News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by g_p on Saturday April 09, 2022 @09:36AM (#30967946)
For anyone not familiar with the world of academia, grad students actually have a good bit more power available to them by organising sensibly than you might think. The same is also true for early career postdoctoral research staff. This is because most of the work that actually matters is being done by these individuals, in a very pyramidical structure, but the money stops rolling in without the work that the base of the pyramid is delivering.

Tenured professors and others win research grants, and are only as good as their last grant. If they stop running on the treadmill, they won't get any more grants, as their pitch becomes less compelling than others'.

They win a grant, but the actual research work is then done by postdoctoral researchers and grad students. They do the actual work, write it up, and pretty much everything else. Often they even win the grants in the first place. The exception is that when there's some credit to be gained for the work, the professor will reappear to take center stage and give interviews.

If the grad students organise, the wheels could begin to fall off quickly - if projects are delayed, grant payments won't come through. If they are not teaching classes, someone else has to teach them. If the research isn't getting done, someone has to speak with funders on calls. Someone has to write reports. There's more to be done than the professor can do, and they will rapidly end up snowed under, unable to function, and unable to deliver papers on their grant. That will make it harder for them to get their next pet project funded.

Unfortunately, many people go into academia believing it to be a bastion of meritocracy where their efforts and skill will be rewarded, and they spend some number of years believing this before they start to realise what is actually going on. Some will make it to be a professor, others become disillusioned and go elsewhere. In my view though, the model is quite broken, and too reliant on a professor claiming credit for others' work without challenge, even though the work of their (hidden) team was the meaningful intellectual input, and some of them would probably be better as the professor.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by cycomanic on Saturday April 09, 2022 @11:20AM (#30968794)
You write like the professors are just sitting around raking in the glory, but not doing anything while they let everyone else does the work. The reality is that professors tend to work just as hard as their grad students. I completely agree that academia is very disfunctional, but it actually affects all levels. I am familiar with many academics that work >60h a week every week, in fact I believe the most outrageous examples of overworking grad students comes from academics who work crazy hours and expect everyone else to do the same.

What many don't see is that the way academic financing works is that academics spend probably >30% of their time on writing grants and evaluating others grants and then they have to report on the grants as well. Then there is all sort of other buerocratic work that they have to do, and the view by most of the admin staff that surround them is that academic time is not counted, which means most reporting systems are made so it's easy for the administrators but not the academics.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by whimsicalism on Saturday April 09, 2022 @12:29PM (#30969449)
> You write like the professors are just sitting around raking in the glory, but not doing anything while they let everyone else does the work.

I've worked at two major research universities in multiple labs. While this is not entirely true, it is more true than not.

Professors work hard, but many are not working hard on the actual research work, especially once they have been tenured for a long time.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by asdff on Saturday April 09, 2022 @02:44PM (#30970789)
It depends on the lab. Just like in private industries, some superiors merely phone it in, while others are a lot more hands on with their subordinates.
Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by aardvarks on Saturday April 09, 2022 @11:49AM (#30969053)
It's true that professors rely on grad students/postdocs to do work. And, at least in my experience, advisors are actually pretty good about giving students credit for their work -- having successful students reflects well on the advisor. But a student is even more dependent on their advisor than vice versa. It's not like undergrad where the main thing that matters to your future employment is to collect the diploma, because for most fields the main reason to get a PhD is to continue in academia, and academia right now is an extreme employer's market. The things you need to leave grad school with are 1) impressive recommendation letters, like "best student in N years, reminiscent of <mid-career hotshot> at that age", and 2) (lots of) refereed publications. If you manage that, the diploma should be automatic.

Yes, you can push back against advisors who require 12 hrs a day in lab. But if that means you take longer to produce work, your letters might be just good instead of positively glowing, which might mean you fail to launch in academia. Several hundred other people will apply for each tenure track job you apply to; those with "just good" letters tend to get crowded out. The tenured advisor might have a bruised ego because their publication rate has slowed, or be more frazzled because they have to save money and write more proposals, but at least they still have a job.

