Of course, you can always take off the training wheels and shoot raw.
Apple even worked with Adobe to create ProRaw, which allows you to selectively turn on or off various parts of their image processing pipeline after you shoot the image.
The big picture is that cameras profoundly influence how we see and share ourselves, others, and the world. Fairly recently, cameras (and their developers) started making opinionated decisions for us about things like the color of sky, the texture of skin, and much more. Sure, any one of us can opt out and do things RAW, but the rest of the world will go on taking pictures with these decisions baked in. I don't think the answer is RAW, because the problem is not pixel data -- it is who controls image making in the first place.
That's called "auto white balance" and we've been stuck with it since the advent of digital cameras. Phones don't do much more than that; if they detect the sky it's to adjust denoising to not cause banding artifacts etc.
Is there any company out there doing just HDR, and not making color choices? Or is it baked in at the SOC level now?
I think that's the definition of a "smart" appliance, and you just described what my problem with "smart" appliances is: they are too smart by a half, and end up making bad choices when pushed a little.
That's seems like the opposite of smart—instead, it's dumb yet intrusive. Or as Kurt Vonnegut said: "Beware of the man who works hard to learn something, learns it, and finds himself no wiser than before." These devices do a lot of thinking, but have no wisdom.
But you can't encode a set of heuristics that works every time into a physical device - that is the real problem with "smart". In a small minority of cases, the situation will get so complicated that the rules you embedded will produce suboptimal behaviour. To overcome that, you'd need to embed a human-like intelligence in the device.
Similarly will they fail for the minority of people who have drastically different goals (e.g. aesthetics) for the purpose of the device. Now you end up having to clone the owner wholesale.
Okay, really the problem with "smart" devices is that they typically don't disclose what rules they follow, and typically don't come to the user asking for help choosing when tradeoffs enter the picture (literally in the context of this article).
"Dumb" devices, meanwhile, lay all choices flat.
Granted, cameras have long stopped being comletely dumb - but they often make a good job opening themselves to doubt with things like optional manual color balance, and different priority modes.
I don’t, really. Making lots of good decision, sure. But just because they’re complicated? No.
Aren't hardware manufacturers also making choices for you?
I get that software allows for far broader picture manipulation but there are a decent amount of similar choices on the lens and sensor level, no?
Software makes it more of a black box. The same picture taken days apart could look different due to a software update you weren't even aware of. Hardware is also a forced choice so is more deliberate which again is the opposite of the software situation of changing algos and processing.
11 years ago, I gave a talk about this at the Internet Archive. It seems to have held up. https://youtu.be/UMMogOoWEbI