on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:14PM (#31319839)
Oh that's standard fare. Institutional incentives are not always aligned with human needs. Not to reduce the severity of it all. It's really bad.

I'm more incredulous about academically trained domain experts being "brainwashed". Corruption and incompetence are simpler explanations that also make sense.

Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by eurasiantiger on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @08:03AM (#31326048)
Is there a difference?
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by epgui on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @02:31PM (#31330699)
Yes, there's a really big difference lol. I would encourage you to consult a dictionary or wikipedia to clear it up.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by chillacy on Monday May 09, 2022 @03:12PM (#31318454)
In my experience, insinuations of brainwashing are applicable in both directions. We all hold assumptions about the world which lay upon foundational beliefs like a pile of bricks. The ones at the bottom are often invisible or taken for granted.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by colordrops on Monday May 09, 2022 @12:09AM (#31310522)
Often an intuition as to whether a particular comment is a paid shill is inaccurate, but one cannot deny that there are clear trends that indicate that paid shilling is occurring in general for a particular topic or organization. There are swarms of posts and comments with the same talking points that you find on the company's website, small subreddits in support of them that have no real reason to exist other than as aggregators of talking points, and an exaggerated responses to seemingly non-controversial statements that go against the company.

It's not some lizard man conspiracy that bot nets and sock puppet accounts exist. In fact they are a pretty standard MO on the internet.

Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by acidburnNSA on Monday May 09, 2022 @01:17AM (#31310863)
+1 same stuff happens in nuclear power. I spent 15 years getting trained in the field and every time I say something factual on the internet people scream shill. It's nuts.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by coldtea on Monday May 09, 2022 @08:56AM (#31313469)
>I'm pro-GMO just in principle

One doesn't have to be a shill though - they can genuinely believe and spread what they read from shills and their "expert" "independent" arguments.

Wouldn't innocently reading and accepting as genuine science Monsanto's astroturfing and Monsanto-ghost-written "scientific" papers, "independent" experts defense, etc. play quite a role in making many people pro-GMO "in principle"?

Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by mike00632 on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:52PM (#31320276)
Parent coment talks about pesticide use and you pivot to "GMO"... Interesting. Why the deceptive debate tactic?
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by aa-jv on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:00AM (#31311973)
You've also stumbled over yourself to avoid any criticism of Monsanto for perfectly valid reasons, so that factors into whether people consider you to be a shill or not. You have set the precedent for how to defend imperialist monopolies, that's for sure. If you're not being paid, you probably should be ..
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by epgui on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:49AM (#31312242)
If Monsanto's competitors aren't paying you, they should be. /s
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by aa-jv on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:44AM (#31312562)
Monsanto doesn't have any competitors. It just buys them.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by gcheong on Monday May 09, 2022 @09:22AM (#31313685)
Wrong, Monsanto was bought by Bayer.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by aa-jv on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @09:29AM (#31326887)
You say Bayer, I say Monsanto, the distinction is entirely irrelevant since they both have a history of aggressively buying/smothering any perceived competitors that threaten their "own all the foodz" business model.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by epgui on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @02:29PM (#31330676)
Precision and exactitude are almost always relevant, and even more so when directing criticism.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by aa-jv on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @04:13AM (#31337190)
It is precise to call Monsanto and Bayer the biggest threats to food security the human species has ever faced.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by gcheong on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @04:43PM (#31345499)
Certainly could say something about how concentrating power in a few corporations is not a good thing but that is a result of capitalism under a lax anti-trust environment and all companies play under the same incentive. Not in terms of the technology though.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by aa-jv on Thursday May 12, 2022 @05:24AM (#31351317)
Bayer/Monsanto certainly have set the standard for corrupt control over the worlds food resources, though, and they're definitely playing evil games in Ukraine, for example ..
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by gcheong on Thursday May 12, 2022 @02:19PM (#31358065)
And Greenpeace and similar ilk wanted to block golden rice which could potentially saves many lives and prevent blindness in areas where vitamin A deficiency is common. They care about nothing but to demonize a technology for the purposes of their misguided ideology https://amp.theguardian.com/environment/2019/oct/26/gm-golde... . As far as I know Monsanto/Bayer do not own any IP around it.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by epgui on Saturday May 14, 2022 @05:20AM (#31376279)
I don't agree with this.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by edanm on Monday May 09, 2022 @03:18AM (#31311494)
FWIW, Monsanto isn't as much of a household name in my country (I don't think), so I'd heard of Matasano before I heard of Monsanto. And i'll probably be mixing the two up for the rest of my life :)
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by fartcannon on Monday May 09, 2022 @01:19AM (#31310879)
What's yet even more funny is the website in your user info is suckpuppet.org. Heavy irony I guess? I hope?
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by tptacek on Monday May 09, 2022 @03:04PM (#31318360)
I've owned that domain since before the word took on its current message board meaning. I just liked puppets made from socks.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by fartcannon on Monday May 09, 2022 @10:09PM (#31322577)
The term has been in use since 80's Usenet - has it been that long? Wow. Fair enough that you just like sock puppets. Though I hope you do you see the humour in someone who defends big corporations like Monsanto on forums having an email ending in sockpuppet. It's so on the nose its almost painful. Anyways, enjoy your day.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by raxxorraxor on Monday May 09, 2022 @05:58AM (#31312281)
It works because it is finely tuned to appeal to the target demographic. Low confidence users swallow anything that is classified as "privileged information" or painted as such.

