News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by comex on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @12:46AM (#31079832)
Let's see how things have changed since 2004 when this was published:

> The x86 has a small number (8) of general-purpose registers

x86-64 added more general-purpose registers.

> The x86 uses the stack to pass function parameters; the others use registers.

OS vendors switched to registers for x86-64.

> The x86 forgives access to unaligned data, silently fixing up the misalignment.

Now ubiquitous on application processors.

> The x86 has variable-sized instructions. The others use fixed-sized instructions.

ARM introduced Thumb-2, with a mix of 2-byte and 4-byte instructions, in 2003. PowerPC and RISC-V also added some form of variable-length instruction support. On the other hand, ARM turned around and dropped variable-length instructions with its 64-bit architecture released in 2011.

> The x86 has a strict memory model … The others have weak memory models

Still x86-only.

> The x86 supports atomic load-modify-store operations. None of the others do.

As opposed to load-linked/store-conditional, which is a different way to express the same basic idea? Or is he claiming that other processors didn't support any form of atomic instructions, which definitely isn't true?

At any rate, ARM previously had load-linked/store-conditional but recently added a native compare-and-swap instruction with ARMv8.1.

> The x86 passes function return addresses on the stack. The others use a link register.

Still x86-only.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by ncmncm on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @01:06AM (#31079908)
Apple M1 supports optional x86-style memory event ordering, so that its x86 emulation could be made to work without penalty.

When SPARC got new microcode supporting unaligned access, it turned out to be a big performance win, as the alignment padding had made for a bigger cache footprint. That was an embarrassment for the whole RISC industry. Nobody today would field a chip that enforced alignment.

The alignment penalty might have been smaller back when clock rates were closer to memory latency, but caches were radically smaller then, too, so even more affected by inflated footprint.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by jnordwick on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:23AM (#31080451)
> as the alignment padding had made for a bigger cache footprint

I argues with some of the Rust compiler members the other day about wanting to just ditch almost all alighnment restrictions because I of this exact thing. They laughed and basically told me i didnt know what i was talking about. I remember about 15 years ago when i worked at market making firm and we test this and it was a great gain - we started packing almost all our structs after that.

Now, at another MM shop, and we're trying to push the same thing but having to fight these areguments again (the only alignmets I want to keep are for AVX and hardware accessed buffers).

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by kevingadd on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:59PM (#31089048)
There are other things you need to take into account too - padding can make it more likely for a struct to divide evenly into cache lines, which can trigger false sharing. Changing the size of a struct from 128 bytes to 120 or 122 bytes will cause it to be misaligned on cache lines and reduce the impact of false sharing and that can significantly improve performance.

The last time I worked on a btree-based data store, changing the nodes from ~1024 bytes to ~1000 delivered something like a 10% throughput improvement. This was done by reducing the number of entries in each node, and not by changing padding or packing.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by ncmncm on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:15PM (#31090025)
True. Another reason to avoid too much aligning is to help reduce reliance on N-way cache collision avoidance.

Caches on modern chips can handle keeping up to some small fixed number, often 4, objects all in cache whose addresses are at the same offset into a page, but performance may collapse if that number is exceeded. It is quite hard to tune to avoid this, but by making things not line up on power-of-two boundaries, we can avoid out-and-out inviting it.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by anyfoo on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:13PM (#31088385)
FWIW, it's still better to lay out your critical structures carefully, so that padding isn't needed. That way, you win both the cache efficiency and the efficiencies for aligned accesses.
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by mjevans on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @08:40PM (#31091351)
One of the forms of 'premature optimization' that's often worth doing. Just align everything you can to the biggest power of two data-size you can. Also, always use fixed sized data types. E.G. (modular int) uint32 or (signed 2s comp) sint32 rather than int
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by titzer on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @08:24PM (#31091214)
WebAssembly ditched alignment restrictions and we don't regret it. There is an alignment hint, but I am not aware of any engine that uses it.
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by ncmncm on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @11:24AM (#31084382)
Superstition is as powerful as it ever was.
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by cryptonector on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:10PM (#31089973)
It's definitely received wisdom that may once have been right and no longer is.

Most people are not used to facts having a half-life, but many facts do, or, rather, much knowledge, does.

We feel very secure in knowing what we know, and the reality is that we need to be willing to question a lot of things, like authority, including our very own. Now, we can't be questioning everything all the time because that way madness lies, but we can't never question anything we think we know either!

Epistemology is hard. I want a doll that says that when you pull the cord.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by cogman10 on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:48PM (#31090390)
Sort of depends on the knowledge.

It's certainly true that in the tech industry things are CONSTANTLY shifting.

