News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by naoqj on Friday March 25, 2022 @05:34AM (#30800118)
It's so easy to destroy a sector when you have nothing to lose.
Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by ckastner on Friday March 25, 2022 @06:25AM (#30800402)
> It's so easy to destroy a sector when you have nothing to lose.

The EU is choosing to favor acting on behalf of their people, rather than some sector. If that sector can't make money in ways that are not immoral with regards to the people, so be it.

For example: Why shouldn't a 30%-fee walled garden be destroyed?

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by postingawayonhn on Friday March 25, 2022 @07:46AM (#30800929)
I don't feel like I need protecting by the EU. Overall I'm very happy with the products produced by the US tech sector.
Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by bobajeff on Friday March 25, 2022 @09:20AM (#30801804)
As someone in the US I wish this sort of thing happened here and sooner. Maybe we wouldn't be stuck with Windows and Office if MS had been forced to interoperate.

Free market isn't really free if you have no competition due to network effects and lock-in.

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by Mindwipe on Friday March 25, 2022 @09:23AM (#30801837)
> I don't feel like I need protecting by the EU. Overall I'm very happy with the products produced by the US tech sector.

I do. Apple repeatedly discriminates against sexual minorities in the App Store, and it's appropriate for a government to step in and stop that.

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by robertlagrant on Friday March 25, 2022 @06:50AM (#30800556)
30% fees are not immoral. You may not like them, but that's very far from the same thing.

A moral question would be "how much should governments control voluntary interactions between customers, platforms and products?" The immoral answer might well be "As much as it will help them gain short-term votes", not the moral one.

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by ckastner on Friday March 25, 2022 @07:33AM (#30800833)
I didn't say 30% fees are immoral, I said 30% fee walled gardens are immoral.

Especially when you make it all but impossible for third parties to operate outside of that walled garden.

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by ericmay on Friday March 25, 2022 @08:11AM (#30801152)
Yea but you except and promote them in other areas of your life. Even countries are walled gardens.

I don’t think third parties really add value either. It’s just going to result in a bunch of spam and scams, with us losing out on privacy features and convenience.

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by TheCoelacanth on Friday March 25, 2022 @01:39PM (#30805070)
Countries are walled gardens. The only thing stopping them from being immoral is democracy and respect for individual rights, neither of which exists in tech giants' walled gardens.
Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by arunkant on Friday March 25, 2022 @09:26AM (#30801865)
Don't use third parties then. Problem solved!!
Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by ericmay on Friday March 25, 2022 @09:38AM (#30802013)
Don't use an iPhone then. Problem solved!!
Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by dane-pgp on Friday March 25, 2022 @09:56AM (#30802223)
It's difficult for an iPhone user to notice that apps they might want aren't available (unless they search the web and find references to an Android-only app that does what they want), but, even more so, it's very expensive for users to buy a new Android phone just to use that one app.

Equally, when someone is considering buying a phone, they are unlikely to compare the lists of apps available for each platform when making their decision, just as car buyers don't look at the levels of tailpipe emissions when comparing possible cars. In such situations we accept that the government can intervene to prevent socially negative outcomes, even if it means increasing the costs (or decreasing the profit margins) for companies.

In any case, the problem isn't just the switching costs for users who discover their platform is limiting their app choices (or increasing their app charges), it's that companies trying to sell apps to users can't choose to simply "Don't use an iPhone", as Apple is preventing commerce between iPhone users and those companies, which is again not socially beneficial.

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by ericmay on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:02AM (#30802271)
Similar logic can be applied when comparing app stores. Users aren't going to compare Company XYZ app store with Apple's app store line-by-line to see how they're missing out on having their data hoovered up for ads or other purposes. App Stores have high switching costs too. Apps won't be available on different stores, that would defeat the entire purpose of having the third-party store for the company wanting to escape Apple's rules.
Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by arunkant on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:43AM (#30802748)
What if, and hear me out, what if there was a technology which allows two or more App stores side-by-side as to minimize the undue burden to switch between them. If only we were so advanced in technology. If only...
Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by ericmay on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:57AM (#30802953)
Why stop at two? Why not five?

- You can download Facebook and WhatsApp from the Meta Store

- You can get Google software from the Google Store, except Gmail and Maps which are available in the Apple App Store too, but YouTube is a Google Store exclusive. Or and Authenticator is only available on the Google App Store with a valid company login. So you'll have to switch accounts depending on if you are logging in as a user for yourself or your company.

