Every Billionaire who recently acquired a large media house[1] mentioned in the interviews as doing it for 'Upholding Journalism' or something of those lines which also implicitly meant 'Supporting right to free speech'.
But I'm bewildered about how this particular acquisition is only about 'Right to Free speech' vs 'No Right to Free Speech' and not really about hostile takeover of a business by a Ultra-Billionaire with impunity?
I guess that has something to do with how good Elon is at controlling the narrative, Even reputable news agencies start with 'Elon who claims himself as a free speech absolutist...'. And that was before he controlled Twitter.
Anyways, Two major social media firms seems to have consolidated with individuals who are supposed to run a social media firm.
Musk has proven himself to be a very savvy investor. And his operational track record is nearly unmatched. Particularly because it straddles so many different industries: internet 1.0 (Zip2), banking and payments (PayPal), manufacturing and transportation (Tesla), aerospace engineering and spaceflight (SpaceX). If there is anyone in the world who could pull this off, my money would be on him.
... if you're not failing some of the time, you're not trying things ambitious enough ...
And since he's got so many projects on-going, you think he has all of the time in the world to pull this one off? Explain that ONE to me?
Also, reminder, he didn't found Tesla. He was one of its initial investors.
We can split hairs and refine definitions until we exclude him from the category of successful investors, but, at a certain point, it's a little hard to believe.
In any event, it is quite clear that Musk has no intention of being a silent investor. Rather, he's going to be an operator. And in that regard, he is nearly unparalleled.
His track record speaks for itself. I would certainly have far more confidence in Musk than the current leadership team.
Musk is at least competent in software engineering, aerospace engineering, and finance. It is hard not to see that as a strong indicator of an intelligence well above average. People bend over backwards to look past the glaring facts about Musk that contradict their biases.
Musk is hyper intelligent. Musk is one the most successful business people of all time.
I’m not saying he’s dumb, he’s clearly a smart guy, but I don’t think he’s anything special
That just is doing a lot of heavy lifting there. When Musk took over Tesla, it was a very small startup with 6 employees or so. All the subsequent growth into the behemoth that it is today has happened under his management.
If someone adopted a newborn and raised him to adulthood, would you dismiss them as not-a-real-parent of that kid?
Musk's role in Tesla is similar to Ray Kroc's in McDonald's. Not a founder either, but the person that took over a totally irrelevant small business and developed it into a world class superpower in its field.
To be dismissive of such an accomplishment is unwise at best.
Why I think he upended the auto industry:
- He bought Tesla within the first two years (IIRC) of it being founded; before there was even a working prototype
- He laid out the groundwork for the three-stage plan, and followed through
- Stage 1: Prototype -> Roadster
- Stage 2: Model S/X
- Stage 3: Model 3/Y
- He adopted high-tech in Teslas which make them compelling and ‘cool’ (for the general public), through Autopilot, games (Cuphead, Asteroids, etc), video (Netflix, Hulu, Disney+, etc), OTA software updates, and moreAnd, the most important piece:
- He led and developed the Supercharger network initiative, partially solving the problem of EVs as true ICE replacements
Each of those decisions could have, and likely would have, been handled differently by Random CEO. It was only through each of those decisions, and a lot of luck, that Tesla is a viable car company today.
I’m quick to criticize Musk, but what he did with Tesla is truly incredible and deserving of praise.
PayPal: Musk founded X.com. X merged with PayPal. Through that merger, Musk became PayPal's largest shareholder. He was ousted as the company's CEO. He did attempt to move the company's tech onto Windows. None of this invalidates his accomplishment's at PayPal. To wit, he walked away with $100M.
Tesla: Musk did not buy Tesla. 8 months after Tesla was founded, he funded the majority of Tesla's series A at which time he became the chairman of its board. He then stepped into the CEO role and has maintained that role ever since.
SpaceX: Musk trained himself in rocket engineering and pioneered private spaceflight while pushing rocket tech far into the future. Self landing rockets. <- I don't even need a full sentence. Self. Landing. ROCKETS!!!!
