News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There's no shame in looking good by sdurkin on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @01:57PM (#306040)
Pretty is good. Ugly is bad. It has always, and will always be this way.

If you don't make beautiful products, its probably because you can't.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by unalone on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:01PM (#306052)
Yes. Nobody sets out to make ugly things. It's just that if they CAN'T make it look good, they justify it by saying that it doesn't matter how good it looks.

All due respect to Matt Maroon, as always, but it's SUCH a snotty thing to dismiss a line of products because they're pretty. It's not only backwards thinking, it's snotty, too.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by aneesh on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:17PM (#306077)
He didn't dismiss a product because it was pretty. He dismissed the people who buy products solely because they were pretty.
Re:There's no shame in looking good by sdurkin on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:35PM (#306111)
Equally stupid. People can buy products for whatever reason they want. Why is beauty any less of a valid criterion than any other?

I must have been born without the desire to dictate to people why they should want things.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by Herring on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:54PM (#306139)
Yeah, you're probably wired to dictate to people who they should dismiss.
Re:There's no shame in looking good by unalone on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:50PM (#306130)
Yes.

Even when I see people using things I dislike (anybody heard of Twilight? That book is the scourge of intelligent life), I find fault not in the person who likes it but in the people that chose to make that product available (in that book's case, the publishing company). People can like whatever they want, and while that might change my opinion of the person, I don't blame the product for it.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by unalone on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:25PM (#306097)
But I think that's a bit snotty as well. Some people like pretty things, some people like things with insane benchmarks. To each his own if it works.
Re:There's no shame in looking good by Herring on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:49PM (#306127)
Most people, i think, like both. Problem is when some company in Cupertino, CA tries to pass off crap using pretty packaging. Nobody likes to wake up one day next to a fruit colored laptop.

Edit: Too soon?

Re:There's no shame in looking good by unalone on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:53PM (#306138)
I use Apple's MacBook Pro, and it runs quickly, its programs are all aesthetically pleasing, and it's an absolute joy to use. I didn't get an Air because I plan on doing some pretty intensive stuff on here, but from what i've seen of it it does a great job of being very fast for basic processes while looking beautiful.

I haven't seen a single Apple product that I think is crap, not in a decade. I think that a lot of them could be BETTER, but Apple absolutely cares about making the best product that they can, and they've shown it time and time again. Also, for the record, I LIKED the original iMac. I like the new ones better, but I think that iMac was great when it first came out. So unless you've got a quantitative argument against Apple, close it: I don't care to hear insults against a company that I like without any sort of backing-up.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by Herring on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @03:15PM (#306166)
I must have been the only one paying attention last few weeks during the iphone complaints. Apple is fun, i imagine, when you don't care about OSS, drm, or anything that Jobs has a tight fist clenched around.
Re:There's no shame in looking good by ashu on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @03:36PM (#306200)
You may have a different requirement from a product (OSS, etc. - I myself prefer to use Linux because of the open-ness) while others may have different (wanting it to look good, do the common things without a hassle) - but why is that a reason to say "passing off crap"? I will agree to the iPhone complaints, so they botched up the launch by sending out a half-baked product. The 2.1 update seems to have fixed a lot of problems for many people. The iPhone is driven by software a whole lot more than other phones are, and so gets updated at a very high rate. That is a good thing. How many phones you know keep adding features to themselves or fixing their own bugs via software updates? Or do other phones just not have any bugs or annoyances?

I will admit, though, that Apple tends to go overboard with its cheesy marketing tricks and ploys many times. They should let the products speak more. In most cases, they just do.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by unalone on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @07:43PM (#306452)
Out of curiosity: what tricks and ploys do you think it pulls, beyond the "I'm a Mac" ads?
Re:There's no shame in looking good by ashu on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @10:03PM (#306569)
The "twice as fast" and "half the price" ads were rather disingenuous. The "most advanced operating system" -- what? that's true only if you consider how great it looks. Otherwise, we can easily rattle off many Unix variants which kick OS X's ass when it comes to performance. Xcode: "the best IDE ever". MobileMe: "you can't believe this is a web-app, unheard-of usability in a web-app!" It just doesn't stop. They go overboard.

As for the "I'm a Mac" ads, they are not that bad at all.

Disclosure: I own an iPhone and am madly in love with it. I also own a new iMac, and love its looks and would like to make OS X work for me, but have not been very successful at that. Perhaps because I am just used to Linux.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by unalone on Wednesday September 17, 2008 @02:30AM (#306753)
The "twice as fast" I agree you with. Xcode I've heard nothing about. MobileMe I agree with them: it's beautiful unlike any other web app I've used. The service rocks too.

