News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by acidburnNSA on Sunday March 20, 2022 @06:04PM (#30747164)
Note that, despite the headlines, the final units at the Chernobyl nuclear plant stopped generating power in 2000. These aren't like the Zaporizhzhia units which are still providing power to the area. Once a nuclear chain reaction stops, the afterglow heat reduces exponentially. By now it is exceedingly low, and can be fully cooled passively.

Best info on this whole situation comes from the UN's "nuclear watchdog" (the IAEA), who now has 27 individual updates from this overall event.

https://www.iaea.org/nuclear-safety-and-security-in-ukraine

Not to say people shouldn't be allowed to rotate shifts, of course. But don't let the word Chernobyl freak you out too much is all.

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by jnsaff2 on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:34AM (#30752044)
What is actually funny was after watching the show was .. huh, this was interesting .. but if the worst nuclear disaster we have has about a few hundred direct deaths, and a few thousand indirect .. with other health complications to some tens of thousands. Then compared to the respiratory illness related deaths caused by burning fossil fuels NOW and all the future wars and deaths and ecosystem collapses caused by climate change is absolutely nothing.

Now I have read quite a few books on nuclear disasters before and was aware of the fact that the megaton explosion was not true. So I may not be a representative example of how people reacted to the show.

What was scary to me was the relatively accurate representation of the behavior of the soviet brass. I even found their representation quite mild. And as we see in Ukraine these days, nothing has changed, russians have zero regard for civilians, nuclear power plants are being endangered with shelling, maternity wards are being bombed, bread lines are bombed. Post-soviet mafia does not care about anything but their own kleptocracy and looting.

Every time I think about this I get reminded the Fork Yeah! talk by bcantrill.

https://youtu.be/-zRN7XLCRhc?t=1986

"An open mind is completely wasted on russians"

"The lawnmower does not care"

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by jnsaff2 on Monday March 21, 2022 @10:22AM (#30754458)
I however want to acknowledge that there are some brave people in russia who stand up and protest and risk their lives. It may seem futile but I still respect them. There is a great book [0] by Masha Gessen called The future is history that talks about them too.

[0] - https://mashagessen.com/

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by Barrin92 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @08:52PM (#30748704)
>But don't let the word Chernobyl freak you out too much

After the TV show with its absolutely cartoonish depiction of the risks of nuclear energy I have no hope that's happening any time soon. It was genuinely baffling to me how a show, that was about as accurate on the threats of nuclear energy as Jaws was for sharks, got so much praise heaped on it.

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by datatrashfire on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:19AM (#30750579)
The US continues to fail to effectively clean up the 56 million gallons of high level waste at the Hanford nuclear site and others throughout the US. Nuclear waste is slowly seeping into the water table and the Columbia river. The site is threatened by the risk of earthquakes, volcanoes, and flooding. We are no where closer to making it safe now than we were in 1985.

While I appreciate the devotion to facts, I feel the portrayal still rings true. These risks are catastrophic and are to this day being handled with scandalous incompetence.

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by ahelwer on Sunday March 20, 2022 @09:20PM (#30748912)
Funniest part is that the tagline and theme of the show was “what is the cost of lies?” despite itself taking ridiculous liberties with the truth. Just off the top of my head there was:

* the “bridge of death” scene that never happened

* irradiated firefighters portrayed as themselves being radioactive

* military dude threatening to throw a member of the academy of the sciences out of a helicopter for trivial/arbitrary reasons

I remember there being other notable ones when briefly looking into it after watching it a couple years back.

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by tablespoon on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:53PM (#30750038)
> Funniest part is that the tagline and theme of the show was “what is the cost of lies?” despite itself taking ridiculous liberties with the truth. Just off the top of my head there was:

It's worth noting that show was not a work of nonfiction. In fiction, when the needs of drama and factual accuracy collide, drama usually wins, and there's nothing wrong with that.

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by colechristensen on Monday March 21, 2022 @12:54AM (#30750444)
There is when the drama comes from lying about how the world works and dressing up your show just like reality.

Most people who watch something like that without foreknowledge of the truth of the situation are going to believe the drama is real.

