News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by humanistbot on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @10:10AM (#30699061)
I think this is more of a version of the "why have we stopped making good music/movies, almost everything today is garbage?" issue. With the benefit of hindsight, we only remember the greats (and the very worst villains) from past eras. While if we look around today, we see all the people who will never make it into the history books, just like we see all the songs and movies that will never become "classics."

Edit: And yes, the internet has brought about immense and immeasurable benefits to science and innovation. It can both be true that most people on Facebook are dunces and getting dumber because of Facebook, and that there has been massive developments in research and development that would not have happened without the internet.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by lodi on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:42AM (#30700183)
I think that's part of it, but I also think there's some merit to our intuition as well; sometimes you can viscerally feel if you're in a boom or bust cycle. During the reality TV phase I remember thinking "this is all garbage", and then shows like The Sopranos and The West Wing kicked off an era that had me thinking "I literally can't keep up with all the good shows; there's too much good TV to watch." I think this was a pretty common feeling, and not in hindsight but during the era. In gaming I remember marvelling at a PC boom in 98-99, and then hating the "xbox-ification" of PC games for a few years after that.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by dllthomas on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @12:36PM (#30700978)
> During the reality TV phase I remember thinking "this is all garbage", and then shows like The Sopranos and The West Wing kicked off an era...

The West Wing and The Sopranos l started in 1999. Jackass and Survivor started in 2000.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by hexis on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @01:07PM (#30701379)
The Real World started in 1992. It was "credited with launching the modern reality TV genre" - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Real_World_(TV_series)
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by p_j_w on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @02:14PM (#30702123)
Yes, but the reality TV boom didn't hit for quite some time after. Maybe my memory is off, but it felt like a mid aughts thing.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by bmhin on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @02:31PM (#30702318)
Survivor in 2000, American Idol in 2002, The Bachelor in 2002, The Amazing Race in 2001. That always felt to me like when they found their "reality game show" formula that was then replicated off of those base archetypes into the entire rest of the genre. So mid-aughts does feel about right for when the explosion happened.

The more pure reality shows like original Real World or COPS seem more like ancestors than anything and didn't spawn as much of an immediate copy cat proliferation. Real World if anything morphed to be more like those later incarnations.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @03:04PM (#30702663)
Unscripted television had been bubbling beneath the surface for a good long while (game shows have existed since basically forever), but the 2007 writer's strikes was the catalyst that caused MTV-style trashier reality TV to take over.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by alx__ on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:10AM (#30699736)
Been reading Chuck Klosterman's book, But What If We're Wrong?. Which is partly that thought. The things that get remembered in the global consciousness are not always the people or things we'd expect. It's possible that we have a "genius" right now that will be remembered in 100 years. But due to all the local noise it's hard to see through that and remain objective.

Basically we're really terrible at guessing what the future holds.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by dav_Oz on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:57AM (#30700426)
I would argue that is actually the norm. The more I dig deeper into the history of any field the more I realize how many publicly unknown geniuses there are. Mostly only recognized and praised as such by the connoisseurs of the respective field.

And it makes sense, especially in our times, sophisticated PR (and Einstein enjoyed that, too, in addition in being a genius) just trumps any recognition one might get in a life time, in the short term that is.

If you are not seeking some grandiose recognition (like Newton or Edison, famously) you are potentially a better explorer of the yet Unknown not bothering wasting any energy and being less corruptable by discoveries, you are happy to share with others and helping to bring about.

Off the top of my head: Three examples of rather unknown "geniuses" in physics in no particular order:

Chien-Shiung Wu, Oliver Heaviside, John Michell

One could also argue, as I sometimes do, too, that a genius is just a convenient narrative device in order to highlight and illustrate some important turning point with the historical person serving as some responsible "actor" in bridging over an otherwise complex and often self-contradictory development into a tangible coherent state.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by gotaquestion on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @12:42PM (#30701062)
I think there isn't enough distinction in the term "genius". How do you even compare their contributions? It is easy when you have someone like Euclid or Newton, who's work is taught in pre-college grades. Who is the last person to have an impact on pre-collegiate math syllabi? It's been centuries. Then you look at someone like Einstein who was discussed in every major magazine and newspaper at the time his general theory was articulated. I think Hawking got the similar treatment, but has he impacted what is taught in 4-year college the way Einstein did? I think Hawking's genius is too esoteric.

