There's a long history leading up to those events. I find it unlikely another planet will share it.
>> "There are things in the universe billions of years older than either of our races. They are vast, timeless. And if they are aware of us at all, it is as little more than ants…and we have as much chance of communicating with them as an ant has with us. We know. We've tried. And we've learned we can either stay out from underfoot, or be stepped on."
I think my favorite variation on why we seem alone was how Earth exists in a space version of the Bermuda Triangle, called the Veil of Madness, that all spacefaring civilizations avoid: https://creepypasta.fandom.com/wiki/Mankind
People get all worked up about dyson spheres and radio signals, but these are so deeply rooted in the human understanding of things in our tiny tiny slice of the universe.
The beauty of the film Arrival was showing the challenge of interacting with a truly alien language.
We see a variation of this in convergent evolution across distantly related species (e.g. the evolution of wings).
But in any case, there will be some commonality in environments across many planets, owing to what environments are the most probable hosts of life, and to the fact that the laws of physics are universal.
Intelligence across species shares common characteristics even between dolphins, apes and birds which all evolved it independently.
50-100 years is probably par for that particular course. A very narrow timespan in the grand scheme of things.
When you pick up an encrypted signal, it's still obvious there's a signal there. Radio telescopes will pick up cell phone signals, for example; that's why there is a radio quiet zone near the Green Bank telescope. You just can't decode the message itself without the encryption keys and algorithm.
When it comes to interplanetary reception, though, any intelligently-constructed signals will likely be below the noise floor unless deliberately broadcast for our benefit. No coherent carrier or sidebands? No spreading sequence? No chance of detection, whether encrypted or not.
Many spread-spectrum applications such as GPS use signals that are well below the thermal noise floor by the time they're received. Those signals generally can't be detected without a known sequence to correlate them against.
Really we are more likely to pick up recognizable signals from civilizations that are intentionally trying to contact us. It's possible we could pick up radio leakage, but the signal would be a lot weaker. So there are orders of magnitude more stars that could be intentionally contacting us, vs accidentally leaking a signal. (At least assuming the ratio of the strength of their intentional vs accidental radio emissions is similar to ours.)
That is true historically, but historically we weren't at a distance of light years. Given the vastness of the universe, it seems quite possible that by the time we detect another alien civilization via their emissions in the radio spectrum, that civilization has already gone extinct.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Waitangi
More controversially I would pick India and China's encounters with Europe. I think it's possible to argue that both India and China were substantially more technologically advanced than the Europeans when significant links were established. India had maths and spinning (also probably better guns), China had silk, porcelain, paper, printing and the compass; also bigger better ships.
There were several meetings of civilizations of comparable level of advancement and strength on Earth. I posit that in space it's significantly less probable, unless we consider these civilizations to also be sisters, all humanoids coming from a common source, like these of Earth.
Not to mention the impracticality of communicating with your home planet across several light years.
If you’re basing this off of what’s happened in the past on this planet, without a good explanation as to why that would apply to an alien civilization, I’d suggest that you’re not using a good model. Bayesian epistemology is not a good way to decide what’s true, because new knowledge is created which makes the old models not work anymore.
It is simply a result of Shannon's entropy. To be detectable, signals have to be broadcasted and low entropy, the opposite of what we need for efficient communication. A signal that makes best use of its bandwidth would be indistinguishable from noise for someone who doesn't know the protocol, it is also likely to be precisely targeted at the recipient and unwanted emissions kept to a minimum in order to limit interference.
It is already happening on earth as we are replacing loud analog TV emissions with more subtle and better targeted cell phone signals.
Imagine there are 1% chances that an encounter with an alien civilization spells the end of humanity.
Or 0.1%, or 0.01%
Now roll that dice for millions and millions of years. It's probably a good idea to switch to communication technologies that don't broadcast your location (and your technological unsophistication). Just in case.
Chances that two civilizations, if they detect each other, would be on the same level of development are slim. And once a less technologically advanced civilization meets a more technologically advanced one, game is over soon. Ask Aztecs, or Sioux, or pick any other historical example.