News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by ggm on Monday March 28, 2022 @01:11AM (#30827333)
Without an economic model which monetises saving water into the aquifer higher than selling water for direct consumption, and an associated public-interest governance model with directing force, this is one of those "so simple, so hard" things.

Australia has a comparable problem. The Great Artesian Basin is being drained by morally, and sometimes financially corrupted process which vests in inter-state rivaly, "I want to" farm-gate logic, and "Its muh right" views of water falling on the land. An attempt to construct a 4 state agreement to manage flows has failed because of acts of bastardry by one state (NSW) against the down stream wishes of two others (Vic, SA) and acts of indifference by a fourth state (qld) where much of the headwater springs from.

As a species, we're incapable of making decisions which matter. I despair, or wonder if tyrants would do better right now.

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by leed25d on Monday March 28, 2022 @12:03PM (#30831953)
I have a way to monetize this: start charging Nestlé. Currently they are extracting billions of gallons of water every year from California aquifers for free so that they can sell it back to us for two dollars a bottle. Put a stop to this now.
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by taktoa on Monday March 28, 2022 @08:16PM (#30837157)
This seems pretty innumerate to me. Just off the top of my head: ordinary people use over an order of magnitude more water in showers and toilets and lawn sprinklers than they drink (let alone the amount of _bottled_ water they drink), and farms in California use an order of magnitude more water than ordinary people and businesses (which is why low flow faucets and the like are not really doing much for California's droughts).
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by mike_d on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @01:06AM (#30838977)
The biggest consumer of water in the state (about half) is environmental concerns. Trying to maintain wetlands, fish populations, etc.

Agriculture is 40%, and all consumer/urban consumption is 10%.

The solution to the water problem is trivial, but quite unpopular. Tax crops by the gallons per human calorie. That would eliminate a lot of the feed crops that we grow using our water and ship overseas, as well as dumb shit like almonds.

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by r00fus on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @01:38AM (#30839143)
Almonds pale in comparison to meat use of water. Your plan would work but CA milk/beef production would collapse - almonds would just get costlier (CA makes most of all almonds in the world).
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by rhinoceraptor on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @02:13AM (#30839389)
That's not really accurate, the vast majority of water "used" in beef production is green water. That is, rainfall and ground moisture in the grass that cattle eat, which obviously is subsequently urinated out and reincorporated into new grass and new topsoil. And the majority of what cattle eat, even conventional beef, is grass.

The amount of blue water use, that is, irrigated water pumped from aquifers and water bodies, is about 240 gallons per pound of beef [1]. Compare that with almonds, which clock in at about 630 gallons per pound [2].

If you use the misleading numbers that prevail in most publications, that's where you get the around 1800 gallons figure, since about 95% of that is green water.

1: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0308521X1...

2: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1470160X1...

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by ncmncm on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @09:36AM (#30842355)
That assumes the cattle are eating only grass, when in fact they are fattened for months on grain that has been irrigated.
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by rhinoceraptor on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @10:23AM (#30842905)
That first study was for conventional CAFO beef, it breaks down the component blue water usage from corn, soy, hay, grains, etc.
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by frumper on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @02:06PM (#30846250)
Driving up and down the state doesn't show a ton of grain being grown here, so either way the water isn't taken from California aquifers.
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by ncmncm on Thursday March 31, 2022 @07:26AM (#30865984)
Last time I drove to Livermore, I passed one hell of a lot of maize.
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by mistrial9 on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @09:45AM (#30842449)
> 1800 gallons figure, since about 95% of that is green water

ninety-five percent of a previously cited number is actually OK?

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by yetihehe on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @01:41AM (#30839163)
> Your plan would work but CA milk/beef production would collapse

Yeah, better to make beef for 10 more years and change your place into desert.

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by rhinoceraptor on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @02:19AM (#30839429)
Beef actually has a pretty moderate groundwater footprint, from what I've read it's less than half that of almonds per pound. That number is even smaller for grass finished beef. The numbers cited for water use for beef include rainfall that is incorporated into the grass that cattle graze, which is highly misleading.
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by ArnoVW on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @04:44AM (#30840255)
That's like saying : our nuclear power plant didn't have such a horrible accident, it has only released half of Chernobyl.

It's the same sort of reasoning that is leading people to say that they shouldn't have to pay tax / reduce CO2 because "someone else is richer / more polluting".

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by rhinoceraptor on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @05:07AM (#30840387)
Everything we eat has some groundwater use. I'm just saying that for its nutrient and caloric density, beef is vastly overrated in its water use. We tend to compare pounds of food to other pounds of food, but that is a misleading comparison. The nutritional value of meat has been very undervalued in the past few decades, and meat has a lot of nutritional value that we as humans cannot get on our own from plants.