There needs to be a new term. "Genius" is too limp to describe individuals who radically alter the curriculum taught to undergraduate students.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by marcosdumay on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @01:03PM (#30701327)
> Who is the last person to have an impact on pre-collegiate math syllabi?

Shrodinger, maybe? He is a really large part of the reason people study matrices before college, and then go and complain because nobody can show them a use for the thing.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by dboreham on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @01:47PM (#30701810)
Showing a use case for matrices is extremely easy : 3D graphics. At least 50% of school students will have a good understanding of that field.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by marcosdumay on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @02:18PM (#30702171)
Yes, matrices got everywhere in the 20th century. There is basically no field that doesn't use them nowadays.

But any demonstration requires modern knowledge, and matrices are one of the very few modern thing students see. If you want to show them 3D graphics, you will need to teach programing first. Yeah, some will know it by them, but schools also can't rely on that.

(As an aside, chemistry also has some weirdly modern knowledge on its curriculum. Also out of context, just thrown in there because it's important.)

The nearest application I can think of is for modeling stochastic processes, but students see so little statistics that I imagine that will only change the object on the "why am I even studying X?" complaint.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by syntheweave on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @07:48PM (#30705661)
You don't have to teach programming to teach computer graphics at the level of pedagogical example. The programming is bookkeeping for assets and occasionally a clever optimization(e.g. a Bresenham line rasterization, instead of one done by linear interpolation); the algorithms that are most critical to understanding graphics are often one-liners and analytic in nature, and so can directly reflect the underlying mathematics.

The kind of example you would get for matrix math would be something like: "Here is a triangle described by these points, here is a matrix that projects them in a 3D camera. In such-and-such 3D library, points are projected with the matrix by doing these steps. Compute and plot the result of applying the matrix to each point." And then in successive examples you can add some details about how you go about building up the matrix by computing the camera, translating the poly and so forth, and make comparisons to how it can be done in some scenarios using only trigonometry, and further comparisons to camera lenses and artist's 3D projection with horizon and vanishing points. If you put all those connections there in one place, you have the starting point, and then it can be elaborated on into both the pure math topics(why does this mathematical representation work) and the computing topics(how do I automate the process of plotting points).

What tends to happen is that the text doesn't allow enough of a detour to make all of those connections, so you instead get an extraordinarily brief allusion to application in a single word problem, after a completely abstract introduction.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by mabub24 on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:26AM (#30699982)
This is a well studied phenomenon in literature. Some books we regard as classics today sold relatively little upon release, while authors in the past were incredibly popular then, upon the author's death usually, the name was utterly forgotten from aesthetic appraisals. Ideas of a "canon" are much less stable than people think.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by paganel on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:40AM (#30700156)
Even when it comes to philosophy I think it holds true. Up into the 1930s Bergson was regarded as one of the most important philosophers in Europe while Wittgenstein was barely mentioned outside a few, select circles, even he had already published his Tractatus. Nowadays Bergson returns blank stares when you mention his name to an Anglo audience while Wittgenstein is seen as one of the most important philosophers of the last few hundred years.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by Der_Einzige on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @12:31PM (#30700881)
Which is profoundly sad since Wittgenstein is only saved by his prophetic beliefs about language - despite writing like a post-modernist while somehow being considered part of the "analytic tradition"...

He is fashionable nonsense.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by bwestergard on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @01:36PM (#30701694)
Have you read the Tractatus? After Frege, and Russell, it's difficult to think of a philosopher who contributed more to the analytic style of exposition.

There is some irony in dismissing him as "nonsensical", because he himself suggested the Tractatus was "nonsense". The point of writing it was to demonstrate that philosophy in his time (e.g. the logical atomism of Russell) had gone astray.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by aqsalose on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @01:28PM (#30701603)
Funny, I thought his musics about "language games" was the part of his output more amenable to fashionable nonsense. I have met very few students who attempt to say anything about Tractatus, but quite many who espouse deep-sounding platitudes about "language is a game".
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by ceejayoz on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:50AM (#30700304)
Art, as well; Van Gogh died a failure.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by vkou on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @01:53PM (#30701880)
Art's a little weird, because the price of a lot of million-dollar art pieces is driven in large part by the need for an appreciating-on-paper vehicle for tax evasion. (That you can lend out to art galleries.)

And the last thing these schemes need is a living artist who can - upon his work reaching stardom - simply make more of it.