The operating system is absolutely the most advanced. The fact that it gives you so much power without any tinkering is stunning. Corner-window commands, the vast keyboard commands, and the incredible efficiency of Spotlight are my favorite quick things to point out.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by derefr on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @03:37PM (#306201)
The iPhone is owned by wireless carriers first, Apple second. No matter how Apple feels about OSS or DRM, they still have to treat the iPhone as a signed-and-sealed-and-dictated black box, because that's what the carriers demand in order for Apple to be let onto their networks. If they only had the iPod Touch (and had built their own VoIP suite on top as the "phone" part, say) they would likely be taking a very different approach with the App Store.
Re:There's no shame in looking good by SwellJoe on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @07:34PM (#306435)
The iPhone is owned by wireless carriers first, Apple second.

And yet Microsoft produces a more open mobile platform. If you believe AT&T is dictating the abusive iPhone terms, I'd recommend you lay off of the Jobs Kool-Aid for a while. It's effecting your perception.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by mattmaroon on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @08:24PM (#306493)
Exactly. The tech industry has had so much of the Microsoft monopoly that they're anxious to run out of the arms of one dictator and don't even care that they're headed straight into the arms of another.

Unfortunately, trading Gates for Jobs is like trading Mussolini for Hitler.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by mattmaroon on Wednesday September 17, 2008 @12:32AM (#306686)
Also, AT&T is one of many carriers around the world that they partner with. I don't hear anything about openness on any other.
Re:There's no shame in looking good by rbanffy on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @05:39PM (#306329)
Yeah. I am pretty sure Apple´s iPhone business would collapse the moment they decide to sell unlocked phones to anyone who wants them, anywhere in the world. It would also not resist if Apple decided to allow people to install software from any third party phone owners wanted to.

With all the demand for iPhones, the only reason to this closedness is maximizing profit at the expense of end-user flexibility.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by unalone on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @07:39PM (#306447)
You seem to forget that AT&T had to create an entire new system for handling voice messages just to let Apple host their phone. You also forget that Apple refuses to compromise their design, which means that they needed AT& T specifically because Verizon's a dick about stuff like that.

Usually Apple isn't against making tons of money, so I think it makes sense that there's a logical reason behind their actions.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by jcl on Wednesday September 17, 2008 @02:00PM (#307294)
Does the same logic apply to T-Mobile? As Apple's exclusive iPhone provider in Germany, T-Mobile must already have both a sufficient voice message system and an adequate deference to Apple's sense of design. Why not allow them to be an iPhone provider in the U.S. as well?

The truth is that Apple feels it can make much more money from exclusive contracts with the carriers than it can selling the phones directly to consumers.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by lief79 on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @04:10PM (#306238)
Unfortunately, this tends to be true.

It will very be interesting to see how this changes once Verizon opens up their networks to all products that prove their compatibility. Hopefully it will be much better then the locked down equipment they currently sell.

The only network I get home reception from won't even include flashes on the vast majority of their camera phones.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by comatose_kid on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @03:38PM (#306202)
I have a 3G iPhone and it is definitely not crap. It is a beautiful product that works really well for me (checking email, surfing, voice).

DRM sucks, but the iPod has proven that the presence of DRM doesn't mean a product is crap.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by mattmaroon on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @08:22PM (#306490)
Even the original Apple TV? You could watch rented videos from iTunes on it, but couldn't purchase. It required a HD hookup, but had no HD video. It sold like 8 units total.

If that wasn't crap, I don't know what was. Even the much improved version is still a misfire, but probably not crap.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by whatusername on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @09:03PM (#306524)
Hockey-Puck mouse? G4 Cube?

And as much as the performance of the MBA is derided on here.. It's probably better performing than my thinkpad (Due to being much newer). Has what you do in the last 2 years or so really changed that much needing extra performance (On your laptop?!)

Re:There's no shame in looking good by trevelyan on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @04:50PM (#306286)
Whatever the merits of how people make decisions, this is the market.

I've found the most effective way to deal with it is to aim for a very simple base design, and add design elements iteratively rather than attempting to build a complex design and forcing it into place. A few highly polished and professional graphics make a site seem polished, and are easier to get working across multiple browsers.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by mattmaroon on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @08:21PM (#306489)
That misses the point. I don't dismiss the Apple product because it's pretty. I just don't think it's style of pretty is the right for its market.

The Lenovo has a better design aesthetic for getting people to pay $2,500+ for an ultra portable laptop.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by william-newman on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @05:49PM (#306342)
"Pretty is good. Ugly is bad. It has always, and will always be this way."

Pretty is often good. Ugly is even more often bad. It has often been that way, and it will often be that way.

"If you don't make beautiful products, its probably because you can't."

Or because your product is wooden pencils, or bulldozers, or parachutes, or test tubes, or transistors, or pillows, or ammunition. Various things resist beauty enough that all you get is the elegance of something that's efficient and reliable, which is not the usual meaning of beauty.