Its very important to get the facts right before moving on to interpretation.
Of course, Musk didn't do all of this himself. He has again and again hired top notch engineers and scientists. But even in the most biased publications, his critics begrudgingly acknowledge his technical prowess and commercial acumen.
Again, just look at the list of accomplishments. He is a man, not a god. But in these domains, he is absolutely something special. Many sigma special.
Jay Z
I guess for cashing out though it doesn't matter, since the shareholders won't need to care about what Twitter's stock does in the future. So, maybe you're right.
Easy to verify, we'll just have to wait and see if he succeeds.
Those promises are predicated on him owning it though.
I'm doubtful of Twitter's LTV whether he owns it or not, but then again I've never had an account and now that you pretty much can't read it without one, I basically don't use it at all. So I may not be a qualified observer, but to me Twitter seems to only get worse for years now.
If that price isn't reasonable for Twitter long-term then you must have someone other than the current management in mind to realise that value...
I think if I were an investor, my thought might be that Musk might not be necessary to realize that growth (again, speaking in the long term, not that the current price is wrong). But I'm not an investor, I don't really know Twitter's numbers.
I guess the caveat I should give is that if I were an investor and I thought Twitter was falling and that Musk couldn't save it, this would be a particularly good opportunity to jump ship. So that could also be an angle I'm not thinking of.
He or anyone else
Twitter is a natural monopoly - evidenced by it's not having any real competition. Will it be a regulated monopoly? In that case, it should be valued like a water company. Is it an unregulated monopoly? In that case the market will decide if it can turn that monopoly into profits. There are a lot of commercial Twitter users. Charge them all ten cents a tweet. That adds up to about $10m per day.
I guess it depends on that, do you think Twitter stock will just keep going down, or could it relatively quickly outperform that offer?
I didn't even know this existed until you said it, which doesn't bode well for mass adoption given that I'm someone who's on the internet daily.
Moreover, Mastodon.com is owned by a forestry machine business, and googling Mastodon gives a first result for a rock/metal band. I think "Mastodon.social" might be about as bad as a web address can get for mass appeal / catchiness.
is absolutely not a priority for the Mastodon software project.
Try looking on Github:
The only people with coherent philosophies of free speech are for absolute freedom of speech or absolutely no freedom of speech.
It's by pusuring incoherence, by threading the needle between those extremes that we create an open, free speech culture where freedom is the norm and censorship occurs only in extreme situations.
I generally agree with the rest of your post ("who cares?"). I would add that if Elon buys twitter and deletes it, I would be fine with it.
This is completely off topic and not at all your fault, but even though we are actively talking about Elon Musk and he should have been the primary person in my head, and even though the spelling is different -- for some reason my brain still interpreted "Elon" in the above sentence as Ellen DeGeneres, and I got really confused for about 10 seconds about why you felt the need to add that you would also be OK with her specifically buying Twitter.
For sure. Dozens of users will migrate to Mastodon.
Anything pushed to its logical extreme becomes its own opposite. Since society can't or won't reign in either corporate or social media, perhaps we should remove all restraints and let then destroy themselves, and hopefully each other.
Further, how could Musk possibly be any worse than @jack, Zuck & Sandberg, Murdochs, Theil, etc, etc.
Pox on all their houses.
Elon also doesn't need to innovate himself, he simply needs to be a signal, a beacon or lighthouse to others who know they are capable of innovating - and where they may now actually attempt to work for/at Twitter/with Elon because they may now believe they have a chance of implementing systems as they may believe Elon will be able to understand their design - and therefore getting approval.
Tesla survived because of government subsidies and a neverending deluge of hype from Musk. Boring Company is utter nonsense and a huge failure.
That track record seems... pretty random. Maybe Musk was an important factor, maybe his engineering and marketing teams were, maybe luck was the most important thing.
You going to then argue "but we'd have it all better if there were no meddling government!" ? There are plenty of places that have no government and they seem pretty miserable.