In this respect, dead poets are much safer to bet the farm on.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by ecshafer on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @01:22PM (#30701528)
A good example of this is the Author of the famously "bad line", "It was a dark and stormy night" was Edward Bulwer-Lytton, who was perhaps one of the most famous authors of his time, who also coined many very common expressions we use today.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by pas on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @03:05PM (#30702682)
> While if we look around today, we see all the people who will never make it into the history books

because it's simply extremely cheap to create stuff. so we have a glut of stuff.

because nowadays everyone can buy an instrument and take a few classes, and put it on youtube. and since there's enormous demand for novelty, and there's a lot of styles, niches that producers/creators can fill, quality isn't really a singular thing anymore.

> just like we see all the songs and movies that will never become "classics."

well, that's .. true, but also there's no classics anymore. there's a gamut of things. hundreds of years ago we had a few hundred/thousand extremely talented people who got into arts because they were talented, they visited each other in person to learn from each other over months and years. it was very very very homogeneous in time and space (and it was apparent who's the amazing real boss of that level/period/era) compared to today's hyperfast superglobal heterogeneous all-in content-bonanza, where it's impossible to consume all of it, impossible to filter it, impossible to comprehend/contrast/compare all of it to itself.

Sure there was no point in comparing Van Gogh to Tchaikovsky even then - but there was room for two, now it got even more impossibler not less since there are so many new forms/genres/styles and a lot more amazing feats of creation, and more new talents each day, so relatively there's even less room (less time, less space) to fit the contemporary greats.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by mwcampbell on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @10:45AM (#30699469)
> I think this is more of a version of the "why have we stopped making good music/movies, almost everything today is garbage?" issue.

Tangentially, though, I think there's something to the complaints about music. Why does pop music have any noticeably autotuned singers at all, when anyone who regularly goes to karaoke bars knows that there are lots of good singers everywhere? In other words, why is being a good enough singer that one can record an impeccable vocal in one take apparently not a prerequisite for a recording contract?

Edit: To bring this back around to the topic of the article, I think the discussion of autotuned vocals might hint at an answer to the question about individual geniuses: it's not as important for individuals to have extraordinary abilities when technology can help us all do so much. I admit I was being a curmudgeon above; I know that autotune can be used to subtly improve mediocre vocals, in addition to enabling the obviously artificial sound that many of us consider crap.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by thebricksta on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @01:53PM (#30701874)
Most superstar pop singers have fantastic singing voices and great pitch control. Autotune shows up because of some mix of 1) the modern pop aesthetic demands superhuman tuning, 2) some degree of autotune artifacts are expected as part of the modern sound, and 3) it can intentionally be used as an effect (T-Pain).

To give some more detail about both 1 and 2 -

Pitch control is more than just hitting the note; its about how well you can onset at the right pitch, how well you can hold the pitch once hit, how well you can jump each pitch interval and land on the right pitch, how well you can pitch through different articulations, different vocal ranges, etc. The modern pop sound has accepted that superhuman levels of pitch control that lock the vocal into tune with the perfectly tuned synthesizers/samplers are more important than a natural sound.

Also, since we've been using autotune for so long, it has almost become natural. We expect to hear it to some degree on every track, especially in more difficult vocal areas. If it wasn't present, one might feel the song sounds "indie" or worse, dated.

Lastly, one thing that fascinates me about the autotune complaints are that it's just one stage of a very long vocal processing chain. To my ears, the tweaks provided by dynamics processors are much more dramatic than autotune when applied to a reasonably proficient singer. Autotune is just one step of a processing chain that can easily run through 10+ processors to end up at the right sound.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by RC_ITR on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:28AM (#30700006)
Autotune is a tool like any other. Generally those who consumed media before that tool was invented will be skeptical of it because “things I like didn’t need it.” Those who begin consuming media after the tool was invented don’t have the same biases.

A 50-years ago version of that would be microphones on broadway. It used to be a point of pride to fill a theater without amplification. Now we don’t really care.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by mwcampbell on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @12:29PM (#30700861)
Fair. When I was a teenager in the 90s, my favorite vocal groups made obvious use of overdubbing, and they sounded different when performing live.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by aqsalose on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @01:19PM (#30701498)
I am unsure if it tells more about any general attitude about "tools" or more about Broadway. Microphones are still not used in opera or classical music.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by RC_ITR on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @02:56PM (#30702567)
https://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/30/arts/music/wearing-a-wire...

