News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by shafyy on Monday April 18, 2022 @08:41AM (#31069860)
> We are entering a new age, the current iteration will become the badlands, where unknown wallets lurk in the shadows, we will see the rise of a new blockchain economy, not one driven by greed, but instead driven by trust, not trustlessness.

(Public, permissionless) blockchain will never be a mainstream technology. It simply doesn't have any practical advantages over existing technologies, and hence doesn't solve a problem better than existing technologies.

There are technologies like VR which are also in their infancy, but already provide real value to customers. And if you squint your eyes you can see where incremental improvements will lead to (and no, I don't mean everyone living in the metaverse). But with blockchain - I have tried, I really tried. I just can't see it, and I yet to have find a crypto proponent that gives me a real example where a blockchain based tech adds real value to customers.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by DebtDeflation on Monday April 18, 2022 @08:56AM (#31069978)
>(Public, permissionless) blockchain will never be a mainstream technology.

Right, but neither will private permissioned blockchain. For every single use case I've seen thus far, there is no good response to the "why not just use a database instead?" question.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by seaourfreed on Monday April 18, 2022 @11:58AM (#31072449)
The Establishment / Wall Street abuse is what caused the massive effort behind Crypto (open source, open ledger, etc.)

* Why not use a database. Because that means the Establishment/WallStreet are the only ones with full control.

* Banks / WallStreet / Establishment long-term abuse is what created the mandate. The crypto industry is the equivalent to people taking to the streets to fix the problems.

* Open ledger fixes Bank / Wall Street / Establishment long-term above.

* Open source code prevents rigged economy theft by wall street. High Frequency, Front running, Data centers for front running, distance between exchanges for front running purposes.

* The article author is saying "Give the few establishment players full control. Data base. Ledger. Code. Block innovation. Block competition."

* Competition is the fix. 1inch.io takes in trades. It routes to the best exchanges with the smallest: Fees, margin spreads, order book fraud, etc. The fix is many 1inch.io to send trades to, that finds the lowest fee, most ethical set of exchanges. So orders are carried out ideally. Free market, competiton, not blocking new competitors, transparency (ledger + code + order book + etc.) is the fix

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by atq2119 on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:07AM (#31070067)
If you squint hard enough, Git is kind of a permissioned blockchain. So, I wouldn't dismiss the possibility completely. But yeah, it's difficult to see it becoming mainstream. Git certainly isn't mainstream.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by ogogmad on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:30AM (#31070272)
This stretches the meaning of the word blockchain past breaking point.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by Dzugaru on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:00AM (#31070021)
I bought some crypto for the first time recently. Because Mastercard and Visa don't work for me anymore - I can't pay for services outside my country of residence, and maybe there is some obscure way to do it not touching crypto, but I chose to get some Bitcoin because that was relatively easy.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by neoromantique on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:05AM (#31070053)
So, illegally overcoming sanctions.

That's literally the problem

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by jrsj on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:09AM (#31070082)
Only a problem if you’re a fan of U.S. imperialism.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by neoromantique on Monday April 18, 2022 @11:13AM (#31071790)
Нет, но я понимаю что сейчас есть большее зло.

I'd much rather have some regulation than no regulation at all. It doesn't have to be one of the extremes.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by CTDOCodebases on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:14AM (#31070118)
It's not overcoming sanctions if you are not a sanctioned individual.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by aYsY4dDQ2NrcNzA on Monday April 18, 2022 @11:44AM (#31072236)
Or the counterparty.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by ogogmad on Monday April 18, 2022 @08:53AM (#31069949)
Agreed. I think whatever small value crypto provides is outweighed by how slow and expensive it is. It's a nice technology, but I think it left the lab too soon.

Its multitrillion dollar valuation is pure speculation (sometimes called HODLing by its acolytes). It's virtually impossible that it will maintain this valuation, and most investors will make a loss.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by darioush on Monday April 18, 2022 @08:57AM (#31069984)
What is insisting that Blockchain does nothing useful?

