News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by nirui on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:23AM (#30750597)
I don't really care how a company arrange their PCBs. It's just like writing code, as long as the code is correct, easily readable, expressive and have great eventual performance, it's a good code, you don't have to keep your lines in a visually beautiful perfect symmetry to achieve that.

The same is true for PCB design: as long as the board is correct, reasonable, stable and have good performance, it's a good board.

Based on the video, in order to clean up the dirty fans in this machine (something you'll start to do eventually), you'll have to:

1. Un-glue the button rubble stand ring to access the body screws,

2. Remove the exposed power supply (Risk getting shocked or worse),

3. Detach almost everything (screws, tapes and cables) you can see, so you can un-mount the main board to access the fans.

Then, after done cleaning, you have to do everything again but in reverse.

My opinion is, Apple can make their circuits look like a Steve Jobs thonk pose, but if an user has to go through all that many trouble and risks to preform such simple and (rare but) routine task, this design is bad.

Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by oxplot on Monday March 21, 2022 @02:55AM (#30751034)
> if an user has to go through all that many trouble and risks to preform such simple and (rare but) routine task, this design is bad

You're assuming an Apple user is meant to service their own product. That's not the case as far as Apple is concerned. You have an issue, you drop by the Apple store (or send your device in) and they repair it for you.

Determining good-ness or bad-ness of a design has to take into account the intended usage and design goals. Whether a customer should be able to repair their device easily/at all, is a whole separate topic. Apple doesn't think so and their design decisions have clearly reflected that over the decades. As far as that goes, whether the end user has to dig through 20 layers of hardware before cleaning a fan is irrelevant. What's relevant is whether Apple employees who'll be fixing/cleaning these devices will be wasting too much time for the most frequent support requests. That's what Apple should be (and most certainly is) optimizing for.

Also note that the majority of the end users will not have the time nor the interest to repair their own devices, especially when in most cases, their repair is covered under warranty. A lot of people with the technical skills far more than needed to to the self repair fall into this category as well. I've been modding and hacking expensive hardware for decades mostly for fun, but also for practical reasons, in order to add to/modify behavior of the hardware. Even I have little interest to repair my Apple products I have paid premium dollars on. I increasingly value where I spend my time and I let Apple do my laundry for me.

I must also mention (given the high degree of Apple/Google/Facebook/... bashing on HN) that Apple is among the better, if not the best, manufacturers in terms of warranty service and support (at least where I live). I have requested warranty services for dozens of products and not once have had to "prove" my case, or so much as try to convince Apple of an issue. Compared to every other worse interaction with other brands, I will continue to pay top dollars for Apple products even at the cost of whatever the hot Apple knocking topic of the day is. Having said that, there are of course tools that I need full access and repairability as a given and I never go with Apple in those cases.

Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by Osiris on Monday March 21, 2022 @02:58AM (#30751053)
He's not talking about repair. He's talking about cleaning. Cleaning should not require an Apple certified technician.
Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by ksec on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:28AM (#30751241)
From Apple's perspective, cleaning and repairing are the same thing. You should pay Apple to do it for you.
Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by grumpyprole on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:56AM (#30751445)
And this means very expensive prices for having the machine cleaned. I agree with the parent, cleaning should not require an expensive and risky strip and rebuild. This is, at best, a misguided design.
Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by ksec on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:14AM (#30752283)
I agree. But knowing Apple, that is not how they think about it.
Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by oxplot on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:04AM (#30751078)
Cleaning becomes repair if it's affecting your machine's performance. If it's not affecting performance, why would one care if the inside of their machine that they can't see nor access, is dusty or not?

EDIT: OK, let me help you arrive at the destination: your machine gets dusty and slow, just as if its electronics was failing. You take it to Apple and they fix it under warranty or ask for some $$ if it's out of warranty (given that they have to spend time doing it, time that you would be spending yourself, whether it's easy or hard to open up the machine). Calling it cleaning or repairing is splitting hairs. If it's degrading performance, it's a problem, if it's not, it's cosmetics.

BTW, all this fuss with cleaning fans — no one I know opens up their stuff and clean the fans until the device malfunctions. You are in the small small minority and no company, including Apple optimized for your habits.

Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by cormacrelf on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:16AM (#30751159)
You should be able to avoid having your machine’s performance degrade simply by its inevitable coexistence with dust. If you want your worldview to make sense, please invent a fan and computer interior that does not collect dust.
Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by mschuster91 on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:56AM (#30752169)
Yeah, but with most tower-style computers and even most Apple laptops it's easy to clean after the inevitable coexistence with dust: once a year, remove the screws and the bottom (or in case of a tower, side) lid, apply a vacuum cleaner, close it up again and that's it.

The nastiest opponent to cleaning that Apple sells is the iMac lineup after the Late 2012 iMac. The iMacs before had their display glass attached to the frame with magnets, with 2012 Apple switched to adhesive... which makes servicing these really painful because it is easy to break that glass and pretty difficult to separate the front glass from the panel.

If you have cats, dogs or other beings that shed fur though around you, I'd recommend once every six months.

Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by brailsafe on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:22AM (#30751211)
The key bit is "their machine that they can't see nor access". If I could easily clean out my macbook's fans, I would, for regular maintenance, so it doesn't get to that point. It feeling like I'm risking everything but simply opening it up increases the liklihood that it will get to the point of needing repair.
Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by oxplot on Monday March 21, 2022 @04:20AM (#30751598)
You're in a small small minority who spends time cleaning fans to avoid slow down of a machine. The rest of the world only care when they hit that point after which they send their machine in for service.
Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by wpearse on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:20AM (#30751953)
I took apart a 2010 Mac mini the other to install an SSD. It’s basically been running non-stop since new in a corner of our office for over a decade. Sure, there was some dust but it wasn’t at the point where it would affect performance. A quick wipe with a soft paint brush and it was as good as new — the first time we had ever opened this machine.