Microphones are still not used by purists in opera or classical music, exactly because of the point I made above.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by kixiQu on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:46AM (#30700253)
Pop performers are optimizing for something outside what hits a recording -- that is to say, in the same way that opera singers have to have some theatrical ability in addition to singing the music, pop performance these days involves a huge amount of choreographed dance. A pop singer I'll not name performed on a late night show and was a target of internet ribbing for having brought only some semi-awkward samba-like side-stepping -- though it's more than I or the karaoke singers could do! Once you start looking at the best singer-dancers rather than the best singers, you'll get closer to the real prerequisites for that genre.

(And of course, "the obviously artificial sound" can be an aesthetic choice made by vocalists fully capable of recording impeccable vocals: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CIjXUg1s5gc)

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by wutbrodo on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @12:19PM (#30700745)
> A pop singer I'll not name performed on a late night show and was a target of internet ribbing for having brought only some semi-awkward samba-like side-stepping

For anyone wondering, I believe this is referring to Lana Del Rey. Not sure what the purpose of redacting the name was...

Maybe that's not who you were referring to though? Iirc, the criticisms weren't just about her swaying, but singing that was described as "mumbling". That latter criticism is explicitly the opposite of what we're discussing.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by kixiQu on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @01:06PM (#30701371)
It was not referring to Lana del Rey, that criticism would be the opposite of what we're discussing, and thus it's sort of funny you'd assumed that's whom I'd meant... The purpose of redacting the name is that I like the singer, her music is great, and I don't think there's a point to invoking her as "a bad dancer" in a discussion on HN of all places.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by wutbrodo on Saturday March 19, 2022 @07:14PM (#30738423)
> The purpose of redacting the name is that I like the singer, her music is great, and I don't think there's a point to invoking her as "a bad dancer" in a discussion on HN of all places

It's kind of funny that you'd think this invocation would be harmful, given that the very premise is that how she chooses to move onstage is irrelevant to her musicianship.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by barbecue_sauce on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:31AM (#30700058)
Because the technical proficiency of a singer, or any musician/instrumentalist for that matter, is not what makes a song interesting or memorable.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by yakubin on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:57AM (#30700425)
There is no single thing that makes a song interesting or memorable, but technical proficiency is one of factors. Of course, I don't think that being "at the top" in technical proficiency makes a song any better than being just among a broader set of "best performers", but autotune makes people sound flat, generic, robotic, which is on the opposite end of the spectrum. That it doesn't contribute positively to a song is an understatement.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by giraffe_lady on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @12:39PM (#30701019)
Does a trumpet with a straight mute contribute positively to a song? Compared to an unmuted trumpet it has reduced dynamic control and a flattened, generic timbre. But using them is common, and the distinctive sound is a key part of many well-known musical passages.

The technical proficiency of a trumpeter is completely orthogonal to whether they use a mute on a particular piece, since it is just a simple hardware technique. And the same thing with autotune. Incredible singers can and do use it for its technical effect, because they think that effect contributes to the song.

As a listener you can disagree, just as I find the heavy strings vibrato of classic pop a distraction. But you can't assess how good a song is by categorizing techniques used in it. Claims that new techniques rob music of something ineffable, or just sound bad, are ubiquitous for new musical techniques and are as old as instruments at least.

If you think autotune is the First Bad One when people said the same things about piano pedals, metal violin strings, geared tuning pegs, electric amplification, I just want you to consider the company you're in here.

You can not like it but stop claiming it's objectively bad when it is not.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by yakubin on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @12:59PM (#30701278)
You make it sound as if pop singers used autotune selectively, judging when it's better than natural technique. I wrote my comment in the context of large swaths of pop singers who use autotune indiscriminately in all their songs, throughout. (At least that's my impression from songs recommended to me by YouTube in incognito mode.) Now show me an acclaimed pianist who keeps their foot down on a single pedal throughout all their performances. I'd be surprised if the most common motivation for using autotune wasn't being unable to hit the right notes.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by giraffe_lady on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @03:11PM (#30702739)
You're making assumptions about the motivations and goals of the people making the music. It's likely they do think it adds something to every song they use it on. The same way almost all contemporary musicians use amplification and digital mastering "indiscriminately." Not using those techniques is a specific, intentional part of the "sound" of some genres, and outside of that they are ubiquitous.