It provides the following features which everyday financial institutions do not:

- 24/7 operation. Did you ever try to start a transfer on the weekend? - Near instant results. No more waiting several business days to get your own money. - Transactions will not trigger "account reviews", potentially locking you out from accessing your funds for an indefinite time, since you were traveling or otherwise spending your money in a way you usually don't. - Transparency on what data is retained about you and who it is sold to. - Authentication with cryptographic signature not SMS

All modern Blockchains will do the above without sending you paper mail or requiring you to update your income and address all the time.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by 01100011 on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:28AM (#31070247)
None of that requires a blockchain.

Blockchain provides no advantage for any of those features over a centralized authority.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by datadata on Monday April 18, 2022 @11:51AM (#31072364)
Can you provide an example of a centralized authority providing a service with these features that is widely adopted? Because there are blockchains that provide these features currently, and central authority finance has had a lot more time to figure things out.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by danbulant on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:30AM (#31070274)
yes.

And then you copy paste the wrong account number or amount, and you're screwed as transactions are irreversible, and there's no central authority which can revert that.

Oh and money laundering

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by darioush on Monday April 18, 2022 @04:31PM (#31076081)
Right because money launderers prefer a permanent public record of all their TXs?

Seriously I don't get the money laundering angle on chains.

Maybe in early days it was assumed chain analysis would be difficult, these days many contractors specialize in on-chain analytics and governments are investing in this too (as they should).

In fact I would LOVE to see traditional banks settlements as public record, y'know for all that money laundering that never happens on their books ;)

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by KomradeKeeks on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:45AM (#31070451)
Tell me you've never used Zelle in the US or a bank wire without telling me you've never used Zelle in the US or a bank wire.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by y3sh on Monday April 18, 2022 @08:58AM (#31069997)
^^^ for your user class, probably true. But for others, it is deeply needed. The two mainstream use cases I see are transferring money where a fiat bank was too problematic (fees, limits, audits, etc) and purchasing items with the perception of anonymity (e.g. an incognito subscription with a coingate payment option alongside Visa). It is nice to know there is a way to digitally pay for things without major payment processors running analytics on my spending.

And in providing foreign aid, crypto has helped us reliably transfer funds without corrupt intervention. Culture ebs and flows, but in this case core user needs are being met by the tech.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by shafyy on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:04AM (#31070038)
Re transferring money: Do you think transferring money abroad is expensive because of technology? It's not, it's because of regulation, international agreements etc. What do you think will happen when crypto should go maintstream? Do you think it will just stay unregulated? No, we're already seeing countries starting to regulate crypto. And then you'll just end up at square one.

Re anonymity: Your every crypto transaction is publicly viewable under your pseudonym. Once somebody connects your pseudodynm, all your anonimity is gone. If you purchase something with Visa, only you, Visa, and the company your purchasing from sees your info. I'd take that each time over a public trail of my purchases.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by y3sh on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:43AM (#31070417)
These are great points, let's go a bit further.

Trying to regulate crypto is like trying to regulate the internet. There are some good attempts, but by using different routes we can circumvent (even in china). Blocked by firewall, use cell, blocked cell towers, use satellite, block satellite??? With crypto, regulate one, fork it, change the network, make another... change the route... use a different crypto/fiat vendor. Good luck.

Right on anonymity, but users doen't care... they just need the "perception of anonymity" or good enough. If you watch teenage trends, it's a great predictor of the near future.

Consider the teen buying weed with the choice of fiat or crypto. On their child bank account under their parent, even if they use cash, those withdrawals raise questions. But that same teen who tells their parent, yeah I just put $300 on coinbase for crypto. Now that teen can use funds without their parents knowing. Sure the trail can be traced back with some work, but it's really hard for the parent. And by trading crypto for cash outside regulated exchanges, it becomes increasingly difficult to unwind anonymity. Now reread this paragraph swapping out teen for average citizen, parent for government, and buying weed for sending money to support mom.

