News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Heresy by Aeolun on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:01AM (#30977535)
I don’t think people want to say bad things without consequence. They want to be able to discuss a topic without the rabid tone police descending on it.

Like, I say I cannot understand trans people at all, and people will jump on me because I’m rejecting them and making them feel bad, when I’m just stating a fact.

There’s a lot of this stuff.

Re:Heresy by UncleMeat on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:06AM (#30977614)
“I don’t understand it but I’ll trust their feelings and the recommendations of their doctor” is very different from “I don’t understand it so I’ll call them mentally ill, misgender them, or insist that legislation prevent access to medical care”.
Re:Heresy by Aeolun on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:12AM (#30977713)
Indeed. But I do not feel like the wolves care about the distinction, or they just don’t attempt to figure out that nuance before they descend.
Re:Heresy by philjohn on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:58AM (#30978292)
I've seen more than a few posts where people have said "I really don't get this whole issue, but live and let live" and haven't been descended upon, that's just anecdata though.
Re:Heresy by ModernMech on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:03PM (#30978367)
On one hand, you're right. The nuance is sometimes lost. On the other hand, think about what we're talking about: a political party is trying to erase the existence of a class of people, and they are wielding the power of the state to do so, especially in places where there's one party control and no hope of electing any opposing party.

When you say "I don't understand trans people", trans people have heard this many times before. Unfortunately for you, many people who have said this phrase before followed it up with "...and therefore I hate them. I will legislate against them; I will pass laws against their existence in public space; I will demonize them; I will jail them; I will murder them."

Those are the stakes, so the pushback is in proportional to the life and death nature of what's going on here. When you say "I don't understand trans people" they are expecting you to follow it up with more of the same. And I get that's not great for the general public's understanding of trans people. But understand that it's a reaction to years and year of abuse from other people who also proclaim that they "don't understand."

Your general confusion is being received in an environment where people are literally fighting for their lives. Maybe in a different time, when people aren't facing down the vast power of the state to dictate their existence, there would be more room to treat you gentler. But the pressure has been ratcheted up to 11 by powerful forces bent on a 21st century new moral panic, and that's not the fault of trans people and their defenders, but the people who are trying to make their lives hell for no reason other than intolerance.

Re:Heresy by confidantlake on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:15PM (#30979223)
This kind of rhetoric doesn't seem true or helpful. The state is not organizing a genocide against trans people.
Re:Heresy by ModernMech on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:36PM (#30979476)
I didn't say anything about genocide, I said they are facing down politicians in state legislatures who are passing laws that deny the rights of trans people to exist in public places and to participate in public life. These lawmakers use rhetoric that does indeed question the very existence of the concept of a transgendered person. They deny that these people exist, and claim they are in fact mentally ill and not trans at all. If republicans had their way it would be illegal to be trans. That's the erasure of a class of people, but it's not genocide, I wouldn't go that far.
Re:Heresy by falcolas on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:56AM (#30978268)
If you don’t understand, why are you drawing the attention of the “wolves” by speaking before trying to understand?
Re:Heresy by UncleMeat on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:56AM (#30978262)
My experience has been the opposite. Empathy and willingness to learn are treated well, both by activists and trans people themselves.
Re:Heresy by lexicality on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:23AM (#30977846)
> I say I cannot understand trans people at all

Seems like a weird thing to say. I don't understand FORTRAN at all and as such I stay away from people discussing it.

Why do you want to tell trans people that you don't understand them? Wouldn't it be easier to read some literature so you can gain a basic understanding?

Re:Heresy by i000 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:10AM (#30977685)
Perhaps replacing "trans" with "black", "Jew", "Muslim" or any other marginalized minority group, would help you understand why such blanket "I cannot understand X at all" causes people to object?
Re:Heresy by nicoburns on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:16AM (#30977769)
I don't think that's fair. Nobody is debating what it means to be black, jewish or muslim. People's attitudes to people who are those things vary, but for the most part everybody is in agreement about which people are black, which people are Jewish, etc.

On the other hand, there is no such agreement around gender. People are using terms such as "gender", "man" and "woman" to refer to vastly different concepts ranging from "how someone subjectively feels inside" to "what physiological traits someone has" to "how someone is treated by society".

To the extent that not understanding someone comes from not understanding how they personally define gender and how that fits with how other people are using the same term, it seems quite reasonable to be confused.

Re:Heresy by hobs on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:36AM (#30978004)
No - there's very much active disagreement on which people are black (colorism in general in the black community is alive and well) and who thinks you are a jew might change a good bit if you ask the local white supremacist or a rabbi.

