— South Bend, Ind., Mayor Pete Buttigieg (D), in remarks in Bow, N.H., Oct. 25, 2019
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/10/30/did-racia...
Also don't forget about Bush v. Gore. It's apparently a "historic" moment when Gore finally conceded the election to Bush.
https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/al-gore-concedes...
Those are legitimate political arguments about voter suppression laws.
No one on the left claimed Kemp and Republicans stuffed ballot boxes or China hacked whatever.
The argument is based in facts. Many Republican controlled states, especially in the south, have historic issues with suppressing the votes of black and brown Americans.
You can argue over the extent to which this suppression still exists and how much it affects election outcomes.
But it is not even close to the same as arguing that the election was completely fraudulent because of real voter fraud, that the SOS or whatever bureaucrats should overstep their authority to throw it out.
- The Pennsylvania Supreme Court (not the legislature) changed their voting laws to accommodate widespread mail-in ballots and drop-boxes which was against the state constitution. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/28/us/politics/pennsylvania-...
- There are a number of reports that many nursing homes in Wisconsin had near 100% voting turnout. https://justthenews.com/politics-policy/elections/wisconsin-... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Y2REQS5kKo
And yet no one challenged the law until after the third election it had taken effect. Until after the results had come out. There's a doctrine called laches: you have to complain about things that wrong you when you find about them, and if you wait too long, you don't get to complain anymore.
Furthermore, as for election challenges go, you're not going to invalidate any votes that had already been validly cast under the existing interpretation of law, even if the interpretation is incorrect per court rulings. For example, when there were last-minute challenges to absentee ballot procedures, any absentee ballots cast before the decision came out under the old procedures would still be valid, even if they didn't meet the new procedural requirements.
So anyone thinking that courts would invalidate election results via after-the-fact court challenges is either ignorant, lying to themselves, or is stuck somewhere in la-la land.
On your second point: If a state holds an election contrary to their constitution and it's proven that it was contrary to their constitution, the votes wouldn't be constitutional. In other words they're illegal. So wouldn't it be sensible to hear calls to count only the legal votes?
There are many, many more irregularities that are too numerous to list but here are a few:
https://rumble.com/vhj5at-2020-election-irregularities-compi...
No. Those who voted using improper procedures had reasonable basis to believe that the procedures they used would have been proper. If they had known those procedures where improper at the time they availed themselves of them, they very well could have used proper procedures instead. After the election and the votes are counted, it is absolutely too late to cure any defects. Why should those people be penalized for actions that they have done through no fault of their own?
Traditionally, older Pennsylvanians support conservative candidates. And with the state's population skewing older, Republicans in the state realized the thing that could dampen votes for their candidates was that the state's ancient, overly-tight restraints on what constituted a valid excuse for an absentee ballot meant that older Pennsylvanians who were shut in in nursing homes and couldn't find transportation to the polls increasingly wouldn't be able to vote for their candidates.
It was one of those bipartisan pieces of legislation that passed because Democrats believed the more of the population voted, the more would vote for them, and Republicans believed supporting the elderly's right to vote meant more Republican votes. In the end, they were probably both right.
Point is, the state Supreme Court rightfully saw through it when the people who'd supported the law in the first place called foul, but only in the third election the law was used, when their candidate wasn't the one who won.
... well, their candidate for President. An awful lot of their down-ticket candidates won. Which would be a weird thing to happen if the election had been rigged, wouldn't it?
No one of reasonable mind is questioning whether ballots that were automatically sent to people - without explicit laws instructing counties to do that - were somehow sent back en masse by fake or dead people, or adding additional ballots onto it.
Yeah a lot of places like that get very high turnout. Especially older people in general.
One reason is from what the right calls 'ballot harvesting' which is usually legal. where someone goes into a high voter concentration area and goes door to doo, helps to vote, then turns the ballots in on behalf of the voter.
Both sides do this.