(Yes, I remember our host's SR-71 example. And good sailboats look nice too. But efficient submarines and high speed rockets aren't particularly pretty. Once simple design constraints become too extreme --- streamlining in this case --- it can become hard to satisfy the constraints in an interesting way.)

Various other things like books are borderline cases. A well-done book may have more appealing aesthetic touches than a well-done wooden pencil. But not so many more, because mostly its presentation should keep out of the way of the words. A particularly beautiful fire alarm or fire extinguisher is not necessarily a good idea, either.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by river_styx on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:00PM (#306051)
Right. That must be why Google, Craigslist, and MySpace are such monumental failures.
Re:There's no shame in looking good by sdurkin on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:09PM (#306064)
Google is pretty, downright beautiful in fact.

Notice I said that pretty is good, but not the only good.

Myspace and Craigslist 'can't' make beautiful products, Myspace because that would detract from user personalization, and Craigslist because they never hired the design muscle because it works well enough.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by ashu on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:09PM (#306066)
The grand-parent is merely suggesting that Pretty is good and ugly is bad. NOT saying that is the only thing that matters. So your comment is not a refutation. (and hence, I see no reason for sarcasm either.)
Re:There's no shame in looking good by sc on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:11PM (#306067)
Google and Craigslist are minimalist relics that do a job and do it well. They're too plain to be _ugly_.

MySpace is popular with the same personalizing crowd that would put stickers on their MacBooks.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by drm237 on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @03:03PM (#306148)
I disagree that craigslist does what it does well. I think it does it extremely poorly. They've managed to get a huge critical mass though which means people will deal with the flaws because its where the content is.
Re:There's no shame in looking good by mattmaroon on Wednesday September 17, 2008 @12:29AM (#306681)
And for all we know, both would be twice as popular with good design.
Re:There's no shame in looking good by brlewis on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:14PM (#306071)
People don't have an emotional connection to classified ads or search results. This was an epiphany for me which I detail here: http://ourdoings.com/2008-02
Re:There's no shame in looking good by nonrecursive on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:23PM (#306093)
I'm sure this conversation has been had on news.yc, but how do you account for ugly ass sites like myspace, plenty of fish, and craigslist?
Re:There's no shame in looking good by brlewis on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:51PM (#306134)
Aesthetics speak. Craigslist says "cheap". MySpace says "My parents wouldn't like this place and I can decorate it how I want". I don't know what plentyoffish says.
Re:There's no shame in looking good by dissenter on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @03:03PM (#306149)
rationalization / post-hoc. If you were setting out to make the next MySpace or Craigslist, would you consciously decide to make it ugly as a competitive advantage? Ugly designs happen by accident [re: neglect] and in spite of the underlying site's success. By the time the site is successful it's too late/unnecessary to change it.
Re:There's no shame in looking good by mechanical_fish on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @03:42PM (#306206)
If you were setting out to make the next MySpace or Craigslist, would you consciously decide to make it ugly as a competitive advantage?

Sure. But the word you're looking for is functional, not ugly. The ugliness is just a side effect.

Craigslist was criticized for being too plain from the moment it was built. But it's buried a lot of better-Photoshopped competitors.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by nonrecursive on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @04:35PM (#306270)
I disagree. As other's are pointing out, a site's design says a message, and having an ugly design might send the right message.

Dove is using this idea in their "Campaign for Natural Beauty" (http://www.dove.us/#/cfrb/) . The models aren't ugly, but they also aren't the usual perfect-looking models.

When I was in grade school, I remember there were anti-smoking and tobacco posters on the wall of severely aged, sick looking people along with some text about how "chewing cost me my mandible". Those were examples of actual human ugliness, and they worked.

So that's all to say, ugly could be part of your message. Which isn't really a novel idea.

What's more interesting, in my opinion, is when something seems bad from a usability standpoint and still succeeds. plentyoffish.com fits under this category.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by brlewis on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @03:10PM (#306158)
I would test different designs to see what gives the best results.
Re:There's no shame in looking good by mattmaroon on Wednesday September 17, 2008 @12:31AM (#306684)
All three of those are about the network effect. People will choose the site that most people are at.

Facebook has made serious inroads largely due to better design (in terms of aesthetics and usability) than myspace.

Plentyoffish, craigslist, and Wikipedia are ugly ass sites that seem pretty much unassailable though.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by sdurkin on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:27PM (#306099)
Tradeoffs. Pretty has costs, in one form or another, and each of these firms takes these costs into account.

The original walkman was ugly as sin, but it was cheap and reliable. Had it been beautiful, it would have been even better, but it couldn't, without costing more.

Re:There's no shame in looking good by omouse on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:53PM (#306137)
MySpace allows people to customize their profiles and while it may be ugly, it's only because the people who design them don't really know any better. They're still learning how to design.
Re:There's no shame in looking good by Herring on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @03:30PM (#306190)
Myspace actually looks a lot better these days. Almost normal.

http://www.myspace.com/