News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by sofixa on Thursday March 24, 2022 @11:50AM (#30791584)
I wonder what kind of innovations we're missing in the EU with our affordable healthcare.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by jaykk on Thursday March 24, 2022 @12:15PM (#30791933)
the whole title is clickbait. he got insurance.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by sofixa on Thursday March 24, 2022 @12:21PM (#30792032)
> Luckily, Osman's insurance covered most of the bill, but that still left him on the hook for $2,500.

That's still far more than you'd pay for most healthcare related things across the EU.

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by db48x on Thursday March 24, 2022 @02:08PM (#30793458)
True, but it’s also more complex than that. I don’t know the story here, but the $69k bill sounds like he went to a hospital to get treated.

Hospital prices in the US are always lies; his insurance company probably paid around $10k in total and perhaps even less than that. Of course the insurance company doesn’t generally tell their customers exactly how much they actually paid the hospital. He could have gotten a more reasonable bill by asking the hospital for the cash price for everything, writing them a check for that amount, and then getting reimbursed by his insurance company. It might still have been more than his out–of–pocket limit, in which case he still would have paid the $2,500.

But his real mistake was probably going to the hospital in the first place. He probably should have gone to his Primary Care Physician or to an Urgent Care Clinic. Either one of them can admit him to a hospital if it turns out to be necessary, but it probably would not have been. I see in another comment that he needed an X–Ray, a CT scan, and some medication. He could have gotten all of that at an urgent care clinic for $1,000 or so, and slept in his own bed that night.

It pays to shop around, and you can do so _before_ you get hurt.

Finally, don’t forget that in addition to the $2,500 he paid, he also paid his insurance company even in years that he wasn’t injured or ill. Likewise, you pay taxes every year and part of that goes to pay for healthcare, even if you aren’t actually injured or ill.

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by Dylan16807 on Thursday March 24, 2022 @02:36PM (#30793733)
$10k is still a ridiculous amount.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by jhallenworld on Thursday March 24, 2022 @04:15PM (#30794824)
I was just in the ER in SouthWest Florida: $12K for two CT-scans and blood tests over two days, basically to check if I was having appendicitis (I did not- probably infection from prior kidney stone). No overnight stay, but two visits over two days. $12K is the initial bill to my insurance company, so not sure what they will actually receive.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by yazaddaruvala on Thursday March 24, 2022 @05:06PM (#30795342)
I had a similar ER visit for "possible appendicitis". It turned out to be a sprained psoas.

I've since had it again, but was more aware of what to feel for and didn't seek out the ER. Might be worth it to keep in mind if you have something similar again.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psoas_major_muscle

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by db48x on Thursday March 24, 2022 @03:39PM (#30794428)
I agree. That’s why most of the time you shouldn’t visit a hospital; you can get the same work done elsewhere for much less money.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by its_ethan on Thursday March 24, 2022 @03:18PM (#30794213)
So how much should it cost? And how do you arrive at that number?
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by fesoliveira on Thursday March 24, 2022 @04:59PM (#30795267)
In Brazil an x-ray exam will cost you no more than 90 BRL, or less than 20 USD in todays rate. And this is out of the pocket, without insurance. If a 3rd world country can have affordable healthcare, why should having minor health complications be synonym to bankruptcy in the richest country in the world?
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by db48x on Thursday March 24, 2022 @05:25PM (#30795523)
I live in one of the highest–priced areas of the US, and a simple x–ray exam costs about $200 whether you have insurance or not. The difference in price is primarily due to the higher cost of living here than in Brazil; the tech who takes the x–ray and the doctor who looks at it to diagnose the problem get paid more here than there. I should know; I got hit by a car last year and sprained my thumb when I hit the ground. The x–ray was to check that the thumb was only sprained, and not broken.

But if you go to a hospital to get the same thing you will pay 10× as much or more. You’ll also have to wait a lot longer, as anyone with a more serious complaint will get prioritized ahead of you. Both of these are reasons why people should not generally visit the hospital, unless they have a problem which is immediately life–threatening, or they are admitted to the hospital by their primary–care physician.

> why should having minor health complications be synonym to bankruptcy in the richest country in the world?

It’s not. For all of the problems that our health–care system may or may not have, people don’t go bankrupt because they needed an x–ray.

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by yesenadam on Thursday March 24, 2022 @08:31PM (#30797395)
> I live in one of the highest–priced areas of the US, and a simple x–ray exam costs about $200 whether you have insurance or not. The difference in price is primarily due to the higher cost of living here than in Brazil

Well, most x-rays are free here in Australia I believe, thanks to Medicare, so that "higher cost of living" explanation seems not to be right.

