If the benefit is only storage, you have to ask if we are out of storage options. Our reservoirs are typically low so why would we put water in a storage place that is both expensive and carbon intensive to access?
In times of plenty it makes sense to put some water back in the ground if you have a short-term capacity.
The idea of putting water back in just for the sake of it because that's how it was when you found it is pointless
This is literally what the article is about. Nobody's doing this because they're bored and looking for fun hobbies on the side. California's groundwater systems are being depleted rapidly and people are desperate to find solutions that don't require pulling less water out of the ground.
Even with this that outcome won't be avoided.
It fails to answer the question of "so what?"
* a lot of these areas also flood, so you either now have more flooding or now you have to shore up levees and other flood protections at great expense
* land subsidence due to groundwater draw is not necessarily evenly spread. most buildings and infrastructure are not supposed to unevenly shift large distances.
My most familiar example is the central valley of CA, which is a basin, and which will flood either way,
>* land subsidence due to groundwater draw is not necessarily evenly spread. most buildings and infrastructure are not supposed to unevenly shift large distances.
this is absolute nonsense, no building has ever seen differential elevation gain. we are talking about meters across many kilometers.
Here’s an article discussing how subsidence caused by overdrawn aquifers in Mexico City is causing buildings to noticeably tilt. https://amp.miamiherald.com/latest-news/article1938721.html
The article about Mexico city wildly conflates building settling with groundwater subsidence - Like old buildings where the entire first floor is below ground level.
Is that good enough, besides preventing seawater intrusion, and not draining what is effectively a nonrenewable resource? At best, it takes centuries for the aquifers to replenish naturally.
Many areas have water aquifer levels that start a hundred or more feet down. No tree roots are in that, let alone other plants.
beg to differ.
There are many examples of where ground water in the ground helps maintain the environment in ways that benefit everyone.
You cant just take something as significant as an existing water table away and expect the ecology and geography of that environment to stay the same.
Goundwater in the ground doesn't help anyone.