News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by msrenee on Sunday May 01, 2022 @05:47AM (#31223558)
I'm missing the logic of the second 10k. He had already exceeded the limit. Why did he think that doing it again would change the outcome?

It looks to me like he was going to get the extra $25 returned to him and have 10k in bonds. It's definitely vague though.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by adrianmonk on Sunday May 01, 2022 @11:29AM (#31225809)
They assumed the government's software would do this:

(1) Purchase #1 for $25 successful --> reduce remaining limit from $10000 to $9975.

(2) Purchase #2 for $10000 rejected and refund pending --> DO NOT reduce limit since you know the purchase didn't go through.

(3) Purchase #3 for $9975 within limit --> allow purchase, reduce limit to exactly $0.

Instead, at step 2, the software seems to handle the purchase by unconditionally taking $10000 off the limit at purchase time and putting $10000 back later when the refund is processed. (And consequently, at step 3, it failed the purchase.)

There isn't an obvious reason to do it this way, so it's surprising. It seems like if you can reduce the limit, you can check if you've exceeded it and just fail the purchase and never modify the limit (at purchase or refund time).

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by leephillips on Sunday May 01, 2022 @11:44AM (#31225963)
The email clearly says that the excess purchase will be refunded. He lost me here; I was mystified when he decided to purchase another $9975.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by adrianmonk on Sunday May 01, 2022 @12:29PM (#31226333)
Oh, I think the email is ambiguous! I had a totally different interpretation, although I absolutely see yours now.

I interpreted "refund of the excess purchase" to mean that it is a refund of the whole purchase. If it were a partial refund, they could have just written "refund of the excess".

By adding "purchase", they made it sound to me like there are two categories of purchases (excess and non-excess) and that this purchase belongs to the excess category. That is, I saw "excess" as an adjective that says why the refund is happening, not how much is being refunded.

The more I analyze the wording, the less I'm sure which interpretation is right.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by leephillips on Sunday May 01, 2022 @12:44PM (#31226457)
Me too! My interpretation was obvious to me at first, but after reading your comments and others I can easily see it the other way. I still think my interpretation is more natural, but there’s no question that they should have been less ambiguous. How easy it would have been to use a few more words for more clarity. Also, ideally, the actual amounts in question should have been spelled out in the email.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by sam1r on Sunday May 01, 2022 @03:01PM (#31227675)
Wait a second, does that mean that his original plan to invest $10k, after the excess refund, was accomplished?

The last statement of the post mentions how he will not get any return. But he's only going to be refunded the excess.

So ultimately, did he, or will he still make his $850, as initially intended?

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by leephillips on Sunday May 01, 2022 @03:07PM (#31227741)
The author is invested, but there is some question about whether he or she has realized that.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by scarface74 on Sunday May 01, 2022 @12:17PM (#31226240)
If I have a $10K credit limit, I charge $9975 and then I pay $9975, my credit limit is automatically increased back to $10K before the payment goes through.

She didn’t have a completely incorrect mental model. But the credit card company is being a lot more lenient than the government is being and the government should be more strict.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by londons_explore on Sunday May 01, 2022 @12:21PM (#31226274)
I expect the logic for allowing a transaction looks at all 'purchases', including the current one, and sees if the total is over 10,000. If it is, throw an error, send an automated email, and let a human deal with reversing the transaction when they see what happened in the error log.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by tillmannhgl on Sunday May 01, 2022 @04:42PM (#31228480)
Exactly, this!
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by viraptor on Sunday May 01, 2022 @05:51AM (#31223573)
They thought they exceeded the limit by trying to send $10000+$25, so given that the $10000 was coming back, they expected that they're again $9975 under the limit.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by eterm on Sunday May 01, 2022 @06:02AM (#31223628)
That's an odd interpretation of the refund. The email clearly states,

> "A refund of the excess purchase..."

So they'd be refunded the excess, i.e. $25.

Putting another $9,975 through just feels like being "too smart".

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by zarzavat on Sunday May 01, 2022 @09:42AM (#31224946)
It’s bad English. The unambiguous terminology would be simply “excess” or “excess part of the purchase”. The term “excess purchase” sounds like the entire purchase is excess i.e. the adjective “excess” is modifying the noun “purchase” [the purchase was excess]. But they intended it as a noun adjunct where the noun “purchase” is modifying the noun “excess” [the excess was a purchase]. But this parse is not at all preferably taken syntactically, only the semantics clue you into it.

