News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by qiskit on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:50PM (#30978909)
Hope so. IP is rent seeking and should be abolished. Or china might as well demand everyone pay IP for firecrackers or paper.

India, middle east, ASENA, africa, etc should steal as much IP as they can and develop. Just like china did. Just like the US did. Just like everyone did.

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by dataangel on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:12PM (#30979181)
Time limited "rent seeking" that feeds the technologists necessary to develop the technology. In the absence of IP businesses just rely on obfuscation to try to get the same effect, except now you don't have a patent application to read and can't take someone to court for stealing your years of research.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by t0suj4 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:52PM (#30979672)
Except that it is used now to drive companies out of business. I honestly think that it has done more damage than benefit.

IMO If the funds used to prevent people from applying technology would be used to fund research instead, the gains would net at least zero.

Right now the benefits are localized to jurisdictions that don't care about IP. It is impossible to measure how much could have been gained from businesses that never existed due to uncertainty arising in the jungle of IPs.

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by bsder on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:34PM (#30981428)
> I honestly think that it has done more damage than benefit.

Then you will wind up with the Chitu/Chitubox issue where everybody puts encryption chips into their stuff to lock it down.

Moving everything to the cloud wasn't just about developer convenience. It had the side benefit for companies that their software couldn't be pirated anymore.

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by imtringued on Monday April 11, 2022 @05:37AM (#30986509)
>Hope so. IP is rent seeking and should be abolished.

In my opinion exclusive rights shouldn't be abolished, they should be time limited (up to a quarter of the human lifespan) and extensions should be gated behind very high taxes.

Humans capture water from the environment for their personal use (e.g. drinking), however, eventually they release that very same water. What modern corporations are doing is akin to sucking a pond dry and swelling up to an absurd size while never intending to release that water back to the environment.

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by cscurmudgeon on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:58PM (#30979010)
Should Russia also do the same? Going back a year, would a similar statement apply to Russia too?
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by xtian on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:04PM (#30981703)
Yes, they should, and there’s good odds they will.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by hulitu on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:03PM (#30979072)
No Russia shall be better than US /s
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by ksec on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:26PM (#30979352)
Depends on how you define stolen in this context.

It uses GPU IP from IMG commonly known as PowerVR, the same technology powering current Apple's GPU and some Mediatek SoC. And IMG the company is now wholly owned by Chinese Private Equity Fund. The fund acquired IMG when Apple claimed to no longer be using any of their IP and caused their market valuation to drop by more than 70%.

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by marcan_42 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:08PM (#30983772)
Apple GPUs have little to no IMG technology left. You can tell there is some remaining influence in the design, but Apple's is much better and cleaner and what IMG's GPUs should have been.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by ksec on Monday April 11, 2022 @09:14AM (#30988197)
>Apple GPUs have little to no IMG technology left

They still uses PVRTC and are still licensing and paying IMG royalty. Surely if there were little to no IMG tech left Apple could have simply stopped paying them and dont renew the contract. They are not paying substantially less royalty than they were previously either.

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by marcan_42 on Tuesday April 12, 2022 @01:54AM (#30999085)
What the lawyers do and how the technology actually works are not necessarily related.

The shaders are completely different, the controller is completely different, the command submission structures are different. Sure, it's still a tiled architecture and they probably have to keep PVRTC for compatibility and pay the royalty for that, and you can see some remaining PVR influence in the design. But it's not PVR, and quite possibly has zero actual PVR technology left (as in silicon IP from IMG). They're probably only paying patent royalties.

We know this because we're reverse engineering AGX and IMG just dumped an upstream submission to Mesa and now anyone can compare them. PVR's architecture is, for starters, a lot more insane than Apple's.

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by StopDarkPattern on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:57PM (#30982128)
And has 100% appropriated Western hero names.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by WithinReason on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:53AM (#30978238)
The bigger question is, does it violate any patents? Not necessarily intentionally, but because there's only so many ways you can build a GPU and (almost) all of them are patented already. Apple themselves failed to build a GPU from the ground up, so it's actually difficult.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by Retric on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:09PM (#30978445)
Many of those core GPU patients must be expiring right now.

The GeForce 4 is 20 years old at this point, and many newer technologies are going to have significantly older patents.

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by WithinReason on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:12PM (#30978496)
That's right, but then you're building a GPU with 20 year old tech
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by Retric on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:29PM (#30978671)
It’s a question of wiggle room. Foundational patents are generally a lot harder to work around.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by speed_spread on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:29PM (#30981387)
Even with 20 year old design, you'd be using modern process which in itself should make room for significant improvements in scaling, frequency and power usage.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by ac29 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:41PM (#30982006)
Yeah, but it would still be stuck at supporting something like DirectX 8 and OpenGL 1.3 (like the GeForce4). It would certainly be faster and more efficient but modern games and other software wouldn't run on it.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by MichaelBurge on Sunday April 10, 2022 @06:19PM (#30982298)
The hardware seems separate from the software interface. Projects like WINE can convert DirectX calls to OpenGL or Vulkan calls, so it seems like a driver update could support a newer interface if needed.