While there are a few instances of bad actors filling in ballots for people (almost always Republican..) that would have to be proven. And there isn't any evidence in those instances. Even if it did happen for a few hundred votes - which I personally doubt - it would not have changed the outcome of the election, likely not even at the very small local level.
Others talk about stopped counts, regions not reporting until seeing the results of other regions, and then ballot harvesting to make up numbers.
There are many such examples.
- Abrams defends lack of concession after 2018 gubernatorial loss (CNN) https://www.cnn.com/2021/12/03/politics/stacey-abrams-conces...
- Stacey Abrams is running for Georgia governor in 2022 (AJC.com) "Abrams lost to Kemp by less than 1.4 percentage points in 2018, the closest Georgia gubernatorial election in decades, and her refusal to concede defeat because of what she called an “erosion” of voting rights" https://www.ajc.com/politics/politics-blog/breaking-stacey-a...
Her whole platform for her new gubernatorial race is predicated on the "fact" that she was cheated out of her last election.
https://www.thegatewaypundit.com/2022/01/huge-georgia-ballot...
and videos coupled cell phone data show many other traffickers going in between democrat NGOs and drop boxes. Abrams run some of these NGOs.
https://www.thegatewaypundit.com/2022/01/new-video-voterga-r...
This is an example of us living under Marcusas repressive tolerance where people with the correct ideology can make claims with no evidence, while the other side is censored and persecuted even when coming with concrete evidence. It’s a Mao style cultural revolution. For Bernie, orange man and many other candidates we have proof of rampant cheating.
I was watching the latter seasons of X-Files and Fox Mulder made a comment on 2000 elections, something like “that sounds about as reliable as our elections.”
Plenty of folks, Howard Dean comes to mind, said they were straight up illegitimate.
Even now many on the left insist it was a tie or something.
This thing of “if you don’t win the elections, question the results” started then.
The press had no problem allowing baseless speculation and outright dishonesty in 2000. But when it was a Democratic cadidate, suddenly the truth matters.
To make matters worse, so many journalists are Democrats … it’s insane. Not just Democrats, but urban, college educated Democrats. Not exactly a cross section of the country.
It was very close. Close enough to reveal the messiness that extremely close elections can create.
But not enough to change the outcome.
Bush won. He probably won by double digits in Florida. But he still won.
As late as 2008, Howard Dean was falsely claiming SCOTUS had “snatched” the election from the Dems, which was demonstrably untrue at this point.
https://latimesblogs.latimes.com/washington/2008/05/howard-d...
Read that article. Nowhere do you see the “this is a lie” disclaimers. Yes, Trump is spreading disinformation, as Howard Dean did (and probably still does.)
Here’s another good example: by the end of the Democratic Primary in 2020, Biden had more than enough votes for the nomination. He had won, plain and simple.
But he and Sanders kept campaigning, because they knew an active campaign would turn out Democratic votes in downstream elections.
The press went along with this facade. At no point did they “declare a winner” even though Biden had effectively won.
They allowed the charade of a campaign to go on, allowing Democrats a heavy advantage in elections like the Wisconsin State Supreme Court.
Again, the election was already over, and a winner should have been declared. But it wasn’t.
The press is very selective. And study after study after shows journalists are almost exclusively Democrats.
President Trump. What was Howard Dean? The distinction really matters.
> They allowed the charade of a campaign to go on, allowing Democrats a heavy advantage in elections like the Wisconsin State Supreme Court.
Primaries are not elections, though, and there is no reason a political party has to call them off just because someone believes the game has already been effectively won. I.e. it ain't over until it's over. It's bad enough that voters in later primaries basically believe their vote doesn't matter, but you're suggesting that we should formalize that? The parties are private organizations, so who do you propose gets to decide when to call the whole thing off?
I’m criticizing the press for not calling the winner.
In most elections, the press takes their duty of calling the winner very, very seriously. Almost like it’s a constitutional role.
And yet when it would have mattered, they decided not to.
It doesn’t help that the US system can have a winner who didn’t get the majority of the vote.
There are a number of aspects of the US voting system which are less than perfect, and that’s just one.