That's not to say you should eat it for every meal, but ethically, environmentally and nutritionally, I really believe it is the best choice in terms of meat. Even CAFO beef, which is ethically pretty bad, is still vastly superior in that dimension to poultry and pretty much everything else.

Methane is another issue but I believe there is also a good argument in favor of it there as well. There is actually quite a lot of methane release from crops like rice which do not get media derision, as does the methane release from cattle.

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by ncmncm on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @09:40AM (#30842398)
People eat way more beef than almonds, in sum. So, beef production is an enormously bigger drain on water than almonds.

That said, most of the almonds are grown by a billionaire on stolen water.

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by anjel on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @12:47PM (#30845032)
"Lynda Resnick and her husband, Stewart, also own a few other things: Teleflora, the nation’s largest flower delivery service; Fiji Water, the best-selling brand of premium bottled water; Pom Wonderful, the iconic pomegranate juice brand; Halos, the insanely popular brand of mandarin oranges formerly known as Cuties; and Wonderful Pistachios, with its “Get Crackin'” ad campaign. The Resnicks are the world’s biggest producers of pistachios and almonds, and they also hold vast groves of lemons, grapefruit, and navel oranges. All told, they claim to own America’s second-largest produce company, worth an estimated $4.2 billion." https://www.motherjones.com/environment/2016/08/lynda-stewar...
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by _jal on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @12:06PM (#30844356)
> That said, most of the almonds are grown by a billionaire on stolen water

Well, don't keep us in suspense. To which wealthy, wetfingered nut nut do you refer?

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by mike_d on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @03:44AM (#30839904)
> CA makes most of all almonds in the world

Because they are water hungry and we have broken water economics here.

A single almond requires 12 liters of water to produce.

Almonds have no practical role in American diets aside from cakes, cookies, and liquors. Almond milk is inferior to oat milk in every way except in vitamin E levels.

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by legostormtroopr on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @05:29AM (#30840500)
But that 12 litres of water doesn't "disappear". It sits in the ground, it persperates in to the air, it becomes a part of the water cycle.

Its not like we are destroying 12 litres of water per almond (or I hope not).

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by UncleMeat on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @08:48AM (#30841798)
We have plenty of water. What we don't have is plenty of water in all the right places. Moving water is expensive. Water carried by the water cycle away to another region where there is little agriculture is roughly equivalent to disappearing it.
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by mschuster91 on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @05:53AM (#30840633)
The key thing is the supply of water is limited, no matter where it ends up at. And as the supply of water is so limited, it is better from a point of efficiency to produce goods with a higher value for humans.
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by imtringued on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:45AM (#30841304)
It's not much use to us in the oceans.
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by wbl on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @02:02AM (#30839318)
Wisconsin is a real place.
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by schimmy_changa on Monday March 28, 2022 @09:29PM (#30837689)
Nestle specifically, yes, but Agriculture overall, no- check out PPIC for reports on this. The equivalent price that farmers pay for water is about 25 cents… you’d pay more for a shower as an individual I think!
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by phkahler on Monday March 28, 2022 @09:08PM (#30837534)
Easier to regulate one company than millions of peoples shower habbits.
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by rkhassen9 on Monday March 28, 2022 @03:48PM (#30834744)
Groundwater is so important. It's part of a system we do it fully understand. In our area, the groundwater where the wells draw from have become contaminated with saltwater because the freshwater was too low, and the saltwater seeped in and we no longer have a key way of providing water to the community. Many people including myself got sick and had to start buying water, something that was enjoyed by countless previous generations. Fixing it isn't straightforward either, it would take decades to fix, according to the hydrologists.

37% percent of people reply on groundwater as a source, and I wonder how many plants and animals in the system do as well.

If only we could think of the earths resources as a single body or systemthat we share, I think we could make some steps. I feel like we are still at the stage where collectively we are selling our kidneys for iPads, and our lungs(forests)for gas money and think we'll still be able to function as well when the vital organs are gone.

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by imtringued on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:56AM (#30841386)
"But man, unlike the plant, cannot remain satisfied with part of the earth; he needs the whole; every individual needs the whole undivided earth. Nations living in valleys or islands, or shut off by tariff - barriers, languish and become extinct. Trading nations, on the other hand, that spice their blood with all the products of the earth, remain vigorous and populate the world. The bodily and spiritual needs of men put out roots in every square foot of the earth's surface, embracing the globe as with the arms of an octopus. Man needs the fruits of the tropics, of the temperate zones and of the north; and for his health he needs the air of the mountains, the sea and desert. To stimulate his mind and enrich his experience he needs intercourse with all the nations of the earth. He even needs the gods of other nations as objects with which to compare his own religion. The whole globe in splendid flight around the sun is a part, an organ, of every individual man.