Very sloppy for a consumer financial communication, but I guess that governments can get away with it.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by oneeyedpigeon on Sunday May 01, 2022 @05:35PM (#31228916)
Imagine if the email had just said "excess part of the purchase: $25". No way thy would've made that mistake.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by msrenee on Sunday May 01, 2022 @10:43AM (#31225402)
They could purchase up to $10k in bonds. They exceeded that by $25 dollars. Each dollar or penny or half-penny is a separate portion of a bond in my mind, although I don't know how that works legally. So the excess purchase would be the $25 he was in excess of the maximum purchase. Just the way I interpreted it, but by no means the legal or actual way it's handled.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by scoot on Sunday May 01, 2022 @03:02PM (#31227690)
Parent is correct however. "Excess" or "excess amount" would be clear. "Excess purchase" is confusing.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by OJFord on Sunday May 01, 2022 @06:12AM (#31223684)
I found that ambiguous, could either read it as the excess amount or the entirety of the purchase that resulted in excess balance.

But anyway it just shows more UX issues - if it's the former then why didn't the balance update to show $10k; in either case why does it accept the payment before checking? It should just say no you've hit your limit this year, or you've already subscribed $25 this year you're limit is $9975.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by Ekaros on Sunday May 01, 2022 @07:10AM (#31224006)
It is probably backed by some old mainframe system and done in batches. Earlier the post told it took couple days for 25$ to show up.

So it is not real time system, but likely processed weekly, monthly or like. And all of the messes are bunched up and processed for single out come for period of time.

User was just stupid not to wait a week before next attempt...

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by OJFord on Sunday May 01, 2022 @08:14AM (#31224398)
'Cannot make further subscription while one is pending, try again later' then.

But I don't see why you can't just record '25' even if it won't settle for days/weeks, and not allow >$9975 in the meantime. (If the $25 doesn't go through then fine, you just end up with $25 capacity still.)

I bet it allows you to make a single >$10k payment only to reject it (on an 8-10week time frame) if it behaves like this.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by isaacgreyed on Sunday May 01, 2022 @08:55AM (#31224647)
I wouldn't be surprised if the process is intertwined with a paper one as well. That adds significant complication, but it still shouldn't take it.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by dwighttk on Sunday May 01, 2022 @07:44AM (#31224214)
Why do they take the money before checking if they should take the money?

If they waited a week they wouldn’t get the 8.5% (I believe)

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by Ekaros on Sunday May 01, 2022 @08:23AM (#31224446)
The email of over payment seems to be dated 13th of April so there should have been some time left in that month. At least I think it is tied to month and not certain date in a month.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by dwighttk on Sunday May 01, 2022 @10:58AM (#31225539)
Oh… gotcha. Yeah shoulda waited.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by OJFord on Sunday May 01, 2022 @01:34PM (#31226898)
Missed the edit window, but I can't leave that - I meant 'your limit', of course. I blame Android keyboard.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by viraptor on Sunday May 01, 2022 @06:12AM (#31223680)
You could interpret the "excess purchase" as the excess amount (so $25 refund) or as the excess purchase transaction (so $10000 refund).
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by hedora on Sunday May 01, 2022 @10:19AM (#31225197)
A purchase is a well defined noun, and this thing's UI was written by a lawyer that's paid to interpret US tax code.

I'm 90% sure the author will end up with a $25 bond. There's a 10% chance it won't actually cancel the $9975 purchase, due to races between the probably bolted on email part and the thing that reconciles all the transactions by scanning their (emulated?) tape drive at night.

Either way, it's pretty clearly a bug in the server implementation (unless this behavior is accidentally required by law, which wouldn't surprise me either...)

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by msrenee on Sunday May 01, 2022 @10:36AM (#31225335)
I can see the logic.

Is there no way to purchase these bonds besides this website?

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by caymanjim on Sunday May 01, 2022 @10:51AM (#31225475)
The only other way is via your annual tax return.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by dx034 on Monday May 02, 2022 @07:26AM (#31233751)
You can purchase government debt via tax returns? How does that make sense? I've never heard of anything like that in other countries.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by msrenee on Sunday May 01, 2022 @11:28AM (#31225806)
That certainly is a pain.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by xiphias2 on Sunday May 01, 2022 @06:08AM (#31223662)
He didn't understand the email, and thought that buying the bonds wasn't successful.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by randallsquared on Sunday May 01, 2022 @06:34AM (#31223808)
At the end, it's clear that he still thinks that, rather than that he has 10K in I bonds and 10K to be refunded, which seems more consistent with the language and events.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by raverbashing on Sunday May 01, 2022 @07:17AM (#31224046)
Yeah, I noticed that too

His 10k bonds should be there, they will refund the excess, not the whole thing

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by xen0 on Sunday May 01, 2022 @08:02AM (#31224319)
Still leaves them with $200, waiting for the erroneous $10k to be returned.

The author's reading comprehension may leave something to be desired, but so does the interface they were using.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by randallsquared on Sunday May 01, 2022 @08:25AM (#31224455)
Actually, only the second transaction's rejection is good evidence that the author's interpretation is wrong! The wording of the interface is definitely pretty terrible.