This is incorrect.
You require a majority of votes in the USA in the presidential election. What you seem to be missing is that people do not vote for the President but vote to direct how their state votes.
States vote for President. People vote for states.
https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2016/12/16/13920444/...
https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/11/the-ele...
> “There’s just a lot that I think will be revealed. History will discover,” the Democratic Party’s 2016 presidential nominee continued. “But you don’t win by 3 million votes and have all this other shenanigans and stuff going on and not come away with an idea like, ‘Whoa, something’s not right here.’ That was a deep sense of unease.”
[1]: https://news.yahoo.com/hillary-clinton-maintains-2016-electi...
Hilary Clinton again in 2020 (which is the same election that Trump complains about, by the way) [2]:
> The 2016 Democratic presidential nominee predicted that among several scenarios, Republicans are going to try to “mess up absentee balloting” so that they could get a potentially narrow advantage in the Electoral College.
> “We've got to have a massive legal operation, I know the Biden campaign is working on that,” she said. “We have to have poll workers, and I urge people, who are able, to be a poll worker. We have to have our own teams of people to counter the force of intimidation that the Republicans and Trump are going to put outside polling places. This is a big organizational challenge, but at least we know more about what they're going to do.”
[2]: https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2020-election/hillary-clint...
I also remember well the "Selected not elected" days after Bush v. Gore. That went on the entire time that Bush was president and went to sleep for a couple of terms when Obama won.
Just to be clear, I'm not making a judgement on who is right here. I think the truth is a lot more nuanced than "right or wrong." I;m just pointing out that we have a long history of politicians/parties questioning election results, but until now we've never had widespread attempts to silence it.
The republican party just literally spent months on questioning the election in places like Arizona with no evidence of any fraud, and there's plenty of documentation on how (almost always republican) politicians use lies to get people to not vote: https://lawyerscommittee.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/Dece...
Basically, if you want to argue that its a "he said, she said" thing, you're going to need to come to the table with receipts about it, and trump is just completely full of shit on a level that's untenable and weirdly turned into this January thing where we almost had lawmakers killed.
I am not happy with either, but I don't really compare them in the same sentence.
Had there been statewide recounts, according to that page, things may have been different.
... actually conceded the night of the election. Bitched about it later, for sure. But conceded the election immediately. Something that hasn't happened yet for Mr. Trump.
See especially:
Chapter 6: Wisconsin Election Officials’ Widespread Use of Absentee Ballot Drop Boxes Facially Violated Wisconsin Law.
Chapter 7: The Wisconsin Elections Commission (WEC) Unlawfully Directed Clerks to Violate Rules Protecting Nursing Home Residents, Resulting in a 100% Voting Rate in Many Nursing Homes in 2020, Including Many Ineligible Voters.
The author, Former Supreme Court justice Mike Gableman, concludes:
"This Report has documented not just one, but a great collection of Wisconsin election law violations. As a political matter, the actions of state actors certifying electors in any Presidential election can be reconsidered as the Wisconsin Legislature sees fit using its plenary power under Article II of the federal Constitution, as recognized in McPherson and Bush v. Gore. Indeed, McPherson noted that “there is no doubt of the right of the legislature to resume the power at any time.” McPherson, 146 U.S. at 35 (emphasis added)..."
https://legis.wisconsin.gov/assembly/22/brandtjen/media/1552...
I hope the MSM will pay due attention to the issues that this report identified.
In Milwaukee County, 30 nursing homes vetted, 1084 registered voters, 1084 votes, 100%
In Racine County, 12 nursing homes vetted, 348 registered voters, 348 votes, 100%
In Dane County, 24 nursing homes vetted, 723 registered voters, 723 votes, 100%
Etc.
An exemplar of the problem is detailed in the case filed in Waukesha County, Wisconsin, by one Paul Archambault on behalf of his mother, "Jane Doe", who was "adjudicated as incompetent by the Waukesha County Circuit Court due to a degenerative brain disorder on June 23, 2015." But, it was discovered that, "Jane Doe had cast ballots in the August 11, 2020 Partisan Primary, and the November2020 General Election".
https://empowerwisconsin.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/Summ...