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by ako on Monday March 21, 2022 @02:58AM (#30751051)
The problem with fictional drama is that it does frame how people perceive the world.
Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by mixedCase on Sunday March 20, 2022 @09:04PM (#30748809)
How does the show portray modern nuclear energy in a bad light?
Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by Barrin92 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @09:15PM (#30748882)
by inventing complete nonsensical dangers. From claiming that the meltdown would result in a "4 megaton explosion" (that's off by about a million as this is the yield of a thermonuclear weapon, a plant isn't a bomb), claiming that the plant would render Europe uninhabitable (no such thing is possible), to portrayals of radiation sickness in Pripyat (the residents received about 3 x-rays worth of radiation), portrayal of radiation sickness as weirdly contagious (which it is not), and so on.
Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by DangitBobby on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:27PM (#30749870)
The impending explosion was going to be from the molten reactor and sand they dropped on it melting through the concrete and hitting a large underground lake, instantly vaporizing it and causing a massive explosion, and ejecting radioactive debris in a very wide area. I have read several articles criticising some aspects of the accuracy of the show (though none even venture close to saying "nonsensical"), and none of them say anything about the inaccuracy of that plot point. Do you have a source?
Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by nand4011 on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:35PM (#30749918)
https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/480113/how-large...

The risk of an explosion was very real, but the show claimed it would be measured in megatons, which is completely ludicrous.

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by DangitBobby on Sunday March 20, 2022 @11:37PM (#30749926)
I see comments there explaining that the writer got that estimate from a phsycist, so maybe wrong, but definitely not ludicrous. Linked from that same discussion: https://old.reddit.com/r/TVChernobyl/comments/boo19f/did_she...
Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by colechristensen on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:06AM (#30750510)
No it’s ludicrous.

Much of the point of the manhattan project was devising mechanisms to bring fissile materials together fast enough and precisely enough that they could reach criticality for long enough to produce an effective weapon. To propose that you could get comparable effects via nuclear materials burning through their containment vessel melted in a pool is absurd and just extraordinarily unlikely.

That quote is about “testimony” of a Soviet physicist… who knows what political or other motivations were at work to justify that statement. I can’t imagine any modern physicist saying that was reasonable and it seems the writer couldn’t make that happen… it just seems like a fishing expedition for the most impressive quote that found someone saying something ridiculous and used that as a source of truth ignoring everything else which wasn’t as “fun”.

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by DangitBobby on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:31AM (#30750629)
You sure are interpolating a lot of your own angle into this discussion. Do you think most laypeople would understand (or even remember) the implications of the difference between a 100kT explosion and a 4MT one? Probably not, right? Why do you think the writer would? Is it actually an important difference as far as the narrative is concerned? You'll find that no, it isn't. Even if it were, it's pretty ridiculous to think that expert testimony from the event wouldn't be an appropriate figure to use for a dramatization of the event.
Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by colechristensen on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:53AM (#30750738)
I’m really not.

The contemporary quote was either misattributed, missing context, or a straight up lie.

It’s not hard for an ordinary person to imagine what 4 million tons of explosive equivalent might be, or a hundred thousand, both are ridiculous. The actual risk was an explosion on the scale of a few buildings or a minor criticality incident which splattered melted nuclear material in a very small local area.

You’re not going to find a nuclear physicist who could back anything else up with calculations, the author tried and couldn’t.

The problem with your “viewers are ignorant so it doesn’t matter point” is that viewers aren’t totally ignorant and are then fed with very false information which makes any understanding that they did have considerably worse.

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by 3np on Monday March 21, 2022 @02:27AM (#30750894)
Could the earlier points be seen as less nonsensical if viewed in the light of "the (mis)understanding at the time"?

> portrayal of radiation sickness as weirdly contagious

Thanks for pointing this out. That part threw me off completely when watching it. Like how would that even work.

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by tormock on Sunday March 20, 2022 @09:15PM (#30748881)
> After the TV show with its absolutely cartoonish depiction of the risks of nuclear energy

it was not perfect but it was a good show... aren't all movies cartoonish in some way?

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by colechristensen on Monday March 21, 2022 @12:56AM (#30750456)
Ratatouille is about a rodent who can cook but doesn’t leave the viewer with major misconceptions about soup or what life working in a kitchen can be like. It doesn’t leave people with misconceptions about reality.
Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by acidburnNSA on Sunday March 20, 2022 @09:17PM (#30748899)
Yeah only got a few risks off by more than 5 orders of magnitude.

Too bad they can't make something that scary about air pollution.

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by Lochleg on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:55AM (#30751437)
There are units that still require cooling. https://www.wired.com/story/the-situation-at-chernobyl-is-de...

Wired also had an old article about the long-term situation with radioactive contamination, which the surrounding environment has to absorb including wildlife that continues to mutate rapidly last I checked. So, I would say secure containment is paramount.

Nuclear energy can be safe, but we keep failing to recognize how short of foolproof the many fail-safes involved really are even in a high-tech society. Things going bad when you lose power or a single (water) pump are the prime examples.