People (ideally) select other people every interval of time to make important decisions (aka "government"); sometimes those decisions adversely affect some people and help others disproportionately (your job is cutting down trees and 99% of the trees are gone? Well, you may lose your job before cutting down that last 1% because the trees have value as trees instead of lumber; sorry them's the breaks).
Life is hard and full of difficult choices. There are winners and losers. It's better for everyone to make decisions by discussion and consensus rather than violence.
But free speech is "will the government arrest/fine/murder you for what you say (or don't say)" not "do I have to listen to you blather on when I'd rather not".
There's tremendous nuance to "free speech". If I'm a cake maker and you ask me to make a cake saying "Fuck Jewish Space Lasers!" can I say no I'd rather not? I'm not sure. Maybe I've got terms of service already, maybe I'm just a harried cake maker trying to be civil and a good person and I'd rather not be an asshole even by proxy. You could probably switch the message to "Happy anniversary Steve and Paul!" and offend some other set of people.
We seem to live in a society where some set of people just want to be rude and uncivil and force us all to watch like we're in a clockwork orange needing programming. Please no, and while you're at it I'd rather you stop pouring garbage into my father in law.
I agree that many of businesses survive only because of subsidies and that "free speech" does not mean that private entities cannot censor themselves.
The objective measure of a business leader's success seems pretty obviously the value of their businesses, is it not?
- luck/timing
- investor enthusiasm (longer runway)
- regulatory environment
- early hires
- later hires
etc.
Like I said, the objective of business is to make money. One guy made more money than anyone else.
There's also a lot of luck in sports but the team with the most wins at the end of the season is the best team in the regular season.
No, we just don't attribute it to a single man with an incredibly inconsistent track record.
> Like I said, the objective of business is to make money. One guy made more money than anyone else.
Tesla is an unusually unsuccessful company when compared to other public companies that have existed for the same amount of time.
Musk is wealthy because of his incessant promises/lies about Tesla, not because the business is making so much money.
Arguably, his stubbornness against learning the lessons of 100 years of vehicle manufacturing is holding Tesla back.
> There's also a lot of luck in sports but the team with the most wins at the end of the season is the best team in the regular season.
This analogy is ridiculous. Sports teams compete in tightly-controlled environments. Even then, we attribute some success to coaching, ownership, luck of the schedule, etc.
But even if we accept the analogy, Musk's "team" has not scored the most points.
I think you're packing a lot into the definition of successful there. Tesla has been an excellent investment. The value of the company as determined by the market is high. Your definition of "success" is not dissuading investors. Investors believe in the future of Tesla.
> Musk is wealthy because of his incessant promises/lies about Tesla, not because the business is making so much money.
Lots of things that people consider unethical still make you money. That doesn't change the objective fact that he's made a ton of money through business ventures.
> But even if we accept the analogy, Musk's "team" has not scored the most points.
But Musk has.
You can attribute all you want to luck if you'd like but I think that makes you look like a fool when you consider that he didn't just do it once, he did it twice and changed both markets he entered drastically.
His businesses are worth a ton of money.
He is personally worth a ton of money.
Your earlier comment
> That track record seems... pretty random.
is absurd. Most people can't start one successful business. You think he got lucky twice? Three times if you count Starlink which likely gets spun out into it's own business eventually.
And those business aren't just successful in that they aren't out of business, they're massive successes and have made him the richest person in the world (minus some saudi's who probably hold more non-public wealth).
Musk's particular talent, in my view, is his ability to manage exponential growth where there's an extremely narrow set of possibly successful outcomes given a set of constraints.
Maybe he sees a way to get twitter back to exponential growth? I don't.
I appreciate your nuance, patience, and civility.
There's nothing wrong with that. It's immensely valuable to society to be able to inspire, attract, and organize talent.
Reddit is turning into a Tiktok aggregator as well, overbearing music, aggressive edits, and juvenile takes. At least those are short though.
lol
Twitter has 400 million users GLOBALLY. How many are bots? How many are active? How many are "anti-capitalists"?
Twitter is not representative of anything except twitter.
First, I really do not think twitter is a anticapitalist forum and second, controlling twitter communication yields quite some power.
