Results being what Google wants the user to see seems to be the real problem.
Youtube for example in the past would show suggestions from small channels that were interesting and fun, but now you can't even find them in search using an exact video title. I've seen Google News completely shut out a breaking news story for half a day and the only reason I can think of was the ranking AI saw some 'bad' words in every story - even from NYT/WaPo, whose articles were among the many dozens on Bing News. Presumably they've applied their anti-"I hated it" ideas to Search as well.
So now is a great time to compete with Google because they're handicapping themselves and even though they could just turn off the bias and return good results, they probably would rather lose than stop trying to influence users.
What do you mean? What configuration options would you like?
Suppose you're a gamer - You could configure search results related to gaming to be limited to games you own, games you want, the subset of platforms or genres you care about, games your friends own, and so on. It wouldn't be a priority for most search companies to make something like that, but it would certainly provide some value for certain people. Decentralized configuration would allow for communities with given interests to configure and distribute customizations for that audience, in a way that would appeal to that audience. It's not that farfetched of an idea, very realistic both from a tech and adoption POV.
You.com is starting the building blocks of such a thing, but I don't know how far they're going to push the envelope. https://about.you.com/apps/
Can you elaborate?
"Decentralized configuration would allow for communities with given interests to configure and distribute customizations for that audience, in a way that would appeal to that audience."
> This configuration would also need to be sharable, maybe something akin to an App Store, because not all users can be asked to be technical enough to configure everything.
Or, as with any other software, there's this thing called a default, which usually works for the average user.
Having results come up that are also explicitly labelled "You are viewing results through the FOOBAR lens - click here to use another lens".
Our results are already skewed by factors that we don't have much visibility in to - being more explicit/transparent about it, while giving people some ability to influence/change the lens they view results through would be useful.
https://www.quora.com/Is-it-possible-to-beat-Google/answer/M...
A few competitors such as you.com are in the works. I think there’s a lot of potential, but the ranking algorithm is going to need to be decentralized (aka user-configurable) in some way. This configuration would also need to be sharable, maybe something akin to an App Store, because not all users can be asked to be technical enough to configure everything.
There is an enormous amount of wasted value stemming from the disconnect between what Google thinks the user wants to see, and what the user actually wants to see.
If I had to guess why this happened, I’m betting that Google and others had a notion that AI and other advances could eventually approximate a user’s needs to a degree that would keep up with the demand. But the monopoly set in and there was no longer an incentive to innovate that far. I’m sure Google tried, but not to a degree that would have happened if the competition had really stepped it up, or even existed. However, I’m sure by now there’s less optimism that the above effort is even a solvable problem, or one worth solving. One-size-fits-all is extremely suboptimal, but that paradigm is Google at its core. Without a paradigm shift, it’s diminishing returns all the way.
What Google is good at, however, is monetizing what they do have. If you’re trying to challenge them in the monetization game, with the same business model competing for the same customers (advertisers), you most certainly will lose. Seriously, don’t do that. Get to unicorn status first.
Focus on the tech, make sure the business model isn’t competing with the giants, and say no to any buyout offer from Big Tech.