Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by beloch on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:03PM
(#30558919)
With NATO unable to intervene militarily due to the threat of nuclear war, it initially looked like Ukraine was on its own. Once again, the Russian bear would do as it wills.
However, coordinated sanctions backed by the crucial will to take an economic hit if necessary have made it possible that, if it the bear cannot be fought, it might instead be fenced in and driven back with starvation.
Germany is still importing Russian oil, but less of it. Do they and the EU have the will and the coordination to turn off Russia's last pipelines of money for munitions?
If the West can tame the bear without fighting it, that will be a huge win for Western diplomacy. It will prove that the post WWII world order can do what it was designed to do. It will prove that its possible to tamp down the aggression of bad actors without threatening the world with nuclear war.
If the West fails in this and either lets Ukraine fall or decides to roll the dice and intervene militarily, then the future security of the world is going to take a big hit. The bear must be tamed, but without war.
If you're in Germany, tell your government to ban Russian oil. This will hurt Germany, but could be the key difference that keeps nuclear conflict off the table.
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by zepearl on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:31PM
(#30559299)
> And Russia would sell to China. So Germany hurts itself and Russia doesn't care
Russia would probably sell to China (not sure about the added complexity involving currencies => probably depends on the goods that Russia could buy from China), the question is probably how much of it China would buy & when (e.g. existing contracts with other parties, potential negative impact on foreign public relations, not sure if oil quality plays a role for certain types of consumptions, etc...).
Currently it looks like that Germans and probably all other european countries (why do we always end up talking only about Germany? Are other EU countries that much less relevant?) would be willing to be "hurt themselves" by paying more in/directly (I guess something similar to the whole blood-diamonds theme, but in this case it's more direct), I guess that the question is "how much more".
Maybe if most of the countries are impacted the same way and therefore there aren't major "hotspots" that would have access to a low price (and therefore boosting their lower-cost production) then the only impact would be a little bit of spread inflation?
EDIT:
forgot to mention that the price of oil from Russia "urals" is currently as well increasing, but less, as it's detaching itself from the reference "brent" ( https://ibb.co/mXGf5XX ) because of less people/companies/countries willing to buy it (because of inability to pay for it because of the various sanctions, and/or because of bad public relations that that would generate).
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by beloch on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:12PM
(#30559040)
The U.S. produces more oil than they consume and are sitting next to massive export capacity in Canada too. Biden has no excuses here. Build some damned infrastructure and get off Russian oil.
Russia does vastly more trade with the EU than China. Even if China continues to do nothing, that doesn't mean demand for Russian goods will suddenly undergo a massive increase in China. Supply will exceed demand, prices will fall, and Russia will have less money for bombs.
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by hef19898 on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:30PM
(#30559282)
You do know that Russia isn't buying arms and ammunitions, it's producing them, domestically. Throwing the economy at that can make a lot or arms before the lack of hard currency from oil and gas sales slows that down.
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by birdyrooster on Friday March 04, 2022 @05:41PM
(#30561591)
It's not worse, it's slightly better because if it was larger we wouldn't be able to easily turn it off and the amount of money going to Russia would be greater.
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by birdyrooster on Wednesday March 09, 2022 @05:27AM
(#30612958)
Well, it wasn't worse morally because we cut our purchase of Russian petroleum yesterday. Who was worse? The British, who will need until the end of 2022 to end their contracts with Russia.
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by thawaya3113 on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:58PM
(#30559596)
Europe have the advantage of time. A few weeks in it’s gonna get warm and the need for Russian gas will drop dramatically. Especially at the consumer/voting public level.
That will give Europe another 8-9 months to find alternatives. The only alternatives that are available in that timeline are gonna be a massive ramp up of wind/solar and possibly restarting expensive coal operations. And energy efficiency, which I suspect governments in Europe are gonna bring in a raft of policies to emphasize.
I suspect they will go in big for renewables and then try and fill in any gaps with coal.
Those 9 months also give the US time to ramp up their gas exports to Europe.
Cutting off energy imports from Russia right now wouldn’t just be shooting them selves in the foot, it will remove the last piece of leverage the Europeans have against Putin. The Ukraine invasion isn’t likely to involve NATO troops and so needs to end at the negotiating table, at which time Europe needs the stick of imposing further pain by ending energy imports.
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by hef19898 on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:06PM
(#30558972)
If Putin can be tamed without a war between Russia and NATO depends to a large degree on Putin now.
EDIT: I had this discusion a couple of times now, consensus: As long as invoices are paid, transportation is avaialable, neither party (customer, supplier, banks,...) nor product are on a sanctions list or under embargo you continue to respect your existing contracts and obligations and continue business. Things like oil and gas have been excluded from any snactions (last I know, things are changing incredibly fast...).
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by Barrera on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:09PM
(#30559007)
> ... Yet a Wende—a watershed, a turning-point, the crossing of a Rubicon—is a big, important, intimidating thing. ...
