I have to vigorously disagree with the assertion that the real world offers fewer second chances. In fact, it's the other way around, the real world (i.e. marketplace) offers as many chances as you can create.
It's the rigidity of academia that closes off chances for a lot of people who don't fit the predefined molds (categorization by major, standardized pedagogical technique (the lecture), and on and on). Additionally, academia is often a zero sum game (because of grading on a curve).
Right! I don't know why doctors have to practice on cadavers. Stick a scalpel in their hand and let them operate!
You first.
That's also a completely different argument from the one I was addressing. It sounds like your version is that 18 to 22-year-olds are too dangerous to be unleashed on society (the person getting the "operation" in your analogy), so we need to send them to school to keep them out of trouble.
But I don't understand why school is a better alternative than the job market.
That's the most important lesson you don't learn in college: how to do something completely novel. And it's the most important lesson one can ever learn.
Ignoring that many people don't live near large cities like these, how should a 17-year old support themselves? What would they do instead of going to school? Waiting tables isn't scalable--there aren't enough restaurants.
(Although I don't think those particular objections are valid, I'm still not in favor of the "uncollege" concept.)
You know what provides that atmosphere? New York. Or SF. Or Boston, Seattle, Austin--pretty much any city. I did not miss out on those opportunities from dropping out. The difference was that I was in the real world that colleges theoretically prepare you for: no RAs, no meal plans, fewer second chances, etc. I don't know why a fake version of the real world is a better preparation for the real world that the real real world.
There was one other difference: not going to school is far, far cheaper. And you have enough free time to defray even that minimal cost by working.