However, talk physics and you'll find that things rarely change, especially the physics that most college graduates learn.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by cryptonector on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @11:01AM (#31097936)
There was a famous study about the half-lives of "facts" in different fields. They do seem to vary by field.
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by MBCook on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:02PM (#31088231)
Is this superstition or more received wisdom, which may have been true at one point in the past as is now just orthodoxy?
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by notriddle on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:04PM (#31088260)
Fifty bucks says it isn't even about performance, but is instead about passing pointers to C code. Zero-overhead FFI has killed a lot of radical performance improvements that Rust could have otherwise made.

I don't know, because nobody's actually posting a link to it.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by ncmncm on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:04PM (#31089906)
This strikes me as likely. Bitwise compatibility with machine ABI layout rules has powerful compatibility advantages even in places where it might make code slower. (And, for the large majority of code, slower doesn't matter anyway.)

Of course C and C++ themselves have to keep to machine ABI layout rules for backward compatibility to code built when those rules were (still) thought a good idea. Compilers offer annotations to dictate packing for specified types, and the Rust compiler certainly also offers such a choice. So, maybe such annotations should just be used a lot more in Rust, C, and C++.

This is not unlike the need to write "const" everywhere in C and C++ because the inherited default (from before it existed) was arguably wrong. We just need to get used to ignoring the annotation clutter.

But there is no doubt there are lots of people who think padding to alignment boundaries is faster. And, there can be other reasons to align even more strictly than the machine ABI says, even knowing what it costs.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by nynx on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @09:05PM (#31091527)
Rust structs have non-C layouts. You can optionally specifiy that a struct should be laid out in the same way that C does it.
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by notriddle on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @09:35AM (#31096714)
Structs aren’t the problem here. It’s the primitives.

You can take a pointer to an i32 and pass that pointer to C code as int32_t. This means it has to have the same alignment in Rust that it has in C.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by ncmncm on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @12:27PM (#31099370)
The topic at hand is, specifically, that nobody makes cores that enforce alignment restrictions anymore. So, it doesn't matter where the pointer goes. All that matters is if your compiler lays out its structs the same way as whoever compiled the code a pointer to one ends up in.

There are embedded targets that still enforce alignment restrictions, but you are even less likely to pass pointers between code compiled with different compilers, there.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by notriddle on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @02:42PM (#31101176)
> The topic at hand is, specifically, that nobody makes cores that enforce alignment restrictions anymore. So, it doesn't matter where the pointer goes.

Compilers can rely on alignment even if the CPU doesn't. LLVM does, which is why older versions of rustc had segfaults when repr(packed) used to allow taking references. While it would be pretty easy to get rustc to stop emitting aligned loads, getting Clang and GCC to stop emitting aligned loads might be trickier. https://github.com/rust-lang/rust/issues/27060

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by ncmncm on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @10:25PM (#31092075)
People arguing against changing struct layout rules are probably mainly interested, then, in maintaining backward compatibility with older Rust, itself.

Anyway, same policy applies: annotate your structs "packed" anywhere performance matters and bitwise compatibility with other stuff doesn't.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by zozbot234 on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @04:26AM (#31094181)
Rust does not keep backward compatibility like that. In the absence of any statement forcing a specific ABI, the only guaranteed compatibility is with code that's part of the same build, or else part of the current Rust runtime and being linked into said build.
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by ncmncm on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @12:34PM (#31099480)
Even in Rust, mapping memory between processes, or via files between past and future processes, happens. Although structure-blasting is frowned upon in some circles, it is very fast where allowed.

But... when you are structure-blasting, you are probably also already paying generous attention to layout issues.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by ceeplusplus on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @05:52PM (#31089775)
TSO has a performance cost, on M1 this is 10-15% [1] loss from enabling TSO on native arm64 code (not emulated).

[1]: https://blog.yiningkarlli.com/2021/07/porting-takua-to-arm-p...

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by ncmncm on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:17PM (#31090055)
Yes, there are sound reasons for it to be optional. It is remarkable how little the penalty is, on M1 and on x86. Apparently it takes a really huge number of extra transistors in the cache system to keep the overhead tolerable.
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by cryptonector on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:07PM (#31089938)
TIL. I should have known this... Maybe I'll start packing my structs too.
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by cesarb on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:05PM (#31088274)
> ARM introduced Thumb-2, with a mix of 2-byte and 4-byte instructions, in 2003. PowerPC and RISC-V also [...]

x86 is still the weirdo. Both Thumb-2 and the RISC-V C extension (I don't know about PowerPC) have only 2-byte and 4-byte instructions, aligned to 2 bytes; x86 instructions can vary from 1 to 15 bytes, with no alignment requirement.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by classichasclass on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @05:41PM (#31089647)
Power10 has prefixed instructions. These are essentially 64-bit instructions in two pieces. They are odd even (particularly?) to those of us who have worked with the architecture for a long time, and not much otherwise supports them yet. Their motivation is primarily to more efficiently represent constants and offsets.
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by cryptonector on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:13PM (#31090007)
I suspect variable-length instructions are a big gain because you get to pack instructions more tightly and so have fewer cache misses. Though, obviously, it's going to depend on having an instruction set that yields shorter text for typical assembly than fixed-sized instructions would. (In a way, opcodes need a bit of Huffman encoding!)

