News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by Larrikin on Thursday March 24, 2022 @10:07AM (#30789946)
Probably hoped the effects would negatively effect people there so they could put pressure to stop the murder of other innocent civilians.

Arguments like this are similar to the BLM protest that try to equate property with human lives.

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by gruez on Thursday March 24, 2022 @10:16AM (#30790082)
>Arguments like this are similar to the BLM protest that try to equate property with human lives.

Yeah, but the problem with this is that, taken to its logical conclusion, you end up with a nihilistic view that's basically "do you support The Cause? if yes then any protest action is acceptable, if no then any minor transgression should be cracked down by law enforcement". This works especially well when The Cause is something that could plausibly affect tens of millions of people, so you can excuse quite a lot of damage.

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by HideousKojima on Thursday March 24, 2022 @11:23AM (#30791187)
I have a legal (and moral) right to defend my property, often with deadly force. My property came into my possession by my own labors and time, i.e. by sacrificing part of my life to obtain it. Even if the property was gifted to me, that means that someone else sacrificed part of their life to give it to me. When someone violates my rights in the process of "protesting" something, I am legally and morally justified in using force to protect my rights. This includes the right to the property that I own.
Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by Larrikin on Thursday March 24, 2022 @11:32AM (#30791293)
Where is this true? In the US you have the right to murder if the person is in your home and in some states you have the right to murder if you feel your life is being threatened, in this case because you're being robbed.

If you left your car running while you ran into the store you don't have the right to shoot the guy in the back as he drives off. You file a police report and potentially sue for damages.

You definitely don't have the right to shoot someone for burning down your local Target.

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by HideousKojima on Thursday March 24, 2022 @11:34AM (#30791325)
If someone is trying to burn down my house with me in it, I have a right to shoot them in pretty much every jurisdiction in the US. If someone is burning down my store with me in it, I also have the right to use deadly force to defend it.
Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by SamoyedFurFluff on Thursday March 24, 2022 @12:39PM (#30792273)
Let’s step back a little, please. This original context was about some BLM protests doing property damage, which included smashing storefronts and trash fires on the street.
Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by HideousKojima on Thursday March 24, 2022 @02:55PM (#30793959)
They also included burning down buildings, not just trash in the street.
Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by potta_coffee on Thursday March 24, 2022 @10:23AM (#30790183)
Arguments like this are superficial and justify bad behavior. Destruction of property isn't murder, but it's still not ok and it still causes harm to living people who have no influence over the issue.
Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by shadowgovt on Thursday March 24, 2022 @10:55AM (#30790758)
> who have no influence

I believe the crux of the political theory is that in a representative democracy, nobody has no influence over the issue.

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by Miraste on Thursday March 24, 2022 @11:07AM (#30790940)
That is obviously not true, and even if it were, the country in question is Russia, an autocracy. What is our poor hypothetical node developer expected to do, march down to the Kremlin and beat Putin with his MacBook?
Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by mrguyorama on Thursday March 24, 2022 @01:24PM (#30792856)
This is Russia we are talking about right? A country that has had countless uprisings of literal serfs with farming implements replacing their government.
Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by shadowgovt on Thursday March 24, 2022 @11:38AM (#30791394)
Parent comment originally referred to Black Lives Matter; I had been responding to that part of the comment (and its relation to US politics).
Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by vorpalhex on Thursday March 24, 2022 @10:54AM (#30790735)
It's not acceptable to burn down someone's house because you disagree with them. Even if you disagree with them a lot. Please don't burn people's houses down.

If you burn down people's houses, you will be arrested and go to jail.

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by bnt on Thursday March 24, 2022 @10:11AM (#30790015)
Or, you know, I’ll never touch Vue.js again?
Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by JumpCrisscross on Thursday March 24, 2022 @10:16AM (#30790089)
Charitably, it creates a new friction for Russian business in deploying open-source software. That drag further diminishes Russia’s economy, and thus, its warmaking ability.
Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by rrsmtz on Thursday March 24, 2022 @12:15PM (#30791940)
This is the line that every extremist group uses to justify their horrible acts.

Weaponizing open source is such an awful precedent. There are extremist groups of every shade who harbor ill intent towards some other group or institution. For a rather mundane example: "My malicious npm module detects you are running the Brave browser? The evil Brendan Eich runs that, say goodbye to your filesystem!" Never mind if you are part of a group that is mired in controversy, chief among them at this time being Russian.

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by vkou on Thursday March 24, 2022 @12:54PM (#30792462)
> This is the line that every extremist group uses to justify their horrible acts.

And in this case the 'horrible act' is not wanting your free labour to be used in another country.

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by FerociousTimes on Thursday March 24, 2022 @11:00AM (#30790835)
At best, this operation could be construed as an act of vandalism or at worst an act of CYBER terrorism. This indiscriminate and malicious act of hostility was carried by what amounted to be a cyber weapon (think IED) housed in a very ordinary and non-suspicious package to cause the greatest damage to the users' data.
Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by JumpCrisscross on Thursday March 24, 2022 @11:14AM (#30791041)
> this operation could be construed as an act of vandalism or at worst an act of CYBER terrorism

Could be. But by whom? To what effect?

