You also completely skip one of the main arguments in favor of a college education. Does Khan Academy also provide an atmosphere where students can study, party, hook up, make mistakes, and otherwise learn how to become members of society? I don't think there's a YouTube channel with that feature.
Granted, kids shouldn't pay $40k a year to party, but you're declaring victory over lecture halls with a collection of online classes that started a week ago. We're a long way off from fixing education--a couple of YouTube videos and a single co-working space on the West Coast are one in many steps we need to take.
You know what provides that atmosphere? New York. Or SF. Or Boston, Seattle, Austin--pretty much any city. I did not miss out on those opportunities from dropping out. The difference was that I was in the real world that colleges theoretically prepare you for: no RAs, no meal plans, fewer second chances, etc. I don't know why a fake version of the real world is a better preparation for the real world that the real real world.
There was one other difference: not going to school is far, far cheaper. And you have enough free time to defray even that minimal cost by working.
I have to vigorously disagree with the assertion that the real world offers fewer second chances. In fact, it's the other way around, the real world (i.e. marketplace) offers as many chances as you can create.
It's the rigidity of academia that closes off chances for a lot of people who don't fit the predefined molds (categorization by major, standardized pedagogical technique (the lecture), and on and on). Additionally, academia is often a zero sum game (because of grading on a curve).
Right! I don't know why doctors have to practice on cadavers. Stick a scalpel in their hand and let them operate!
You first.
That's also a completely different argument from the one I was addressing. It sounds like your version is that 18 to 22-year-olds are too dangerous to be unleashed on society (the person getting the "operation" in your analogy), so we need to send them to school to keep them out of trouble.
But I don't understand why school is a better alternative than the job market.
That's the most important lesson you don't learn in college: how to do something completely novel. And it's the most important lesson one can ever learn.
Ignoring that many people don't live near large cities like these, how should a 17-year old support themselves? What would they do instead of going to school? Waiting tables isn't scalable--there aren't enough restaurants.
(Although I don't think those particular objections are valid, I'm still not in favor of the "uncollege" concept.)
How does 20 Under 20 change education in any way?
You start with just 20 Under 20, and then scale it out after initial success. Just like YC. also provide an atmosphere where students can study,
party, hook up, make mistakes, and otherwise learn how to
become members of society...
kids shouldn't pay $40k a year to party
Well, we are in the middle of a Great Recession and the projections are that the double dip is coming [1].We need to decouple the stated reason (it will get you a job) from the actual reason (it is fun). Because it is not so much fun when it doesn't get you a job and the party is over.
[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/09/your-money/a-recession-for...
The problem with scaling is that is assumes most people start at the same base line, need the same resources, and progress at the same speed. We've had an industrial model of education in this country for decades and it's not really working for us. I've seen countless people try to "solve" the education problem by modeling business practices and generally speaking it never works out.
Many of the Thiel Fellows have already undertaken 3rd level studies but the majority have not, and the Thiel Fellowship is not meant to be a condensed college replacement. It's a platform from which the Fellows can launch their ideas.
Education is a very broad term. We shouldn't limit it to what happens on a college campus, but I think that we should bear in mind that for the majority of people a college setting works best for their development, both social and intellectual.
But LinkedIn/github/etc. are starting to provide better networks. As an employer, I give more credence to a kid with a good github account than I do to even a CS major from Harvard.
As for credentialing, that is the next big step. It is already the case that if you see a CV with Google or Facebook on it, it doesn't matter whether that person has a college degree. You know they've been vetted by an institution of comparable prestige to Harvard.
Solving the vetting and credentialing problem is going to be important, but it's not insuperable by any means. For example, ai-class.org, db-class.org, and ml-class.org are providing certificates of accomplishment. Any kid who nails Andrew Ng's CS229 class is definitely someone to consider over a liberal arts major, or even most CS undergrads.
Instead of a school what we really need is a company that does some of what a school does (guided education/training/ credentialing), some of what a recruiter does (identify and matching talent), and some of what an HR department does (onboarding company specific training).
This is just based on my experience (not a pleasant one) in identifying and recruiting talent.
ootachi's comment is spot on. big companies like google, microsoft, and goldman sachs get way too many applications to not care about degrees.
yeah, if you filter by college degrees, you're going to miss out on some great candidates, but there are a lot of great candidates out there. you don't need all of them to find a great hire. its simply not practical to do in depth examinations of every candidate. a good github account? big companies get so many resumes that they don't even finish reading many of the resumes, so forget about looking at code on github.
maybe in the future, certain online universities may get enough general recognition that merely the presence of that university on a resume will pick up the interest of HR people, but currently, that's nowhere close to true. and until that happens, most kids will prefer harvard to taking classes online.
plus, its not like its mutually exclusive. a kid from harvard can have a good github account.
on the question of networks:
linkedin is a joke. i'm way more likely to get a job or start a business with someone i knew in college than someone off of linkedin.
github is a lot better, but its a pretty restricted space. you can get interviews for lots of kinds of jobs by going to harvard. programming is probably all you can get with a good github account (and probably not at really big companies). maybe if you're 18 and you know that all you want to is programming, maybe you should take a bunch of classes online, but the majority of 18 year olds probably want more flexibility.
They might be better off not accepting resumes and just recruiting people with outstanding github accounts.
So, they already do that kind of thing :)
Outside of that top 10, the value is only in certain subjects (e.g. engineering, accounting, nursing).
I think what you are saying is a "Khan Academy" concept as opposed to the actual Kahn Academy...
As of the latest info on the Khan academy site (2/23/11) Kahn had done all the videos:
http://www.khanacademy.org/about/faq#videos
You're not suggesting that Sal Kahn is in any way shape or form a replacement for learning from multiple qualified professors, instructors etc in their respective fields (even in they are only phd candidates for example) are you?
Someone with no real world experience in many of the things he is teaching is "as good" as someone who has actually done something?
Sal says
"What topics do you plan to cover?
"My goal is to cover everything."
If you look at some of the latest videos, you'll see Sal recording videos side-by-side with Vi Hart and professors from Stanford (focused on medicine in this latter case) This is just the beginning.
I've heard Sal say many times, "In no way do I want to be the only person making videos. I just want to make videos until I die."
That said, I'm not convinced that 20 under 20 is a very good model for the long run. Hopefully Thiel will iterate.
Oh come on, surely you know pre-calculus better than that.
Third, the extent to which the beneficiaries of usurious student loans now find themselves on the back foot is amusing. "First they laugh at you, then they fight you..."
Wadhwa has realized that he can't simply shame the critics of higher ed into silence (as he's attempted for the last few years [1]), so now he's saying:
I don't think Wadhwa understands what this means. It means things like ai-class.org, ml-class.org, and db-class.org replacing large lecture classes. It means companies doing a lot more stuff like MCSE, and a lot less stuff like paying for people to do two years of an MBA. It means coworking spaces like biocurious at $150/month [2] replacing the expensive (and inaccessible) university labs.Most of all, it means obsolescing the higher ed business model of charging $60,000 per year [3].
In other words, while it's refreshing to hear people in higher ed finally start to acknowledge that the benefits they provide need to be greater than their costs, they don't understand that the solution involves the end of college as we know it.
How could it be otherwise when there is now a six-order-of-magnitude gap between the cost of watching a Khan Academy video ($0) and the cost of dozing through the same content in a Harvard lecture hall ($250,000)?
[0] http://techcrunch.com/2011/10/13/founders-fund-33-million-le...
[1] http://techcrunch.com/2010/09/25/students-stay-in-school/
[2] http://biocurious.org
[3] http://www.admissions.college.harvard.edu/financial_aid/cost...