Any losses from having to do more decoding work are probably offset by having sufficiently deep pipelines and enough decoders.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by phdelightful on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:32PM (#31090235)
The counterpoint is that variable-length decoding introduces sequential dependence in the decoding, i.e. you don’t know where instruction 2 starts until you’ve decoded instruction 1. This probably limits how many decoders you can have. If you know all your instructions are 4B you can basically decode as many as you want in parallel.
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by astrange on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @07:59PM (#31091002)
A larger problem is that they're bad for security; you can hide malicious instructions from static analysis by jumping into the middle of a cleaner one. Or use it to find more ROP gadgets, etc.

I can imagine ways to deal with this, but x86 doesn't have them.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by gpderetta on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @07:35PM (#31090786)
I think what happen in practice is that the decoders still speculatively decode in parallel then drop all misdecoded instructions. Easy when instructions have only a couple of sizes. Hard and wasteful for something like x86.
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by chasil on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:28PM (#31090195)
ARM Thumb actually licensed patents from Hitachi Super-H, who did this first.

Supposedly, "MIPS processors [also] have a MIPS-16 mode."

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/SuperH

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by phamilton on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:19PM (#31088459)
I vaguely recall that LL/SC solves the ABA problem whereas load-modify-store does not.

It's been a while, so I'm going to define my understanding of the ABA problem in case I misunderstood it:

x86 only supplies cmpxchange instructions on which will update a value only if it matches the passed in previous value. There's a class of concurrency bugs where the value is modified away from it's initial value and then modified again back to it's value. cmpxchange can't detect that condition, so if it's a meaningful difference often the 128-bit cmpxchange will be used with a counter in the second 64-bits that is incremented on each write to catch this case.

LL/SC will trigger on any write, rather than comparing the value, providing the stronger guarantee.

(Please correct me if this is inaccurate, it's been a hit minute since I learned this and I'd love to be more current on it).

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by zozbot234 on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:29PM (#31088615)
AIUI, a cmpxchg loop is enough to implement read-modify-write of any atomically sized value. The ABA problem becomes relevant when trying to implement more complex lock-free data structures.
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by ungamedplayer on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @01:13AM (#31079930)
Thank you for writing this. I was going to cover quite a lot of these points and you have done it so very succinctly.

It may be obvious, but I think it bears repeating. This blog entry should not reflect badly on Raymond C as he was reporting on the architecture at this time.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by zinekeller on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:11AM (#31080402)
The 2022 follow-up also said "And by x86 I mean specifically x86-32." Also, I don't he was on the AMD64 team yet at that time (still Itanium) so probably that is something.
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by NtGuy25 on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:31AM (#31080205)
In regards to memory alignment, it's even worse. Most instructions work on unaligned data. But some instructions require 8 byte, 16 byte, 32 byte, 64 byte and I think there's even some 128 and 256 byte alignment. One of the more common pitfalls someone can find themselves in when coding x86-64 asm.
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by ceeplusplus on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:03PM (#31088250)
There is still one big thing that hasn't changed but has been the subject of discussion on whether x86-64 is fundamentally bottlenecking CPU architecture. Variable length instructions means decoder complexity scales quadratically rather than linearly. It's been speculated this is one reason why even the latest x86 architectures stick with relatively narrow decode but Arm CPUs with lower performance levels (e.g. Cortex X1/2) are already 5-wide and Apple is 8-wide.
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by ttybird2 on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @01:37PM (#31100332)
"As opposed to load-linked/store-conditional, which is a different way to express the same basic idea? Or is he claiming that other processors didn't support any form of atomic instructions, which definitely isn't true?"

It refers specifically to things like fetch_and_add. Supported by risc-v and i64.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by gpderetta on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @07:31PM (#31090756)
>>The x86 has a strict memory model … The others have weak memory models

> Still x86-only.

SPARC supported (eventually exclusively) TSO well before x86 committed to it. For a while Intel claimed to support some form of Processor Ordering which I understand is slightly weaker than TSO, although no Intel CPU ever took advantage of the weakened constraints.

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by moonchild on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @10:39PM (#31092180)
>> The x86 supports atomic load-modify-store operations. None of the others do.

> As opposed to load-linked/store-conditional, which is a different way to express the same basic idea?

Perhaps that x86 has atomic addition, where other architectures must use a cas/ll+sc loop?

Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by wolpoli on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:05PM (#31089911)
Thanks for summarizing this. Did they do any other clean-up when moving to 64 bit?
Re:The x86 architecture is the weirdo (2004) by moonchild on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @10:38PM (#31092176)
PC-relative code.