Single tweets made furor on the stock market.
It is probably way more about money, than anti activism, or pro free speech activism. (plus the personal vendetta of the twitter bot, who published Elons flights).
Potentially this is Musk bringing back systematic misinformation, troll farms, accidentallly enabling genocides etc. etc.
It's certainly the case that Musk could potentially make that worse, but I guess I have so little confidence in Twitter's ability to get better on that front that I'm not sure it matters all that much in the long run.
Better moderation on these platforms requires a large re-think in how we approach moderation in the first place, and it requires a more socially responsible perspective about the platform's purpose. I don't think that Musk being in charge or not will make that happen, and if he does turn Twitter into even more of a cesspool, then maybe that'll encourage alternatives.
I'm not an accelerationist when it comes to social media, but I think that Musk/Twitter's attitudes towards free speech online are often both naive and incompetent and the site continuing to worsen might be the only way to get people off of it; and I'm not sure what blocking Musk actually preserves about the site (other than possibly that Musk might push for more aggressive monetization). There are people right now who rely on it that would need to find other hosting, and that does genuinely stink. But... I mean, it's gonna get worse for them regardless.
> Silicon Valley social media companies have taken an extra-ordinarily long and painful path to understanding how they need to handle speech on their platforms
I don't want to be pessimistic, but I don't really feel like social media companies have learned how to handle speech or that they've become competent about doing moderation at scale. I don't think there ever was a point where they figured it out. If we've learned anything it's that moderation at a global scale is kind of unworkable, and that's why having smaller communities that pay more attention to the content they host is so important. I'm particularly pessimistic about the possibility of AI/algorithmic moderation (which many of these companies are leaning into more and more), mostly because I don't see a ton of evidence that it's good enough at scale to replace human moderation.
So I'm not worried about Musk bringing back systematic misinformation or troll farms or accidentally enabling genocide because as far as I can tell Twitter already has that problem; I don't think Musk can bring it back because I don't think it ever went away.
Good or bad Musk wants to open the platform up. Whether that will just change the speech to what he likes or actually broaden it we'll see.
“the more an owner, for his advantage, opens up his property for use by the public in general, the more do his rights become circumscribed by the statutory and constitutional rights of those who use it.” (Marsh v. Alabama, 326 U.S. 501, 506 (1946)
They have since narrowed their interpretation somewhat, but some states (including California) have ruled that de-facto public gathering places such as shopping malls are areas where free speech is protected, even though they are privately owned.
So generally, yes a private platform can do what they want, but if their primary focus is to be open to the public, they may be more bound to providing first amendment protections.
AFAIK no court has specifically ruled on whether online public spaces should be treated the same as physical public spaces.
A culture of free speech is just as important as a law prohibiting Congress from abridging it. It is true that private companies have their own free speech and private property interests they should safeguard, but that does not mean they cannot do more to raise a culture of free speech on their platforms, and they should!
Government, no question about it. Twitter doesn't throw you in jail.
It is not. The first amendment of the constitution of the United States is, but freedom of speech is just freedom of speech.
All that being said, I don't really see the problem with him trying this, and I don't necessarily see a ton of downside to him succeeding or failing. I'm perfectly willing to grab the popcorn and just watch.
Twitter is not a great social network, and I don't think it's amazingly well managed. If it gets worse and Musk does a bunch of radical changes, maybe more people will start using Mastodon. If he fails, no harm done. If he joins on and does nothing and just monetizes it more aggressively, then :shrug:, Twitter is probably eventually headed in that direction anyway.
Go for it. I've got no confidence that Musk can actually innovate in this space, and little to no confidence that he'll actually even get the control he wants, and he might actually make things worse if he does succeed, but on a certain level who cares?
It really stinks for artists/communities on Twitter that might be hurt by that happening, but again, I don't really have a lot of confidence that Twitter isn't going to start hurting them anyway, so I don't know that this really matters all that much for them.
:shrug: Maybe 2 years from now I'll look back at this comment and think it's naive.