I don’t understand the insistence that we must regularly clean our computers, it seems daft. Maybe vacuum your house/office once in a while. The computer breathes the same air as you.

Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by brailsafe on Monday March 21, 2022 @10:08AM (#30754294)
I think the main point was serviceability, possibility of cleaning being one reason you might want to, another being an SSD install.
Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by brailsafe on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:34AM (#30752038)
On my mac, I'm not a part of any group, because I'm highly discouraged from doing so. I can with my stupid gaming pc, because it's literally 3 screws, and if that's beyond the capacity for people to do occasionally, then that's a pretty fucking low standard. To me it should be like blowing leaves out of your cars engine compartment. If people around me don't do it, even though it's extremely easy, then that's fine. If people feel like "only the ford dealer can fix this" then that's not fine.
Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by nirui on Monday March 21, 2022 @08:34AM (#30753325)
> You're assuming an Apple user is meant to service their own product. That's not the case as far as Apple is concerned.

> Determining good-ness or bad-ness of a design has to take into account the intended usage and design goals. Whether a customer should be able to repair their device easily/at all, is a whole separate topic

I was just talking about the product design itself, did not touch the self-repairability issue at all.

There are certain expectations a device should be providing, been Apple does not grant them the exception. No, Apple is not a special company that produce magic rainbow out of their computer/phones, it's a company that produce digital product and service, just like those in Shenzhen, Apple is not special. They're expensive, they're a monopoly, and they hire some good people, but they're not special, keep this in mind.

I would complained the same thing if Dell or Lenovo designed their wind system like that. Fun fact, I kind like how Dell designed their OptiPlex MFF system, at least I don't have risk my life trying to clean them. But of course that computer, not a Mac.

But with all that said, I'm not here to stop you. If you want one (because it look beautiful I guess???), then treat yourself. I'm just here to complain what I saw as a consumer.

Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by oxplot on Monday March 21, 2022 @08:56AM (#30753545)
> If you want one (because it look beautiful I guess???)

Why would you say this, after I explained in length the warranty advantages? Did you not read that part or do you disagree with it?

Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by Casteil on Monday March 21, 2022 @02:22AM (#30750872)
Had this same thought when I watched this teardown when it came out a few days ago.

I'm a big fan of the power/efficiency of the M1 (and all variants), but it's completely ridiculous that the teardown is so involved to get at the fans/heatsink for cleaning.

Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by kiratp on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:18AM (#30751178)
Our devs aren't cleaning their machines - it goes to Apple. As long as their techs can do it it matters not. Its cheaper that way anyway.

This design optimizes for the rest of the (365 * 3) - 1 days that the machine takes less space on your desk and is whisper quiet.

Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by AHTERIX5000 on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:44AM (#30752096)
Cheaper to send the whole machine to Apple for servicing? I worked at a company where most users had simple PCs with dust filters and it took 5 seconds to clean those when fans started ramping up due to accumulated dust. I can't really see how it would be cheaper to pause all work and send the machine somewhere else for cleaning.

Heatsinks and thermal pastes, no-one really cared since they should be fine for years until the machine is replaced anyway.

Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by Hamuko on Monday March 21, 2022 @08:18AM (#30753192)
I've definitely cleaned my work machine by myself. I imagine my employer also appreciates it, since the alternative would be to be without a work machine for however long.
Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by hughrr on Monday March 21, 2022 @04:04AM (#30751492)
I service far more dangerous and complicated things regularly. Some from an era before safety was even a thing. This Mac is fairly easy to service.

Not that I’d bother to service it as I’d rather apple handled it these days so I can go and play inside the old dangerous stuff instead.

(HP 141T on the bench at the moment)

Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by lwhi on Monday March 21, 2022 @02:37AM (#30750952)
I think Apple would rather you buy a new machine.
Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by Maursault on Monday March 21, 2022 @11:45AM (#30755393)
> in order to clean up the dirty fans in this machine

Maybe do something about the dirty air instead? Also, unless in a dusty industrial environment, by the time a computer fan and chassis is filthy, it's already legacy equipment. If a computer is used for work, to generate income, replacing it every 2 years is the cost of doing business and a write-off. But I suppose if a typical Mac user, one would have to go through the trouble of blowing out the dust every 4 years.

Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by jazzyjackson on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:39AM (#30751319)
Or get a separate HEPA filter in the same room as the mac so you and your CPU can skip breathing dust bunnies
Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by Cthulhu_ on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:44AM (#30752452)
Or like, clean your room / house for a change. A vacuum and dust cloths go a long way. A roomba isn't enough. HEPA filters should only be used for the rest, if any, but those small particulates won't affect the fans much.
Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by willcipriano on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:51AM (#30751397)
Isn't the problem this is trying to solve fan noise?
Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by k8sToGo on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:08AM (#30752245)
Ah yes, the apple way. Buy more to fix our bad design decision.
Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by everyone on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:49AM (#30751382)
Those sort of shenanigans will be illegal in EU soon hopefully.
Re:Mac Studio M1 Ultra Teardown [video] by _ph_ on Monday March 21, 2022 @04:42AM (#30751731)
At minimum, Apple should be required to perform a cleaning for free. That would quickly ensure good accessibility. Equally, the cost for a keyboard exchange on a laptop should be capped at about 100€.