Also, PIs themselves generally work a lot as well (often the ones insisting on lots of hours from their students think, rightly or wrongly but based on their own experience, that that's the only way to succeed....). I agree academia is broken, but think it's at a deep structural level, and more complicated than schools exploiting students and hanging them out to dry.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by adminprof on Saturday April 09, 2022 @01:38PM (#30970103)
I think your comment is pretty spot on. Just three things I'd add to, are that 1) the advisor is not intentionally downgrading your letter to "just good", but it's that they're obligated to write a better than "just good" letter for someone who has been more productive both in terms of research and in being a leader in the community (these two things go hand in hand). Writing the same letter for two students regardless of what they accomplish would be unfair.

And 2) sometimes getting more funding is simply not possible, as in the advisor has basically reached the limit of what they can do. There's a limit to the number of proposals that one can submit and the number of calls that fit their research agenda. So what I think you're missing is that if an advisor has less funding, there's going to be more pressure to finish sooner and less freedom to explore ideas beyond what's written in a previous grant proposal.

3) I've never heard of a tenured professor that concerned about their publication rate. In fact, most of them don't even update their CVs or websites with the last few years of papers. It's always the student who is trying to get more papers.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by neutronicus on Saturday April 09, 2022 @10:00AM (#30968133)
On the other side of this equation, I think international students comprise a potent reservoir of strikebreakers.
Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by klyrs on Saturday April 09, 2022 @11:03AM (#30968631)
In my experience, international students are very active in grad student unions. Also, good luck bringing in scabs during finals week. Admission runs on a schedule, visas add delays, and even if they show up in time, they'll soon be informed that it's a closed shop and scabbing has financial penalties. Oh, and there's typically a high degree of solidarity between profs and their grad students -- you don't just get admitted by a university, you get admitted by a committee of professors in the department you apply to.
Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by azernik on Saturday April 09, 2022 @11:14AM (#30968730)
Yup - especially because student unions (in the labor-union sense, not in the faux-government US sense) are the norm in many places abroad rather than an exception.
Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by walkhour on Saturday April 09, 2022 @10:23AM (#30968302)
There's a reason why Academia and Big Tech love immigration.

And then there's the argument they use to justify why immigration is good, like diversity, inclusion, globalization, ... which may be valid or not.

But isn't it just perfect when your objectives are so closely aligned with what is considered morally right.

To regard these agents as moral actors instead of self-serving profit seekers is just lunacy.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by jrochkind1 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @11:53AM (#30969105)
Except in general people from other countries may be more amenable to union organizing and joining, since they often come from cultures where unions are viewed more positively than in the US, and where more of the workforce is unionized, and may possibly even have experience themselves with unions, or else have family members who do -- or if not with unions, with other kinds of collective political action of sorts that have become less common in the USA

I think this has been shown to be true in grad student unionization drives in the US.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by whimsicalism on Saturday April 09, 2022 @12:31PM (#30969463)
Speaking from my personal experience - which includes involvement in unionization drives, that has never been true. I think this is supported by the evidence.

Maybe if you're talking about immigrants from Western Europe. Otherwise, no.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by walkhour on Saturday April 09, 2022 @12:21PM (#30969373)
> where more of the workforce is unionized

Is this fact coming from the weighted average of how unionized is the workforce in the diferented countries from which workers comes to USA? Is this true for high and low paying jobs? Are the migrants from these countries representative of the workforce of their country?

Could you provide proof? My first reaction is to be agnostic upon this claim.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by jrochkind1 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @12:32PM (#30969474)
I know from observation that international students are often involved in grad student unionization efforts, especially in leadership positions -- anecdotal but generally noted by anyone else paying attention.

The rest is, yes, a theory I have that I don't currently have the data to back up -- and the theory is not just about union density in countries of origin, although that's part of it.

But as far as that part, just for some quick napkin math sanity check, if we're talking "countries from which workers come to USA" -- let's choose Mexico for example. First google hit (this is just a sanity check) says "Approximately 90% of Mexican production workers in industrial enterprises that employ at least twenty-five employees are unionized."

As far as international students, the top countries are China and India. China is it's own thing where unions exist in a completely different context. First google hit for India says "Over all, in India, 34.13% of regular non-agricultural workers are trade union members" -- this is of course much higher than the US. (First google hit says 10% USA, although that may be general not "non-agricultural").

The US is very low in unionization rate compared to most countries, most countries on the planet are going to have higher rates.

