Is it more likely to find negatively correlated securities across industries, like the SPDR ETFs, rather than individual stocks?
And most people blow up their account, because their trading strategies worked for a long time.
Speaking for a friend, of course.
Setting stop loss for qualified trader should be like looking around when you are crossing the street on intersection.
There some people may have gambling problem, or software has bugs, but it is another story..
I've never understood stop-loss, it seems to me that by using stop-loss, one is basically saying "I don't know what the fundamental value is and if it goes down I want to sell". Then, why buy the thing in the first place?
A strategy that indiscriminately buys more of an asset as the asset price goes down only works with an infinite bankroll. Such a strategy run with a finite bankroll will necessarily blow up eventually. Rigid stop losses mostly just increase the volatility of a strategy though (which also contributes to portfolio drag). A sustainable strategy harvests volatility of the underlying (mean reversion) and/or dynamically deleverages (momentum) as the price moves against the entry.
because your strategy/estimation looks like not perfect in this case, and you may consider to cut your losses at 38, and not become broken if it goes down to 20.
I’ve never used the stop loss. Not once. It’s the dumbest concept I’ve ever heard. [If a stock goes down 15%] I’m automatically out. But I’ve also never hung onto a security if the reason I bought it has changed. That’s when you need to sell.Trading strategies is more for shorter term investors, when circumstances can change very fast while you are visiting bathroom, and induce significant losses, that's why you need stop loss to limit your risks in such cases.
Having said that, if you can find a negative correlation AND there is a strong reason to believe that the negative correlation will hold as long as X and Y hold, then the tool could be very useful.
The correlation is only a first indicator.
- Building things like this is always great. And its a fun site to poke around on.
- I would not count on this approach or expect it to be reliable in terms of actually hedging. Correlation, as a measure, has lots of issues. You are boiling down a lot of complex relationships into a single number. While it is convenient for many calculations, there are many problems. For example, many asset classes will go through periods with positive correlation and then later, negative correlation. This is due to a factor driving both securities price becoming more or less volatile compared to the other drivers. E.g., recent increased volatility around inflation expectations driving correlations between rates and equities. Whereas, few years ago, inflation was not driving anything.
- One alterative approach is to have a "risk model". Which essentially decomposes a security into drivers. Each security then represents a basket of these drivers. You can then use this model for range of purposes. While not perfect by any means, the model contains more information than a correlation. These too have a range of issues and creation and use is as much art as science.
- In general, you won't find many negative (or even very low) correlations across individual equities. Most stocks are driven by a common set shared risk factors that drive much of the risk. But if you can find negatively correlated securities (or lowly correlated), then that is certainly helpful.