It's ok to not see the use case personally if you don't need it. In 1993 people thought mobile carphones were a pointless trend, and they kindof were -- nobody today uses phones mounted in a leather case in their car to call people. But with some design iteration the most profitable companies on the planet emerged. I think we're at 1993-carphone of blockchain. The use case is kindof there, but as you said the "mainstream" use case hasn't really emerged yet. However that doesn't mean it won't.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by matthewdgreen on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:23AM (#31070199)
> Re transferring money: Do you think transferring money abroad is expensive because of technology? It's not, it's because of regulation, international agreements etc.

Yes! And this is artificial and problematic, and cryptocurrency is an inevitable symptom of such an artificial regime.

There are a handful of communication functions that people in every society want to avail themselves of: to talk to each other, to read/write and find information, and to transact value for commerce. For the first two applications the Internet has made those functions possible in increasingly powerful and useful ways: we went from 300-baud modems and BBSes to broadband and Twitter. Search and unlimited music catalogs and electronic bookstores are all available in virtually unlimited amounts at 1/100,000th of the 1990 cost on amazing portable devices we carry in our pockets.

So you’d expect that the ability to transact value on a computer would also have followed a similar trajectory. But weirdly (and crucially: artificially) it hasn’t. Sending an international wire is better than it was in 1990, but not orders-of-magnitude easier or cheaper like the functions I listed above. Similarly, buying products on retail websites has improved in many ways, but it still involves typing in a 16-digit number off a plastic card (and then insuring that card expensively to guard against fraud.) Sending money to a friend is just barely possible in small amounts recently (thanks to a few services like Venmo etc.) ACH will go from 3-day to 1-day settlement “soon” (has it already happened?) There’s nothing like the visible improvement and IT cost reduction you see in every other electronic product.

And the reason you don’t see that improvement is not because the technology makes it impossible, or that sending money cheaply and easily is technically infeasible. The reason you don’t see those improvements is entirely artificial. The technology can exist but has been deliberately held back by cozy business arrangements and government regulation. I will even grant that much of this regulation is well-intentioned. But the thing is, nature abhors a vacuum. The result of trying to artificially stop technical progress is that the technical progress happens anyway (when PCs and p2p gets cheap enough) and then it happens in weird ways that are outside of society’s control. That’s where we are now, and it’s our fault for letting things get here.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by shafyy on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:33AM (#31070309)
Transferring money has also become extremely easier compared to the past. I mean, using something like Revolut or Wise I can transfer money quickly and cheaply to all major currencies and countries.

But keep in mind that money is different than sending an email, because of crime. Rightfully, governments want to prevent criminal transaction, money laundering and so on - and that leads to increased transaction costs.

I'd rather have my transaction take one day or cost a couple of cents than let financial crime run rampant.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by matthewdgreen on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:45AM (#31070461)
“It has become easier” and “it has become easier in proportion to the massive many-orders-of-magnitude technological improvements every other IT function benefits from” are very different statements.

Re: crime, I am in agreement that the purpose of much regulation is to prevent crime. But it’s 2022 and I still buy things on the Internet by typing in a 16-digit static credit card number, or send wires/ACH by giving people my static bank account and routing number (from which, here in the US they can withdraw arbitrary funds!) We have the technology to vastly improve the security of these mechanisms, but instead of doing that we operate with 1980s-era technology undergoing constant fraud, and rely on layers of regulation to keep them viable. That’s not inevitable, it’s a very artificial choice. Cryptocurrency is the inevitable result of making that choice, just as Napster and Apple Music were the result of record labels' decision to pursue a (profitable) CD-based music sales model in the era of the Internet.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by jrsj on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:08AM (#31070075)
Walmart any other major retailers are about to start taking payments via Lightning Network this year. Will be able to pay from cash app or others without explicitly converting from USD. Cheaper and faster than Visa etc.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by shafyy on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:33AM (#31070316)
I'll believe that when I see it.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by user3939382 on Monday April 18, 2022 @08:59AM (#31070010)
The best example I have is the stock exchange. Here's a DTCC discussion from 5 years ago before the whole GME-AMC fiasco https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AXy0qbwaqhY

There's an issue with unaccounted-for shares that is solved perfectly by the blockchain.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by edem on Monday April 18, 2022 @08:48AM (#31069917)
You obviously have no idea what blockchain tech is about.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by mritchie712 on Monday April 18, 2022 @08:57AM (#31069982)
How would you send someone in China (or Nigeria, Peru, ...) money?