But I'm definitely not going to convince you of anything in this HN thread, it would require actually doing some research, like probably original research,, probably including sociological qualitative research actually talking to immigrants and such, not just the off-hand googling I am willing to put the time into now. It's just a theory I am sharing, yes. It would be an interesting research topic... for a grad student in some social science field. :)

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by walkhour on Saturday April 09, 2022 @12:39PM (#30969530)
> But I'm definitely not going to convince you of anything in this HN thread

You'd be surprised :). I appreciate your response, it was an interesting read.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by jrochkind1 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @01:06PM (#30969771)
Reading my post again, I think to be fair we should say that Mexican unions can often definitely be corrupt in a way that doesn't serve the interests of workers. While this could result in people from there being very cynical about and uninterested in unions -- that is often my personal experience with people from former soviet countries -- my personal experience with people from Mexico (totally anecdotal and subjective sense, not proof in any sense) is still that they come from a culture where it's generally understood that collectively organizing as workers -- and collectively organizing for grassroots political power in other ways -- is a good thing, and a culture where they may have some experience doing so, very differently from most people in the USA.

It's just my theory based on my personal observations and thoughts though, yeah!

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by slim on Saturday April 09, 2022 @10:43AM (#30968458)
Not if the international students get unionized. They're actually the most prone to unionization if the union is able to defend them.
Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by Ar-Curunir on Saturday April 09, 2022 @02:56PM (#30970899)
are you an international student? I am one, and the position of international students is much more precarious than most other PhD students: their very presence in the country depends on the whim of the advisor. In many unionization efforts that I’ve seen, there’s been lots of leadership from international students
Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by PeterisP on Saturday April 09, 2022 @11:42AM (#30968996)
Not really, strikes are a short-term thing and bringing in new international students is something that takes many months at least.
Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by the_only_law on Saturday April 09, 2022 @10:52AM (#30968525)
In fairness, these already seem to form the majority of PhD students at universities near me
Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by ModernMech on Saturday April 09, 2022 @10:46AM (#30968473)
> They do the actual work

Used to think this as a grad student. Now as a professor I see how naïve this attitude is. There is so much work beyond what grad students are tasked with including getting research funded, staffed, and results out the door. Grad students are cogs in a research machine, cogs that need to constantly be readjusted and recalibrated because they are quite green (sorry, it's true) for a number of years. Most 22 year olds coming out of undergrad into a PhD program are not doing what you would consider publishable research for a number of years, and what work they do is usually heavily based on a foundation of research that was laid to get funding in the first place (usually by the professor), based on ideas that have been thought of and refined over a number of an entire research career (not by the grad student doing the "actual work"). Grad students may have great technical ability, but they have next to 0 research sense and ability. As I said, doing research is so much more than the technical aspects and writing the paper.

Grad students love to feel like since they got a paper published, that they are 100% responsible for what happened in that paper, and I just have to ask: where were you 2 years ago when I was up at 4am finalizing the Nth draft of the grant application, based on research that I have been working on since 6 years before that? Oh, you were partying, drunk off your ass at a frat in undergrad, and when I started this research project you were learning your times tables. So tell me again how you're 100% responsible for the results here, and I'm just taking credit for all you have done on your own?

Sorry if you haven't noticed this post has turned into a rant at someone I have in mind, not at you. But I just needed to say this.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by dotnet00 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @09:18PM (#30973647)
I was with you until that rant in the second paragraph, it's pretty insulting to treat your grad students as if they must've spent their time partying.

Being as green as grad students are, it's entirely understandable for them to feel good about themselves about their first publication, especially when you also consider the problem of imposter syndrome. Working on my first publication, getting feedback on drafts, finalizing results etc has been a big confidence booster when working directly with people who've been doing research longer than I've been alive.

Then again, I understand the work the advisor/professor has done to set things up for me (was even surprised that I'm supposed to be the lead author despite being under their supervision) and my advisor is always pretty clear on matters relating to credit, often even more than I expect. So perhaps I just haven't seen the sort of friction leading to your rant.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by ModernMech on Saturday April 09, 2022 @09:54PM (#30973813)
> it's pretty insulting to treat your grad students as if they must've spent their time partying.

