News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by incanus77 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @11:49AM (#31111032)
Once, just once, I would like to see someone say “why is this so expensive, it’s just […]” and then build one themselves, and bring it to market, for that lower cost. Go ahead, just try.
Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by an-unknown on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:04PM (#31112108)
If you actually build one yourself (not just limited to this particular mixer, but also e.g. analog synthesizers, FM synthesizers, samplers, …), you'll be surprised by how ridiculously overpriced almost all of the available audio hardware really is. The sad part is that in many cases your prototype will be cheaper than the commercially available audio hardware.

In practice you'll probably skip the "and bring it to market" step though, because usually you'll start such a project because you wanted to have a specific mixer/synthesizer/sampler/…, and once you have it on your desk, the next project usually looks more interesting than spending the extra time to sell whatever you just developed.

Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by IAmPym on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:03PM (#31113021)
As someone who literally does this for a living at Sequential, you couldn't be more wrong
Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by javajosh on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:46PM (#31113619)
I don't do this for a living and can't imagine how a statement like "your prototype will be cheaper than commercially available options" could be taken seriously by anyone.
Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by eternityforest on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:09PM (#31114600)
If you don't count your time whatsoever and don't go for the nice case design.

I mean at the extreme case, if you can tolerate 40ms of latency and stuttering, a Raspberry Pi and some USB soundcards can do it all. The actual power needed is reasonable and ADC/DACs aren't that insane.

A Teensy 4.1 connected to an ESP32 could probably do most of this, if you wanted to do $15k of software development in your spare time and were really good at DSP.

Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by an-unknown on Thursday April 21, 2022 @08:13PM (#31116752)
Interestingly enough, it seems like the KORG wavestate is actually based on some Raspberry Pi, according to KORG's github page, so you can definitely get less than 40ms latency and no stutter. And yeah, Teensy or even FPGA evaluation boards can get you very far, since software development in your spare time is "free". If you search the web, you'll find many examples of such projects. For example I remember some FPGA based project with iirc a small ~50€ Spartan-6 eval board which implemented a fancy 32 voice 6op FM synthesizer.
Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by eternityforest on Friday April 22, 2022 @05:57AM (#31119856)
I wonder how they're doing it? Do they have a custom kernel?

Or maybe they just have some good IO. It doesn't seem to be CPU limited exactly, it's just the built in sound device doesn't like it if you turn down the block size too much. USB cards are a bit happier.

Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by TheRealPomax on Thursday April 21, 2022 @07:13PM (#31116327)
Anyone who can tolerate 40ms of latency should stick to Bluetooth. If it's more than 3ms, it's already more latency than a good RF system gives you, if it's more than 10ms things are getting questionable, and at 20+ms you've lost the ability to monitor, because what your fingers/voice do and what your ears hear are now noticeably out of sync. Try singing while monitoring yourself at 20ms delay. It's hilarious.
Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by eternityforest on Friday April 22, 2022 @05:53AM (#31119837)
I can kind of mostly sing up to 35ms or so, but at 40ms and up it's a real clown show.

My playing is already sloppy enough to not be affected till maybe 15 or so.... but it would clearly be different with a pro!

Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by zokier on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:45PM (#31113607)
> The sad part is that in many cases your prototype will be cheaper than the commercially available audio hardware.

Are you including those probably custom knurled knobs, buttons and sliders in that guesstimate too? Because those are the sort of things I'd expect to bring the cost up here. Heck, that beautifully finished aluminum case with its beveled edges alone is good chunk of money.

Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by alfalfasprout on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:22PM (#31115905)
As others have mentioned you're not considering the enclosure at all. And doubtful you're including your time, QA, etc.
Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by an-unknown on Thursday April 21, 2022 @08:54PM (#31117007)
Except that's exactly the point: if you do this in your spare time, the development time is essentially "free". The only things that cost money if you do it in your spare time are the actual materials / PCBs / components / energy. And that is in fact rather cheap, provided you have the necessary skills and tools.

Since this whole post was about a Teenage Engineering hardware module originally, which has a strong focus on the case: if you own / have access to the necessary tools already (e.g. lathe, milling machine, …), it's a bit time consuming but not exactly expensive to build something similar. Sure, e.g. aluminum costs money, but together with the electronics I'd be surprised if you really spend 1200€ (price of the TX-6). Of course in that case it wouldn't really scale if you wanted to produce more modules in the end. For completeness, the TX-6 page specifically mentions the ADCs and DACs used. If you check the (current!) prices on mouser/digikey, they are ~5€ for the 4ch ADC chip (you'll need 3), ~15€ for one of the DAC chips and ~13€ for the other one. Then maybe add some fancy STM32 microcontroller for another 15€ and you essentially got the digital part already, excluding wireless connectivity. You'll still need a few analog components, the faders, the switches, connectors, and a display (probably the most expensive part). Feel free to guesstimate what the complete electronics and aluminum case would cost, but as I said, I'd be surprised if you get even close to 1200€, even if you need a 2nd revision of the electronics.

There are also various examples of people building e.g. clones of Moog synthesizers like the Minimoog (including keyboard, wooden case, …) in their spare time, for less money than what the original Moog synthesizer would cost.

Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by joemi on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:33PM (#31112578)
What all the people disagreeing with you are ignoring is the work and skill that goes into the product design. It takes a lot of iteration, which means lots of prototypes, which means lots of time and money spent just developing the product. This means iteration on the electronics, the UI, the case, etc etc. Anyone could whip together something that's bigger, uglier, and has a worse user interface, all for less money, but to make something equivalent to what TE makes is a what takes all the time/money/effort/skill.

Also most of the disagreers are also ignoring the "bring it to market" step. Even if you built something of equivalent product design as TE, building one for yourself is vastly different than doing a product run where you expect each product to be the same. PCB design and manufacturing is relatively easy and inexpensive, but all the plastic/rubber forming/molding is much trickier and significantly expensive. Getting past the manufacturing aspect, there's the whole marketing, sales, and distribution aspect, which aren't anything to be sneezed at either. Seriously a lot of work goes into bringing a product to market that DIYers building single devices or very tiny runs of devices don't even consider. While TE might not be doing Behringer-level runs of products, their runs are definitely bigger than a lone DIYer could ever handle by themselves.

(Note: This isn't to say that TE's products are necessarily better for everyone than something they could make themselves (or buy for less from a different company), of course. After all, the world's musicians got by just fine before this mixer was released. I just wanted to chime in and explain some of reasons why TE's stuff costs more than what you might think you could make yourself.)

Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by nathanvanfleet on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:14PM (#31111399)
Not really a valid argument. Plenty of similar products out there with more competitive prices. "Make this complex product yourself" is the equivalent argument as "if you don't like something with your country just leave." People can complain that something is expensive.
Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by alfalfasprout on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:23PM (#31115914)
This is a ridiculous equivalence. If you live in a country you don't have a choice but be subject to its laws, politics, etc. You'd have to leave.

No one is forcing you to buy this product.

Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by elihu on Thursday April 21, 2022 @08:22PM (#31116798)
Honestly, this thing works pretty well for my use case: https://www.amazon.com/Moukey-MK0149-RD-FR-Ultra-Low-Noise-6...

It's not quite the same thing as the TX-6, but if I were to go to the substantial effort of making a small mixer product marketed to people like myself, that's the sort of competition I would be intimidated by, not Teenage Engineering.

Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by dsr_ on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:27PM (#31112498)
If you insist on the portable form-factor, it will be slightly troublesome.

If it's going to sit on a desk and be used all the time, a Behringer 1222USB is $250 when they aren't running a special sale. It has more channels, some usable effects, and you can add an iPad Mini with some synth software to handle the rest of the functionality. So that's half the price, and you get to play with the iPad whenever you aren't making music; or it's about 1/6 the price of the TX-6 without the synth.

Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by bombcar on Thursday April 21, 2022 @07:28PM (#31116436)
You don’t get the “look” - some people will buy this for the portability but a majority will be using it to fit into a particular look they want.

Think YouTube podcast where everything on the desk is sleek and apple or apple-like. This fits in in a way the Behringer doesn’t.

I wouldn’t be surprised at all to find YouTube videos with this on the desk but obviously not being used - where the actual dirty work is done offscreen.

Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by sanderjd on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:03PM (#31111259)
Don't people do that all the time and sometimes fail and sometimes succeed? Isn't this why we have competitive products and competing price points for most things?
Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by rchaud on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:13PM (#31113174)
Just say it costs $100/mo for 12 months for on-prem. They'll think it's an exciting new enterprise B2B SaaS.
Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by aikinai on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:16PM (#31111431)
That’s how Anker got started I believe.
Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by arkades on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:55PM (#31111960)
My understanding is that anker got started with standard white labed alibaba type goods, but differentiated themselves with good curation, meaning you actually got something decent at a low price
Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by vvvzxd on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:45PM (#31113615)
not understanding this argument. i'm not a synth manufacturer. korg and roland put out plenty of gear with great features for a lower price than this
Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by incanus77 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:58PM (#31116210)
Well, someone should tell TE then, because they obviously don't know they're making a huge mistake and this will fail miserably.
Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by vvvzxd on Thursday April 21, 2022 @07:56PM (#31116638)
im sure there are plenty of fools willing to spend the money on this for cool points, doesnt necessarily mean it isnt stupid
Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by squarefoot on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:33PM (#31111632)
No need to try as it already exists: Any Linux tablet with Reaper and a couple soft synths and a decent external sound card if needed would do a lot more for a lot less. A good portion of the cost of this device could be justified only if it really had motorized knobs and faders, which are shown in the video but not mentioned among the features; that would be a completely unnecessary gimmick (in such a device) which however would impact a lot on the cost.

Portable music devices aren't that expensive these days. Take a look at what SunVox can do on old hardware, or maybe the Polyend Tracker, which is a hardware solution that costs less than half of the tx-6 and doesn't kill the eyes on a toy display.

https://warmplace.ru/soft/sunvox/

https://polyend.com/tracker/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MQufJBVvAtY

Re:TX-6 – Teenage Engineering by abxytg on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:10PM (#31112193)
neither of these are remotely close to the tx-6....