News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by danbruc on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:57PM (#31157612)
What happens in busy places when tens or hundreds of vehicles or robots illuminate the environment? How do several independent time-of-flight camera systems coexist? Are there existing solutions from other areas that are already using time-of-flight camera systems?
Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by xnx on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:15PM (#31157869)
Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by ARandomerDude on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:03PM (#31157700)
Headline 2035: terrorists cause 200 car pile up with cheap DRFM-like device.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_radio_frequency_memory

Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by rbanffy on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:27PM (#31158026)
Cars (of 2035) ought to have multiple sensors and should be able to discard discrepant input - if (stereo) visual, radar, sonar and lidar disagree, the car should switch to a "degraded safe" self driving mode and signal it to cars around it via multiple channels (visual, radio, ultrasound, etc).
Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by bdamm on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:40PM (#31158209)
Cars of today already have this problem. If one sensor says there's a solid object right in front of you that just popped out, and another sensor says there probably isn't but is confused, what do you do? Slam on the brakes?

Teslas today have this "degraded mode" and the reaction is to sound an alarm and ask the driver to pay attention and grip the wheel, while slowing. This seems like a reasonable thing to do. Cars of 2035 that have no wheel better have perfect sensor integration and false-data elimination.

Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by rbanffy on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:54PM (#31158386)
If you have two sensors, you have one. You can't resolve a disagreement of two sensors. Stopping the car is the only option in this case, but, say, if you have four sensors and one says there is 100% certainty of a solid object ahead of you, one says it's 50/50 and two others say it's a 100% no, then a mild braking action may be all that's needed, to give the car and its sensors more time to react and assess. Worst case scenario you still hit the solid object at an easily survivable speed. You also signal cars behind you to actuate their brakes accordingly (and, in turn, inform traffic behind them of their actions).
Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by samstave on Monday April 25, 2022 @02:50PM (#31159065)
And it gets way more interesting when every care itself is a cluster, or node of sensors, and all of these sensors of the same type can form telemetry fabrics of all the families of sensor-types across the nodes.

Each a plane, and then ultimately being able to see the relationships of patterns of sensor groups. I wonder how that information will become useful?

Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by rbanffy on Monday April 25, 2022 @04:34PM (#31160237)
First use could be to model traffic patterns - as undoubtedly all online mapping apps already do. As the meshes get denser, the cars can become aware of traffic patterns around them and make decisions in a coordinated way, forming "trains" to reduce drag in highways, for instance. Eventually enough data is gathered that we have predictive models for traffic jams and accidents and can act to prevent them.
Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by astrange on Monday April 25, 2022 @08:17PM (#31162533)
This seems fanciful - "if it'd work so well, why don't we already do it" is a real point against it. I think people imagining this are forgetting problems with communications overhead, trusting each other, and how much it'd actually be useful.

What we do have are realtime traffic alerts and Waze, and presumably a robot car could use those as well as we do.

Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by samstave on Monday April 25, 2022 @05:00PM (#31160518)
exactly
Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by Tade0 on Monday April 25, 2022 @04:11PM (#31159920)
> You can't resolve a disagreement of two sensors.

Two sensors are still useful when all you need to know is if there's a disagreement.

Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by rbanffy on Monday April 25, 2022 @04:29PM (#31160170)
True, but the usual action is to hand the decision to the human, who can look out, figure out which (if any) sensor is right, and take appropriate action (737 Max feelings).
Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by astrange on Monday April 25, 2022 @08:15PM (#31162522)
Humans are better at using our big two sensors because we can interrogate the world with them - i.e. move our head or refocus our eyes on what we want to look at, or just put the sun visor down if there's too much glare.

I assume the people working on cars also know they could build this, but most people don't seem to notice it's a failing of passive sensors like most camera setups.

Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by AlotOfReading on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:50PM (#31158338)
You can't and won't get perfect sensing. It's simply not possible.

A safe vehicle design avoids the situation of having to decide whether to slam on the brakes constantly by realizing that's a fundamentally unsafe mode to be operating in. You should already be slowing/able to safely brake/pulling over/stopped before that point excepting rare "everything explodes simultaneously" situations you can try to engineer away with safety ratings and MTBF numbers.

Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by rbanffy on Monday April 25, 2022 @02:17PM (#31158669)
> A safe vehicle design avoids the situation

And, since you aren't driving a fully automated vehicle, it driving below speed limits becomes much less annoying (and, if all cars can coordinate their speeds, prevent traffic jams altogether).

Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by shadowgovt on Monday April 25, 2022 @04:00PM (#31159774)
Drivers of today also have this problem in the form of a lack of standards for vehicle height and headlight power.
Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by rightbyte on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @05:00AM (#31165366)
I have worked with Velodyne Lidars and I noticed ghosting at sun set with direct illumination of the units. I.e. small cloud shaped ghost objects.

There are interference problems.

Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by alimov on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:17PM (#31157902)
> What happens in busy places when tens or hundreds of vehicles or robots illuminate the environment?

I think about this one a lot. While I haven’t looked into it I wonder if this will impact insects and birds somehow

Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by robocat on Monday April 25, 2022 @08:48PM (#31162724)
Sonar for bats and dolphins etcetera. I think illumination from different sources can help resolve the location of objects (using reflections on objects from other sources, or tracking the source itself such as a car with LIDAR).
Re:New Lidar System Promises 3D Vision for Cameras, Cars, an... by alimov on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @01:35PM (#31170482)
Yeah if the sources are in communication with one another :)