News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How a small nuclear war would transform the entire planet... by Synaesthesia on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @09:53AM (#30600523)
In military scenarios any use of nuclear weapons always escalates. So I don't think its possible
Re:How a small nuclear war would transform the entire planet... by stinkytaco on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @10:04AM (#30600653)
In a military scenario nuclear weapons have been used precisely once (twice if you don't count them as a single strategic maneuver) and it ended the war. I'm not sure we have enough data to go on.
Re:How a small nuclear war would transform the entire planet... by emteycz on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @10:17AM (#30600788)
Aren't nukes used all the time, by their mere presence?
Re:How a small nuclear war would transform the entire planet... by stinkytaco on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @10:40AM (#30601052)
That could be said of anything, military or not. An object, by its presence, influences the world around it. If you are talking about the deterrent effect of mutually assured destruction, I again point out that we don't really have the data. A war between large powers is likely to be devastating even if nuclear weapons are never used and that doesn't seem to deter aggression over a long enough timeline.

I don't disagree that an escalation scenario is possible or even likely. It probably is, but I don't think the term "always" really takes into account either the breadth of possibilities or human nature. Part of the problem is that we still frame this in a very binary "Western Europe vs. Eastern Europe" way. If Iran or North Korea fired a nuclear warhead, I don't think that it would necessarily provoke a nuclear response, but an overwhelming conventional response. It's unlikely that either has enough warheads to provoke an all out nuclear conflict and they could likely be overwhelmed conventionally. Our desire not to enter into a catastrophic conflict is probably quite high.

Obviously I'd really like there to be no possibility of this occurring.

Re:How a small nuclear war would transform the entire planet... by Cerium on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @10:46AM (#30601151)
Also in that scenario all functional nuclear devices on the planet were detonated, iirc.
Re:How a small nuclear war would transform the entire planet... by bombcar on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @10:09AM (#30600697)
This is the accepted (and perhaps it's very good that it is!) wisdom, but obviously it isn't the case; if the nuclear powers decided to nuke the living daylights out of Africa for some reason, it wouldn't escalate as the countries hit have no way of retaliating.
Re:How a small nuclear war would transform the entire planet... by petercooper on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @10:29AM (#30600908)
It's fictional, of course, but the movie By Dawn's Early Light covers a scenario where a limited nuclear strike could occur (essentially the two sides negotiate to nuke each other equally as much, but not to an all-out extent): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/By_Dawn%27s_Early_Light