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by db48x on Thursday March 24, 2022 @08:43PM (#30797478)
There’s no such thing as a free lunch. You pay taxes, and some of the taxes go towards health care.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by kube-system on Thursday March 24, 2022 @05:27PM (#30795544)
There is no good reason the US can't bring down healthcare costs, but there are also some not so good reasons that some countries have very cheap healthcare.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by its_ethan on Thursday March 24, 2022 @05:48PM (#30795736)
Genuine question, how are you so confident that reducing prices from current levels wouldn't cause unintended consequences like causing innovation to stifle, hiring to become more difficult, or health infrastructure to degrade? You can point to other countries having lower prices, sure, but just like you said - there are plenty of reasons why other countries can be cheaper than in the US.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by kube-system on Thursday March 24, 2022 @06:18PM (#30796081)
Because we have inefficiencies that are baked into the status quo. Insurers, for example, provide little value to health outcomes. Their purpose is purely financial, and there are much more simple ways to shift that money around that requires less administrative overhead, and allows prices to be set by better methods than threats by insurers, which is basically how they're set now.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by its_ethan on Thursday March 24, 2022 @09:17PM (#30797670)
That's a very fair point. I think transparency in pricing for medical services would help out a lot with cleaning up the insurance mess. Not that either of us have the answer, have you put in any thoughts on how to eliminate those inefficiencies?
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by phkahler on Thursday March 24, 2022 @03:49PM (#30794551)
It should not cost more than a pair of shoes. They used to use x-rays to check fit at the shoe stores - for free.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by its_ethan on Thursday March 24, 2022 @04:08PM (#30794744)
You mean back in the 1930s when you stuck your foot in a wooden box with an open X-ray tube and got yourself and nearby customers exposed to radiation at a significantly higher dose than even a full torso x-ray in modern times? Okay, my guy...
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by db48x on Saturday March 26, 2022 @02:08AM (#30809652)
You’re right about that, but cost is a funny thing. The x–ray photograph itself costs mere pennies, especially with a modern digital imaging system. Even x–ray film is just an incidental cost.

However, when you are getting an x–ray to diagnose a medical problem, you do want more than just the image itself. You want the person who takes the x–ray image to be practiced and able to reliably take the correct image with the correct camera settings and so on. But most importantly, you want the diagnosis to come from a highly educated doctor who knows what your insides are actually supposed to look like. Whether these two roles are handled by one person or multiple, you are monopolizing someone’s time. You can’t really expect them to take x–rays of multiple patients at the same time, or to look at two x–rays and diagnose them both simultaneously.

If it takes the imaging tech 10 minutes to set up the x–ray machine for you and make the images the doctor asked for, then you have to pay 10 minutes of that tech’s salary. If the doctor spends 20 minutes asking you questions about your injury and then 10 more minutes looking at the images and telling you that you will live, then you’re going to have to pay for half an hour of their salary. The staff at the front desk who hand out forms and answer phones get a slice. The nurses who do most of the grunt work get a cut too.

The shoe salesmen didn’t directly charge for use of the x–ray fitting machines, but they did recoup their costs out of the shoe sales. Either by increasing the price of every pair of shoes by a small amount, or just by selling additional shoes (due to the novelty factor, or because it genuinely saved time allowing them to sell more shoes in a day).

The bulk of the price of any good or service comes from paying the people.

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by Dylan16807 on Sunday March 27, 2022 @02:18AM (#30818157)
> The shoe salesmen didn’t directly charge for use of the x–ray fitting machines, but they did recoup their costs out of the shoe sales. Either by increasing the price of every pair of shoes by a small amount, or just by selling additional shoes (due to the novelty factor, or because it genuinely saved time allowing them to sell more shoes in a day).

Well sure, that's why they were saying the price should be capped at a pair of shoes, not literally free.

And while a few minutes of a doctor's time costs more than a salesman, the entire materials costs of the shoes goes away. It seems like a reasonable benchmark.

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by lbriner on Thursday March 24, 2022 @03:58PM (#30794643)
The problem is that the cost for healthcare is hidden. In the UK, we have "National Insurance" but it doesn't work like normal insurance. It goes into the same big pot as everything else and gets spent on whatever.

It is a hard balance but sometimes when I see people doing stupid things that land them in the ER, I kind of wish that their premium would increase as a result. That said, I think the largest cost in healthcare is the care of the elderly: We somehow keep people breathing for much longer than 50 years ago but it doesn't stop their bodies needing some big maintenance or long-term residential care.

