News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by kelnos on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @05:41PM (#31103422)
The grid operator cited is the California Independent System Operator. How much of CA's electricity consumption is fed by that operator?

In the article they mention 23GW from wind and solar. A quick search says in 2018 CA's electrical generation capacity was 80GW (which I assume has only gone up). So this 97% is a bit misleading, no? It doesn't represent 97% of total CA electricity usage... it's less than 30%?

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by IvyMike on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @05:59PM (#31103609)
"The CAISO is one of the largest ISOs in the world, delivering 300 million megawatt-hours of electricity each year and managing about 80% of California's electric flow." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Independent_System_...

Right now, 3PM in California, the CAISO demand shows around 21GW of demand. http://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/index.html

Note that CAISO's peak, ever, was 50GW. (PDF) http://www.caiso.com/Documents/CaliforniaISOPeakLoadHistory....

The "installed capacity" of 80GW I believe is the number if you add the theoretical max of all hydro, solar, wind, gas peaker plants, etc. But each source will never simultaneously be at max, so we never get close to this 80GW number. https://www.energy.ca.gov/data-reports/energy-almanac/califo....

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by Mvandenbergh on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @06:54PM (#31104111)
That is all the capacity added together before de-rating. Capacity is de-rated based on how likely it is to produce during a system load peak. So a nuclear plant might be counted as 75% of nameplate to account for outage risk. Renewables are de-rated a lot and by how much changes over time as they make up a larger share of the connected capacity.

California de-rates solar by less than, say, the UK since Cali has a lot of air conditioning load which is coincident with insolation whereas summer days are the low-load periods in the UK.

The capacity before de-rating > capacity after de-rating > highest anticipated load > actual load on a normal day.

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by mschaef on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @06:12PM (#31103751)
> A quick search says in 2018 CA's electrical generation capacity was 80GW (which I assume has only gone up). So this 97% is a bit misleading, no? It doesn't represent 97% of total CA electricity usage... it's less than 30%?

Their full installed generation capacity is 80GW, but there's huge variability in actual load. As I write this, current load is around 21GW, on a range of between 18.7GW and 27GW over the day. It gets into the 40's in the summer.

https://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/default.aspx

There's a significant need for reserve capacity to deal with this load variability, as well as plant failures, etc.

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by danans on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @05:46PM (#31103459)
> How much of CA's electricity consumption is fed by that operator?

80% of California and part of Nevada also. Don't confuse the grid operator with the utility. Those are separate entities.

The ISO is the market maker for electricity - ultimately responsible for keeping supply and demand on the grid in balance. They contract with numerous entities to achieve that.

The utility is responsible for some combination of generation, transmission, distribution, and billing, depending on where you are located.

There are many other players in the markets, including spinning reserves, independent generators, demand aggregators, community-choice-aggregators, and some that play multiple roles.

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by vmception on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @06:08PM (#31103711)
> “If California is to have any hope of getting to 100% renewable energy on an August day in the future ... it will take 100 GW more energy produced by solar. Halting the progress of rooftop solar makes that goal impossible"

I'm also confused by the scales here. How are they praising the use of 15,000 MW (15GW) and 8,000 MW (8 GW) in one sentence, in an article about 97% of California's energy being used, and saying they need 100 GW in the next sentence and being sad they can't put it on rooftops. In an article showing a photo of a solar cell field in a vast, desolate, arid region of central valley.

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by Retric on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @06:10PM (#31103732)
In California August requires a lot more electricity due to AC than April. Seasonal demand differences can be huge, and why a lot of maintenance for nuclear reactors etc take place in the spring and fall.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by vmception on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @06:11PM (#31103745)
I'm catching on. Is there not enough space in central valley for this? is there too much loss transporting that electricity to population centers?
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by jeffbee on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @10:02PM (#31105309)
Space is of no concern. You would not install solar in the Central Valley generally because it is the most productive irrigated farmland on the planet. You would however put it right on top of Edwards Air Force Base, which is large enough to supply the energy needs of the entire United States, if paved over completely with solar panels.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by throwaway48375 on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @10:51PM (#31105577)
There's plenty more empty space in the adjacent area.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by Retric on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @06:20PM (#31103823)
In theory moving electricity 1,000 miles can have minimal transmission losses. Unfortunately California’s grid lacks the infrastructure to support significant long distance transmission.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by incomethax on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @06:39PM (#31103993)
Sort-of. Transmission for HTHV lines (745kV single circuit cost $2.5-4M/mile with ~1% line loss; 345kV single circuit will cost ~$1.5-2M/mile with 5% line loss). For 1MW solar capacity you typically need about 4 acres. 100GW of solar would require 400k acres of land - and come at a cost of about $3 billion for the panels, not to mention the price of land or entitlements. Add in cost of substations and transmission you’re realistically looking at a $10+ Billion project. Which while doable would not profitability compete with other grid solutions. If panels drop by another 30% and power densities improve the grid will naturally tend towards that direction.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by Retric on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @09:26PM (#31105115)
The US already has 121GW of solar installed the majority of that being large scale Grid solar. Which shows the transition is already happening at current prices.