Just because "I know it when I see it" applies to your personal lens its an inarticulate way of viewing the world.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-drop_rule

Re:Heresy by nicoburns on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:11PM (#30978482)
Right, but when we discuss racism we're not discussing who is black or not black with the proviso that "of course it's fine to treat them badly if they're actually black", whereas it is commonly accepted by people on all sides of the gender debate that people should be treated differently on the basis of their gender.
Re:Heresy by erikerikson on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:01PM (#30979041)
Many of us believe treatment of people should be invariant of who they are.
Re:Heresy by woodruffw on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:40AM (#30978056)
> Nobody is debating what it means to be black, jewish or muslim. People's attitudes to people who are those things vary, but for the most part everybody is in agreement about which people are black, which people are Jewish, etc.

If this is the case, it’s only the case in the most vanishingly contemporary moment of ours. Both the Holocaust and the American system of chattel slavery were fundamentally predicated on questions of identity (“one drop”). Both moments also fundamentally shifted how and when people consider themselves Black or Jewish, because they are aware that others might consider them so for the purposes of persecution.

Re:Heresy by nicoburns on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:09PM (#30978444)
What I see as different here is that people on both sides of the gender debate seem to see differential treatment of "men" and "women" as just. The primary argument is over which people belong in which group. This is different to at least a modern take on slavery where we're usually less concerned with people being mislabelled as black and more concerned with the mistreatment of those who were labelled as black.

Incidentally, my view on a lot of gender issues is that's it's not so different, and that the reason trans women experience so much pushback as it least partially due to stigma which is also directed at cisgender men.

Re:Heresy by woodruffw on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:21PM (#30978584)
> What I see as different here is that people on both sides of the gender debate seem to see differential treatment of "men" and "women" as just.

I think this needs qualification: I don't think that treatment of individuals on the basis of gender (or sex) is just in the abstract, but I do think there are social policies that are inequal in scope that are justifiable on the basis of making all individuals more equal.

> Incidentally, my view on a lot of gender issues is that's it's not so different, and that the reason trans women experience so much pushback as it least partially due to stigma which is also directed at cisgender men.

I think a lot of people agree with this! The tension is again in scope: the stigmas and cultural pressures that cisgender men are subjected to don't generally induce people to kick us out of our homes as teenagers, to threaten us in bathrooms, &c.

Re:Heresy by nicoburns on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:43PM (#30978822)
> I think this needs qualification: I don't think that treatment of individuals on the basis of gender (or sex) is just in the abstract, but I do think there are social policies that are inequal in scope that are justifiable on the basis of making all individuals more equal.

I pretty much agree with that. But I think that most people are thinking about rights being as assigned to gender in the abstract. It seems to me that the reason there's so much fuss about statements like "trans women are women" is because the assumption is that "women's rights" are assigned to women in the abstract, and that who gets them is therefore determined by who counts as a woman.

> the stigmas and cultural pressures that cisgender men are subjected to don't generally induce people to kick us out of our homes as teenagers, to threaten us in bathrooms, &c.

That's only true if you accept that cisgender men won't want to act in ways that we associate with trans or cis women (e.g. wearing dresses or make up (and if you define gender in terms of identity then you could even include making changes to their bodies here)). And IMO that assumption is pretty sexist. I also think that there is a tendency to assume that such men are trans women, but identity doesn't work like that, and if we want to talk about assigned-gender-non-conforming people in general then we should talk them instead of trans people. I guess I don't really accept that that trans women are under more pressure to behave in certain ways than cisgender men are. But if you have a good argument as to why you think they are, then I'd be interested to hear it.

Re:Heresy by nullc on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:51PM (#30979661)
XKCD386-- there is a LOT of dispute over who is White/Black, particularly as its become popular in some circles to define racism as something which can only happen to black people. And thus a discriminatory policy against asians isn't racist to those adopting that definition when they conclude that asians are "white".

Or see this op-end regarding the ADL changing their definition of racism to require it be against "people of color" and Whoopi Goldberg claiming the Holocaust was not about race: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/02/03/whoopi-go...

The same kind of postmodernist thinking that is comfortable redefining well understood biological terms like "male" and "female" to be about "not doing the dishes" or "liking climbing trees" instead of generally unambiguous biological properties is just as comfortable deciding that you're "white" on the basis of not wanting to extend the protection of anti-discrimination laws and norms to you.

Re:Heresy by jleyank on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:07AM (#30977619)
I can’t understand bigots at all, particularly things like language. Yet Quebec is full of them.