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by kube-system on Thursday March 24, 2022 @05:39PM (#30795640)
Health insurance premiums in the US don't raise people rates if they do stupid stuff, with the single exception of smoking. Rates are basically set based on three factors: age, location, and smoking status. You do share costs if there's an accident, but daredevils and school teachers get the same rate at the same age in the same city.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by floor2 on Thursday March 24, 2022 @12:46PM (#30792363)
So about 3-4 days of work as an entry-level Facebook developer, or 3-3.5 weeks of work at a McDonalds (based on every fast-food place around me having billboards up offering starting wages of $18-20/hr).

Getting access to emergency life-saving treatment, which leverages billions of dollars in research & development and hours of work from a team of doctors, radiologists, nurses, pharmacists, support staff, etc in exchange for being asked to contribute back to society by cooking burgers for a month feels like a pretty amazing offer compared to how almost all humans have existed in history and most still do around the world today.

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by ljp_206 on Thursday March 24, 2022 @01:11PM (#30792687)
The fact that we have better health infrastructure in most places worldwide than ever before in human history is true. But saying a surprise, out-of-the-blue 2.5k medical bill can be taken care of by working nearly a month at McDonalds without factoring the high cut of that wage that goes to living is facile at best and cruel at worst.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by mustacheemperor on Thursday March 24, 2022 @01:33PM (#30792978)
Since the typical fast food service worker see almost their entire paycheck go to living expenses before any opportunity for luxuries or savings, that does indeed sound like a crippling if not insurmountable financial burden for someone who incurs an x-ray expense like this unexpectedly. Especially since whatever reason they have for needing an x-ray could affect their ability to earn income from McDonalds. I don't think hourly wage work offers the same perks as entry-level development roles at facebook with regards to paid sick leave.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by buescher on Thursday March 24, 2022 @01:46PM (#30793158)
This example is totally unrealistic. In the USA someone supporting themselves working at McDonalds would qualify for Medicaid and have essentially no out-of-pocket medical expenses.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by matthewmacleod on Thursday March 24, 2022 @01:45PM (#30793152)
Alas, still no cure for Stockholm Syndrome.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by cjrp on Thursday March 24, 2022 @01:30PM (#30792935)
> 3-3.5 weeks of work at a McDonalds

With a broken limb (which is presumably why you required the X-ray in the first place)?

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by roywiggins on Thursday March 24, 2022 @01:59PM (#30793347)
> 3-3.5 weeks of work at a McDonalds

Sure, if you don't pay for rent, food, or transportation to work.

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by squarefoot on Thursday March 24, 2022 @01:34PM (#30793001)
> the whole title is clickbait. he got insurance.

Those fees are crazy nonetheless.

I don't have any insurance and during the last 1.5 years I suffered symptomatic Covid (medicines and vaccines free), then a road accident with multiple fractures: left arm, right shoulder, both wrists and L4, (nearly 2 months hospitalized plus long rehab to learn to walk again: all free excluding the fees for printing the medical data, which were over 400 pages, and MRI/RX/CT images DVDs: around 20 Euros all included), then last January I got a heart attack and was hospitalized in a coronary care unit for 4 days plus 1 day at the ward where I was planted two stents: again all free including the 1st bag of medicines.

20 years ago I worked in the IT, pays were very good and therefore taxes were high, but all considered, in the end I got a lot more than I paid for. I could think of a thousand things I don't like at all about my country, but healthcare is definitely not one of them.

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by Teknoman117 on Thursday March 24, 2022 @02:16PM (#30793510)
I think my post major car accident care (x-rays, ct, ambulance ride - had concussion) 10 years ago cost me $100 all said and done on my parents' kaiser plan in California.

When I walked into a kaiser urgent care last year for serious back pain I had chest X-rays and a CT and I paid $20.

The major issue is that you only get that kind of healthcare working for a decent company (and using an HMO plan). Not everyone has the access and that's the issue.

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by dekhn on Thursday March 24, 2022 @04:35PM (#30795032)
IMHO kaiser is amazing. they have a different incentive from typical for-profit medical companies.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by Teknoman117 on Friday March 25, 2022 @12:32AM (#30798675)
The even better thing now is that with the "No Surprises Act" taking effect, I could presumably walk into any hospital in the US and never get billed more than I'd have to pay with Kaiser.

If you're in an area where Kaiser's hospitals are, non-Kaiser hospitals will generally work with Kaiser. It's not like you get to choose which one you go to in an emergency. Outside of the states that Kaiser is in, you're usually fine but there are many horror stories about hospitals asking for fees beyond what Kaiser will cover under their global ER coverage.

