News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shutting Down My Baby by ganbatekudasai on Sunday April 03, 2022 @04:25AM (#30895383)
> Like so many startup founders, I was driven by the motivation to build a product that I would like to use myself (or so I thought). My goal was to allow authors to automatically generate new creative text based on text they had written so far (basically a literary autocomplete).

Lesson learned I hope: It seems to me that the author wanted to be an entrepreneur foremost instead of solving an acutal problem. What the author wanted was their own startup with the accompanied startup experience, and so the "problem" was rather secondary and maybe even thought of after that desire?

I mean:

> It turned out that writers actually like to write themselves, and the current level of technology was just not good enough to make them really satisfied with whatever output they got from my product.

Really? It continues:

> Even though nearly everybody on this planet has heard the “machine learning” buzzword by now, the less technologically experienced hobby writers that I talked to didn’t have a real understanding of what they could expect from my product. This fundamental knowledge divide really made me think about how to reach this group of people.

Again, this really gives me the impression that you're not trying to solve a problem. You're "thinking about how to reach this group of people" to sell them your dream of having a company, not something they want or need.

Re:Shutting Down My Baby by eganist on Sunday April 03, 2022 @05:08AM (#30895557)
Hm

I mean, to a certain extent, running a startup often means convincing people of a problem they didn't know they had. I think a more accurate simplification of their post mortem is something like:

"I had a problem and solved it for myself. I thought it was a problem others had, but it turned out most people didn't think it was a problem, and I couldn't convince them otherwise."

Re:Shutting Down My Baby by fuzzfactor on Sunday April 03, 2022 @09:31AM (#30896774)
>"thinking about how to reach this group of people" to sell them your dream of having a company

This is actually a very effective approach if you have something to offer they both want & need.

Re:Shutting Down My Baby by WJW on Sunday April 03, 2022 @10:15AM (#30897079)
I think the criticism was that the author of the article was more interested in "being an entrepreneur" than in offering something they want and need. In this case in particular, offering people a way to automate away things they do for fun seems to be basically the opposite of what they want and need.
Re:Shutting Down My Baby by fuzzfactor on Sunday April 03, 2022 @01:10PM (#30898539)
I agree, but I wouldn't want to throw the baby out with the bathwater.
Re:Shutting Down My Baby by Vespasian on Sunday April 03, 2022 @05:17AM (#30895586)
I was wondering the same.

It feels like a mature version of this product would be ideal for publishers and other customers of authors.

However I suspect we are not there yet technological wise and therefore he was unable/didn't attempt to sell the product to these companies.

Re:Shutting Down My Baby by yakak on Sunday April 03, 2022 @07:29AM (#30896094)
It would be ideal for someone, but either he can't summarize his product well or it gives me the chills.. Autogenerated texts with correct form and an appearance of putting in the thought is the kind of thing that turns people off to whole industries and gets them to go back to reading things with an earlier publication date than the technology.
Re:Shutting Down My Baby by lozenge on Sunday April 03, 2022 @08:16AM (#30896303)
This seems like a product fit for content farms/SEO optimised sites that have no intention of anybody reading the output.
Re:Shutting Down My Baby by Aeolun on Sunday April 03, 2022 @09:31AM (#30896773)
> publishers and other customers of authors

To do what? Auto-generate new books about a particular series when the writer doesn’t want to write any more?

Possibly with some prompting help from a ghostwriter?

Re:Shutting Down My Baby by manmal on Sunday April 03, 2022 @09:40AM (#30896838)
It IS basically Github's CoPilot, but for plain text, no?