There are some key topics where this won't work and where PR must lay low. At least for a while. But some sites are a very fruitful ground for that. It will be eaten up by some that too argue for it without having used more than 5 minutes looking into the topic itself.

I believe we also have seen this for nuclear power a lot lately.

Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by KennyBlanken on Sunday May 08, 2022 @10:28PM (#31309830)
A couple years ago there was a reddit account that did nothing but pop up like clockwork whenever Mons.anto was mentioned. It cited these ghostwritten studies, claiming that they were proof Gl..ypho-sate was safe.

It was so obvious other commenters would poke fun at them and tell other redditors to go look at their comment history.

Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by shostack on Sunday May 08, 2022 @10:31PM (#31309851)
I'm a marketer, and when I see that sort of thing I have to question why nobody on their social team is seeing it be called out (for the crap that it is) and at the very least says "this is not performing well).
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by heavyset_go on Sunday May 08, 2022 @11:12PM (#31310141)
They've probably subcontracted and outsourced some of their reputation management to shitty providers. You see this all the time with SEO and link building, for example.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by grapeskin on Sunday May 08, 2022 @11:09PM (#31310112)
A large number of people probably just skim the top 5 comments. For them, seeing an astroturfed “actually X is great and here’s why” comment is enough for them. They’re not digging 8 levels deep into a thread until it’s finally shown that the person is decisively a shill.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by heavyset_go on Sunday May 08, 2022 @11:15PM (#31310166)
It's this. Normal people might quickly read some comments on Reddit and then go on with their lives without digging into them, building a false consensus in their minds. They never really think to challenge what they read, not because they're dumb or anything like that, but because people only have so much time and energy to put towards critically analyzing what they see online.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by vasoolibhai on Sunday May 08, 2022 @11:22PM (#31310219)
Why did you spell Monsanto as Mons.anto and Glyphosate as Gl..ypho-sate ? Any specific thing you are trying to stay out of ?
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by AtomicOrbital on Sunday May 08, 2022 @09:56PM (#31309699)
Credit must also go to mass purely for max profit agribusiness who just don't care and are too big to fight so responsibility to stuart falls to the enlightened citizens knowing government is toothless
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by charcircuit on Sunday May 08, 2022 @10:20PM (#31309799)
What strategy do you think they should use instead to correct people spreading misinformation about their company and products. Being a popular brand to hate is not a good pr image.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by nickpeterson on Sunday May 08, 2022 @10:27PM (#31309827)
What misinformation?
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by charcircuit on Sunday May 08, 2022 @10:31PM (#31309853)
Any kind that it sees.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by nickpeterson on Sunday May 08, 2022 @10:34PM (#31309875)
I’m sorry are you arguing that this is a reasonable course for Monsanto to take? How about they just disclose when products are shown to cause cancer and try to make ones that don’t?
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by tptacek on Sunday May 08, 2022 @10:37PM (#31309893)
Do you have an argument ready that people who do not already agree with you about the evils of Monsanto might find persuasive? Your response here is pretty conclusory.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by nickpeterson on Sunday May 08, 2022 @10:45PM (#31309951)
I don’t understand the point you’re making, explain it to me like I’m a complete moron so I don’t misinterpret you.
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by tptacek on Sunday May 08, 2022 @11:13PM (#31310156)
There's an actual controversy over whether Monsanto's best known products are actually harmful to people, especially on balance vs. their substitutes. Your response for how Monsanto should handle this situation seems to be that they should dispose of the controversy and just concede your side of it. That's only persuasive to people that already agree with your side of the argument. Do you have a better one?
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by harry8 on Sunday May 08, 2022 @11:59PM (#31310463)
Sure I'll believe there's an "actual controversy" I don't know any better.