Sorry I thought I was clear I had gone of on a tangent with someone in particular in mind. That wasn't literally directed at all grad students.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by dotnet00 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @11:44PM (#30974314)
I had gotten that, I could've sworn I added a caveat about "unless you know that the student you're referring to was like that" but looks like I did not.
Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by Ar-Curunir on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:00PM (#30970935)
I’m sorry, but you sound like a terrible, patronizing advisor; anyone who views their students as “cogs in the machine” is someone I would not want to work with.

Yes, professors work hard, but let’s not kid ourselves that they’re involved with the nitty-gritty research work. You just sound like someone who’s bitter at young people.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by ModernMech on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:23PM (#30971121)
Again, kindly see my reply about attacking me personally. If you feel affronted by my calling grad students cogs, make a case for why they are not. I spend plenty of time shaping those cogs into fine researchers, and they're all better for it, so my results speak for themselves. But you're kidding yourself if you think a green 22 year old fresh out of undergrad is able to perform at a level much higher than a cog in a research lab. There's usually a researcher in there, but it takes a lot of work, usually years, to properly shape their minds.

I'm quite young myself so I don't understand why you would say I'm bitter at young people, but I guess it just goes to show I hit a nerve and you want to lash out at me even though you know nothing about me, not even my age. You want to form an opinion about me and my personality and my entire professional posture based on a rant go ahead, but keep it to yourself.

As for professors not being involved in the nitty gritty research, there's just no basis for this statement. Like I said I've spent almost a literal decade getting my research agenda up and running, and that's pretty much the common case. It takes at least 6 years to get tenure. Students joining me today are getting involved in a project that began when they were preteens. Students claiming full credit over research done at that point is pure hubris.

How do you think research labs come to be without professors getting involved in the "nitty gritty"? Research happens over a long timescale, longer than any one grad student's tenure.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by Fomite on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:26AM (#30974474)
"Yes, professors work hard, but let’s not kid ourselves that they’re involved with the nitty-gritty research work. You just sound like someone who’s bitter at young people."

This week I've:

- Worked on a research grant that doesn't have any students on it, so who else is doing the "nitty gritty research work"?

- Gone through a student's research code line-by-line to try to hunt down a particularly pernicious bug.

- Done a ton of data wrangling for another project to minimize the number of hands currently using a restricted-access server.

If the parent poster is painting with an overly broad brush, so are you.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by dennis_jeeves1 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @07:24PM (#30973114)
>I’m sorry, but you sound like a terrible, patronizing advisor; anyone who views their students as “cogs in the machine” is someone I would not want to work with.

He pointed to the state of affairs, not how he treats them. Understand?

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by thylacine222 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @12:55PM (#30969658)
lol I hope for the sake of your graduate students that your institution has a union. Your personality sounds exactly like the countless professors I've seen abuse their workers.
Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by ModernMech on Saturday April 09, 2022 @12:58PM (#30969686)
edit: sorry I'm just going to disengage from this, I feel trolled so that's that. If you want to interrogate my position, then maybe ask a question. No questions have been asked so an interrogation is not what's taking place here.

Ranting about a third party not involved in the discussion here, who nobody knows, is completely different than writing a response to someone, attacking them directly, and calling into question their professional capabilities directly, then doubling down and tripling down on that even after they asked you to stop is just rude and unnecessarily antagonistic. I asked you to make a point a couple times now and you don't have a point to make except to attack me personally, so kindly find someone else to troll.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by thylacine222 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @01:03PM (#30969746)
i'm sure that your students are very happy to criticize the person that pays them, and who has a complex about them not being deserving enough, to their face

edit: if you expect to be able to use your own anecdotes as evidence against unionization, expect them to actually be interrogated. if this is how you handle conflict with a random person on the internet, i shudder to imagine how you handle conflict with someone who works for you.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by thylacine222 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @01:29PM (#30970011)
bruh you spent all of your first post writing a rant attacking one of your grad students don't act all high and mighty now
Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by Fomite on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:22AM (#30974456)
The grant that covers the largest portion of my salary doesn't even have grad students on it.
Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by canjobear on Saturday April 09, 2022 @10:37AM (#30968407)
> They win a grant, but the actual research work is then done by postdoctoral researchers and grad students. They do the actual work, write it up, and pretty much everything else.