A major part of that equation is there is a lot of land in the US available for under 2,000$/acre, however spending more is a tradeoff to reduce the need for longer distance power transmission etc.

PS: 10B for 100GW at 30% capacity factor for 20 years is 10,000,000,000$ / (100,000,000kW * 0.3 * 24h * 365 * 20) or 0.2c/kWh ignoring interest. So, I think you messed up your estimate somewhere if you think that’s uncompetitive.

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by outworlder on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @08:25PM (#31104748)
If I were a billionaire, I could spend 10 billion project with a massive reduction in fossil fuel emissions.

Or I could spend over 4 times as much to buy a social media site.

Decisions, decisions.

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by vmception on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @09:08PM (#31105010)
One sounds like an expense, the other sounds like a transfer from one pocket to the other while allowing for shifting the public perception any way desired while retaining unparalleled access to capital.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by zeroonetwothree on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @08:42PM (#31104860)
If only we weren't spending $105 billion high speed rail no one will use, we might have been able to scrounge up $10 billion for solar.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by VintageCool on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @07:00PM (#31104156)
California already has some big long-distance transmission lines.

Path 65 (aka Pacific DC Intertie) is a 3.1 GW line connecting the hydroelectric dams of Washington and Oregon to Los Angeles.

Path 27 (Intermountain DC) is a 2.4 GW line connecting LA to a big-ass coal plant in Utah that is being shifted to wind+solar+natgas+hydrogen.

Path 66 is a set of AC lines that combine for 4.8 GW from Oregon to Southern California.

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by Retric on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @09:05PM (#31104993)
Yes, but not of the places you listed are where you would put solar to supply California. If anything they will likely be used to move excess solar power out of California.

The map of solar production shows a compromise between building it in the most efficient place vs where demand and incentives is located. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_in_the_United_Stat...

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by imachine1980_ on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @06:17PM (#31103790)
not all california energy is produce in california california fo example pays to nevada if don't remember wrong to, shut down their panels to make their output higher than it is for example, or like this articule say pay other state to buy their electric excess output meaning the technically could be true

article: California invested heavily in solar power. Now there's so much that other states are sometimes paid to take it https://www.latimes.com/projects/la-fi-electricity-solar/

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by ocbyc on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @08:57PM (#31104937)
Shame only one period in this entire reply.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by everybodyknows on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @07:26PM (#31104380)
Earlier rooftop solar discussion:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30193521

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by joebob42 on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @05:46PM (#31103469)
My interpretation is that this was a low demand moment where that 27gw was more or less equal to the demand (e.g. a demand trough not a renewable output spike).
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by onlyrealcuzzo on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @05:49PM (#31103497)
So the title should be - CA generated 97% of electricity from renewable energy for a brief moment on April 3?
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by simpsond on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @06:37PM (#31103975)
Yes, the article says that in the first paragraph.

Also, solar generation is highest during march/April. Cooler temps and good angles. Demand is lower too, as temps are good for people.

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by KarlKemp on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:36AM (#31107184)
No. The whole day was the „brief moment“.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by CrimsonCape on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @05:49PM (#31103499)
No, because joebob's interpretation is wrong.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by throwawaylinux on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @07:07PM (#31104218)
How so?
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by jweir on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @05:52PM (#31103534)
Capacity is the ability to produce energy and with renewables that number is very different than with fossil fuels or nukes.

Renewables never reach capacity, well your solar might for a peak moment, but then it will drop as the sun drops.

For example - you have a 200 MW wind farm, you might only be able to produce 10MW at that moment. The capacity is 200MW, the generation is 10.

Also the 3rd was a Sunday in spring - no office workers, less demand, not a heating or cooling day in a lot of California, ie a lower energy day than say a week day in summer where the temp is 105 in the Central Valley.

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by tppiotrowski on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @05:50PM (#31103511)
From the article:

> Rooftop solar advocacy group Save California Solar said although this milestone should be celebrated, California’s renewable energy progress is better measured by conditions on a hot August summer day than a cool April spring day. Renewable peaks typically occur in the spring, due to mild temperatures and the sun angle allowing for an extended window of strong solar production.

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by ajsnigrutin on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @05:53PM (#31103545)
April 3rd was a sunday, and probably a very sunny one, with temperatures in ranges where a lot of people don't really need AC nor electrical heating.

What do you do when it's not sunny, very cold/hot, no wind, and businesses and factories are open?

Somehow we talk a lot about solar, and not enough about nuclear.