The author might want to review things that happened in the US immediately after 9/11. Action, yes, but in almost every case exactly the wrong actions were agreed to in short order and executed. Both parties, united as one. Just look at all the unity! Maybe out of this tragedy will emerge a new sense of cooperation.
We're still paying the price for that fever-induced debacle.
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by vincentmarle on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:04PM
(#30558935)
European politics is a textbook example of the Shock Doctrine [1]: they will not do anything unless they're forced to do so. Which unfortunately often means too little, too late.
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by zegerjan on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:26PM
(#30559227)
Interesting take, especially if you factor in action on climate change. The US is unable to get anything done, while the EU has a track record of getting results.
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by Overtonwindow on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:15PM
(#30559071)
Europe seems to turn a blind eye to the former Soviet bloc states, but perhaps Ukraine has showed them that they could be next. I’ve always found it extremely frustrating by how little Europe seems to do to support its neighbors instead pushing the US to intervene.
Some point the European Union has to grow a spine and stop thinking America’s going to bail them out of every conflict.
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by hef19898 on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:27PM
(#30559242)
The other way to look at that is that the US needed NATO and the Coaltion of the Willing in Iraq and Afghanistan. The EU is a economic and political thing, not a military one.
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by imwillofficial on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:00PM
(#30558873)
I come to a different conclusion.
As this situation has unfolded, we’ve seen waffling on important issues, such as Germany helping the Ukraine at all, blown promises, such as the planes that never got to the Ukraine, and weapons support that is too little too late.
I see the same Europe as always. Conflicted in direction, visionless in strategy, and slow in implementation.
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by hef19898 on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:04PM
(#30558950)
Well, the war is merely a week old. The changes that happened aince are profound. And the EU did deliver thousands of AA and Anti-tank missiles. Sure, loads of those are basically Cold War surplus. But deliver they did, figuring out deliveries of weapons that cannot be packed on a truck is different, just look at the length the US had to ge before lend lease was passed to get planes cross the Canadian border.
I don't think I can remember such a unified Europe in my adult life.
EDIT: NATO dod sends tons of help before, mostly money. It's fair to assume that money wasn't spend on new smartphones for everyone.
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by dragonwriter on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:16PM
(#30559092)
> NATO dod sends tons of help before, mostly money. It's fair to assume that money wasn't spend on new smartphones for everyone.
With a lot of Western (mostly NATO/EU members, not all via NATO or EU) money and training, Ukraine has, IIRC, doubled the size of and significantly modernized it's military since the Russian invasion began in 2014.
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by yardie on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:10PM
(#30559014)
President Biden has been sounding the alarm for a month, "Russia is preparing to invade Ukraine". Literally none of the EU nor NATO members did much until they literally started driving the tanks in. Russia was trying to convince the world they were simply doing military exercises near the Russia/Ukraine border and most of the EU actually believed it!
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by dragonwriter on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:21PM
(#30559148)
> President Biden has been sounding the alarm for a month
The White House has been doing that for, at least, approximately 3 months; it's been since early December (maybe even earlier). Here’s the Dec. 7 Press Briefing where it is the main issue:
> Literally none of the EU nor NATO members did much until they literally started driving the tanks in.
That's very much not true, which is why they were able to do quite a lot right away when the invasion happened despite all the diplomatic efforts to dissuade it.
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by hef19898 on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:16PM
(#30559080)
You really think that? Not even in the background, while readying for the inevitable? It wasn't public or covered by the news, sure. But NATO and the EU did prepare. Just just not openly, because that could have pissed of Putin, and there might still have been the chance to prevent this war.
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by sdoering on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:07PM
(#30558978)
While we also, additionally use the media frenzy to quietly either bury other topics or do implement laws that would otherwise create a big outcry.
Like throwing money at energy companies to keep nuclear power plants running longer while already having thrown money at them for over a decade for closing down these plants.
I am all for becoming more energy independent. But this is just something I can't wrap my mind around.
Re:With war at its doors, Europe discovers a capacity for ac...
by koshergweilo on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:09PM
(#30559002)
Although I agree that weapons support could have been done earlier, you must concede that the western response has been an order of magnitude larger than what happened in 2014. A simple look at the value of the Ruble can confirm this.
However, coordinated sanctions backed by the crucial will to take an economic hit if necessary have made it possible that, if it the bear cannot be fought, it might instead be fenced in and driven back with starvation.
Germany is still importing Russian oil, but less of it. Do they and the EU have the will and the coordination to turn off Russia's last pipelines of money for munitions?
If the West can tame the bear without fighting it, that will be a huge win for Western diplomacy. It will prove that the post WWII world order can do what it was designed to do. It will prove that its possible to tamp down the aggression of bad actors without threatening the world with nuclear war.