One of the downsides of losing credibility as a nation state is the concepts of deference, retaliation and proportionality lose weight. There is no indication that the facts on the ground would affect whether Putin deems something a cyber attack. Worse, one's own policing actions are likely to cause more damage as propaganda pieces than ignoring the issue.

Yes, in an international law framework this would be prosecuted in the U.S. But in that framework Russia wouldn't be in Ukraine. Add to that it's tacit approval of its own hackers, and it's difficult--in a realpolitik frame--to find support for doing anything about this other than minor finger wagging.

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by FerociousTimes on Thursday March 24, 2022 @11:42AM (#30791463)
> Could be. But by whom? To what effect?

The general public. I speculate that publicity was one of the main objectives behind this operation to draw attention to his political grievances and maybe demands.

Perhaps we should focus more on the issue of bragging rights. The perpetrator probably thinks he's some kind of a hero having conducted this operation and it was some kind of a heroic feat sticking up to Putin when he in fact is more of a lousy vandal destroying some poor guy's store window than an epic warrior conquering foreign lands and subduing evil emperors.

The more people realize this and esp. people who are prone to commit these acts, the more innocent people would be spared the damage incurred by those reckless attacks.

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by maccolgan on Friday March 25, 2022 @04:31AM (#30799768)
This isn't a charitable take, you have reinvented total war from the first principles. If all of the currently in war countries start engaging in total war, the world wouldn't be worth living in.
Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by yyyk on Thursday March 24, 2022 @12:03PM (#30791754)
I can't agree with these arguments.

A) IP geolocation is far from perfect, quite a few completely unrelated people could have been affected.

B) There was a chance of massive collateral damage to stuff like hospitals, water company, etc. and therefore affecting civilians, including children. If you think Putin wouldn't use that to rally Russia and launch a massive war, you haven't observed Putin for long.

We got very lucky this software equivalent of a warcrime was stopped early. Yet the punishment was absurdly light. I will staying away from NPM after that.

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by FDSGSG on Thursday March 24, 2022 @12:41PM (#30792290)
> If you think Putin wouldn't use that to rally Russia and launch a massive war, you haven't observed Putin for long.

Do you believe that node-ipc would do this but the current vastly more impactful sanctions regime wont?

Also, everybody capable of thinking understands that Russia isn't capable of launching another "massive war" when it already has almost all of its conventional combat power committed to Ukraine.

If you think Putin would launch a nuclear war over wiper malware, you're an idiot. There's no other kind of "massive war" he could launch at this point.

> this software equivalent of a warcrime

Why not call it software holocaust if we're gonna go there? What's wrong with you?

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by yyyk on Thursday March 24, 2022 @01:52PM (#30793250)
>Do you believe that node-ipc would do this but the current vastly more impactful sanctions regime wont?

>There's no other kind of "massive war" he could launch at this point.

Russian society isn't anywhere near enthusiastic. That's why Putin has been searching for ever dumber excuses. Give him an actual indefensible incident to rally society around, and he'll get a lot more manpower. That could expand the war to Odessa and Moldova, and also 'retaliatory' cyberwar in the West.

Now, there's a level of escalation I'm fine with risking - say, over stationing peacekeepers in parts of Ukraine. Stuff that actually helps Ukrainians. But over an self-appointed idiot's personal action which doesn't help anyone and nobody asked for? $#@! no.

>Why not call it software holocaust if we're gonna go there? What's wrong with you?

It's attacking civilians as to influence their government (except Russia is a dictatorship and the government doesn't even care). I have more pointed comparisons in mind, but I'll spare the thread.

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by def_true_false on Thursday March 24, 2022 @03:18PM (#30794211)
What next? Is refusing doing business with Russia a war crime, too? After all, some civilians might lose their livelihoods and starve to death, right?
Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by yyyk on Thursday March 24, 2022 @03:32PM (#30794358)
There's an obvious difference between trying to hurt people and not trading with them yourself. If the distinction is difficult, there are laws to define this 'war crime' thing, you may wish to consult them.

Also, Russia is relatively self-sufficient foodwise. There'll be shortages but no starvation. I'm sure though that if starvation was serious possiblity the West would exclude food imports.

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by FDSGSG on Thursday March 24, 2022 @08:18PM (#30797285)
> There's an obvious difference between trying to hurt people and not trading with them yourself

Ah yes, because seizing Russian assets overseas is the same as "not trading with them".

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by yyyk on Friday March 25, 2022 @01:27AM (#30798914)
>Ah yes, because seizing Russian assets overseas is the same as "not trading with them".

Your bank account is held under terms. There are cases where freezing withdrawals is allowed.

If you wish to avoid that, you are entitled to store your money under your mattress (or use the latest crypto fad and be subject to absurd exchange rate variations).

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by vkou on Friday March 25, 2022 @01:54PM (#30805234)
Using another country's financial systems exposes you to significantly more counterparty risk, than using your own's.

Nobody was forcing Russia's ruling class to have all their money in overseas bank accounts.