I'm not saying autotune is this good. I'm saying that if nearly everyone is using it and continues to use it after, at this point, decades, they must be getting something out of it. Masterful singers also use it, some quite a lot, so it can't be as simple as covering up limited skill or range.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by p_j_w on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @02:20PM (#30702200)
>I think there's something to the complaints about music. Why does pop music

I'm going to stop you right there and point out that there is an absolutely massive space outside of Top 40. If you're willing to actually expend some effort to go looking, there's undoubtedly music out there for you. And this is nothing to do with age. I'm 40 and there's more new music coming out that I like than I can keep up with. I was recently talking to my almost 60 year old uncle and he finds the same to be true.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by seibelj on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:37AM (#30700123)
Pop music is about so much more than being a good singer. The hook is key, as is the content, the brand (artist), and how it's marketed. It takes a village to manufacture successful pop music. Being able to sing super well isn't required anymore, but having an army of people to assist making it popular most certainly is. The rare artist that goes viral on a shoestring quickly accumulates all the same help that other pop artists have to ensure future releases are also hits.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by hansworst on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:19AM (#30699874)
My take on it is that because there are so many good singers out there, people generally don't really care about that aspect of music as much (anymore?).

With so much technology available to basically anyone who cares enough to learn how to use it, it's becoming much more important to use that technology creatively than to have some natural talent for singing.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by brimble on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @02:22PM (#30702217)
I can't believe they autotune so much kids' media these days. Daniel Tiger will teach your kid that their amazing singing voice sounds wrong, because all the singing on DT is auto-tuned like crazy and doesn't sound like actual human singing. WTF.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by lupire on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @03:53PM (#30703228)
It's because pops stars need to be gorgeous celebs and also dancers, so singing gets replaced by computer.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by mhh__ on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @01:28PM (#30701611)
Because good musicians don't need to make pop music anymore.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by yetihehe on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @10:22AM (#30699166)
I agree. It's just that there is so much innovation everywhere, that those geniuses of old are not THAT outstanding. There are many geniuses, who make big contributions, but they don't work by themselves, so their contributions are not seen as advancing a field by one big leap. The same with music. You just need to search more. Youtube and spotify made this easier, I discover totally new astounding music authors and songs almost every month. Yeah, not everyone likes my music taste, but I see that many people also find new music they love. We just have so much variety now, that there is no single commonly recognisable genius.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by armada651 on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @10:41AM (#30699428)
> There are many geniuses, who make big contributions, but they don't work by themselves, so their contributions are not seen as advancing a field by one big leap.

I think this hits the nail on the head. Because we now have access to an instant world-wide exchange of ideas scientists work more closely together on developing their respective fields than ever before. By the time a major breakthrough happens most experts in the field will have already seen it coming.

Breakthroughs consist of many smaller leaps in knowledge and we are now hyper-aware of each small development, thus it doesn't seem like we're making big leaps anymore. Rather than creating new geniuses the Internet eliminated the need for the classic "genius" to make a breakthrough in a scientific field.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by duxup on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @10:37AM (#30699370)
Reminds me of the old "best music of the 70s" or whatever decade you picked.

If you had a CD of 20 songs, they were pretty great. If you got a box set ... oh man you hit A LOT of stinkers.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by alfor on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @03:44PM (#30703106)
The problem is that there's not much control group.

My kids were homeschooled, they did around 20 min per day of school, now at public school they find the pace way to slow.

School is 90% daycare so the parents can work, not really to teach kids.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by ViViDboarder on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @03:59PM (#30703306)
> School is 90% daycare so the parents can work, not really to teach kids.

That probably depends on each persons means to teach their own children.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by kosasbest on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:50AM (#30700316)
> While if we look around today, we see all the people who will never make it into the history books

I think this is largely because modern geniuses don't market themselves well. I mean the world is undeniably rampant with genius, but if you can't market your genius via social media or other means, then you fade into the background.

Consider that there are people on the spectrum who are bad at social interaction and can't be a 'Youtuber' or 'influencer' so easily.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by toyg on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @12:03PM (#30700518)
It's not just that - it's that the competition is now the scale of the planet.

Back in the day, if you made it in print somewhere, you were officially an intellectual of some prestige. Then it became about access to radio. Then it was all about reaching TV. All these channels were very limited, so just by getting there one could ensure they had a position among the officially recognised elite.

Now one is competing with a literally infinite amount of channels, from all over the planet, unloading talent in any discipline 24/7. You can market the hell out of yourself and the world can still decide they are too busy caring about Korean singers and African memes.

