News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by worik on Monday March 21, 2022 @02:39PM (#30757996)
> $52 for the notice, $52 to remove the limiter

The very rich come up with novel and creative ways to take money off the very poor.

Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by BaseballPhysics on Monday March 21, 2022 @04:28PM (#30759286)
Just another way that it's incredibly expensive to be poor. Can't get cheap credit to pay for your leaking roof? That's fine, here's a usurious loan. Can't afford a new car? Okay, buy a cheap (well, not anymore...) used one that'll constantly break down and require repairs or replacement. Forget a bill was coming out and accidentally use your overdraft? That's fine, we'll just charge you a hefty fee for that. The list goes on and on...
Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by oh_sigh on Monday March 21, 2022 @02:58PM (#30758229)
The alternative is for the company to eat the cost of payment enforcement, and raise the price of everyone's service a little bit. Which doesn't seem exactly fair, since many of the service users may be in similar financial circumstances as the lady in the article, but just make better decisions regarding their money.
Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by tomrod on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:34PM (#30758669)
> The alternative is for the company to eat the cost of payment enforcement, and raise the price of everyone's service a little bit

Seems moral to me. As a community member, I'm happy to play a bit to ensure those unable to pay don't freeze in the winter

Signed,

-Texan who was without power during a major cold snap and wonders why the "independent" electric grid isn't an active priority

Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by slibhb on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:44PM (#30758790)
No one's stopping you from emptying your savings account and giving all your money to people who would derive orders of magnitude more utility from it than you.
Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by giraffe_lady on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:59PM (#30758969)
"We have a necessary resource in sufficient quantity to allocate it to everyone who needs it, how can we do that with the current allocate-to-almost-everyone system that already exists?"

"HA TRICK QUESTION! that's unnecessary because individuals can simply choose to partially and temporarily alleviate this issue in a very limited way!"

??? This is how you think?

Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by mikestew on Monday March 21, 2022 @04:11PM (#30759099)
A lot of people think that way. Try a conversation about taxes, specifically what one might consider a "fair share". Inevitably some jackass waltzes in with "well, nothing is stopping you from paying extra", and sometimes even handily posts a link to the IRS site, as if that's a clever argument.

"Nothing stopping you..." is all-too-often another way of saying, "I will make no attempt at making a good-faith argument".

Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by tomrod on Monday March 21, 2022 @08:13PM (#30761402)
Aye. Its this type of folks that also suggest leaving a community when they hear another's complaints.

In short, trolls.

Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by worik on Monday March 21, 2022 @07:36PM (#30761132)
> No one's stopping you from emptying your savings account and giving all your money to people who would derive orders of magnitude more utility from it than you.

That is an unhelpful comment and an antisocial position. (And as another commentator put it "a tax on empathy")

Humans are social creatures, we cannot survive on our own.

We are also monkeys with enormous brains, we can do better

Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by tomrod on Monday March 21, 2022 @04:39PM (#30759406)
Right, and my point was that the system should charge you and I, as consumers, to also cover the safety net need for utilities.

I'd be happy to reiterate my point if it was unclear and you thought I was suggesting we run a voluntary social safety net.

Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by googlryas on Monday March 21, 2022 @04:00PM (#30758981)
That's nice of you. Presumably you aren't living hand to mouth.

How much extra per billing cycle should someone in exactly the same financial situation as the lady in the article pay?

Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by tomrod on Monday March 21, 2022 @04:44PM (#30759465)
> That's nice of you

Nah, that's being a human. We put clawbacks and riders in utility rates all the time, even breaks to operating companies. This isn't out-there policy and charitable help programs for utilities are common. Were I still living hand to mouth I'd continue supporting social safety net policies.

Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by googlryas on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:09PM (#30759748)
No, that's not being human, unless your argument is that poor people who can't afford to pay into social safety nets are not human.

> This isn't out-there policy and charitable help programs for utilities are common.

Yes, in fact, that is what the first lady in the article utilized - an assistance program provided by the utility itself where they zeroed out her outstanding balance.

Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by worik on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:13PM (#30758423)
> Which doesn't seem exactly fair

There is so much injustice perpetrated in the name of fairness

Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by oh_sigh on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:15PM (#30758455)
I guess it is a difference of opinion about injustice.

I see it as an injustice to take money out of a poor person's pocket now to pay for the failures of a different, unrelated poor person.

Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by abdullahkhalids on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:12PM (#30759766)
In my country electricity rates increase in slabs as you consume more. The highest consumption users (usually the rich and fortunate) subsidize all low consumption users. So poor people are not affected by the choices of their own class. But we as a society show benevolence to the poor and the unfortunate in this way
Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by pythonaut_16 on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:23PM (#30758544)
In many situations unfairness is a form of injustice.
Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by __del__ on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:21PM (#30758527)
i don't think raising rates for other customers is what "eating the cost" means. it's also possible to profit less.
Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by oh_sigh on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:34PM (#30758678)
Enmax doesn't make a profit, because it is wholly owned by the City of Calgary and returns all remaining funds as a dividend to the city. Which amounts to about $50M/year, or about $40 per citizen.
Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by __del__ on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:43PM (#30758788)
i'll correct myself: maintaining the $40/citizen city funding by raising costs for other customers is not what "eating the cost" means
Re:Calgarians detail life with an electricity load limiter by googlryas on Monday March 21, 2022 @04:06PM (#30759051)
The payments to the city are variable. There is no fixed "$40/citizen" payment being made. The utility company not charging individuals responsible for increased costs those increased costs leads to the utility returning less money to the city, which would ultimately lead to cost increases if the excess funds went negative.

I find it interesting that you're latching onto the "eat the cost" phrase(which may have been incorrectly used) but you aren't too interested in rectifying your gross ignorance of the actual details of the system you're making claims about.