If they had an ethereum address and you already had a wallet yourself, it's crazy easy. Setting up and funding a wallet is currently a little tricky, but not as hard as some like to make it seem.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by cool_dude85 on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:14AM (#31070113)
You've described how to send someone in China, Nigeria, or Peru etheriums, but not how to send them money. It turns out when there are capital controls, taxes, laws against crypto, etc., the two are not quite the same.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by atq2119 on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:20AM (#31070172)
Other countries do have banks, and international money transfers are a solved problem. I have personal experience with sending money from Europe to Latin American countries. It generally works just fine. I assume Venezuela and at times Argentina may be exceptions due to their political situation, and yeah, for those cryptocurrency may be useful, as an instance of the general rule that cryptocurrency is mostly useful to route around laws and regulations.

In principle, cryptocurrency could act as competition to drive the price of transfers down (which would be awesome), but in practice and at the scale I was looking at, there was no price advantage, and the convenience advantage was clearly with the traditional banking system.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by mritchie712 on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:29AM (#31070254)
Yes, I know other countries have banks. How would you do it though? What are the steps and services involved?

With Ethereum it's (again, assuming you have an address, which is trivial):

1. Get their address (a single universal unique value, no "what's your routing #")

2. Send the Eth to that address

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by shafyy on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:35AM (#31070329)
3. They go and buy bread with their ETH.

...

Oh, wait?!

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by KomradeKeeks on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:52AM (#31070560)
TIL HN doesn't know what stablecoins are.

Stablecoins are basically on-chain gift cards, with each token priced at about a dollar. Some (USDC, PAX, etc) have businesses you can directly redeem the stablecoins in order to get $1 sent to a bank account, and others (DAI, FRAX, UST) have more complex mechanisms to stay at or ~$1.

If you're using a chain that isn't BTC (technically you can use USDT on Omni but almost no one uses it for this), you can probably send the person a stablecoin that is priced at $1 USD.

And yes, people in Nigeria and other EMs do this every day, either for remittances, FX trading, or other reasons (reasons can be legal or illegal, i'm not supporting harm or illegal use cases but at some point we gotta recognize the 'freest' countries either still support race-based class discrimination or legalized slavery, so it's insufficient for the purposes of good faith discourse to throw pseudo mic drop rebuttals that assert legal institutions are infallible).

EDIT: and to pre-empt the "what if the stablecoin goes up to $2 or down to $0.50???" questions: - Centralized stablecoins like USDC, PAX, etc have licensed businesses that use actual banks to store the reserves, so if anyone wants to sell me their USDC for $0.75, please do and jog on - Decentralized stablecoins like DAI have more complex checks nad balances, and with those, unless you're a market maker or doing something that requires a non-top 3 decentralized stablecoin, it's often better to go with the ones that have been audited and/or battle tested, provided it suits your use case.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by atq2119 on Monday April 18, 2022 @10:31AM (#31071143)
I'm pretty sure the point was that your average bodega doesn't accept cryptocurrency.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by Ekaros on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:19AM (#31070165)
Three steps, first you buying intermediate currency, then transfering that, and then them selling it for their own. First and second are mostly solved, but is there sufficient for third? And what are the conversion costs or fees in each of these? And what are the market fluctuations?
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by mritchie712 on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:25AM (#31070215)
Sure, there are issues, but the question remains, how would you send money to someone in China? I'm seriously asking. I don't know a simpler way then crypto.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by mminer237 on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:29AM (#31070261)
I believe Alipay would be the easiest for that.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by nodemaker on Monday April 18, 2022 @08:50AM (#31069927)
What do people do with their money when central banks only offers 0.03 percent interest while inflation is 9 percent. They can convert their money to a crypto stablecoin and get upto 20 percent yield.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by Broken_Hippo on Monday April 18, 2022 @08:59AM (#31070003)
You are under the impression that most folks are investing money somehow?

Nope. Most folks are pretty poor, and realistically the money at the banks isn't collecting interest at all. The banks provide a service: Somewhere fairly safe to stick your money, where it will be available to pay for food and rent and utilities.