It doesn't "prove" a stolen election but it does raise suspicions.
The "ballot harvesting" video was debunked thoroughly in a matter of hours after it was released.
I'm not familiar with ballot harvesting.
> It is our conclusion, based on the facts detailed in the Committee's Report, that the Russian intelligence services' assault on the integrity of the 2016 U.S. electoral process[,] and Trump and his associates' participation in and enabling of this Russian activity, represents one of the single most grave counterintelligence threats to American national security in the modern era.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Senate_Intelligence_Committee_...
The left was screaming about Trump directly colluding with the Russians. When the facts came out and it was clear he didn't collude, the goal posts shifted to "well the Russian troll farms helped Trump win!"
That's not collusion.
> Trump and his associates' participation in and enabling of this Russian activity
If you want to understand more, there is a summary of "Links between Trump associates and Russian officials" in the Wikipedia article about "Russian interference in the 2016 United States elections"[0], including this section, for example:
> In the email, Goldstone said the information had come from the Russian government and "was part of a Russian government effort to help Donald Trump's presidential campaign". Trump Jr. replied with an e-mail saying "If it's what you say I love it especially later in the summer" and arranged the meeting. Trump Jr. went to the meeting expecting to receive information harmful to the Clinton campaign, but he said none was forthcoming, and instead the conversation then turned to [US sanctions against Russia]
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_interference_in_the_20...
Not really, no.
From your own source:
"The Special Counsel's report, made public in April 2019, examined numerous contacts between the Trump campaign and Russian officials but concluded that there was insufficient evidence to bring any conspiracy or coordination charges against Trump or his associates."
It literally states there was no evidence of collision or conspiracy.
> Mueller privately wrote to Barr, stating that the March 24 Barr letter "did not fully capture the context, nature, and substance of this office's work and conclusions"
Bear in mind that Mueller was a Republican special counsel, whose remit was set by Trump's DOJ, and that:
> On May 1, Barr testified that he "didn't exonerate" Trump on obstruction as "that's not what the Justice Department does" and that neither he nor Rosenstein had reviewed the underlying evidence in the report.
and:
> In July 2019, Mueller testified to Congress that a president could be charged with crimes including obstruction of justice after the president left office.
so he was prevented by policy (not the law or the facts) from bringing charges against Trump.
The article summary concludes:
> In 2020, a Republican-appointed federal judge decided to personally review the report's redactions to see if they were legitimate. The judge said Barr's "misleading" statements about the report's findings led him to suspect that Barr had tried to establish a "one-sided narrative" favorable to Trump.
In any case, the Senate investigation (which is what I originally quoted) came later, and was more forthcoming about the connection between Trump's team and Russia.
Yes it does, it links to the Mueller Report Wikipedia page that directly states:
"Volume I of the report concludes that the investigation "did not establish that members of the Trump campaign conspired or coordinated with the Russian government in its election interference activities.""
With several linked sources.
>Bear in mind that Mueller was a Republican special counsel, whose remit was set by Trump's DOJ, and that:
And? There were multiple Democrats in the special counsel that also did not find any collision.
"On May 1, Barr testified that he "didn't exonerate" Trump on obstruction ... Mueller testified to Congress that a president could be charged with crimes including obstruction of justice after the president left office."
Obstruction is not collusion. I can hear the goalposts screeching from here.
>so he was prevented by policy (not the law or the facts) from bringing charges against Trump.
And no one, not any of the state or federal ADAs/AGs/etc. brought any charges up for collision... because there was no evidence of it as reported by Mueller. QED.
>In any case, the Senate investigation (which is what I originally quoted) came later, and was more forthcoming about the connection between Trump's team and Russia.
And also found nothing.
I'll say it again: There is no evidence that Trump and Co. colluded with the Russians.
What you believe is an Alex Jones level conspiracy theory that just so happens to be politically expedient to believe.