In this scenario, which does happen but is not the only way it works, the convention is that the student or postdoc is first author and the advisor is final author on the paper. That seems fair to me.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by g_p on Saturday April 09, 2022 @10:47AM (#30968483)
Order of authorship is quite dependent on discipline - in comp sci and engineering the convention is as you say. In other fields they prefer alphabetical order or other orders, as I understand.

Some journals have started requiring specific disclosures of activities that each individual carried out.

Interestingly for some of the professors, some publications' ethics codes don't consider merely obtaining funding as meeting the requirements for authorship of a paper. Of course they'll claim other activities, but a quick review of the papers and input they claim to have made will likely give rise to probable doubt. There's a few papers looking at "prolific authorship" in different disciplines.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by SantalBlush on Saturday April 09, 2022 @11:17AM (#30968758)
I just went through this with a small grant. My only colleague in our dept. quit just before COVID started, so I was doing both full-time jobs on the grant. The university froze hiring and raises in 2020. I wrote all reports, wrote the new grant, handled all of the budgeting and admin. In late 2021, our PI retired and we finally filled the vacant admin position, so I had to train the new hire and the new PI about how the grant worked.

During that time, I received zero merit raises, and as a thanks from the university, they took more money from the grant so we could no longer afford a research assistant. My new colleague with zero years of experience was hired at the same rate as me; she almost immediately started venting to me how she doesn't get paid enough. She wants to earn a big promotion, so she is making her own changes to our reports that end up taking a lot more time. I put my notice in last week. I need to recharge for a month or two before I get back out there.

Basically, most of the value I created went to the university and our PI, and I was expected to be thankful for the opportunity. In spite of that, I think I left the dept. in better shape than it was in when I arrived.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by amitport on Saturday April 09, 2022 @09:54AM (#30968089)
If a professor is only taking credit for underlings' work he / she will, at some point, stop getting good students...
Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by g_p on Saturday April 09, 2022 @10:52AM (#30968523)
In theory this should be true, although the information asymmetries involved (especially for international students who go based on citations or notable papers or "reputation") mean that it can be hard to lose the flow of good students.

Ultimately if they are a tenured prof and can keep winning grants, they can offer postdoc and postgrad contracts, and that is effectively the only internal currency that matters for a student that needs to find a postgrad position.

With a limited number of chairs, it's hard for someone else to get a "rival" chair post and then compete internally, to give students the choice (which you'd get in a free market). If the institution has a good reputation, they'll likely have a flow of willing students regardless of how they act.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by neutronicus on Saturday April 09, 2022 @10:07AM (#30968191)
Yeah in my experience professors are pretty good about giving credit (the student is the first author on the paper, does the conference presentations, etc).

The comment above is right about the general structure (professors pitch, students deliver), though. And perhaps right about claiming credit in some fields, although not mine.

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by g_p on Saturday April 09, 2022 @10:59AM (#30968590)
I'd agree it very much depends on the individuals. I have worked with people all across the spectrum. My advisor was absolutely in the "good" camp - we'd openly describe call academia the "world's biggest hidden pyramid scheme". He led a small, tightly knit group, and the group followed the two pizzas rule.

I've also dealt with people who tried to come across like this, but were the absolute opposite - they'd grown a pretty large research group to get their chair, but had a reputation of over-promising and under delivering. They'd promise things without the technical knowledge to understand what they were saying they'd do, then causing morale problems among their team when people found out what had been promised. They absolutely didn't follow the two pizzas rule - you could barely find their whole group, let alone fit them in a room. This prof would try to give the impression they wanted others to grow and succeed, but ultimately it was all about them, and preserving their carefully crafted hierarchy. They didn't like to hear "no", and couldn't bear the thought that they were over stretched and not delivering, so everyone would tell them things were fine, as they under-delivered, exacerbating the situation...

Re:MIT graduate students vote to unionize by jrochkind1 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @11:57AM (#30969128)
In these kinds of departments, I think the professor PI is understood as basically a management position -- they get the funding, they "hire" and manage the right grad students and other staff who do the work -- and yeah, then they take credit for it. So they aren't "only" taking credit for others work, they are performing administrative and management functions. And if they do that job well, they will not stop getting students. Because it can be the only game in town (literally, in the "town" you are in), and switching labs is a set back (switching schools/departments even harder and more so).