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by FDSGSG on Sunday March 27, 2022 @04:54AM (#30818785)
Same goes for using software from other countries, no?
Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by def_true_false on Friday March 25, 2022 @02:10PM (#30805391)
You might wish to consult those laws yourself before you call random shit a war crime...
Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by vkou on Thursday March 24, 2022 @05:11PM (#30795380)
I thought that food imports were already excluded from sanctions for this exact reason.
Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by FDSGSG on Thursday March 24, 2022 @08:21PM (#30797315)
>Russian society isn't anywhere near enthusiastic. That's why Putin has been searching for ever dumber excuses. Give him an actual indefensible incident to rally society around, and he'll get a lot more manpower. That could expand the war to Odessa and Moldova, and also 'retaliatory' cyberwar in the West.

That's just absurd fanfic. Sending in untrained "manpower" with no equipment would not help advance Russian goals.

"Cyberwar"? Russia has never before needed any excuses to unleash wiper worms like NotPetya onto the whole world.

>It's attacking civilians as to influence their government

Exactly like sanctions. Are you against sanctions too? If not, how do you explain that inconsistency?

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by yyyk on Friday March 25, 2022 @01:22AM (#30798898)
>That's just absurd fanfic. Sending in untrained "manpower" with no equipment would not help advance Russian goals.

Some of them probably have military training, and quantity has a quality of its own. Regardless, Russia will not be able to subdue Ukraine, but there's nothing good coming from a more enthusiastic Russian society.

>"Cyberwar"? Russia has never before needed any excuses to unleash wiper worms like NotPetya onto the whole world.

Our tolerance for that was absurd. As is our tolerance for this action.

>Exactly like sanctions. Are you against sanctions too? If not, how do you explain that inconsistency?

I'm for sanctions. It's not inconsistent. There's a law for these things. That law allows sanctions but not attacking random civilians. It also prefers actions by legitimate authorities and not random vigilants. It also states that any possible harm to civilians must be incidental to the method, and that any harm be proportional to the possibility of achieving a legitimate goal (kicking Russia out).

This action was by a random person (not even an Ukrainian), unauthorized by anyone (definitely not any Ukrainian authority), and was at best counterproductive (nobody has given me any way where this advances kicking Russia out), so any possibility of civilian harm is criminal.

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by FDSGSG on Friday March 25, 2022 @12:44PM (#30804363)
> Regardless, Russia will not be able to subdue Ukraine, but there's nothing good coming from a more enthusiastic Russian society.

You are mistaken if you believe that Russian society isn't already enthusiastic. But this isn't a country with the warrior culture US has, dying for your country isn't cool in Russia, it just means that you were too poor and/or stupid to dodge the draft.

> There's a law for these things. That law allows sanctions but not attacking random civilians.

Which law is that?

> It also states that any possible harm to civilians must be incidental to the method

Many of the sanctions are specifically targeting civilians, civilian businesses.

> and that any harm be proportional to the possibility of achieving a legitimate goal (kicking Russia out).

Oh no, you're deeply mistaken. The sanctions will not go away even if Russia gets kicked out of Ukraine, they're very much intended to be punitive.

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by yyyk on Friday March 25, 2022 @07:39PM (#30808009)
>You are mistaken if you believe that Russian society isn't already enthusiastic.

It's a society where showing up for what the authorities do is common.

>Which law is that?

A long codicil of war conventions (Geneva, Hague) and anti-terrorism conventions. What I wrote is a common exegesis.

>Many of the sanctions... The sanctions will not go away.

As I wrote, there's a difference between 'we won't trade with you' and actively harming someone. Also, if Russia withdraws completely and lets Ukraine join NATO, I'm pretty sure the West will drop sanctions. There'll be no point in maintaining them - if you want to change Russia, you'll need a finer instrument.

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by FDSGSG on Monday March 28, 2022 @07:51AM (#30829490)
>It's a society where showing up for what the authorities do is common.

For a variety of reasons much of my circle of friend consists of Russians living abroad, you're mistaken if you believe that they support Russian leadership out of fear of what might happen if they didn't.

>A long codicil of war conventions (Geneva, Hague) and anti-terrorism conventions. What I wrote is a common exegesis.

But sanctions do exactly that. Attack random civilians.

> As I wrote, there's a difference between 'we won't trade with you' and actively harming someone.

It's not "we won't trade with you", that's a dishonest way of putting it. It's "we won't allow others to trade with you", which is very much actively harming someone.

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by baud147258 on Thursday March 24, 2022 @11:07AM (#30790939)
> they could put pressure to stop

In case you haven't checked, both targeted countries are authoritarian regimes where any kind of civil protest is ignored at best or actively suppressed at worst. And violent regime changes (aka revolutions) coming from the people don't work, at least not without the support of part of the governing elites (which aren't impacted by that kind of actions)

Re:Open source ‘protestware’ harms Open Source by wrycoder on Thursday March 24, 2022 @11:19AM (#30791112)
Revolutions have succeeded time and again. The problem is that in most cases, the kind of people who lead successful revolutions are not the kind who can form a non-autocratic government. It can take generations to correct the resulting chaos and totalitarian excesses.