- You can get Netflix from the App Store, Google Store, or Facebook store but each requires that you log in to the respective store with an account before logging in to your Netflix account and the pricing is different depending on the cut each of the stores takes. Google is interested in finding what Netflix shows you are watching so they can adjust your YouTube algorithms.

- You can download Twitter from the Apple App Store and Google, but not Facebook.

And you can download the MLB App if you have a Prime subscription because of a new partnership, but only if you have the Amazon Prime App.

Can't wait!

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by itg on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:00AM (#30802251)
Don't operate in the EU then. Problem solved!!
Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by ericmay on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:02AM (#30802276)
If we're going to continue to be pedantic about this, I live in America so I couldn't care less.

-edit-

As a general shareholder I care. But in that area I think Apple will figure out a solution that keeps the status quo. They're #1 for a reason.

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by itg on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:37AM (#30802676)
YOU live in America, Apple operates worldwide. And the USA has plenty of bills in the pipeline targeting the same issues. Apple won't have their cake and eat it too.
Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by ericmay on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:54AM (#30802916)
I think you missed the point, which was I don't care if Apple left the EU market over this, because I live in America where (at least for now) things will be how I prefer them. So saying "good, leave the EU" or similar doesn't really bother me...

You're right that there are other bills in the pipeline. I think the user experience will be worse off because of them and we'll lose lots of ground on privacy and convenience, but it's inevitable because small, vocal minorities usually win even when they make everything worse for everyone else.

It'll be interesting to see the fallout though. It won't take long for others to connect the dots and start filing lawsuits for any store or platform with any sort of standards. Obvious first targets are companies like Sony, Nintendo, and Microsoft for consoles. But other non-obvious targets will start being platforms. Take Chrome - why can I only use (and maybe I can't and I don't know) Google's Chrome Store to install third-party software? Or rather, why can't I install another "App Store" on Chrome and replace Google's? Maybe you can (and I'd argue it has to be identical in terms of convenience and ease of use to qualify) but there will definitely be other, similar targets for lawsuits.

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by arunkant on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:28AM (#30803325)
> I think the user experience will be worse off

Two points

1. User experience is already bed. No access to game streaming services and many valid open source apps not available on iOS

2. User experience is not be the only matrix that matters. What about poor indie developer whose app is banned due to opaque App store rules. What about having control over device you bought with your own money

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by ericmay on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:49AM (#30803588)
Why not just buy a different product with different features then? Mobile phones have a lot of different features. Some have better cameras than others. Some have longer battery life, can fold, or come in different colors. Some have different operating systems. App stores/software isn't any different. The user experience on the Nintendo Switch is terrible. I can't play World of Warcraft of Halo on it at all! And why can't I watch Netflix shows through the Hulu app? Why does Netflix get to buy content and keep it on their Netflix store? At least the Apple App Store is free. I don't have to pay for access to apps.

> What about poor indie developer whose app is banned due to opaque App store rules

They'll just have the opportunity to get banned from more than one store I guess. Then once this indie developer decides its profitable to scam their customers they'll create their own app store and just install their software that way, bypassing any legitimate bans too.

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by arunkant on Friday March 25, 2022 @01:04PM (#30804632)
> They'll just have the opportunity to get banned from more than one store I guess.

1. More app store will compete with each other to provide better app delivery service to developers.

2. Host the app on a website and install it from there. No need for app stores. There I solved it for you

I'm not going to reply to you anymore as your arguments lack depth and seriousness

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by robertlagrant on Friday March 25, 2022 @08:13AM (#30801162)
That seems broadly the same; in fact if anything a 30% fee walled garden is just easier to identify and choose to avoid than one without a walled garden.
Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by yossarian1408 on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:19PM (#30808736)
Anybody is more than welcome to build their own garden, but if you own the garden you also get to decide if it has walls around it or not.
Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by native_samples on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:34AM (#30802647)
EU isn't actually motivated by voting here, because they have power regardless of who votes for them or not. The Parliament "negotiates" with the Commission (executive branch) for this reason - the EU is set up to ensure that decision making is so far removed from voting that it's entirely irrelevant.

The real reason they do this is they perceive it as a free source of income, which they can then use to buy off states to keep them in the EU itself. Note how the rules only apply to really big companies (i.e. US companies), and the fines are really big, and the rules are vague. It'll be a cash cow that avoids upsetting any local interests, the fact they can drape it in pro-consumer clothes is just a bonus from their perspective.