If the West fails in this and either lets Ukraine fall or decides to roll the dice and intervene militarily, then the future security of the world is going to take a big hit. The bear must be tamed, but without war.
If you're in Germany, tell your government to ban Russian oil. This will hurt Germany, but could be the key difference that keeps nuclear conflict off the table.
Like the USA
> you're in Germany, tell your government to ban Russian oil. This will hurt Germany.
And Russia would sell to China. So Germany hurts itself and Russia doesn't care
Russia would probably sell to China (not sure about the added complexity involving currencies => probably depends on the goods that Russia could buy from China), the question is probably how much of it China would buy & when (e.g. existing contracts with other parties, potential negative impact on foreign public relations, not sure if oil quality plays a role for certain types of consumptions, etc...).
Currently it looks like that Germans and probably all other european countries (why do we always end up talking only about Germany? Are other EU countries that much less relevant?) would be willing to be "hurt themselves" by paying more in/directly (I guess something similar to the whole blood-diamonds theme, but in this case it's more direct), I guess that the question is "how much more".
Maybe if most of the countries are impacted the same way and therefore there aren't major "hotspots" that would have access to a low price (and therefore boosting their lower-cost production) then the only impact would be a little bit of spread inflation?
EDIT:
forgot to mention that the price of oil from Russia "urals" is currently as well increasing, but less, as it's detaching itself from the reference "brent" ( https://ibb.co/mXGf5XX ) because of less people/companies/countries willing to buy it (because of inability to pay for it because of the various sanctions, and/or because of bad public relations that that would generate).
Russia does vastly more trade with the EU than China. Even if China continues to do nothing, that doesn't mean demand for Russian goods will suddenly undergo a massive increase in China. Supply will exceed demand, prices will fall, and Russia will have less money for bombs.
So everybody wants from Europe to hurt itself but at the same time the US is allowed to needlessly buy oil from Russia.
Selling to China is a huge profit reduction for Russia.
That will give Europe another 8-9 months to find alternatives. The only alternatives that are available in that timeline are gonna be a massive ramp up of wind/solar and possibly restarting expensive coal operations. And energy efficiency, which I suspect governments in Europe are gonna bring in a raft of policies to emphasize.
I suspect they will go in big for renewables and then try and fill in any gaps with coal.
Those 9 months also give the US time to ramp up their gas exports to Europe.
Cutting off energy imports from Russia right now wouldn’t just be shooting them selves in the foot, it will remove the last piece of leverage the Europeans have against Putin. The Ukraine invasion isn’t likely to involve NATO troops and so needs to end at the negotiating table, at which time Europe needs the stick of imposing further pain by ending energy imports.
EDIT: I had this discusion a couple of times now, consensus: As long as invoices are paid, transportation is avaialable, neither party (customer, supplier, banks,...) nor product are on a sanctions list or under embargo you continue to respect your existing contracts and obligations and continue business. Things like oil and gas have been excluded from any snactions (last I know, things are changing incredibly fast...).
The author might want to review things that happened in the US immediately after 9/11. Action, yes, but in almost every case exactly the wrong actions were agreed to in short order and executed. Both parties, united as one. Just look at all the unity! Maybe out of this tragedy will emerge a new sense of cooperation.
We're still paying the price for that fever-induced debacle.
> This is heart-warming stuff.
For me it's spine-tingling.
[1] https://tsd.naomiklein.org/shock-doctrine.html
https://weltwoche-ch.translate.goog/daily/fuer-das-ausland-h...
The whole planet is pretty much aligned on the sanctions. South Korea is not part of the EU. Nor is Switzerland.
What garbage! It's a political entity. Von Clausewitz had something to say about war and politics . . .
https://www.goodreads.com/author/quotes/67848.Carl_von_Claus...
Some point the European Union has to grow a spine and stop thinking America’s going to bail them out of every conflict.
I see the same Europe as always. Conflicted in direction, visionless in strategy, and slow in implementation.
I don't think I can remember such a unified Europe in my adult life.
EDIT: NATO dod sends tons of help before, mostly money. It's fair to assume that money wasn't spend on new smartphones for everyone.
With a lot of Western (mostly NATO/EU members, not all via NATO or EU) money and training, Ukraine has, IIRC, doubled the size of and significantly modernized it's military since the Russian invasion began in 2014.
The White House has been doing that for, at least, approximately 3 months; it's been since early December (maybe even earlier). Here’s the Dec. 7 Press Briefing where it is the main issue:
https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/press-briefings/202...
> Literally none of the EU nor NATO members did much until they literally started driving the tanks in.
That's very much not true, which is why they were able to do quite a lot right away when the invasion happened despite all the diplomatic efforts to dissuade it.
Like throwing money at energy companies to keep nuclear power plants running longer while already having thrown money at them for over a decade for closing down these plants.
I am all for becoming more energy independent. But this is just something I can't wrap my mind around.