Which really is the beef I have with this article: genius is not recognised anymore because now we are a global village of billions, rather than an elite of a few hundreds of thousands, and we consume all sorts of radically different media rather than a handful of shared sources. So we simply don't agree on what is "genius" anymore, at a societal level; geniuses do their work in smaller groups, where they get some recognition, and that's it.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by atq2119 on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @04:21PM (#30703532)
> Now one is competing with a literally infinite amount of channels

I know this is a losing cause, but you either mean figuratively or you're wrong.

The more important part: what about the cited evidence that, correcting for other factors, "aristocratic tutoring" does make a difference in achievement?

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by toyg on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @05:23PM (#30704282)
For all practical purposes, it is literally infinite. You won't be able to go through the entirety of YouTube in a single lifetime, and that's just one channel of distributed knowledge. And new channels appear every day, somewhere on the global network. The firehose will never stop, the network is effectively an infinite source of content.

> what about the cited evidence that, correcting for other factors

I think the evidence is flimsy that "the other factors" can realistically be corrected for. In terms of access to resources, networking chances, free time etc etc, the aristocrats of the past would have been effectively unbeatable regardless of education methods. They could have powered through the infamous 10,000 hours in a couple of years, without any tutoring, to then spend the rest of their lives getting recognised as geniuses by a minuscule audience of a few hundred individuals - whose opinion determined everybody else's view of them, effectively unchallenged.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by itslennysfault on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:18AM (#30699860)
This is addressed early on in the article. Maybe one of the problems with lack of genius is that we don't actually read anymore.

    Ponder that! Spengler began writing Decline of the West in 1914. Tolstoy was only four years dead when Spengler started his book; Marx was only 30 years deceased. But Spengler could state, with the full expectation that his audience would not question him, that these men belonged in global pantheon of humanity’s greatest figures.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by kixiQu on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:49AM (#30700296)
I don't believe it's addressed well. Many from different intellectual lineages were then hailed whom we'd not recognize today. Many of the pseudo-quantitative takes pointed to are pretty ... flimsy. ("I couldn't find a list with both Kanye and Beethoven on it, so I made up my own!")
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by gmadsen on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:31AM (#30700057)
not only "geniuses", I'm sure the widespread reduction in reading in the general population has had significant affects across all aspects of society
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by adgjlsfhk1 on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @01:09PM (#30701409)
do you have evidence for your claim? everything I can find suggests that literacy is about as high as ever, as are book sales.
Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by waserwill on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @02:40PM (#30702408)
I'm not sure what sort of data could support this, but I'll just say this: there is a difference between reading quantity and quality. I'm merely echoing greater critics, but the quantity of books sold says little about their quality (markets see books as commodities and try to make make profit rather than spreading good literature, and this is understandable). Plus, judging by the number of unread books on my shelf, buying a book doesn't mean reading it. There is an aesthetic appeal to books, and though I want to read all I own, there will inevitably be books printed and sold but unread.

There are high literacy rates, but this says little about whether material has been grasped and digested. References to classics (e.g. in the English tradition, Milton, Shakespeare, Dickens) or even religious texts (e.g. Exodus) are rarely recognized, in my experience. Given how freely great orators of the recent past drew from these (e.g. the speeches of MLK Jr.), this is surprising.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by gmadsen on Thursday March 17, 2022 @10:38AM (#30711669)
purely anecdotally to my own experience, but I firmly believe that not only social media, but the screen size of phones themselves incentivize fast context switching shallow low quality reading, which has detrimental effects on cognition. Sure everyone has the worlds knowledge in their pocket, but all incentives are to only consume the lowest quality of knowledge

If I don't make it a daily habit, it becomes difficult to read a novel, I am unable to maintain the attention required, which phone scrolling im sure has exacerbated.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by ozim on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @06:29PM (#30704961)
So survivorship bias.

Second thing is that it was a lot easier to be a genius in 1900 than it is now.

Not saying that general relativity is well understood by general public but a lot more people has now some grasp on E=mc^2. While in 1900s it was something that most of people could not wrap their heads around.

Last point is that "geniuses" are overrated anyway. Because what we need as a species is that bell curve of knowledge moves up. So mediocre people get more intelligent and know more things and people from lower part of bell curve get to the level where mediocre people were before.

We achieved that because currently average Joe nowadays is much smarter than average Joe 100 years ago.

And we should strive to move forward with that.

Re:Geniuses of the past were aristocratically tutored by barrkel on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:54AM (#30700370)
That idea is countered right in the quoted passage by Tanner Greer.

In the past, it was obvious who was genius, even a few years after people died. Now, it's less clear.