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by azinman2 on Thursday March 24, 2022 @02:03PM (#30793390)
Your healthcare cost a lot more than the 20 euros or “free” that you said. In the US it’s a bit more transparent since you’re receiving the bill. In a shared public healthcare system everyone foots the bill via their taxes. I’m sure hospitals make out more in the US — the entire system is designed to create profit at every stage - but saying things are “free” elsewhere is disingenuous.

He also built an x-ray machine, but his charges per the article were for a CT scan and staying at the hospital. A CT scan is a totally different beast than an x-ray machine, and staying at the hospital means you’re actively under medical care the entire time. It’s all very clickbaity.

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by jackson1442 on Thursday March 24, 2022 @02:05PM (#30793417)
The US spends the most per-capita on healthcare in the world.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by Teknoman117 on Thursday March 24, 2022 @02:08PM (#30793460)
Some days I wonder if we're subsidizing Europe's healthcare in a way.

European counties impose stringent controls on how much money their public health system will pay for something and in response, since said company still wants that money, it ends up jacking up rates in the US.

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by jackson1442 on Thursday March 24, 2022 @03:47PM (#30794518)
We certainly are. But I think global healthcare spend would still decrease if the US were to adopt strict price controls a la Europe. Of course, Europe will need to pay a bit more towards healthcare but the burden on the states would be much decreased.

I don't imagine it would come anywhere close to the cost we currently pay for services here though.

It's the same as university here in the states. If colleges know that students are walking in with a minimum of $45k, guaranteed from the federal government, why wouldn't a university charge anything less than that for a degree?

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by missedthecue on Friday March 25, 2022 @02:35AM (#30799258)
I don't think it's actually possible to get $45k in federal loans. The max is about an order of magnitude less than that, depending a little on personal circumstances.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by jackson1442 on Friday March 25, 2022 @12:27PM (#30804114)
The hard cap for federal subsidized and unsubsidized student loans is $57,500 for undergrad students.

https://studentaid.gov/understand-aid/types/loans/subsidized...

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by Teknoman117 on Friday March 25, 2022 @07:33PM (#30807971)
So I guess there are two classes of student loans then (regarding interest)? When I went to school there were "Parent Plus" loans (the part in my parents' name) and I don't remember what they called the ones in my name. Both were unsubsidized - i.e. interest accumulation starts on day 1, although accumulated interest is not added to the principal until repayment starts following leaving school (graduation, a break, quit, etc.) for >6 months.

I really don't recall how much I borrowed versus the interest accumulation, but when I refinanced it a year after graduation I borrowed nearly $120k to do it. The early loans (from 2011) were 8% and I think the interest dropped to ~5% for the ones my senior year. I didn't have the money to pay for it directly and neither did my parents considering they had to put 3 kids through school and we lived near the bay area in CA.

Admittedly, I'm a bad example for loan burden because I went into tech and was able to pay them off in 5 years while living comfortably, but the take away is that unless you go into one of the wealthiest professions in the US, the cost is ridiculously high. Sadly, there are plenty of professions important to society which require a ton of education but just aren't that lucrative financially. We're putting pressure on people not to enter those fields.

The other thing that doesn't make sense to me is that after high school you are legally considered an adult. Why should your parents' financial situation have any effect on was kind (if any) aid you get? Say you have a bad relationship with your family, what then?

Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by TomK32 on Thursday March 24, 2022 @04:12PM (#30794784)
You mean because a large chunk for R&D in medicine is done in the USA? Maybe that is because in the USA pharma companies can go mental about pricing their products, who wouldn't want such a lucrative market that's easy to exploit thanks to a well-oiled lobby machinery? I highly doubt that pharma companies would stop their R&D if the USA was to introduce universal healthcare for everyone of its citizens.
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by TomK32 on Thursday March 24, 2022 @04:04PM (#30794707)
Re:YouTuber builds his own x-ray machine after $69k hospital... by jotm on Thursday March 24, 2022 @08:08PM (#30797206)
Every single time American healthcare comes up, some European chimes in with this stupid comment.

First of all, yeah, the US system is pretty atrocious.

But healthcare in the EU means months of waiting in line or outright told to look somewhere else as they're full, cheapest procedures with no alternative, having to quite literally beg for prescription medicine that worked for you before but the new doctor doesn't want to give you, tons of preferential treatment and discrimination.

Let's be real here, the only good thing in the EU is emergency care, when you break your arm or something. Good luck with any non-life threatening problems and mental healthcare.

I mean, sure, many people have it easy, living in the good part of a country. But I'm not the only one who has experienced what can only be called absolute horseshit. Reddit is full of such threads.

But "muh affordable healthcare".