For something that isn't supported at all like raytracing, those API calls would have to be dropped so you'd get a blank screen or only a UI. But something polygon-based, maybe you could drop the resolution and polygon count and that could be translated to the newer API.

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by _kbh_ on Sunday April 10, 2022 @07:06PM (#30982665)
This isn’t entirely true. The software that a GPU supports (DX version, etc) is directly tied to certain specifics about the hardware. Have a look at the “Shader model comparisons” to see an example of this. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Level_Shader_Language
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by imtringued on Monday April 11, 2022 @05:47AM (#30986571)
Are there any patents blocking GPUs from implementing all features of SPIR-V?
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by _kbh_ on Monday April 11, 2022 @07:36AM (#30987299)
Probably not as long as you don't trample any implementation specific patents. But the point was more about how it is much harder than just porting an old design to a newer process node to get good performance in modern games, modern hardware is fundamentally different than hardware of even the Geforce 7000 series.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by inetknght on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:16PM (#30978525)
> does it use any stolen ip?

> The bigger question is, does it violate any patents?

The former implies the latter.

On the other hand if the IP isn't stolen but would still fall afoul of the patent then I would argue that the patent is wrongly provided. Patents don't exist to protect obvious implementations.

I'm not a lawyer but we all know patent law is all kinds of fucked up.

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by jhgb on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:03PM (#30979073)
> The former implies the latter.

Isn't it the reverse? Patents are one of the several forms of IP that one can violate, so the latter should imply the former.

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by nynx on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:16PM (#30978529)
Who cares? Intellectual property frankly makes no sense if you don’t worship money.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by JaimeThompson on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:42PM (#30978818)
Should all software be licensed as public domain or the closes available to PD in countries that don't allow public domain software?
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by nynx on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:48PM (#30978892)
Software is a lot less important than patents. Patents should not be allowed or should expire in a year.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by JaimeThompson on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:18PM (#30979264)
Licenses are intellectual property too so I am a bit confused why the difference? Was the first statement just over broad? Not trying to be argumentative, just trying to understand your position when I am a bit tired.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by nynx on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:29PM (#30979396)
Yeah, too broad. Licenses and copyright are a net negative in my view, but patents are far worse.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by pfisherman on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:18PM (#30979265)
> Intellectual property frankly makes no sense if you don’t worship money.

Patents incentivize inventors to publicly disclose how their inventions work. They publicly disclose how their invention works and in exchange are given exclusive rights to it for a limited period of time.

This is predicated on the idea that in the absence of such a system, inventors have strong incentives to not disclose how their inventions work, which ultimately slows the spread of knowledge and puts a damper on innovation.

What parts of this do not make sense? How else would you solve the problem of incentives around disclosing how technologies work?

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by randomhodler84 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:55PM (#30979706)
Open source licensing incentivizes inventors to release their creations to the world to benefit humanity. Their copyright is protected and depending on the license that picked can control redistribution. Their work is protected against people passing their work off as their own, which is the intention of the patent idea.

Patents do nothing like this, in fact, they cause inventors to invent around “protected ideas”. Technology history is littered with examples of inefficient implementations become standard to avoid patent infringement. We end up with negative-incentives with patented ideas. In technology, a patent is a sure way to ensure that an idea is never implemented.

Nothing about patents, or the idea that an idea is exclusive and protection worth is worth salvaging. Patents do not achieve their stated goal.

Closed source software is inherently untrustworthy. The incentive to disclose ideas protected against plagiarism can be achieved through both public trust in our free and open source ecosystem without the need to enforce state violence because some dude dreamed an idea once and wrote a paper.

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by pfisherman on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:28PM (#30981892)
> Patents do not achieve their stated goal.

This assertion is being made without evidence.

Can you point to any modern technologically advanced civilizations / nations that do not have something like a patent system? How did those without well developed legal frameworks for intellectual property perform over time relative to others in measures of scientific output and economic development?

What is the alternative? Wouldn’t open source have been the default prior to the invention of patent law?

I am sorry, but if you are arguing for the abolition of the patent system, then you need to provide some alternative solution for the problem the patent system addresses along with some sort of data / evidence that your solution is not vastly inferior. Otherwise the argument is just not very persuasive.

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by hyperman1 on Monday April 11, 2022 @09:12AM (#30988169)
The USA is a great counter example. In the 19th century it took all kinds of european inventions, did very bad IP enforcement, and built out based on rampant IP theft. The IP relation between China and USA today is basically the relation between the USA and Europe then.