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by naoqj on Friday March 25, 2022 @06:30AM (#30800435)
Because it's their corporation and they can do whatever they want with it, and because it's far from a monopoly since there are alternatives.
Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by madeofpalk on Friday March 25, 2022 @07:43AM (#30800903)
> Because it's their corporation and they can do whatever they want with it

That is not true. there are many things corporations cannot do even if they want to. There's lots of different regulations that impose restrictions and obligations on companies against "what they want".

So now it's just defining where that line is, which is what law-making is.

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by Hamcha on Friday March 25, 2022 @06:54AM (#30800588)
The scope at which those alternatives exist are different than where the monopoly is established. Ie. The App Store has a monopoly on iOS, but iOS does not have a monopoly in the mobile space.

This is like saying a state-mandated ISP/Gas company wouldn't be a monopoly since you can just move to another country.

You might wanna push the argument that nobody is forcing you to use iOS, but I think the problem runs deeper. In many fields and even just everyday life, you are now required to run a modern phone OS (eg. the option for not having the official COVID green pass app here in Italy is to find an authorized place that will print you a green pass on paper, and it's hard to find one, let alone schedule everything and get there without a pre-existing pass) and we're barely lucky that Google is playing by laxer rules than Apple is. If not punishing existing bad actors, these rules are a nice framework to prevent them for taking over in the future.

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by Rayhem on Friday March 25, 2022 @07:39AM (#30800875)
> the option for not having the official COVID green pass app here in Italy is to find an authorized place that will print you a green pass on paper, and it's hard to find one, let alone schedule everything and get there without a pre-existing pass

Apple's pseudomonopoly does not strike me as the root cause issue here, developing processes and using tech to solve a people problem does.

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by Hamcha on Friday March 25, 2022 @08:43AM (#30801446)
When the public administration does things with pen and paper, it's blamed for being ancient and "should get with the times". Now they are getting on with the times, but the times are ones ruled by giant American companies with no regulation.

Also, it's the country's duty to protect citizens from themselves using laws and regulations. For an example of what kind of "far west" digital tech is living right now, I point you back to before TV was regulated as heavily as today, where companies used cartoons to advertise smoking cigarettes to children (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NAExoSozc2c).

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by ckastner on Friday March 25, 2022 @07:39AM (#30800874)
> Because it's their corporation and they can do whatever they want with it

No, they can't do whatever they want with it. Consumer protection laws are an obvious example for how corporate interests can be limited.

> because it's far from a monopoly since there are alternatives.

It's a duopoly. iOS and Android together represent about 98% of mobile devices.

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by giorgioz on Friday March 25, 2022 @05:45AM (#30800189)
Can you clarify in this instance what is

- the sector

- who has nothing to lose

- and what could be lost

I think I understand who/what you imply but I don't want to misunderstand you.

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by naoqj on Friday March 25, 2022 @05:56AM (#30800236)
* Tech sector

* The EU

* Tech sector

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by giorgioz on Friday March 25, 2022 @06:09AM (#30800308)
Thanks for clarifying.

>Included in the rules' scope will be platforms with a market capitalization of €75 billion or turnover in the European Economic Area equal to or above €7.5 billion

So the rules are meant to target only the TOP part of the Tech Sector. Not the Whole Tech Sector. There could be backfires on everyone though.

I do feel though that the Apple/Facebook/Microsoft/Google/Amazon are innovating less and less and are going into cash squeeze mode. There has been a lot of talk on Hacker News on how Google search quality is decreasing.

All the privacy laws containing Facebook push them to bet on something new Meta/Oculus. So I think here the effort is to allow smaller tech to thrive and grow.

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by postingawayonhn on Friday March 25, 2022 @07:48AM (#30800946)
> There has been a lot of talk on Hacker News on how Google search quality is decreasing.

I have a lot more faith in a viable competitor coming out of California than I do in EU regulations improving search results.

Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by giorgioz on Friday March 25, 2022 @02:24PM (#30805508)
Me too...not sure where you are going with this...
Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by psd1 on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:53AM (#30802886)
If poor little Google can't adapt to a changing landscape, it should die. That will not plunge the world into the dark ages.
Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by giorgioz on Friday March 25, 2022 @02:27PM (#30805534)
Yes indeed if Google can't adapt it should die instead of being a monopole and just staying alive by abusing the dominant position. No innovation and abuse of the dominant position will lead to the dark ages, Google dying because not adapting will actually let other smaller companies to thrive and innovate in it's place.
Re:EU negotiators agree new rules to rein in tech giants by amelius on Friday March 25, 2022 @05:21PM (#30807163)
EU has tech (Linux, ASML), they just chose to not screw their real users, a costly but morally better decision.