What most folks actually save for - when they can - is emergencies. We are talking less than a month's income at a possibly average salary. This money needs to be easily accessible. you know, in case your car breaks down. You might save for a down payment, but realistically you aren't going to be much better off by investing in anything long term. And when you are at these income levels, investing in anything that could mean you lose your money is too devastating to deal with, even if you supposedly can get "up to a 20 percent yield". Not to mention that you can't use that money for anything without planning.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by blisterpeanuts on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:07AM (#31070062)
If "de-banking" gains popularity as a way to suppress and punish dissident populations[1][2], crypto stands to gain. There are still issues with traceability and privacy but the basic technology seems pretty sound as an alternative to a state-run currency.

1. https://townhall.com/columnists/johnrlottjr/2022/02/23/canad...

2. https://www.businessinsider.com/mypillow-ceo-mike-lindells-b...

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by Ekaros on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:21AM (#31070185)
Wouldn't those doing the "de-banking" also make it impossible for anyone to provide service to the "de-banked" or punish those who allow it to happen? After all they still need to live in physical world and ignoring some customers is easier than being hit for bigger fine than the gains or outright stopped from operating.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by dd36 on Monday April 18, 2022 @08:53AM (#31069948)
How are they getting a 20% yield and at what risk?
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by nicoburns on Monday April 18, 2022 @08:55AM (#31069968)
Because it's a pyramid scheme
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by CTDOCodebases on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:29AM (#31070259)
My guess would be they are staking UST (stable coin) on Anchor Protocol. The staked funds are lent to traders. Thats how they can promise such high returns since 20% a year is only 0.055% per day. Traders will typically trade positions with a risk to reward ration of 1:1.5 or higher. These fees are negligible at this point for a position that will take a few hours or days to close. This is how you can trade with leverage on exchanges. Risks are protocol exploit or depegging of the staked coin.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by dd36 on Monday April 25, 2022 @10:03AM (#31154894)
Trading what?

IB lends leverage at like 2%.

20% implies a ton of risk compared to what’s available.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by nodemaker on Monday April 18, 2022 @11:17AM (#31071848)
Right answer. (There are some other new interesting protocols on the horizon too MARS, PRISM)
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by dd36 on Monday April 25, 2022 @10:03AM (#31154907)
Trading what on what exchanges?
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by the_snooze on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:15AM (#31070123)
Those are literally Bernie Madoff returns.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by shafyy on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:00AM (#31070013)
They invest it one of dozens of other regulated ways. For example: Stock market, housing, financial derivatives, etc.

Also: A crypto stablecoin is (supposed to be) pegged to a major currency, usually the USD. So in terms of return, it shouldn't matter if you have your money invested in stablecoin or cash under your mattress. Oh wait, it does matter, because most stablecoins are scams and you'll eventually lose all your money.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by nodemaker on Monday April 18, 2022 @11:18AM (#31071872)
Assuming the stablecoin doesnt lose its peg (choose a decentralized one), you can get 20 percent yield from staking it.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by this_was_posted on Monday April 18, 2022 @08:57AM (#31069983)
Considering the crypto itself does not produce anything of value I´d be surprised if it would continue to outperform the stock market as crypto starts to stabilise. Maybe it could be used to be a little more resistant to inflation than with regular cash, but wouldn´t make any sense to me if the value of crypto would consistently grow to a bigger percentage of all wealth on earth.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by nodemaker on Monday April 18, 2022 @11:21AM (#31071912)
Crypto is a technology just like Microsoft Windows is. As more people use it its value increases. Only difference is now there is no bill gates and the rewards are shared by all early adopters.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by YorickPeterse on Monday April 18, 2022 @08:58AM (#31069998)
And the next day the value of their portfolio drops by 200%, and never quite recovers.

If your argument is that banks and savings in particular offer poor interest, the proper answer is to look into index funds and focus on long term growth, rather than short-term speculation.

Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture by nodemaker on Monday April 18, 2022 @11:15AM (#31071820)
I said stablecoin for a reason.