There is also Hollywood, the place where Edison could not get his film patents enforced, so every film maker ran to there. Rampant patent infringement made it great.

Or inside Europe, there were cities complaining how the guild IP rules were not enforced on farms. People bought e.g. cheap low quality pots and pans on the farms, with no frivolities or no correct marks, and no money was paid to the guilds. For shame! This was without patents, with guilds being very protective of their knowledge, and inventions still spread without much trouble.

Necessity is generally the mother of invention. Patents just slow things down to protect the established players.

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by ris on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:24PM (#30981337)
Except that's not how patents are used in the 21st century. Patents are generally written to be as broad in scope as possible while disclosing as little as possible information on how to get said invention to work (if the grantee has actually figured out that part at all). Registering and successfully defending a patent is extremely expensive and patent lawsuits are usually won by the party with the most legal resources, so arguments that it protects small "garden shed" inventors are largely fantasy.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by imtringued on Monday April 11, 2022 @05:51AM (#30986586)
It's like we are fighting an invisible economic war. The question is, why is it worth throwing other people under the bus? Somehow everyone is convinced that it is worth it.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by nynx on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:26PM (#30979364)
I agree that was the original intention, but these days (and possibly the entire time) it just slows innovation by preventing people from using technologies.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by pfisherman on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:18PM (#30981806)
Yes, patents do hamper innovation. But this does not acknowledge or address the counterfactual of whether not having a patent system would hamper innovation to a greater extent.

Without this the argument rests on an unstated assumption / magical thinking, which is not borne out by historical data.

It’s like saying that traffic lights impede the flow of traffic (true), without acknowledging the fact that not having traffic lights would result in much greater congestion (also true).

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by causality0 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:28PM (#30978659)
It makes sense if you have one scheme that creates that is choked out by a different scheme that copies instead. Eventually there is no creation.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by tovej on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:10PM (#30979156)
Patents also choke creativity, and arguably in a worse way. If you can't remix existing ideas, how are you supposed to create anything useful if you need to come up with an alternative scheme to every component problem that has already been solved but is already patented.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by FpUser on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:39PM (#30980892)
Yeah, it had taken me 10 years of heavy R&D investments to come up with this ingenious idea that the phone can have rounded corners. /s

Sorry but the situation now it that one can not even fart without breaking some patent. It is ridiculous, serves only big corps and keeps smaller companies under constant threat of litigations they can not afford. And most of the patents are plain obvious.

I was once asked to come up with the idea of how to implement some XXX feature. It had taken me about 10 minutes to "invent" the main approach and then couple of days to spec it down to such form that it could be given to subcontractor. Upon checking however we've easily found at least 10 patents covering this exact XXX. And this is everywhere.

From a tool to compensate the inventors the patents system has become a tool to serve fat cats.

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by deltaonefour on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:03PM (#30983422)
Who doesn't worship money? Let's not kid ourselves. We all worship money to a degree where we understand how the concept of intellectual property incentivizes the creation of "intellectual property."
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by daneel_w on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:00PM (#30978328)
That's a less interesting question on the whole. But, it quite likely does.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by machinekob on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:20PM (#30978571)
As it is in China you can bet on it. There were no major china tech company that product something and do not steal tech from "west" yet (maybe there are smaller companies but no big tech got it yet).
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by jbay808 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:35PM (#30978740)
DJI seems pretty big. Whose tech are they stealing?
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by chaboud on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:00PM (#30979038)
They scuffed with Autel and initially lost (but then had that patent invalidated), and their currently brewing fight is with Bell Textron for camera control.

(This is just a quick googling. I have no skin in this game either way, but I believe that the assertion that Chinese companies always steal is a bigoted position to take. Perhaps a more accurate description would be that IP is most commonly held by incumbent businesses, and businesses in China in new segments are, necessarily, new to market.)

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by chrischen on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:59PM (#30980477)
I think the last point you make is a big one, and partially used to justify the Chinese industry behavior. Basically China is late to the game and if they follow Western rules they will be perpetually behind, partially because such rules are obviously designed to preserve wealth.

That being said, there is still plenty of legit innovation coming from China and Chinese founders/contributors: ant framework for react, vue, tiktok.

I don’t think it’s a coincidence a lot of the innovation is in the software sector, especially ML, which has less incumbent IP protections.

Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by randyrand on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:02PM (#30979057)
DJI is mostly an assembler.
Re:New Chinese GPU Maker Moore Threads Unveils the MTT S60 GPU by MangoCoffee on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:29PM (#30981380)
i don't think so. the gpu is based on ip from Imagination Technologies. the company is sold to China. unless MTT didn't licensed the tech from Imagination