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by egorfine on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:13AM (#30751899)
Chernobyl is much more dangerous in hands of russian soldiers than Zaporozhskaya Power Plant.

See, a complete destruction of ZNPP Unit by an external force (bomb) is going to contaminate the immediate area but not much further. It won't be nowhere near at the scale of Chernobyl accident.

On the other hand, The Shelter in Chernobyl NPP contains 50,000+ tons of highly radioactive and highly volatile (light) dust particles of graphite and concrete. If they destroy Novarka and The Shelter in the worst case scenario half of Europe becomes the exclusion zone. Source: I am closely working with Chernobyl guys.

Based on what we see so far in this invasion, we have no reason to rule out intentional destruction of The Shelter.

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by kranke155 on Monday March 21, 2022 @07:40AM (#30752877)
You have every reason to rule out the destruction of the Shelter since the plant is right next to the Belarus border... which is Russia's ally.
Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by egorfine on Monday March 21, 2022 @07:54AM (#30752989)
Unfortunately it seems to me that conventional logic isn't really helpful to bring a better understanding of the circumstances of this war.

For instance, you wouldn't expect sane combatant to repeatedly fire ordnance directly into the nuclear power plant units.

In Chernobyl they have already disrupted the top soil level and dug back radioactive particles back in the air and thus in the lungs and GI tracts of their soldiers and civilians unlucky enough to live where the wind blows.

Given the Putin's rhetoric of "why do we need the world without Russia" and similar we cannot rule out destruction of The Shelter.

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by kranke155 on Thursday March 24, 2022 @06:46AM (#30788147)
Yes we can because it makes no strategic or tactical sense.

The so called strikes against nuclear power plants were made far too big of a deal. Ukraine is trying to blow everything out of proportion - and I say this being a total supporter of Ukraine - so that US/EU will help them.

There has been no real danger of incidents around nuclear power plants that I’ve seen, just Ukrainian propaganda efforts to try and frame the Russians for attempting one.

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by egorfine on Thursday March 24, 2022 @09:05AM (#30789176)
> no real danger of incidents around nuclear power plants

Top soil level disrupted in the Chernobyl zone. This is a big deal. Not chernobyl-accident-big, not fire-on-the-unit big, but still not a nuisance.

I can kind of agree with you and I agree that our propaganda over exaggerates.

So if Putin/military make decisions based on rational thought process then yes we don't have to worry. I'm just not sure they really do. I have seen things in this war which I do not understand from the strategic and tactical standpoint. It's not that they aren't reasons, it's just that I have not been able to figure them out so far.

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by kranke155 on Friday March 25, 2022 @08:27AM (#30801283)
Putin is 100% acting according to his rational interests, it's just that his interests appear incomprehensible to us, who believe that progress is peace. Putin and his circle believe that progress is power, and they also believe that the reconstruction of Russian power is both needed and essential.

It turns out that a lot of stuff that Putin was saying was TRUE, not just Trump-style bluster. He does believe that Russia should own a sphere of influence, and that a sort of USSR 2.0 project is both viable and desirable. This is shocking to us (I myself was shocked when he decided to go for a full invasion instead of just expanding the Donetsk and Luhansk republics), but not so much to Ukrainians.

Basically we projected our values onto Putin and believed that he wanted to make his nation rich like the West. Turns out money for him is less important, relatively speaking, than direct power for Russia.

See this video from a Ukrainian analyst where he accurately predicts and explains the war in 2019: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1xNHmHpERH8

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by egorfine on Saturday March 26, 2022 @12:58PM (#30813429)
Yes, we are all listening to Arestovich daily and sometimes even more often. He's the comforting voice for ukrainians and officially an advisor for the president Zelensky.

Meanwhile as we speak we have reports of russian soldiers with radiation poisoning arriving in hospitals in Belarus. While the reports are not yet confirmed, we fully expect that to happen: some of the russian troops are stationed right in the middle of the the Red Forest. Radiation levels in these woods were quite high by themselves even after all these years, but digging that specific soil with tanks and boots - that's a whole lot different story.

Re:After 600 hours 64 workers at Ukraine's Chernobyl nuclear... by Maursault on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:03AM (#30751072)
> Once a nuclear chain reaction stops

Please note that, despite your apparently reasonable handwaving, in fact fission reactions are still occurring in uranium fuel masses buried deep inside what's left of at least one of Chernobyl's reactors. Not saying there is any need to panic. But try not to let a false sense of security lull you into a coma.