How, then, can we suffer individual men to confiscate for themselves parts of the earth as their exclusive property, to erect barriers and with the help of watchdogs and trained slaves to keep us away from parts of the earth, from parts of ourselves - to tear, as it were, whole limbs from our bodies? Is not such a proceeding equivalent to self-mutilation?"

page 54 of https://www.naturalmoney.org/NaturalEconomicOrder.pdf

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by edmcnulty101 on Monday March 28, 2022 @08:52PM (#30837432)
What area are you?
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by labster on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @04:30AM (#30840170)
Nestlé sold most of its water businesses, including those in California, to BlueTriton. Nestlé still owns the European brands, but not Arrowhead Puritas or Nestlé Pure Life.
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by WalterBright on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @01:28AM (#30839073)
So don't pay $2 a bottle. Buy it for $.03 per gallon from your taps.

The only time I buy a bottle of water is when I need a "canteen".

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by vkou on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @05:01AM (#30840355)
> Currently they are extracting billions of gallons of water every year

So, they are a rounding error in California's overall water consumption?

And you think curtailing that is going to fix unsustainable water usage in a desert state?

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by robbiep on Monday March 28, 2022 @09:33PM (#30837719)
You’re confusing 2 issues when it comes to Australia’s water usage.

The first is the Murray Darling Basin, which is the 4 state disaster you’re talking about, and the many poor outcomes it has created. I grew up (and my parents still live and farm) about an hour south of the QLD border. Different regulatory frameworks means NSW farmers can pump with QLD farmers can’t. And we’re talking pumping from the river, and that’s what creates downstream problems. Particularly when farmers on one side can pump and ones on the other can’t.

The Great Artesian Basin is a different story. It requires pumping and drilling and is regulated totally differently. Probably the biggest changes have been the significant cuts to water licences, but even moreso was the capping of free flowing bores that occurred in the 90s and 2000s.

Artesian basin pressures have been generally stable or rising across the last 10-15 years, reflecting stabilisation of consumption-recharge cycle - even in the face of 2 of our worst droughts on record. The largest contributors to drainage have always been stock bores, as agricultural/centre pivot usage got off the ground a lot later in Australia than in the US, and so the regulatory framework wasn’t so far behind usage and didn’t create a tragedy of the commons scenario as in the MidWest USA

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by ggm on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:36PM (#30838475)
Thanks for the correction. Good stuff! There are pretty solid fears from some people that the Qld gas-related fracking (which in principle is well below the artesian water) will cause contamination. I'm not a geologist, and the ones I know are hesitant to say there's "no" risk, albiet small ones. But contamination of groundwater is one of those "hard to unscramble the egg" things.

There was some kind of proposal to fund covering the open bore drains. I think it died/withered on the vine. Capping stops at source, Covering would be stopping evaporative losses in transport. Maybe we should have Qanat like in the middle east!

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by robbiep on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @04:02PM (#30847647)
I agree that fracking is not a great idea with the risk/reward profile.

The cap/cover program is still running but the vast majority of open bores have been covered now. It's an interesting area because the vast majority are not for agricultural irrigation but for stock usage. NSW Govt at least is still spending money on it

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by chermi on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @10:09AM (#30842739)
There exists various forms of "water markets". I'm most familiar with irrigation districts in California, but I know there's other examples that facilitate the monetization of saving water in some form.

Stanford and UC Merced do some work on the problem, with the former having some economists involved iirc. https://waterinthewest.stanford.edu/

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by s1artibartfast on Monday March 28, 2022 @10:35AM (#30830911)
It lacks more than an economic model. It lacks a reason for doing so at all.

Goundwater in the ground doesn't help anyone.

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by the_optimist on Monday March 28, 2022 @08:12PM (#30837130)
Of course it does. Do you lie about on the ground waiting for it to rain when you're thirsty? No, you want to have freshwater stored somewhere, best in tremendous quantities, so that if it doesn't happen to rain for a while you don't die. A glib response to applied risk does not suggest you have expertise.
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by s1artibartfast on Monday March 28, 2022 @08:40PM (#30837339)
As long as there is plenty of water in the ground to serve as a reserve, there is no added benefit to adding more.

If the benefit is only storage, you have to ask if we are out of storage options. Our reservoirs are typically low so why would we put water in a storage place that is both expensive and carbon intensive to access?

