I hadn't heard about this, but looking it up now, it seems that your account isn't accurate. According to these articles he asked the UN to detail how they would spend the money and they did.
https://mashable.com/article/elon-musk-solve-world-hunger
https://fortune.com/2022/02/15/elon-musk-5-7-billion-donatio...
But if the dictators and juntas on the ground aren’t willing to help, and if the logistics companies and war lords redirect it to their friends, more money doesn’t really help.
And nor does a clever plan from the UN, which is already trying to avoid the grifters, but also has its share of internal corruption.
1. https://www.usaid.gov/food-assistance/faq#:~:text=In%20fisca....
Also worth noting that he was one of the ACLU's biggest donors when they were still focused on protecting free speech and liberty.
Yikes.
A more realistic take: this is a petty reaction on par with Peter Thiel suing Gawker into oblivion. Musk doesn't really care about Twitter's role as a tool for good, he cares about his ego.
It's cultish when people say it's bad just because they want to think it's bad.
When the person you're responding to makes a strong assertion about a person's intentions[1] and you respond suggesting that anybody who might not think this way is part of a cult, it comes off very much that you want the assertion to be true.
Unless your belief is truly, "Anybody who might possibly agree with {{some specific person}} is part of a cult," then this comment does not do your thoughts justice. There's more to be said and you did not bother to say it.
[1] > Musk doesn't really care about Twitter's role as a tool for good, he cares about his ego.
Hope that helps your argument.
What are you even saying here?
I'm trying to imagine this statement actually both having meaning and corresponding to reality and failing.
That seems unlikely. USD$43 billion could buy ~1,150,000 homes[0], which is double the number of homeless people in the US[1].
Getting a 1/2 million people into stable living situations could boost the economy by adding a couple hundred thousand to the work force (it's really hard to hold a decent job if you have no place to store your stuff or take a shower), with the median income for all workers over the age of 15 at ~USD40,000 [2] would add ~US$8,000,000,000 to the economy, as well as reducing dependence on public programs to help support them.
Of course, buying whole houses for half a million people isn't actually necessary. A reasonably sized apartment (based on household size) for each set of homeless folks would cost significantly less than that.
What's more, the children who could be helped by something like this are more likely to have good school experiences and improve their education -- boosting their lifetime earnings potential as well. Not to mention the economic boosts to local communities hit hard by homelessness.
So, no. Buying Twitter isn't anywhere close to the best use of US$43B. In fact, I suspect we could end homelessness in the US for significantly less than that. That seems a lot more useful than a payout to TWTR shareholders and making it one of Musk's vanity hobbies.
[0] https://worldpopulationreview.com/state-rankings/median-home...
[1] https://endhomelessness.org/homelessness-in-america/homeless...
[2] https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2021/demo/p60-27...
I remember Musk offered to solve world hunger but the NGO people who said they could do it flaked when (pen in hand) he offered to cut them a cheque. The next best thing is to provide a platform for discourse so that smart people indexed on truth and reality can thrive and wield influence.
The opportunity is that Twitter just isn't funny, and as a signal of alignment to truth, that's a pretty honest sign it has become oppressive and that it has become a thing that most people just do not want. The controversial censorship on Twitter has been against humour, which makes Musk's play such an obvious win. As an activist target, Twitter has spent almost a decade contorting itself and spending a lot of effort to make itself suck, and it just needs to suck slightly less to be a benefit to humanity. Value for money, it's probably the most effective $43B anyone has spent in the US.