What conclusion can be drawn from a company ghostwriting studies and pretending they are not the source of them that support propositions that are convenient to them? Is doing such a thing going to "add to the controversy?" Does the increase in controversy help them in any way? "There are other studies so it is unclear if on balance..."

When they are caught out doing so, should we update whatever prior we have about the truth of the proposition that is controversial? Does it make you trust what they say more, or less? Are there any similarities at all to the "smoking causes cancer, heart disease, strokes etc" controversies of the past you can see? Like for example tobacco companies hiring Berkeley's best statisticians to cast doubt on all the studies showing tobacco smoking is quite unhealthy. New statistical techniques were developed to do so and they're good ones still in use! Of course smoking is no longer controversial at all anymore, is it? They did get decades more sales out of "the controversy" and it really was one!

Once you catch an organization of any kind with a very, very large ulterior motive in influencing "the controversy" doing so dishonestly, where do you think your prior should be before you see solid evidence to update it for claims that such an organization is making?

Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by charcircuit on Sunday May 08, 2022 @11:30PM (#31310271)
I'm just saying in general if it were to happen. Should they just let everyone dog pile onto their company and do nothing?
Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by dylan604 on Monday May 09, 2022 @12:58AM (#31310791)
In the words of Jimmy McNulty, "What the f** did I do?"

Part of being on top of the pile is taking hits. Comes with the territory, and if can't staff up for it with all your earnings, then tough cookies.

Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by ocdtrekkie on Sunday May 08, 2022 @10:39PM (#31309905)
So the issue here is if Monsanto's products were safe, they wouldn't have to pay people to attach their name to company-written articles claiming they are. If you have to buy your support (looking at Google Public Policy team here hard), you probably are not a good company.

In short, if Roundup was safe, it's likely there would be studies proving so from scientists not paid by Monsanto to do so. The fact that they have to ghostwrite them means there isn't any legitimate science supporting their position.

Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by Supermancho on Monday May 09, 2022 @12:28AM (#31310625)
> So the issue here is if Monsanto's products were safe, they wouldn't have to pay people to attach their name to company-written articles claiming they are.

That isn't how scientific evidence has been received by the public and that's blatantly obvious of the last few years.

There are plenty of "independent" roundup-is-safe whitepapers, which unsurprisingly, either use large amounts of Monsanto data or Monsanto facilities. Sifting through the details to discount them is quite laborious.

There are a scant few "roundup-causes-cancer", which is a consequence of Monsanto monopolizing, sabotaging, or restricting traceable data.

Re:Monsanto’s ghostwriting to influence science and media by mike00632 on Monday May 09, 2022 @06:02PM (#31320401)
Actually no. Monsanto pays for studies to be done on just one of the active ingredients of RoundUp, not on RoundUp itself.

RoundUp has chemicals in it that exist solely to help the active ingredients permeate tissues. Test with only active ingredients and it can appear relatively safe. Test actual RoundUp and it is invariably toxic.

That is why there are countless studies showing RoundUp to be toxic and populations who have been negatively affected all while Monsanto publishes an avalanche of paid studies purposefully conducted on a select active ingredient instead of the product itself.