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by ssivark on Monday March 28, 2022 @09:13PM (#30837559)
Given the rapid depletion of ground water levels, and uncertainty about potential changes in precipitation patterns due to climate change, do we actually have “plenty of water” in the ground, compared to a reasonable desire (well thought out planning) for several-decades worth of buffer for a large number of people?
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by s1artibartfast on Monday March 28, 2022 @10:09PM (#30837947)
It depends on the location and it is a huge range. There are places where wells have gone dry and places that receive no rain but have hundreds of years left.

In times of plenty it makes sense to put some water back in the ground if you have a short-term capacity.

The idea of putting water back in just for the sake of it because that's how it was when you found it is pointless

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by stouset on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @03:26AM (#30839791)
> In times of plenty it makes sense to put some water back in the ground if you have a short-term capacity.

This is literally what the article is about. Nobody's doing this because they're bored and looking for fun hobbies on the side. California's groundwater systems are being depleted rapidly and people are desperate to find solutions that don't require pulling less water out of the ground.

Even with this that outcome won't be avoided.

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by bobthepanda on Monday March 28, 2022 @09:07PM (#30837526)
Water draw on groundwater aquifers is so high that the ground is sinking by meters. https://www.hcn.org/articles/south-water-the-central-califor...
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by s1artibartfast on Monday March 28, 2022 @09:13PM (#30837558)
That's not an argument for putting it back in or even stopping.

It fails to answer the question of "so what?"

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by bobthepanda on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:11PM (#30838311)
lowering ground levels is pretty bad

* a lot of these areas also flood, so you either now have more flooding or now you have to shore up levees and other flood protections at great expense

* land subsidence due to groundwater draw is not necessarily evenly spread. most buildings and infrastructure are not supposed to unevenly shift large distances.

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by s1artibartfast on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:57PM (#30838599)
>* a lot of these areas also flood, so you either now have more flooding or now you have to shore up levees and other flood protections at great expense

My most familiar example is the central valley of CA, which is a basin, and which will flood either way,

>* land subsidence due to groundwater draw is not necessarily evenly spread. most buildings and infrastructure are not supposed to unevenly shift large distances.

this is absolute nonsense, no building has ever seen differential elevation gain. we are talking about meters across many kilometers.

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by bobthepanda on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @01:44AM (#30839187)
Sure they do.

Here’s an article discussing how subsidence caused by overdrawn aquifers in Mexico City is causing buildings to noticeably tilt. https://amp.miamiherald.com/latest-news/article1938721.html

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by s1artibartfast on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @11:08AM (#30843574)
any stories from California?

The article about Mexico city wildly conflates building settling with groundwater subsidence - Like old buildings where the entire first floor is below ground level.

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by ako on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @01:38AM (#30839146)
Plants? Plants means animals, food, oxigen... No ground water -> desert, is that where you want to live?
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by s1artibartfast on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @01:43AM (#30839179)
Since when do plants and animals care if their relative Elevation to sea level is off by a few meters ?
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by arbitrary_name on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @02:10AM (#30839371)
California roads and water pipes and aqueducts are being damaged by the drop in elevation. The costs to address the damage are high.

Is that good enough, besides preventing seawater intrusion, and not draining what is effectively a nonrenewable resource? At best, it takes centuries for the aquifers to replenish naturally.

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by ako on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @03:55AM (#30839975)
Plant roots need to be able to grow deep enough to reach water. If the groundwater level is too deep they can’t reach it, and they won’t be able to grow at all.
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by s1artibartfast on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @06:37AM (#30840878)
That is like worrying about satellites hitting birds. We are talking literally orders of magnitude difference.

Many areas have water aquifer levels that start a hundred or more feet down. No tree roots are in that, let alone other plants.

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by aerostable_slug on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:23PM (#30838402)
For one it prevents seawater incursion, a major threat to California coastal cropland.
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by s1artibartfast on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @12:01AM (#30838625)
This is a valid point and should be managed for those specific areas. That said, costal areas suffer intrusion mainly from groundwater pumping. It is far better to reduce pumping and use imported water, than import water and put it in the ground
Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by senectus1 on Monday March 28, 2022 @08:11PM (#30837121)
>Goundwater in the ground doesn't help anyone.

beg to differ.

There are many examples of where ground water in the ground helps maintain the environment in ways that benefit everyone.

You cant just take something as significant as an existing water table away and expect the ecology and geography of that environment to stay the same.

Re:A deceptively simple plan to replenish California’s groun... by s1artibartfast on Monday March 28, 2022 @08:42PM (#30837352)
I think this is largely irrelevant for deep ground water, far out of the reach of surface ecology.