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by strainer on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @06:18PM (#31103799)
You need forms of storage for that. The conundrum can be turned on its head - "What do you do when you have nuclear and the businesses and factories are closed ?" You either simply waste nuclear capacity that you've paid and waited years for to be built - or you need forms of storage to make use of it. Both Nuclear and Renewables really want storage, they will compete for it. If you can only make use of 60% of a nuclear plants capacity, you're price per unit is 100/60 more than the 'base-load' ideal that it was sold for. And another thing future nuclear plants will have to run alongside - is more and more renewable supply since renewables are cheaper and faster to build. We will have a situation where almost all demand is met by renewable supply eventually, and before that situation the demand left nuclear will decrease from 70,60,50,40,30...% - that's even without storage. How many decades do you expect it will take before those plants built with contracts to run for half a century or more, become pointlessly uneconomic ?
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by ajsnigrutin on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @06:40PM (#31104000)
If there's too much power, it will be dirt cheap, and you'll charge your electric car then, which will maybe become affordable by then. Also with smart grid you'll regulate water heaters, ACs etc.

Still better to have too much power than not enough... Especially if eg. Russia decides to close the gas pipe, or if americans decide to "bring democracy" to another middle eastern state and that disrupta oil delivery.

We've sidetracked nuclear for decades now... The best time was decades ago, and the second vest time to build some new ones is now.

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by hedora on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:05AM (#31106170)
Electric cars are affordable now, assuming electricity is dirt cheap.

Nissan Leaf: $17K after tax incentives, $27K before.

Gas is $5/gallon. You can buy 5400/gallons for the price of an unsubsidized leaf.

Assume a leaf-alike ICE car gets 40 miles per gallon. It will go 216K miles for the unsubsidized retail price of the leaf.

Leaf batteries last at least 100K miles, and cost about $6K.

The purchase cost of the ICE car, and 216K miles of motor oil, engine and exhaust work have to be under $6K ($12K if the leaf batteries need to be swapped twice) or the leaf is cheaper.

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by idiotsecant on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @09:27PM (#31105124)
No, having too much power without storage is exactly as bad as not enough. That's how the physics works. It's a zero sum game or it's lights out for the grid. It takes a lot of smart people and simulations to do a semi decent job of walking that tightrope day after day after day. Overproduction is a huge problem, as evidenced by the frequent negative power pricing of CA solar
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by standardUser on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:04AM (#31106167)
"No, having too much power without storage is exactly as bad as not enough."

That makes no sense to me.

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by throwaway2037 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:17AM (#31107085)
I agree. The excess can be used to produce hydrogen gas (for heavy industry) from splitting water.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by adrianN on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:30AM (#31107154)
If you have the infrastructure to produce hydrogen at scale you pretty much automatically have the infrastructure to store excess renewable production. That makes the "baseload!!" argument for nuclear moot.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by idiotsecant on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:55PM (#31113726)
if you have hydrogen splitters than you don't have excess power. You have as much load as you have power.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by viraptor on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @08:05PM (#31104629)
It may be still better to run nuclear plants then. We'll need data from modern nuclear designs, (especially the small ones) but renewables are not exactly free to run. Storage degrades, solar degrades, lithium needs to be mined, turbines mean lots of mechanical parts, etc. We may learn that running just the renewables common today is even more uneconomic.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by simfree on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @08:40PM (#31104850)
The maintenance burden you suggest for wind turbines is exaggerated. Compared to a gas car there are way fewer moving parts in common wind turbines, and some designs with no moving parts are being tested: https://www.windpowerengineering.com/dutch-wind-wheel-genera...

Additionally, battery degradation appears to be primarily related to high speed charging. In decade old battery packs that were not charged at extreme rates like 2C or above, you rarely see significant degredation. Grid scale operators will almost certainly manage their battery farms to limit the C rate to optimize battery life and long term profits.

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by viraptor on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:26AM (#31106522)
Compared to a gas car a wind turbine is a completely different mechanism with a completely different scale, material requirements, elements exposure, and pretty much everything apart from "it has spinning things".

I can't exaggerate the maintenance burden for the turbines, because I didn't claim what it is, beyond that it exists. We'll have to compare it to new nuclear plants before stating which becomes uneconomical.

Solar degradation is commonly estimated at 20% in 25y, but then we get inverter failures on top of that which account for ~80% of issues in home installations. Batteries are commonly estimated to lose 20% capacity in 10y. All of those stack up too. Again - we'll have to compare the actual numbers which we don't have yet.

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by throwaway48375 on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @10:55PM (#31105606)
pumped hydro?
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by labster on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @06:11PM (#31103746)
We talk about nuclear more than we talk about solar on HN. Probably because it’s controversial we get more atomic writes, while solar is presumed to exist.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by cinntaile on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @06:17PM (#31103793)
It's the title of the article after all. We could talk about Intel as well, but it's not relevant.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by selectodude on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @05:46PM (#31103461)
CAISO doesn't cover the city of Los Angeles, but that's about it.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by jjtheblunt on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @06:00PM (#31103623)
> but that's about it

isn't that the major consumer?

Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by selectodude on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @06:05PM (#31103673)
Covers the Bay Area and the entirety of Southern California except for the city limits of Los Angeles. So all but about 4 million people.
Re:California grid set record of 97% renewable power on April 3 by kmonsen on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @05:45PM (#31103446)
That's assuming everything else is 0.